3 ms·
Also, It occurs to me that the approach of having meaning be tied to a fixed position in space is rather limited. As I recall, when the first actual human bei
by joe_the_user 17y ago
Also,
It occurs to me that the approach of having meaning be tied to a fixed position in space is rather limited.
As I recall, when the first actual human beings evolved, they invent this thing called language, in which the relative position of a symbol determined it's meaning rather it's fixed position. Using fixed position anyway is all well and good but it seems that when an app runs out of fixed screen space, it has to start using relative position in a variety of effective ways, taking some clues from the human facility for language.
I suspect that is why the author can't find that many recent examples for his theory - though it is an interesting theory.
- Daniel_Newby 17y agoActually it's very powerful. The mammalian brain has fantastic mechanisms for identifying a location in a context, remembering it for later, returning to that location with modest use of conscious thought, and remembering what characteristics and activities were previously associated with that location. Do a web search for "grid cell" and "conditioned place preference". Also "memory palace" will learn you about an ancient place-based technique for memorizing huge amounts of information.
- tjmaxal 17y agospatial mapping is in fact a really useful way to memorize anything. It works because it engages multiple parts of the brain at the same time creating a stronger memory.
- tobtoh 17y agoWhilst I agree that relative position is used in language, I don't think you can associate that with ease of use. If anything, your example of language is a good one to show how relative position makes things so much more difficult (although it gives you more options) to learn/use. And I think empirical evidence lends credibility to the article - everyone gushes how easy the iphone is to use compared to all the other phones out there. One of the biggest reasons would appear to be the 'fixed' layout.
- tjmaxal 17y agoCan you give an example of relative meaning? I get that language is contextual based on relationship, not position. In other words, the connection between symbol and meaning is fixed in relation to other symbols but the descriptions change based on the perspective of the speaker. Think of it like a family tree. Position is fixed from birth and meaning is derived from position. the only thing that is relative is description. I guess you could be talking about semantics, or the use of a small number of sounds to produce an infinite number of meanings, but that seems like a discussion of speech or typography.