26 ms·
Facebook is building its own Steam-style desktop gaming platform with Unity
- SadWebDeveloper 10y ago> Will require facebook login to play games Is gonna be fun to see this thing rise and fall more faster than the shit uplay is.
- na85 10y agoIf there's one thing I want, it's my wife's friends getting spammed with Facebook notifications about the fact that I got the Monster Kill achievement in Hello Kitty Island Adventure.
- mrcoleman 10y agoNow I won't have to tell my boss that I need a sick day because I was up all night playing Civ. He'll already know....
- dwaltrip 10y agoWhere is that quote? It's not in the article nor the linked announcement.
- SadWebDeveloper 10y agosorry forgot i wasn't in 4chan and made a "thought" quote like we do in /b/
- na85 10y agoHey newfriend, let me remind you of rule #1 and especially rule #2.
- anonbanker 10y agoThose "rules" came from Gaia Online, not 4chan. They didn't want anyone talking about /b/. Some anon adopted them, if mainly for Rules 34 and 35, and the fact that all /i/nvasion threads were compatible with the first two rules (all raids were credited to eBaumsWorld).
- 131hn 10y agoSeems like an electron/nwjs app, does it sounds plausible ?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jcoffland 10y agoThey will have to do something once everyone stops using them as a social network. Like when MySpace became a music site.
- duaneb 10y ago> They will have to do something once everyone stops using them as a social network. Do you really see this happening any time soon?
- ChrisClark 10y agoYears ago I used to think they would be replaced like everyone before them. But they've reached such a large mass of people, I'm not so sure anymore. It has to happen eventually, but I can't even guess when that would be anymore.
- wlesieutre 10y agoAre they going to have two separate game stores/platforms? Oculus store for VR and a separate one for everything else? On the one hand it seems redundant, on the other they can at least share a single sign on and friends list for everything they do, being Facebook and all.
- fossuser 10y agoThis seems like a smart play and necessary if they're going to take Steam/Vive head on in VR. That said they really need to catch up with the Rift - maybe their focus on the lower end of the market with Gear VR will save them, but outside of this the Rift is pretty disappointing. Steam game support for games that run on both the Rift and Vive make it stupid to buy games on the Oculus store, but worse than that once you've played with the touch controls and room scale that the Vive offers it's clear the Rift just does not compare. The Vive is heavier, it's hardware is not as aesthetically pleasing and it's clunkier (more wires, bigger pain to set up). Other than that though it's categorically better - if Oculus doesn't ship some touch controllers and room scale sensors soon I think they'll lose the high end market (unless they're able to power through on brand alone). The Vive also has an interesting front facing camera and doesn't let light in through the nose. I've been seeing people on Craigslist selling their Rift and keeping their Vive - not a good sign for Oculus. My Rift is unplugged and in the closet.
- TrevorJ 10y agoThe thing that killed my interest in the rift was Facebook's transparent desire to make it a walled garden.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- NovaS1X 10y agoI think most people knew something along these lines would happen when Facebook bought Oculus. This doesn't at all surprise me and I fully expect it to get worse. What's frustrating is when people would say anything negative about the aquisition on HN you'd get the usual downvotes for saying something negative and speculative. Facebook is a terrible company.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoWell, they're doing a very poor job with the Oculus store, why would this one be any different? I'm not saying they don't have the money or technical talent, but clearly the politics of Facebook are morally onerous to gamers. Everything about the Rift should have been a slam dunk. It had the mindshare, pr, capital, early adopter advantage, etc. Hell they even have John Carmack. Now its the red headed stepchild of the VR wars. Oculus went from a gamer friendly company to what seems to be something run by a bunch of milquetoast MBA's with zero interest or experience in gaming. Cut-throat deals like exclusives, contradictory and anti-consumer policies, confusing PR (why is Luckey yelling at people on reddit?), inability to catch up (no motion controls yet?), etc have hurt the brand and the Vive seems like the go-to for VR right now. In a couple months the PSVR will be out, with motion controls. Where exactly does that leave Oculus? As the has-been of the industry? I can't see Facebook winning over the PC gamer crowd. Casuals have mobile, they're not installing this thing. Beating Steam means beating Steams street cred which its been carefully building for over a decade. I just don't think companies like Facebook have the culture to win here. The types of people who can work a monopoly well in the social media space are pretty much the worst kinds of people you want in the gaming industry, and Oculus's failures are proof of that.
- tntniceman 10y agoValve/Steam solved a problem that the PC gaming community faced in late 2003, namely streamlined distribution of online content. Now there seem to be countless fighters in the ring; I can only see this experiment ending in either a small fandom based on exclusivity deals or smoldering out quickly.
- TrevorJ 10y agoConsumers don't really need multiple steam-like platforms either. I don't see the market supporting more than a couple. It's a steep hill to climb for anyone who want's to compete with Steam.
- roflchoppa 10y agoyou know as much as a like competition in the market. Ive yet to have an issue with Steam, it works well, when I need service I can get it. thx Gaben&team if you read this.
- paulmd 10y agoSteam, and GoG are the only companies who seem to make it stick. On paper, GoG isn't doing things that differently than EA and Ubisoft (just the no-DRM bit, which is admittedly a pretty great selling point), but I think EA and Ubisoft's brands are just so toxic that people are loathe to use them for anything they aren't forced to use them for. I think Facebook runs into much the same problem nowadays. Their brand is just increasingly toxic outside their core business, and the network effect is strong enough that people don't really have much of a choice there. Blizzard is also a player, but like EA and Ubi they only sell their own products through it. Aside: EA has effectively wiped most knowledge of its existence from the Internet, but I remember when EA launched its first Origin platform back around the 2006 era, and then discontinued it a couple years later. I lost all my Battlefield 2 expansions, and I've been incredibly gunshy about them ever since. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield_2#Booster_packs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield_2#Booster_packs
- cwkoss 10y agoUnity games are not going to strongly compete with Steam. Unity engine just isn't performant enough. I think this is more for mobile-style casual games: think flash games with 3D instead of 2D graphics. Will probably make a chunk of change from bored homemakers, but it isn't going to pull marketshare from 'PC master race'-type Steam gamers.
- bduerst 10y agoDoesn't VR require some pretty heavy hardware? Is the casual gaming market really going to have that?
- lj3 10y agoSome have PS4s. That's plenty beefy enough. They might even pay for the VR equipment too if it's cheap enough and becomes a multiplayer experience. Think mario party for the wii, but with VR instead.
- eropple 10y ago> Some have PS4s. That's plenty beefy enough. Sony has their own competing VR solution, though. That said, I seem to recall some talk about the Xbox One (maybe just their Scorpio refresh?) supporting the Rift, but I can't recall details offhand.
- rtkwe 10y agoThere's been no official announcement about XBox One supporting VR. It's all been speculation. It would make sense for them to wait until the Scorpio refresh though.
- serge2k 10y ago> Some have PS4s. That's plenty beefy enough Not really though.
- ascagnel_ 10y agoGoing based on what Will Smith (the guy who runs The Foo Show) has said on various podcasts, a heavily stylized, low-poly look works well for VR since there isn't as much of an uncanny valley and it substantially lowers the hardware requirements. Superhot, Firewatch, etc., are good examples there, and can be tuned to require less processing power to run. Remember, there's already GearVR, and that runs off of a mobile phone.
- jonathanyc 10y agoMessenger and Facebook are the two buggiest apps I use most often. For about a week now, the "seen" indicators have been completely broken on all platforms for me and for some of my friends. Before that, somehow my messages got pinned to the top half of the screen for a day, which would be neat as a feature except (1) how is that bug even possible in a sane system (2) its not a feature. Can't wait to use a gaming platform engineered by the same people. Who cares about bugs in games anyways? Multiplayer gaming is very resilient.
- msl09 10y agoOn a related note, why doesn't steam install into android? It seems to me like there are hundreds of dozens of android games on steam(literal ports from android to PC/MAC) but there is no way for the player to install the android version on their phones, unless if they also buy from Playstore the games they already have on Steam.
- khalilravanna 10y agoI imagine it could be a myriad of things: legal reasons having to do with uploading an Android game to the Play store as well as another marketplace, Valve not wanting to fragment their product/software, Valve not wanting to have to support an entirely new OS, etc.
- goda90 10y agoIt would also be a popular move for those who want to stream their games to Android devices that don't have an Nvidia card on Windows. GameStream(and Moonlight) work pretty well, but the fact that Steam streaming can work from a Linux machine with AMD graphics is pretty nice.
- tomku 10y ago1) Owning a Windows/Mac/Linux copy of a game does not mean you implicitly have a license to the Android version, even if it's a "literal port". 2) It's not really in Steam's interest to give you that license for free for games you already own, or to set up some kind of cross-buy where you automatically get it if you buy a PC copy. It'd cost them a ton of money and they have no reason to promote Android as a gaming platform alternative to PCs. 3) The juicy market on mobile isn't selling premium games like on Steam, it's selling in-app purchases in freemium games. I don't have an Android device handy but the first paid game on my iPhone's "Top Grossing Games" list is Minecraft at #44. The only other one in the top 150 is Reigns at #106. The premium game market on mobile is just not profitable enough to make a huge loss-leader like 2) above viable.
- Impossible 10y agoI think many developers would opt into giving Android versions of their game to owners on Steam if they have an Android port. If this wasn't the case then something like the Humble Mobile Bundle, which regularly gives you DRM free PC\Mac\Linux + Steam keys + Android APKs would not exist. At this point I think there is a large backlog of titles on Steam that have Android ports, and like with Mac and Linux developers would add those to Steam to make their older titles more attractive to new buyers. This feature would be more of a value add to Steam making the platform more attractive. If Steam on Android was big enough Valve could capture some of the free to play market as well, you're forgetting that even though Steam sells a lot of premium titles many of the most popular games are F2P already, roughly 20 of the top 100 player count games on Steam are F2P. Valve knows how many people have the Steam app installed on Android and it's fully possible that they don't consider the effort worth it for them. For me it'd be a nice way to manage updates for games that I already own on Steam, have APKs for (via Humble Bundle), but don't want to re-buy on Google Play just for automatic updates.
- spdy 10y agoI do not see myself moving away from steam anytime soon. Its easy and works.
- devopsproject 10y agoThey will bundle a killer app with it, just like steam did with half life 2.
- AJ007 10y agoLike EA did with Battlefield?
- overcast 10y agoI REALLY do not see Facebook getting the killer app like Half Life 2, or Battlefield like mentioned below on Origin. Besides, that was a completely different time, before anything even existed. Steam didn't pull users away from the number one software distributor, to become number one. It was more of a killer app, just to adopt the concept. Further segmenting your software between services, is exactly what people use Steam to AVOID. The fact that everything is in one place, no lost keys, no lost disc, is its selling point. It's bad enough I have to also use Origin to play some key games. So I'm certainly not going to further dilute my libraries.
- ssalazar 10y ago> I REALLY do not see Facebook getting the killer app Between Carmack and Facebook's ability to buy any developer who is on the market I think they can put up a solid contender at launch. Probably won't be enough though; I see this more as a Tidal or Apple Music kind of move--existing major player enters the market with desirable exclusives or platform integration but fails to break out of the middle of the pack.
- r00fus 10y agoSo you're guessing they'll end up like Microsoft's Xbox division - spending billions to place a solid constant 2nd place, and still not being net revenue positive after a decade.
- niftich 10y agoI feel like if this Steam-clone were called 'Oculus Play' or some other name more-distanced from 'Facebook', I'd be less uneasy with it. I know in all likelihood it's an irrelevant distinction from a data harvesting standpoint, but the implied expansion of the 'Facebook' brand from its original locus of a yearbook-style personal page makes me uncomfortable. I'm not (entirely) opposed to social integration of my gaming. But if a compelling gaming portal introduces social network integration, I'm more amenable to it than going the other direction, when a social network makes me download another desktop app. It's also somewhat contrary to Facebook's established practice of having distinct brands (albeit as a result of acquisitions); a brand that appeals to a different demographic. Instagram appeals to a different kind of person than Facebook; WhatsApp appeals to a different kind of person than Messenger, and the like.
- rythmshifter 10y agokill it with fire!
- Mikeb85 10y agoI'm beginning to get sick of the Unity monoculture. All their games have the same feel to them, which I can only describe as 'sluggish'. Truly ambitious games built with Unity inevitably wind up buggy as well, since doing anything outside the box requires hacks and workarounds.
- whatever_dude 10y agoDo Limbo, Inside, Monument Valley, or Ori, feel slow or buggy to you? There's a lot of bad stuff out there, since Unity has a low entry point. But Unity is not inherently bad; it's just that some developers lack the chops to do it well.
- Vexs 10y agoThe issue is is that if a game is subpar, or even par, it's really, really obvious it's made with unity. All the best games you can't tell, but unity seems to have a sort of unique feel to it that you can pick out pretty easily, which gives it a bad name.
- Impossible 10y agoMinor nitpick, Limbo wasn't a Unity game, it was a custom engine. Limbo predated Unity having decent console support, they moved to using Unity for Inside (a reference link http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/126729/Limbo_Developer_Playdead_Using_Unity_Engine_For_Next_Title.php http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/126729/Limbo_Developer_Pl...).
- lost_name 10y agoIndeed. This one has proven popular as well. https://unity3d.com/showcase/case-stories/hearthstone https://unity3d.com/showcase/case-stories/hearthstone
- droopyEyelids 10y agoNotable for being one of the most sluggish, buggiest, and resource intensive triple-a title available on each of its platforms.
- happyslobro 10y agoFacebook. Unity. Yuck. I'm sure it will make them a killing, though (not sarcasm)
- JayHost 10y agoWell said! Haha yeah, you've got the two most bloated proprietary apps working together. Woooo!! Some men just want to watch the world burn! These softwares are so terrible for the world. Terrible for any person trying to make a living programming and terrible for education. I only realized recently how easy* it is to create realistic graphics using libre software. (I believe this is what draws most people to Unity - forget that it's hard to replicate their demos) Implement the features I want Forget about all the bloat I don't want Get all the benefits of my custom software, favorite os and editor.
- haydenlee 10y agoAs seen in the comments here there's a strong reaction of "why would I ever use this instead of Steam?" from the existing gamer crowd. Yet from Facebook's perspective even if _not one_ Steam user jumps ship, they could theoretically still grow their platform to 10x the size of Steam based off just their existing Facebook userbase. That's tremendous upside and seems completely worth the risk.
- serg_chernata 10y agoI have to agree, the sheer numbers of people Facebook has access to could crush Steam in terms of active users. I love Steam and think Facebook has enough of my information as it is but you can't ignore these numbers.
- usrusr 10y agoWhy can't you ignore them? The Catholic church also has a very high number of users and you surely ignore those wrt competing with Steam. The Vatican is certainly in an even worse position to convert users to game shoppers, but I don't think that Facebook is that far ahead in this. People have pretty much stabilised in how they expect their relationship with Facebook to be and any offers to extend it to new grounds are likely to be ignored. When Farmville happened, Facebook users were a lot more experimental.
- golergka 10y agoWill they have the same sales though? After buying Ryse for $3 and filling my game library for 300+ titles on a very limited budget, I don't think about switching to any other game store.
- asgardiator 10y agoThere's no way this can go wrong. If Facebook is known for anything, it's moldbreaking and open innovation.
- shmerl 10y agoYou mean Facebook want to get into game distribution business? The last thing we need, is another DRM ridden distributor that also pushes for distributor lock-in features (like they did with Oculus initially). I buy my games through GOG.
- dave_sullivan 10y agoSteam has succeeded (I think) because they've managed to walk a thin line w/ drm and not screwing up the user experience too much. Facebook would be smart to have gaming and social as two separate things with optional integration with Facebook. They'll screw it up because they'll make the optional part super annoying. Because when have they not? I turned off my Facebook years ago. That works fine for me, but I'm frustrated any time someone uses Facebook to post something I'd like to read (like yann lecun or john carmack) because it's a step backwards. It'd be like Doom being released as an AOL exclusive. Anyway, my money's on steam and ue4 dominating for years to come, not a new dist platform and not unity.
- ythl 10y agoI hate to break it to you, but Unity already dominates in terms of popularity.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dave_sullivan 10y agoYes, hence why everyone that doesn't make games is super excited. UE4 is the superior engine, made by a company that actually makes games. Networking, rendering, UI, lots more -- it all comes built-in to ue4 where unity has built this plugins ecosystem that is sort of a mess. Also, does Unity still not give you the source code? I assume they'll change this soon enough; you get the source code with ue4. I kind of see it like blender vs maya or something. Lots of people are using blender, and it's very powerful. But industry is using Maya (because it's more powerful), and that won't change for a bit I think (good for autodesk).
- 6stringmerc 10y agoWait, so I'm going to see more invitations from friends to games that I have no intention of playing than I already do? I mean, I figure that's kind of part of the business model by now. Some days I miss fragging newbies in Half-Life DM, but when seeing stuff like this, I'm glad I freed up my time to do stuff like mowing the yard and scooping kitty litter, which, strange as it might sound, are on par to me now with achieving victory in an online game.
- kelvin0 10y agoSteam is an awesome plaform that doesn't try to piss the user off (looking at you EA Origin and UBI Play). I don't think anyone can outdo this right now (at least on PC). This FB portal will probably also require a FB? Another fail if this is the case.
- aphextron 10y agoUgh. Steam is sluggish enough as it is, being implemented entirely in C++/QT. I cant even imagine how awful this would be.
- freeone3000 10y agoSteam is basically an app that browses a website, and also downloads some stuff. It feels like a clunky web browser because it is.
- tormeh 10y agoIt's mostly just an embedded browser. Anything that's not your library or settings is js/html.
- rv11 10y agoIt is a CEF Client https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Chromium_Embedded_Framework https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Chromium_Embedded_F...
- hkmurakami 10y agoNice move from Unity, which has built a great development suite but is hampered by its own success with its very reasonable fixed cost license per seat business model. This partnership allows them to get a revenue cut of its customers' games without alienating them. I had always expected Unity to build their own steam-like platform, but this short circuits things with an immediate huge userbase. Great move.
- tosh 10y agoWouldn't be surprised if the Facebook app (& Messenger) will be used to distribute & host these games. Skipping the app stores.
- atombath 10y agoThis is going to end up being the junk shed of game distribution. In everything it does, it seems FB's mediocre content curation/distribution is 'good enough' for its users. It's the fast food of the Internet, after all. That said, I assume it will be successful and I'm a fan of the idea. It'll help bridge that gap from a casual browser-flash gamer to start installing clients and move onto more serious entertainment. I'm confident this WILL remain a tool for strictly casual gamers, though. Discerning/younger audiences only use FB for event invites at this point. Steam rules the space because it has fought for credibility in the gamer community. Facebook on the other hand caused so much hate/drama when they bought Oculus.
- runevault 10y agoTo me the question is will people be willing to use it? I feel like a lot of people I know are trying to disengage from FB as much as they can while keeping in touch with people. The older generation are not the ones who are going to buy a ton of games through FB and the younger gen seems mostly happy with Steam. Personally I do not see a market for this. We're not talking about web based games like back in the Farmville days.
- DonHopkins 10y agoBy "desktop" do they mean "not mobile", or "not web" for that matter? Unity's support for mobile (and to a lesser extent for WebGL) is certainly one of its major selling points. The article makes some vague hypothetical referfences to mobile, but doesn't explicitly say if Facebook's "desktop" platform is intended to support mobile devices right out of the gate. >Meanwhile, these platforms’ support for mobile could allow Facebook to earn taxes on mobile games without owning its own mobile operating system. It once tried a different approach, building an HTML5 mobile web gaming platform called Project Spartan to sidestep the iOS App Store and Android’s Google Play. But developers dismissed it as underpowered compared to the native operating systems.
- zuckclue 10y agoUnity is a good engine but I've been playing around with libGDX lately, got a first person XP walking around a cube now with a page of code. Easy, I'm not a game dev. That same code runs unchanged on Android, PC (Windows, Linux, Mac), iOS (I've not tried this) and HTML (using the excellent GWT compiler). I'm using IntelliJ (it works but not as nice as Eclipse, unfortunately Android support seems better now in IntelliJ). Just pick the target and run. Zuckerberg has a good idea but needs to use libGDX to make it a success. Call all stop and go libGDX. He won't succeed with just Unity. As a side note, I don't use Facebook, can't stand it. PS I'm not in favor of Facebook winning on this either, Steam rocks.
- Awkwardio 10y agoI can't see this winning over PC gamers. They'll probably stick with Steam. Casual gamers will give it a shot though.
- jheriko 10y agoi miss being able to install a game without having to install a bunch of associated crap with it. as much as i love steam it has always been borderline malware imo. sits in my system tray, uses my bandwidth, cpu cycles and memory etc... was even worse back when it refused to let you play your games without an internet connection too. :P
- jakozaur 10y agoIf Facebook is serious about gaming it may just acquire GoG and integrate it with it's service.
- touristtam 10y agoAndroid client for Steam is a long time coming. (and no, not just a chat client, but a dedicated one to distribute Android games)