4 ms·
> what happens to an industry when it's made redundant by technology We have over 200 years experience of countless industries being made redundant by technolo
by BurningFrog 10y ago
> what happens to an industry when it's made redundant by technology
We have over 200 years experience of countless industries being made redundant by technology. It's not a new scary thing that has never happened before.
- onion2k 10y agoWe also have 200 years of people in the redundant industries complaining about it, and 200 years of government regulating to make the transition less painful. Why should we stop that with taxis?
- chii 10y ago> 200 years of government regulating to make the transition less painful. i find that hard to believe - what was done in the last 200 years to lessen the pain of any transition?
- allendoerfer 10y agoPensions, accident insurance, and medical care. Not 200 years, but 150-175 years [0]. Universal unemployment insurance came only in 1927. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_state#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Welfare_state#Germany
- onion2k 10y agoHere in the UK there were a number of Factory Acts passed between 1802 and 1961 that were designed to limit the impact of the industrial revolution on workers, lessening the pain of transition from agriculture and cottage industry to the modern mechanised factories. The one closest to 200 years ago did such progressive things as limiting the working hours a 9 year old child could do to 12 hours a day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factory_Acts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factory_Acts
- ambicapter 10y agoHow is that easing the transition? Sounds more like making sure the current working environment doesn't suck, and that the benefits of technology are actually passed on to those who are using it.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAnd it bears reminding that some of this 200 years of history was pretty bloody precisely because people were fed up of being told to "suck it up" and do what the entrepreneurs say them to to survive. The mostly sane working conditions we enjoy today - like somewhat reasonable working hours, like leaves and insurances - things a lot of people in my generation work to destory, for some reason -- all those things were paid for in blood by our great-grandfathers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- xg15 10y agoSo how would you solve the problem based on that experience?
- BigJono 10y agoA good welfare system pretty much solves it. I'm not sure why America is struggling to create one. Here in Australia the government will happily pay you $300 a week until you can find a job. It costs us something like $9.5B per year, which is pretty much nothing. Our government doesn't have to disincentivise innovation to help people adjust. Sure, some people are going to find it hard to live on that amount, but they won't go hungry or homeless. I think it's well within the realms of "suck it up".
- allendoerfer 10y ago> A good welfare system pretty much solves it. I'm not sure why America is struggling to create one. America is still divided even on the question whether healthcare should be universal, which other states introduced ~50 years before unemployment benefits were invented, so I think this will still take a while.
- erklik 10y agoSome sort of basic income or a welfare scheme. As someone else mentioned, Australian's out of job get paid $300 or $400 depending on how many kids you have etc and how much savings. This allows the government to make sure that everyone out of a job doesn't go homeless but its not enough to be comfortable so people don't become dependent on it. ( Some people do become dependent on it, its not a 100% unfortunately )