3 ms·
Right, but isn't it about coping with that response, not eliminating it? That was the impression I had of what it is. The goal isn't to eliminate sadness or an
by empath75 10y ago
Right, but isn't it about coping with that response, not eliminating it? That was the impression I had of what it is. The goal isn't to eliminate sadness or anxiety, but to limit the negative impact it has on your life. So you don't get into these cycles were depression prevents you from moving forward, which makes you more depressed and so on. That's why it supposedly works so well with people with bpd, right? Because bpd is all about fear of people leaving you, while you behave in ways that absolutely ensure that people will.
- morbidhawk 10y agoMy wife has BPD. CBT never worked for her (and it never worked for me either), her therapist switched from CBT to DBT & EMDR instead and it has better results. The problem with CBT is that it tries re-frame situations using a logical explanation to people who don't know how to talk in logical terms to see things from a different perspective. The problem is that people with BPD don't express things in logical terms, so it is easy to mis-diagnose or misrepresent and cause an invalidating statement. Borderlines are great at reading between the lines and trying to understand things in an emotional way. They can easily misinterpret your re-framing to be invalidation. So instead, DBT and a question-based approach that helps them to think through the problem themselves is so much better. My CBT therapist told me to tell my wife "that being out of town for her birthday wasn't abandonment", yeah right that'd go over like hell. BPD requires deeper introspection and CBT therapy will usually cause the client to feel invalidated
- thrwy1287 10y ago>> "The problem with CBT is that it tries re-frame situations using a logical explanation to people who don't know how to talk in logical terms to see things from a different perspective." Not BPD but my experience with CBT and anxiety was that I could see my response was illogical but I didn't believe myself it at the same time. So when the therapist asked about this assumption I had that influenced my thinking he was able to show me it was illogical, I was able to say 'I know in my head', but at the same time - I don't believe you in my gut. His solution to this was exposure. If you are put in the situation and you personal assumption is proven to be untrue or it's is sufficiently challenged enough times then you can start to believe it's illogical.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]