4 ms·
Always used to see a guy cycling on my commute home. He'd roll through every stop sign and most traffic signals. (He explained one day that it "saved energy" fo
by gamblor956 10y ago
Always used to see a guy cycling on my commute home. He'd roll through every stop sign and most traffic signals. (He explained one day that it "saved energy" for him to keep going...even though he cycled as "exercise...")
I don't see him anymore. One day last year, he rolled through a red light in Koreatown, right into a truck which had the right of way. He was thrown from his bike about 20 feet and died from blunt force trauma and/or internal bleeding by the time paramedics arrived.
- ddlatham 10y agoThat's a sad anecdote. It doesn't seem to address the argument or actual safety data presented in the article.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoActually it does. If there is a 1% chance of a cyclists fatality for a certain illegal behavior, you might be that 1%. You will be 100% dead.
- kordless 10y agoIt's a data point and was used as such. The effects of breaking moving vehicle laws can be rationalized away when the mass of the vehicle moving is low. That doesn't preclude other incidences, such as this one, where someone who's job it is to drive a truck has to wrangle with the fact they killed someone. They guy who died could give two shits about the situation. I saw a cyclist roll through a pedestrian crossing with people in it on his side of the road at the intersection at the end of my street. I rolled up to him in my car at the next light and told him he was breaking the law. He asked "but is it safe?". The implication is, with this leading question, is that he thought it was safe to do. What he didn't observe was the car behind him not slowing down for the pedestrians because they were watching him. Stopping at a crosswalk, or yielding right of way, is an important rule because it gives VISUAL indicators to other drivers of nearby vehicles. It's a backup mechanism for safety at times. Rationalizing laws don't apply to oneself because they cause delay do not include the fact it the action may also be the difference between life and death - for someone else. Are we really going to rationalize away the fact driver may float lights more if they see bikes doing it as well? The way Davis, CA handles this is to install special lights for bikes. I would assume they thought through it and decided floating lights is bad. For the last 4 years, up until a few months ago, I had been riding at least 5-6 hours a day on fairly busy roads. I've seen a lot of shit that people do as a result of other's actions, including bikes, and I do NOT think bikes should be precluded from obeying traffic laws, especially when the only point to it might be to speed up a bike commute or "save energy". Whatever that means.
- cmyr 10y agoHere's an explanation from a physics professor (cited in the original article) that might help explain what "save energy" means. http://nacto.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/Fajans-J.-and-M.-Curry.-2001..pdf http://nacto.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/Fajans-J.-and-M.... In case you can't be bothered to read this either: > He also calculated that a cyclist who rolls through a stop at five miles per hour instead of stopping fully needs to use 25 percent less energy to get back to full speed.
- kordless 10y ago> In case you can't be bothered to read this either: My entire comment was based on someone else's comment in these threads, not the article. And, not that I give a shit what you think, I actually did read the article and don't have to agree with it regardless of whether I "bothered" or not.
- TheLarch 10y agoIt is dangerous. However, when you consider the economic, environmental, and health advantages it looks better. See http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/06/13/bicycling-the-safest-form-of-transportation/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2013/06/13/bicycling-the-safe.... I feel notably worse inside a week when I stop cycling. You know what the worst part of cycling is? The endless noise and pollution from cars. Cars are a scourge. It is no wonder why drivers are so angry all the time. Who in their right mind wants to spend their time utterly immobilized, doing nothing but trying to avoid hitting other cars? Cycling is always a bit of an adventure, always exhilarating.
- Idontagree 10y agoI'm all for acceptable public transportation to be the norm, but until then cars work fine. Roads also weren't originally built for bikes. I actually don't know how many of the bigger cities look now, and I imagine most of them have bike lanes, but places like where I live have bikers just taking the right lane because there's no extra space. There also isn't enough space to expand the road to make room for both of us. Ultimately they're a huge hazard because they're difficult to see and hear. I really don't think they should ever mix cars and bikes. Or at least not in high capacity areas. Also you're desire to exercise is completely your own, I'm glad you enjoy it, but it's a personal choice.
- TheLarch 10y ago"cars work fine" Global warming, congestion, obesity epidemic, and arguably peak oil. Also: http://www.roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/ http://www.roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/ I agree that many downtowns such as those of Las Vegas, Houston, and Atlanta simply are not bikable.
- rhinoceraptor 10y ago> cars work fine Except for the brake dust, noise pollution, CO2 emissions, and the tens of thousands of people who die in crashes every year.
- bobowzki 10y agoWhy do you say "exercise" with quotation?
- Idontagree 10y agoBecause he's making a joke about the cycler exercising and trying to save energy...
- cmyr 10y agoFrom the article: >If a cyclist approaches a red light, meanwhile, he or she needs to stop fully. Again, if there's any oncoming traffic or a pedestrian, it has the right of way. If there's not, the cyclist can proceed cautiously through the intersection. Put simply, red light is a stop sign. >This doesn't mean that a cyclist is allowed to blast through an intersection at full speed — which is dangerous for pedestrians, the cyclist, and pretty much everyone involved. This isn't allowed in Idaho, and it's a terrible idea everywhere. Nobody is suggesting that cyclists should just ignore right of way.