4 ms·
A good argument stands on its own. Who the maker of it is, is irrelevant.
by bjourne 10y ago
A good argument stands on its own. Who the maker of it is, is irrelevant.
- city41 10y agoI agree. One of my favorite things about HN (and reddit), is how de-emphasized the user name is. I barely even look at them.
- copperx 10y agoI agree, but one can't forget human nature. We give more weigh to the opinions of those we admire. The same happens often in research. Papers published by well known universities get more exposure. It's not supposed to happen but it does.
- joshstrange 10y agoCouldn't agree more, I use my own name just because I use it everywhere, but on HN it's not called out and I rarely look at the author unless I think "I bet XXX wrote this, yep they did" or "Who wrote this, I'd like to reach out to them". I think it helps, to a degree, to help prevent/lessen group-think and people taking someone's word as law.
- BinaryIdiot 10y agoWhile you're very much correct that seems rather irrelevant to the question posed to the community. At least I do not know the OP's intentions with such data and distinguishing comments may not be a concern of theirs.
- peterhunt 10y agoI very much disagree in cases where the argument is nuanced and I don't have time to do substantial research. In this very common case we resort to heuristics, and "who's making the argument" is one of the most effective heuristics there is.
- lj3 10y agoI wish that were true. Too many conversations on HN essentially drill down to 'my experience contradicts your experience/theory/proof'. It never hurts to know if the person asserting his experience actually has any experience of note.
- johnfn 10y agoThis seems like it should be true but I don't think it actually is. It's very easy to frame up a plausible argument which is actually false, and inexperienced people do it all the time. The problem is that if the reader of the argument is also inexperienced, he will be unable to recognize the flaws in the argument. For people like that, post author is an excellent heuristic.
- JadeNB 10y ago> It's very easy to frame up a plausible argument which is actually false, and inexperienced people do it all the time. The problem is that experienced people do it too, though (hopefully) less often; so, if you get in the habit of trusting arguments more because of who has made them, then you will never have a chance of catching that mistake.
- mod 10y agoWhen you're "unable to recognize the flaws in the argument" you should make that "mistake." If you're enough of an expert on a topic, I think you decide for yourself regardless.
- koolba 10y ago> A good argument stands on its own. Who the maker of it is, is irrelevant. Damn straight! I'd like things to go even further in the opposite direction. Usernames should be hidden for N days, say until the article is locked for updates. You'd want to make sure the usernames remain consistent throughout an article though (so you know it's the same person you're replying to). @dang: If you want a simple way of implementing this that doesn't require any extra storage (per user), how about HMAC(JSON.stringify([username, storyId], secret)?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoIn the absence of killfiles / ignore lists, usernames are important so I know which posts to skip.
- koolba 10y agoPosts or comments or both?
- toephu2 10y agoYep, this is also the reason The Economist does not publish author names [1]. [1] http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/09/economist-explains-itself-1 http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/09/ec...