14 ms·
'Flash Boys' IEX stock exchange opens for business
- tdaltonc 10y agoI wish them the best of luck. It's easy to become resigned to finance being an insiders game. But the efficient allocation of capital is to important to leave to "the professionals."
- murbard2 10y agoMarkets do not allocate capital, they provide liquidity for investors making them more likely to invest during stock offerings in the first place.
- eru 10y agoThose are just different faces of the same coin.
- murbard2 10y agoNo, well functioning exchanges affect the amount of capital that gets invested in ventures not how well it is allocated.
- eru 10y agoPeople are looking forward. How much money individual startups can raise (or established companies when increasing capital) depends on their expectations of future prices on the exchanges.
- qaq 10y agoAn infinitely more interesting question is who owns Capital Group Companies
- chollida1 10y agoIf you're wondering what IEX becoming a full blown exchange means to you, well it probably doesn't matter at all. They have been operating for some time already as an ATS, today they are now part of the RegNMS protected quote, meaning that up until today, brokers did not have to route orders to them. it also allows them to have companies "list" on their exchange, though I don't know of any companies that are planning on listing with IEX currently. They bring 4 unique things to the market - their built in delay of 350 micro seconds on each incoming and out going message, ie they delay order's coming in and they delay fill notifications going out. - they have a patented dynamic peg algo that will allow a user to place an order that the exchange will dynamically price. This order type was a bit contentious as the exchange doesn't delay quote changes when updating these orders, ie these orders are blessed in the sense that they don't obey the 350 microsecond delay. https://www.iextrading.com/trading/dpeg/ https://www.iextrading.com/trading/dpeg/ - they aren't currently allowing co-location - they don't participate in the maker taker model. They charge, I think, 9 cents on dark orders and nothing for lit orders. Maybe the most interesting thing that IEX has brought to the US market is that the NYSE is now filing to add their own discretionary PEG order. https://www.nyse.com/network/article/nyse-order-types https://www.nyse.com/network/article/nyse-order-types
- btown 10y agoFor more on the dynamic peg controversy, this article lays it out in detail: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-12-22/the-flash-boys-exchange-is-still-controversial https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2015-12-22/the-flash... TL;DR: > In other words, the objection goes, IEX uses the magic shoebox (and its router's ability to skip the shoebox) to do "latency arbitrage" and trade with stale quotes on other exchanges before traders on those exchanges can update their quotes, just like it accuses high-frequency traders of doing to its own investors. And, the objection goes, if it's unfair for high-frequency traders to do this to IEX's customers, then it's just as unfair for IEX's customers to do it to high-frequency traders. [but maybe this is just leveling the playing field...]
- waterside81 10y agoIf I ever chose to invest with K2, it would be entirely because of our contribution to HN. You always make great posts about financial news.
- opaque 10y agoFun trivia from Flash Boys they originally were going to use the full name Investor's Exchange, but the url was unfortunate: www.investorsexchange.com Hence they use the short form IEX.
- _asummers 10y agoAh yes bringing back memories of expertsexchange.com I'm so happy Stack Overflow won that battle.
- ddinh 10y agoIn terms of reducing the ability of speedy traders to gain an advantage in a continuous time market, how does IEX's fixed time delay compare to discretizing the timesteps, so all the trades within some finite interval [t, t+e] are treated as if they came at the same time? This talk presents compares discretization to standard continuous-time bidding, but doesn't go into a lot of detail about how it compares to IEX-style delays: https://simons.berkeley.edu/talks/eric-budish-2015-11-19 https://simons.berkeley.edu/talks/eric-budish-2015-11-19
- chollida1 10y agoThe IEX delay and batch auctions are really two completely different things. IEX delays almost all messages in and out by a small amount. They don't delay messages for orders that their own router modifies, their discretionary peg order. This lets their peg orders update before any one, ie HFTs, can update their own resting orders on IEX or at other exchanges in the case of a fill at IEX. It's important to note that even with the IEX design, speed is still very important as its still a price time priority queue for order placement and cancelling. An analogy would be if all 100 meter sprinters reaction times were delayed by 1 second from hearing the starters pistol. The fastest runner still wins, its just that all reactions times are delayed evenly. Batch auctions are a whole different animal, and to be honest, one I'm not very familiar with. Their greatest weakness is that they don't operate in a stand alone environment, ie the rest of the world continues to trade around them which eliminates most of their advantage.
- sjbase 10y agoDo you mind expanding on that last point? I'm interested in your take on how/why a batch auction's advantage is eliminated by the rest of the world trading around them.
- kasey_junk 10y agoLargely because the entirety of latency arb has to do with taking advantage of price differences between exchanges. How those differences are created is largely immaterial. As long as you have multiple exchanges that are not perfectly syncd (a distributed systems problem!) There will be time based arbitrage opportunities.
- esaym 10y agoOn the same topic, I've actually set aside a down payment for a house, but I probably won't be buying for another year or so. I'm wondering what is a good way to invest this money since leaving it in the bank at less than 1% interest really isn't doing much.
- lbotos 10y agoI feel like some sort of CD or Ladder CD is your best bet, you don't really wanna risk those funds.
- jessedhillon 10y agoIf that's close to 100% of your worth, I'd guess you want to put it somewhere conservative.
- davidw 10y agoHow comfortable are you seeing the value of your investment decline? Edit: WTF, downvoter: that's entirely what his question comes down to. If he's cool with it, then maybe something riskier might be warranted. If not, then 'sitting in the bank' might be ok.
- nekopa 10y agoI didn't down vote you, but your original comment didn't add much to the discussion, and could be viewed as snark. If your edit, minus the wtf, had been in the original comment, then probably no one would have downvoted.
- davidw 10y agoIt wasn't intended to be snarky, but brief. If you can't afford to lose money on an investment, seek out something stabler.
- harryh 10y agoIf this is money that you don't want to risk at all (because if you lose some you won't be able to buy the house you want) it's gonna be tough to earn all that much interest in just a year. As lbotos says, you might do a bit better with a CD than your bank account but not by all that much. If you can stomach a bit of risk you might consider buying something like Vanguard's Total Bond Market ETF. https://www.google.com/finance?q=BND https://www.google.com/finance?q=BND
- overcast 10y agoHow appropriate, the Flash Boys book just showed up from Amazon this morning.
- cmiller1 10y agoI wonder if they're using some kind of EDFA or other amplifier for that delay spool. For 350µsec we're talking at least 14.3dB of loss going through that thing, in other words, only 3.7% of the signal is coming out the end in the best case scenario.
- wehadfun 10y agoWas the 30 mile cable necessary to create a speed bump. Seems to me a few lines of code would have worked.
- ocschwar 10y ago30 miles of cable gives your customers proof the speed bump will not go away with a software change.
- fleitz 10y agoAs long as they don't install a second shorter cable, and have the software route to the second cable. The entire thing is a dog and pony show for retail investors who are even bigger suckers than the idiots running IEX. If the speed bump is for everyone and can't be removed then how do PEG orders bypass it? Are PEG orders some kind of magic that travels faster than light? Pro Tip: If a large financial institution tells you they are protecting you, they are bald faced lying to you and you are about to get a serious lesson in business. The same idiots who tell you that IEX is a good thing will also sell you actively managed mutual funds that A) under perform vanguard and B) seriously under perform once you subtract fees.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wocram 10y agoSure it would work, but with substantially more variance than a cable.
- r00fus 10y agoAnd there's a firm guarantee that you can't cheat unless you beat the physics of light propagation... Or find a way to route around the 30m cable...
- jandrese 10y agoThe point is that everybody cheats so the cable was proof that they couldn't cheat. You can't cheat the speed of light.
- eggy 10y agoI've read both sides of the argument about the IEX delay, and my common sense tells me you cannot try and put the genie back in the bottle. If technology exists, has been discovered, you cannot thwart it by trying to mask it by retarding it. It think it is ironic that an exchange, IEX, founded with one of its aims being to level the playing field by calling out HFT as 'wrong' or 'unfair', and yet allow for their dynamic trades to bypass their 350 us delay is an example of we don't need it/we do need it. People cry out about HFT being a game for the super players only, but out of it comes innovation - faster switches, well-honed programming tricks, hardware and software that eventually make their way to other uses. Sort of how the military and porn industry pushed a lot of tech we take for granted today.
- tbihl 10y agoIn what way could this comment possibly be worthy of a down vote? It's complete and thought-provoking.
- tedunangst 10y agoCalled HFT innovative. Can't say that here.
- rrrrsss99 10y agoI think it's inaccurate to put hft in the future tech division with darpa or porn. Maybe it will lead to fpga's/c++/microwaves being widely used for ML, but it seems unlikely that the low latency and minimal cross country transmission has has much value. If you're building a system to process lots of data quickly transmitting a few bytes between the UK and Belgium slightly faster than a wire won't be a constraint. Maybe it will lead to real time instance based learning, but I'm not aware of anyone going in that direction
- eggy 10y agoAlgorithms are also worked on, not just transmission or switching. And speed is always needed by some field or another, so I would argue it has its fruits beyond what you may have posited.
- remarkEon 10y ago-> Lewis declined an interview request because he is on deadline for another book project. For those interested it looks like his next book will be about Behavioral Economics. http://nymag.com/scienceofus/2016/06/michael-lewiss-next-book-will-be-about-the-godfathers-of-behavioral-economics.html http://nymag.com/scienceofus/2016/06/michael-lewiss-next-boo...
- rrrrsss99 10y agoAn interesting data point in the hft rigged market debate I never see is, what do the insiders do with their money? I work at an electronic market maker that trades on colocated servers with fpgas and rents bandwidth on microwaves, so we without a doubt fall under the hft umbrella. My 401k is 100% invested in index funds and my personal brokerage account is split between 80% vanguard index etfs and a few stocks (that I probably shouldn't have invested in, but I didn't know what I was doing when I got started). This is similar to my coworkers and people I know at other firms. Why would we do this if we were knowingly rigging the market against retail investors? To answer my own question, if you're an investor, the microstructure of the exchanges is irrelevant. When I put in an order to by 100 shares of VTI, I'll put in a limit order after the close a half percent above the closing price knowing that it will be sold to citadel or another internalizer who will fill the order at a good price (nbbo, debatable since they're being investigated currently) and take the penny or two spread. I could put in a limit for the close, but either I wouldn't get filled or if I did, it would only be due to the market moving against me and honestly the difference doesn't matter. I have no intent to sell at a particular profit point or watch a screen all day to find some imagined perfect entry point which I wouldn't even know if I saw it. I'm interested to hear if opponents of hft have considered this or think insiders are behaving differently. I won't make the argument that we're looking out for the little guy or we have some mission to benefit society through price discovery. We basically print money when the market goes down, but we're so far removed from the average person that I can only assume that the hatred is based on marketing and false perception.
- chrisbennet 10y agoFor those who haven't read "Flash Boys", this a synopsis of the book: Canadian banker Brad Katsuyama notices prices for stocks he is buying change price almost the instant he places his order to purchase them. Turns out that this happens when he places a larger order than can be filled at a single exchange. After some investigation he determines that HFT traders "see" his trade on the local NJ exchange and buy up stock at other (further away) exchanges before said banker can fill his order at the original (lower) price. His solution: Send orders to multiple exchanges but delay the orders to the closest ones so orders arrive at exchanges more or less simultaneously thus defeating that particular HFT strategy. The coil of fiber is the method used to achieve that delay.
- davidgrenier 10y agoMy understanding was that they had a software called Thor to generate the artificial delay in sending their trades to the different exchanges. This new exchange uses the long coil of fiber to enable all traders from around the world to benefit from that protection. I'm wondering if they really had to go to that extent to get the speed bump. But hey since shame has yet to force formally verified software on anyone's radar, the long coil will certainly do.
- clarkmoody 10y agoThe long coil is a hardware solution that keeps everyone honest. I have a suspicion that the financial incentives offered to the exchange to bypass a software delay would be too great to turn down -- especially years from now if the original players are gone. Edit: Oops. Maybe they can bypass the coil for certain orders. Well that doesn't make sense...
- mmodahl 10y agoThe book picks up in the middle of the story after the first step in electronic trading has started, but before all participants are on a level playing field. Human market makers at those exchanges are entering their quotes(by hand even). And Brad Katsuyama uses new electronic technology to crush them. Taking their entire inventories and moving the markets against them. The human market makers fight back and make their computers do the market making for them and Brad is hurt because his technology is no longer the best way to trade.