13 ms·
How Trolls Are Ruining the Internet
- Aelinsaar 10y ago...Or how people learned to ignore online, what they long have been forced to ignore offline.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tdb7893 10y agoI don't think that trolls are something that comes up often in real life. I can't imagine people acting like that in person unless they were middle schoolers. For example when I played soccer with people in real life I never had people tell me that I suck and to kill myself but people do it all the time in some video games.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoI would argue that the 2016 race has been characterized primarily, by trolling.
- alayne 10y agoThe barrier to entry for online harassment is so much lower that I don't consider them comparable.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoBy the same token, the ability to silence it is far greater. When someone is ranting about the world ending outside of your business, you might have to call the cops. Online, you just hit "ignore".
- DanBC 10y ago> Online, you just hit "ignore". You've clearly never been the target of even a minor troll campaign. Hundreds of accounts each send hundreds of messages an hour across a wide range of social media and email accounts. If they can get your real world details they'll use those too. If they get your workplace details they'll use that to harass your employer.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoPeople have tried, but I've always been "paranoid" about keeping my online and offline social lives separated; it was clear a long time ago that "living open" was absolutely insane.
- LukeB_UK 10y agoWhen was the last time you had a load of people tell you to kill yourself in person?
- mdpopescu 10y agoWhen was the last time someone stole your lunch money and pushed you in a locker online?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tpeo 10y agoI'd say it's very improbable to starve trolls by not giving them attention. So long as the community is receiving new members and the new members aren't acquainted with it all works, there will always be someone there to feed the troll. Think of it as a corollary to the Eternal September. That being said, I think there are people post garbage regardless whether they're given attention or not. Kinda like the people who carve dicks and swastikas at bathroom stalls.
- overcast 10y agoI posted this in a previous discussion about NPR getting rid of their comments. http://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2016/08/17/489516952/npr-website-to-get-rid-of-comments http://www.npr.org/sections/ombudsman/2016/08/17/489516952/n... This is an interesting move, and a topic I've been discussing with friends. I've stopped using sites like Reddit, because the comment sections are just toxic. I've gone as far as installing Chrome extensions that make comment sections disappear from popular sites like YouTube. It's too easy to get drawn into the negativity, and I'm completely over it. "Social Networking" has reached it's low point as far as I'm concerned. Hacker News is about the only civil place I'm capable of contributing to a discussion to at this point.
- autotune 10y agoThe whole appeal about reddit is it's not just one "community," it's multiple subreddits with different rules and different types of comments. If a subreddit becomes too negative, just hit the unsubscribe button and find a better one.
- overcast 10y agoI understand what Reddit is about. Here was my response to someone making a similar comment in the previous thread. You know, I get this response every time I talk about this topic. I really dislike the "well no one is making you use / buy / watch / listen" to something. People can be critical of something they want to succeed. It happens a lot in certain game communities. What if I WANT to talk about politics, in a civil manner? Any sufficiently popular subreddit, just devolves into complete trash.
- 1_2__3 10y ago...So why not hang out in /r/politicaldiscussion, a subreddit created for exactly what you're asking for and that is heavily moderated to keep it on-topic? I definitely agree that many subs - and particularly front page ones - can be a cesspool, although amusingly they don't quite get as bad as just about every news and newspaper site I've seen. But really, /r/upliftingnews is just too toxic for you? /r/changemyview is too negative? There's lots of great, very low-toxicity subs on Reddit. Abandoning the site because you're trying to discuss political issues - touchy in any arena, online or in person - seems a bit like throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- Fifer82 10y agoI don't mind trolls. There is a difference between a troll, a bully, a wanker and a psycho.
- bogomipz 10y agoThat sounds like the opening to a funny joke.
- tdkl 10y ago> Trolling is, overtly, a political fight. Liberals do indeed troll–sex-advice columnist Dan Savage used his followers to make Googling former Pennsylvania Senator Rick Santorum’s last name a blunt lesson in the hygienic challenges of anal sex; the hunter who killed Cecil the lion got it really bad. > The alt-right’s favorite insult is to call men who don’t hate feminism “cucks,” as in “cuckold.” <snip> Trolling is the alt-right’s version of political activism, and its ranks view any attempt to take it away as a denial of democracy. I honestly don't like this burden of trolling to be placed on the right, because both sides consist of people with emotional issues and incapability to handle them. And to be honest, such people don't deserve online access. The 90's and early 2000's were refreshing where you had to be a certain geek to get to the web, which was a filter enough. [edit] To clarify, my impression of the article is that it's not balanced between both sides. Might have something to do that "troll" doesn't necessarily mean the same, as user Fifer82 suggested in his comment "I don't mind trolls. There is a difference between a troll, a bully, a wanker and a psycho"[1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12321968 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12321968
- oolongCat 10y agoHonestly, if you really think "trolls" are ruining the internet, you have no idea what the internet is capable of, about the amazing things it brings us and about the communities that are built around the internet that has adopted to these trolls. Yes trolls make things harder, but they are not able to "ruin" the internet. Garbage journalism on the other-hand might actually have the power to do it. Just like anything in life when it comes to the internet I think you have to use it for sometime before you can somewhat manage to spot whats right and wrong on the internet. The author also mentions something about how the internet is eager to help with technical details and is bad for medical advice? Seriously? I mean, I once saw someone advice a guy to place his router higher than his computer, so that gravity will make the internet faster :) and I have seen complete strangers on places like reddit come together to help people who were having trouble with something, genuinely helping and making a better change in people's lives. The damn internet doesn't care about trolls or there's no ruining these trolls can do to the internet. People are always going to be people, you are going to have to use some common sense when you are living your normal life and when you are on the Internet.
- bradfa 10y agoIt's unfortunate that the word "troll" is starting to define someone who bullies, threatens, and harasses people. There's plenty of ways to goad a reaction out of someone without being an asshole or threatening their safety.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoIf you want to see a site that starts off with noble ambitions but descends into a swamp of thinly-veiled trolling masked in good intentions...I present Nextdoor.com. Brigading, a tactic employed to great effect on Twitter, is just as present in these so-called community discussions. Righteous, uptight, indignant, spiteful, entitled...I never knew how much I despised my neighbors until I joined my local Nextdoor.
- cortesoft 10y agoI am pretty neighbors have always been like that, with gossip and shit talking. It just was never in a place where you could see it all at once, and where as before people would only say those things to people in their confidence, now they can say it to everyone anonymously on a forum.
- organsnyder 10y agoThat probably depends on your neighbors (in particular, the ones that are active on Nextdoor). My neighborhood's space is fairly pleasant. While there are occasional busybodies ("I just noticed some kids walking down the street—should I call the police?"), everyone is respectful and cordial.
- beat 10y agoIt sucks to find out too much about people sometimes. I got friended on FB by a guy I did some volunteering with this summer (and will do so again next summer). Turns out he's a racist, transphobic bigot. So my question is, do I just start laying into him until he learns something (and damage relationship with someone I have to work with), or do I just unfollow and hold my nose later on?
- Cuuugi 10y agoI think it's hard to say that Trolls are ruining the internet. They have been a part of the internet since the first BBS. Sensitivity to them is what's causing this current push back (and emboldening them). I'm not defending them as some of them go way out of line, but I feel like language policing is a large step in the wrong direction.
- orcdork 10y agoYes, obviously it's everyone else that's at fault, not the vocal toxic minority.
- Cuuugi 10y agoI'm not really blaming anyone (or intending to). All i am saying is that there should be a logical disconnect between someone calling someone an asshole on a forum, and someone Doxxing a 14 year old girl because she made the mistake of showing her boobs on the internet. "Trolling" means different things to different people(just as what people find offensive), and legislating that is dangerous IMO.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't respond with deliberately uncharitable interpretations. It's not plausible that Cuuugi meant it that way.
- beat 10y agoI think it's gotten worse. It's one thing for some dude to argue anonymously. It's another thing to make credible death threats and such. My daughter wrote a paper about Gamergate and the crap around that, and she was afraid to publish it widely for fear of retaliation. A bandmate wrote a fantastic song about trolls hating on women in gaming, and we only play it live because she's afraid of what will happen if we release a recording. It's scary. Women are justifiably afraid of what will happen to them if they publicly criticize the trolls.
- Cuuugi 10y ago>I think it's gotten worse. I do somewhat agree, but i feel like that's more a statement about mental patients with a modem than the average level of toxicity. Gamergate is a topic i want to avoid, because it could go on for days, but i will say this. Only a woman could publish a piece of shit game, and get so much great press "seemingly" by sleeping with a bunch of gaming journalists. Only a Man would get so butthurt and release details of the former. Can't we agree that they are both shitty people?
- 1281083181 10y agoAnother word that had an intelligent meaning and now just means "bad behavior or something ...". Unfortunately pg was one of the first who started this when throwing the t-word at arc critics. Really sad.
- woah 10y agoThis is a great article in a lot of ways, but tells lies by omission about Andrew Aurenheimer (who is, by the way, a neo-nazi asshole). > He served just over a year in prison for identity fraud and conspiracy. This refers to his sentence for revealing AT&T's ridiculously lax security practices to a journalist. This sentence was overturned. Using this as some sort of anecdote to illustrate weev's untrustworthiness without mentioning what it was for, or that it was overturned is the epitome of lazy and dishonest reporting.
- kelvin0 10y agoI finally understand what the IoT is! :)
- JoelBennett 10y agoI'm really curious - I've heard no one mention the concept of "hell-banning". Basically, instead of outright banning destructive users, you make all of their content only visible to themselves. It reminds me of the phrase "in space, no one can hear you scream". Eventually, after a while they stop posting. If they don't notice this for a while, they waste efforts posting content that no one will ever see. It's a bit like an automatic cold shoulder from the community.
- forgottenpass 10y agoTime, as a print magazine assumes it role to pontificate on the lower class of publishing medium. In it's knowed position of media, they point out surface level and uncontroversial annoyances. Trolls are easy to spot, but it's a distraction from what Time isn't going after: the under-informed and sensationalized media assaulting the public non-stop from every direction. Time, as a print magazine, doesn't dare acknowledge this fact. They're in the same exact business as tabloids, just at different rungs on the respectability ladder. So they're both going to go after the trolls. The fact Milo works for Breitbart only gets a parenthetical mention. They don't stop to question the quality of Breitbart's content, just play a bit of guilt by association towards it's board. Of course it only gives more power to Weev and Milo's actions. But Time needs the trolls to be powerful, because if they weren't Time couldn't teach you to hate them.
- reader5000 10y agoI guess we have what, 10 years until they carve a "trolling" or "hate speech" exception out of the first amendment? Such already exists everywhere else except for U.S. It's interesting. It used to be that the average American's 5-6 hours of daily media consumption was produced entirely by what 4-5 corporations? Thats literally ~400 million people's media coming from maybe a couple thousand people. How is that good? If "trolling" [which I think is really just a code word for "exposure to interpretations of reality with which I disagree"] is the price of more diverse, more informative media, then so what?
- Vraxx 10y agoWe obviously need some sort of line drawn. Expressing your view should definitely be okay, whether others agree with it or not. Mass harassment is entirely different. It's like how speech isn't protected when you're ordering somebody to kill someone, it's fundamentally different.
- Sideloader 10y agoShhh...don't make the people think about, like, complicated stuff or accept the presence of ideas or opinions they may not agree with. Because that's what is happening. A person who floats a "controversial" opinion that goes against or challenges "accepted" (i.e. imposed) orthodoxy is considered barely more acceptable than a bitter asshole with issues who threatens to rape or kill his ex-girlfriend. Simply asking how encouraging perpetual victimhood empowers women and ethnic minorities is more often than not met with incredulous outrage and accusations. There is no room for debate - one either is with them or against them. Nuance and honest debate are for privileged people dontcha know. Only POC, LGBTQ who buy into victim culture and "womyn" are allowed to express their opinions without interference. Check your privege buddy or GTFO!
- Sideloader 10y agoI know it's not a popular position to take but I still think if the worst trolls were starved of oxygen they would crawl back under their bridge and die. An ignored troll is a defeated troll. Nasty people will always exist of course online and in the material world and thankfully even the meanest, nastiest button pushing trolls very rarely act on their threats to harm or kill the people they target. A more important question is what drives so many people to attack non-white people and women online? Is it simply a reaction to a drop in status as traditionally oppressed groups assert themselves or is there more to this? We likely won't know anytime soon as the trend today is to dissect and discuss symptoms to the point of absurdity but talking about the causes or possible causes is almost taboo. E.g. Trump. Endless articles and opinion pieces bullshitting about how "evil" and "fascist" he is but serious discussions asking if, say, widespread economic disenfranchisement and the Democrats alienating the white working class in favor of identity politics has something to do with it. The culture of outrage that identity politics has morphs into treats words as the fotemost evil in our world. "OMG Drumpf SAYS he's going to build a wall and make Mexico pay for it and HE SAYS he will "ban" Muslims from entering the US!! He must be stopped!" Meanwhile Obama is deporting so many illegal immigrants he earned another nickname from it (Depoter in Chief) and firing Hellfire missiles on wedding parties and other funny acting Muslim civilians. Thousands have been killed or injured by "mistakes". But never mind about that because Trump. And don't ask if the economic lot of black people has improved during Obama's eight years in office or what he has done to stop the deaths of young black men at the hands of police. That would destroy the fantasy of America's first black president as a hip, progressive dude who really cares...and we can't have that. Back to trolls "ruining" the Internet. Instead of cutting off their oxygen (the only proven way to kill trolls) Time gives them a massive infusion of the stuff and a hysterical headline to go with it. Of course possible root causes won't be explored and government surveillance, censorship etc. of the Internet in conjunction with business interests (the MPAA and RIAA to name two very prominent ones) that sends American LEA to foreign lands to violate the liberies of people suspected of...sharing links to pirated movies/music and running a cloud storage service that may have been used to store and share the aforementioned files. It does sometimes feel like the world has gone over a cliff and the media, the establishment political parties and their wealthy owners/donors have glumped together into a mass of crazy that is stealth infecting people around the world.
- vilmosi 10y agoFinally found out what "cuck" meant.