5 ms·
This Is Your Company on Blockchain
- FlailFast 10y agoAs someone who works at a Bitcoin/Ethereum company, and has passionately followed Bitcoin since 2011, every time I hear "blockchain" as a proper noun a piece of me dies inside. It's like saying "This Is Your Company on Website."
- mercer 10y agoI dunno. To someone like me who is all up into Bitcoin but not too serious about it, it sounds okay. Faddish, but okay. I think the crucial distinction is whether you're pointing at an approach versus some specific implementation. 'Blockchain', as I understand it, is a particular approach that isn't linked to some particular instance. "Your company on website" doesn't work because there's really only one 'web'. "Your company on Facebook" does work, as does "Your company on SCRUM/NoSQL/AOL/Mobile/etc." I'd prefer "on a blockchain", personally, but "on blockchain" doesn't strike me as too egregious.
- bergie 10y agoMaybe you could say "This Is Your Company on Web", which could imply plenty of things made possible by web technologies, like remote, distributed teams and cheap cloud infrastructure.
- jackweirdy 10y agoBlockchain, on the cloud. Synergised and vertically integrated for streamlined UX.
- briansteffens 10y agoWelcome aboard!
- koolba 10y ago> Blockchain, on the cloud. Synergised and vertically integrated for streamlined UX. Shit! Where's my checkbook?! I have to cut these guys a seed round before they try to actually build anything. Otherwise it'll become apparent that this series of words have nothing to do with each other!
- ChemicalWarfare 10y ago[un]fortunately this is no longer the case in the blockchain/vc world, which is the main reason you don't really hear much about new blockchain/bitcoin (or some other crypto) companies popping up and getting funded. These days the blockchain world revolves around large companies(or groups of companies) setting things up for internal consumption and consulting companies trying to get in on the action to help those large companies with the setup.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoJust because it doesn't have "the" doesn't mean it's a proper noun. In this case I think it's being used as an abstract noun.
- mercer 10y agoThat's what I was trying to say in another comment, but I don't grammar very well :-/.
- infodroid 10y ago"This is your company on Agile" or "This is your company on Slack" doesn't sound too bad. So why not "blockchain"?
- sethhochberg 10y agoAgile and Slack are proper nouns; names people use to refer to things. "Bitcoin" isn't "blockchain", "Bitcoin" is "a blockchain".
- infodroid 10y agoWould it be better in the plural, as in: "This is your company on Blockchains"? Why is this any different from "This is your brain on drugs"? And what about making it more specific, as in: "This is your company on blockchain technology"?
- mccoyspace 10y agoGood to see there is still room for the high-concept blockchain puff piece article.
- wpietri 10y agoDumb question time: Aren't 95% of these use cases more easily implemented with a single central source of truth, possibly with distributed read-only replicas? I think the blockchain innovation is amazing in the context where you have no trusted party. Bitcoin, for example. But almost all the other blockchain uses I see discussed have obvious central parties that people trust. E.g., Nasdaq already knows exactly how to run a very reliable registry at low computational cost and very low latency. [1] So what cases actually benefit, and which ones are more (mis)applying the latest fashion? [1] As an example, look at the LMAX architecture, which is orders of magnitude faster and cheaper to run than a distributed blockchain: http://martinfowler.com/articles/lmax.html http://martinfowler.com/articles/lmax.html
- mercer 10y agoIt's probably fashion much of the time. Two friends of mine who work for big conslutancies already asked me what this 'blockchain' thing is because they heard some internal system is going to be using it. I both cases I couldn't really figure out why they'd not do as you suggest.
- seagreen 10y agoDumb question time: Aren't 95% of these use cases more easily implemented with a single central source of truth, possibly with distributed read-only replicas? Absolutely. The tech press loves its fancy new craziness. Good engineering should be exciting enough (if they want to write about something cool they could write about immutable databases like Datomic), but no . . . _blockchain_!
- infinite8s 10y agoThat's the only place where blockchains are genuinely useful - when there isn't a single trusted party to maintain a ledger. In this case everybody participating in transactions (which don't have to be monetary in nature) can be sure that their transaction is both unrevocable and untamperable.
- ilostmykeys 10y agothat is just the story. In reality powerful actors can tip the balancein their favor and even revoke and tamper with old transactions
- greggman 10y agoCan someone explain how blockchains work outside of Bitcoin? My poor understanding is Bitcoin only works because you get paid to mine (compute the chain). Since so many people want money there's enough people computing the chain to check for consensus How will there be any incentives to mine in non financial chains?
- wmf 10y agoThese blockchains shouldn't use mining at all; they should use algorithms like PBFT or SCP. Such algorithms require out-of-band agreement on who is and isn't running a node, but once that has been set up they are similarly secure as POW.
- dTal 10y agoIt's a great point that often gets lost in the blockchain hype. Basically, the "coins" have to have some value, which comes from the intrinsic value that the blockchain in question provides - which may not be financial as such, though of course money is generally fungible with value. Namecoin is an example of an appropriate non-Bitcoin, non-"financial" use of a blockchain; the "coins" allow you to "purchase" space on a global namespace, which becomes more valuable as the namespace grows in popularity. [edit: having read wmf's sibling comment, I was not aware that blockchains could be separated from mining. So take all of the above with a grain of salt.]
- zardo 10y ago>How will there be any incentives to mine in non financial chains? You could could pay miners with some other blockchain's assets. Say zoos trading animal tokens (because they don't believe in buying and selling animals) with a small Bitcoin transaction processing fee to pay the miners.
- Unbeliever69 10y ago"Gobs of accountants, bankers, lawyers, and company bureaucrats would vanish." Oh what a world this would become! What other "necessary evil" could we add to this list?