7 ms·
Apple sued over multitouch
- mrcharles 17y agoI wonder if this is a case of a company attempting to give Apple a dose of its own medicine? Apple's own heavy handedness with multitouch related lawsuits and dealings may have triggered this. Either way, I'd like to see a lot more multitouch out there.
- pieter 17y agoApple isn't the only one suing. This is just one more lawsuit, see also http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/03/04/an-explosion-of-mobile-patent-lawsuits/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/03/04/an-explosion-of-mob...
- jws 17y agoSeventeen arcs in that graphic and five of them are wrong per the March 5th correction.
- bad_user 17y agoPerfect ... a patent clusterfuck :) It's about time we had some of these.
- binspace 17y agoThe real losers are the smaller companies that cannot afford to play the game and the consumers. The winners are the legions of lawyers who get paid for all of this litigation nonsense.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoOriginal source: http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?sid=aAUwSSjk1Qjk&pid=20601087 http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?sid=aAUwSSjk1Qjk&pid=...
- jdc 17y agoElan's multitouch product, the Smart Pad: http://www.emc.com.tw/eng/tpn_sp_fun.asp http://www.emc.com.tw/eng/tpn_sp_fun.asp
- spectre 17y agoI like the Apple Macbook in the promotional video.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jodrellblank 17y agoI love the way we take monopolies away in one hand and give them out in the other. I'm glad Apple have so much spare cash that they can afford not to have their arms twisted on this, and can afford to fight it, or negotiate it, or pay any fines or settlements.
- binspace 17y agoI'm not glad that it takes having Apple's money in order to legally defend a product.
- DeusExMachina 17y agoI think that this takes the "nuclear bombs" metaphor for patents to the extreme: once one party begins using them, everybody begins tossing them around. But I think that the more these lawsuits show up, the clearer becomes that patents are really against innovation, so in the end it could be a good thing for those hoping in a patent laws reform.
- rbanffy 17y agoApple once persuaded the Department of Commerce to go after a Brazilian company that had a clean-room (software and hardware) Mac compatible (in 85 or so). After threats of commercial sanctions, the Brazilian government caved in and revoked the company's license to manufacture the machine (computer manufacturing was heavily regulated in Brazil at that time) after a very protracted and atypical approval process. There is little doubt it was revoked because of external pressure. In the end, only a few prototypes were made. A friend of mine has one: http://chester.blog.br/mac512.html http://chester.blog.br/mac512.html It's easy to imagine Apple pulling the same strings again.
- praptak 17y agoI don't think much will change until a huge company loses to an obvious patent troll.
- staunch 17y agoThat happens quite regularly I think. I know Microsoft has paid out many times. The most horrible example is probably related to IE plugins: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eolas#Litigation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eolas#Litigation
- praptak 17y agoYes indeed - I should have written "loses big".
- DeusExMachina 17y ago
- binspace 17y agoAll of this suing goes to show how patents harm, rather than help innovation. Let the engineers decide which technology is best, not the lawyers.
- wtallis 17y agoI think it's clear from the wide differences in performance of multitouch devices that there's a lot of room for valid patents to muddy the waters. labs.moto.com has done some good testing of smartphone screens and found the iPhone to be far more accurate than the competition. My own experience with some non-phone multitouch devices has also shown Apple to be the only one to get it truly right. Even Wacom's Bamboo tablets can barely manage to recognize two-finger gestures, whereas a MacBook Pro can handle jitouch, and recognize those complex gestures well enough for me to consider jitouch indispensable. It's hard to believe that the differences could be due only to software or even relatively obvious improvements in Apple's hardware, so somebody deserves some patents, and it's probably Apple (unless they stole somebody else's technology). The ensuing litigation storm then is more a result of how lucrative the multitouch market is than it is a symptom of messy patent laws. Ultimately, I think it was probably Apple that did (or bought) the research necessary to make a multitouch sensor that is better than a gimmick, and for that they deserve a period of exclusivity to recoup their costs and give them some profits to invest into the next big thing. On the other hand, 20 years is a long time for those of us with lesser budgets to wait for such a cool technology. What we should be hoping for, then, is that somebody more inclined to license their technology can or has independently developed a multitouch sensor that is as good as or better than what Apple's been shipping, and that they can prove this in court if necessary. Reducing the term of these patents might be helpful, but I don't think that there's justification to eliminate hardware patents like these.
- ghshephard 17y ago"Ultimately, I think it was probably Apple that did (or bought) the research necessary to make a multitouch sensor that is better than a gimmick, and for that they deserve a period of exclusivity to recoup their costs and give them some profits to invest into the next big thing. " The only area that patent exclusivity should be granted are in those technologies, processes, and methods that would not have been developed (and divulged) otherwise. If superior Multi-Touch would have happened anyways, then there is no reason to grant Apple a patent on the process. Remember - the entire purpose of patents is "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts..." - if the progress is going to happen anyways, there is no need to issue a patent.
- KirinDave 17y agoGood luck Elan? Last time I checked, Apple had bought Fingerworks which had a patent portfolio that I'm told was "fairly large" and had been developing since before the 2000's. I'm pretty sure that what's going to happen is that Apple's going to pull out a trump patent and get Elan's patent invalidated due to prior art (which was itself approved by the patent office). Why do we even engage in the polite fiction that patents are meaningful anymore? They're just government-sponsored lawsuit cards now. Do they do ANYONE any good in our modern legal system?
- wtallis 17y agoIt's easy for software people like us to fall into the trap of thinking that all patents are bad, because software patents have so many problems. (Terms that are way too long for the pace of the industry, too many vague and overly broad patents being granted, patents being granted for what is arguably mathematics, no provisions against patent trolls, etc.) We see and read about mostly the bad side of the patent system, and unless we actually try to find a good side, we'll assume there isn't one. To give an example, I'm listed as a co-inventor on a pending patent application (though I will never get any royalties from it). The patent is for a type of device that costs more than a hundred thousand dollars to build. The owner of the patent will be a small business that deals with such small volumes that they will mostly have to license the patent to other companies in order to fulfill demand, but they hope to build and sell several of these devices themselves. When the project to develop this device started, most of the experts in the field told us that it was impossible. Now that we've published the basics of how our design works, it would be fairly easy for the large players in the industry to replicate our results without having to buy anything from us. If our patent application isn't granted, then the only way for the company to recoup their costs would be to treat the results of my research as a trade secret. (It's too late for that, though, and I've never signed an NDA.) Going the trade secret route would be a loss for the market, as I've already mentioned that the inventors can't meet the demand on their own. Getting a patent is a good compromise that allows my employer to recoup his costs, but also ensures that our invention can be put to good use.
- barrkel 17y ago
- GHFigs 17y agoApple was sued by Elan a year ago. The news is that Elan has filed a complaint with the US International Trade Commission asking to bar imports of the allegedly infringing products. It's a sharper set of teeth, and more pressure on Apple to resolve the suit. Neither MacRumors nor the original Bloomberg article list patent numbers, but this does not appear to involve any of the specific patents involved in the Apple-HTC thing. It appears to relate more generally to the touch sensing hardware Apple uses across their product line. That is not part of the HTC thing because HTC (like everyone else) uses Synaptics. As mentioned in the Bloomberg article, Elan won a suit against Synaptics over the same patent in 2008. It makes sense that they would pursue Apple next, as Apple's Fingerworks-derived touch technology is (to my knowledge) the only thing out there other than Synaptics with any market presence.
- j23tom 17y agoi hope they win - Jobs finally realize patents are bad