7 ms·
How the Hunt Brothers Cornered the Silver Market and Then Lost It All
- Finnucane 10y agoI remember this clearly. Or at least, I remember going to the camera store for darkroom supplies, and being faced with almost weekly price changes. Of course, I don't recall the prices going down again very much after the market collapsed.
- noonespecial 10y agoMe too. That visceral feeling of how much it cost to press that shutter release and instinctive balance of the dread of missing the moment and spending the money... Even now, every time I empty an sd card, pick 5 images and trash 100, I feel as rich as a sultan. Some parts of the future really rock.
- Finnucane 10y agoFortunately, as a working adult, it is easier to indulge myself in such things now more than it was a student with no money. Hell, I've even got the Hasselblad I wanted then!
- cloudjacker 10y agoIt is only a matter of time before someone attempts this without using too much leverage and credit to make the purchases. The regulators and industries only tool is raising margin requirements (how big your down payment is), as well as position size limits per account
- cm2187 10y agoCornering the market is outright illegal.
- taprun 10y agoHow is cornering the market outright illegal? And in which jurisdiction? There are plenty of examples where one company has a strongly dominant share. Diamonds are an obvious example, search engines are another.
- pjc50 10y agoCommodity trading in the major markets (US, EU) has rules against cornering and other forms of obvious market manipulation. Obviously that only applies to "commodities", whereas it's accepted that manufactured goods have a limited number of suppliers regulated by patent. The entire market for pharmaceuticals is "cornered" in that sense.
- DannyBee 10y agoYeah, i mean, it's not like silly things related to market manipulation in commodities happened for many years before anything was done about it: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2014-11-20/the-goldman-sachs-aluminum-conspiracy-was-pretty-silly https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2014-11-20/the-goldm... etc
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gech 10y ago"The rest was borrowed from over 20 banks and brokerage houses."
- coldcode 10y agoJust because people are rich doesn't make them geniuses. But it takes a special kind of "genius" to turn $16B in $10M.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoThe kind of genius who builds a huge leveraged position in something and is then legally compelled to sell over 95% of it within one month? I wonder what that sort of fire sale would do to the value of your holdings?
- maxander 10y agoWell, yes, the kind of genius that would be apparently blindsided by financial regulation while he goes about causing massive disruptions in a crucial market. Really, the whole story sounds like some guys from Texas got rich and started playing with finance without having lost the "hide everything under the mattress" mentality.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 10y agoSomething about that doesn't quite add up. At one point they owned 6 billion in silver. They had another 10 billion in futures on top of that? At what price? In theory, they could still cover that position. There's some numbers here and there in the article, but not enough to really recreate their paper position.
- leakybit 10y ago$16 billion in assets, but they were on margin with only $1 billion in cash.
- ams6110 10y agoTwo brothers trying to corner the market on a commodity only to have it blow up in their face? Sounds like it must have inspired the movie Trading Places.
- nostrademons 10y ago“The main factor that has caused corners to fail [throughout history] is that the manipulator has underestimated how much will be delivered to him if he succeeds [at] raising the price to artificial levels,” Money quote. People seem to consistently underestimate how much supply may come online with an order-of-magnitude increase in price, and simultaneously, how much demand can come online with an order-of-magnitude reduction in price. This is the story of shale oil, dark fiber, and most stock market manipulation, and on the other side, mass production, personal computers, search advertising, digital music, web content, and cloud computing. It's also why savvy startup investors advise you to work on getting that order-of-magnitude improvement in price/performance/ease-of-use, and not worry so much about how big the market appears to be.
- swyman 10y agoExactly. Taken to its extreme, this is the argument in favor of the seeming paradox that we'll never run out of oil, despite the Earth having an obviously finite supply.
- cstejerean 10y agoIt's not that we'll never run out of oil, but if the price of oil rises to arbitrarily high levels then alternatives start to make economic sense. Those alternatives in the short term may be alternate sources of oil that were too difficult to extract earlier, but alternatives can also be completely difference sources of energy. And once economies of scale start to apply to those alternatives then their price starts to reduce, which further increases demand, etc. Not sure where the long term equilibrium price is for energy and it may very well be higher than in the era of cheap oil but I also don't think that it will rise to catastrophically high levels that were predicted by "peak oil".
- dredmorbius 10y agoNone of "the alternatives" offer oil's tremendous positive energy (net current) surplus with a minimum of effort or technological capability. Colonel Drake punched through 69 feet of Pennsylvania bedrock using 1300 year old Chinese salt-drilling techniques (and early 19th century cast iron well casings). Well Number 1, Bahrain, still supplied 35,000 barrels of oil per day eighty years after it was drilled. http://www.geoexpro.com/articles/2012/12/bahrain-80-years-and-still-producing http://www.geoexpro.com/articles/2012/12/bahrain-80-years-an... Oil (and coal and gas) absolutely changed the world, and quite simply, they're not like other raw materials. They're not transformed by processing, they're consumed, they dwarf all other material inputs to the modern economy other than air and water (both of which are readily available from the envrionment ... usually). And we're using them at rates of 1,000 to 5,000,000 times faster than they were initially produced. Energy itself enables complexity (though it's a, um, complex relationship). Bootstrapping the modern world happened only once, and under what appears to be a singular mix of conditions ranging from geological to philosophical, despite humans having walked over the very sources of our modern wealth in the Middle East, China, Britain, North America, and Australia for many thousands of years. If you're curious about what equilibrium energy prices for energy alternatives -- fungible, storable, on-demand energy that modern civilisation requires -- might be, look to the best alternatives to oil and see what they run. For biofuels, it's about $300 to $1,000 dollars per barrel. Keep in mind that the US presently returns slightly over $1,000 in GDP per barrel of oil consumed. In Europe it's typically higher -- $1,500 to $3,000 (in Switzerland). In much of the world it's far lower -- China and India are in the $400 - $500 GDP/bbl range. At $1,000/bbl, they would forego a tremendous amount of low-return (but vital to their burgeoning populations) economic activity. Solar energy gives lower costs, but that's with tremendous fossil inputs to construction an absolutely enormous capital plant, dwarfing anything we've built to date. Human's largest current technological artifact mostly involved pouring hot tar over prepared ground, and that is a challenging expense and maintenance problem. Consider computer chips spanning tens of thousands of square kilometers, in wind, rain, dust, and hail. You might want to think some over just what it is "cost", "value", "price", and "wealth" mean, represent, interact, and how we got to where we are. Mainstream economic thought strikes me as strongly lacking in substance here, evidenced by much of the long debate over the meanings of those terms. Their current generally accepted values are by no means the only ones proposed, though the debate now is largely quashed.
- canada_dry 10y ago"it is impossible to prove definitively that market manipulation was in their hearts. Maybe, as the Hunts always claimed, they just really believed in the enduring value of silver." Sigh.. yah right. Just like they really believed in the enduring value of soya beans.
- a_small_island 10y agoI can't believe how many typos there were in this article, do editors exist anymore?
- mysterypie 10y agoI didn't notice. I ran the article through spellcheck and the only typo that came up was "Jello-O" (which should have been Jell-O). What else was wrong?
- justinator 10y agoHow about, “I don’t know really know anything,” said Bunker, offering a synopsis of his horse trading strategy that could have just as easily applied to his entire career as an investor. “I am just trying to win a few races.” Should be, "I don't really know anything," [0] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/22/business/nelson-bunker-hunt-texas-tycoon-dies-at-88.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/22/business/nelson-bunker-hun...
- FullyFunctional 10y agoI assumed that the quotes were intended to point to a verbatim quote. I still think that's the most likely case.
- ourmandave 10y agoDid this make surviving silver coins more valuable for their rarity? I remember my dad sold his collection for the metal value back then.
- WalterBright 10y agoCollect coins if you enjoy it, but for an investment they are terrible.
- hansjorg 10y agoNPR's Planet Money had an interesting episode a while back about the successful cornering of the US onion market in 1955-56. As a result, onion futures trading was banned, and still is today in the US. http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/10/14/448718171/episode-657-the-tale-of-the-onion-king http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/10/14/448718171/episo...
- sevenless 10y agoOddly, the same code prohibits dealing onion futures and movie ticket receipts: > 7 U.S. Code § 13–1 - Violations, prohibition against dealings in motion picture box office receipts or onion futures; punishment > No contract for the sale of motion picture box office receipts (or any index, measure, value, or data related to such receipts) or onions for future delivery shall be made on or subject to the rules of any board of trade in the United States. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/7/13-1 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/7/13-1
- 21 10y agoThere was some talk a few years ago about trading futures on movie box-office returns, meaning betting if a future movie will be successful at box-office or not. This supposedly would have allowed movie studios to hedge in case of a potential dud. But it was forbidden for some reason. This might be related to that.
- tedunangst 10y agoHollywood accounting is notoriously cooked, such that even blockbusters "lose" money. A futures market would be a disaster. Maybe if restricted to actual ticket sales, but that still seems very easy to manipulate. What constitutes an "actual" ticket?
- speeder 10y agoThere is a movie I believe, about scammers trying to use futures market to have illegal profits by betting on failure of their theatrical piece, and then making a piece thqt praises Hitler, hoping it would bomb really hard.
- OliverJones 10y agoI was a biophysics grad student at the time of the Hunts' shenanigans. The lab I worked in used a lot of x-ray film for crystallography and electron microscopy. At that time x-ray film was basically silver halide stuck to plastic. Our wizard lab tech cooked up a nice little electrolytic gizmo, involving a screen made of thin copper wire and a battery, and dropped one in each fixer bath we used to fix the x-ray film. The copper wire became coated with metallic silver. The lab made thousands of dollars at the peak of the Hunt-induced silver bubble by selling that recovered silver. That was good, because the cost of film went completely nuts, and we were able to keep from blowing through our budget.
- musesum 10y agoHey, I was in that business, too! I walked around to all the photo labs and offered to take their used developer off their hands. Was still in high school at the time. Meanwhile, my Dad bought $1000 worth of quarters. Then he had us sort out all the quarters that were dated 1964 and before into a separate pile, as those quarters were 100% silver. After that, we sold the all silver quarters by weight. Forgot what the price was, but was worth the time.
- theandrewbailey 10y agoNot 100%, but 90%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quarter_(United_States_coin)#Silver_series https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quarter_(United_States_coin)#S... I will occasionally see some pre-64 quarters and dimes, and I often notice them because they sound slightly different (on account of metal content/weight) than post-64 ones.
- musesum 10y agoCool! I stand corrected.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nstj 10y agoDid you know that Warren Buffett also got in on this same silver trade in 1997? > Our second non-traditional commitment is in silver. Last year, we purchased 111.2 million ounces. Marked to market, that position produced a pre-tax gain of $97.4 million for us in 1997. In a way, this is a return to the past for me: Thirty years ago, I bought silver because I anticipated its demonetization by the U.S. Government. Ever since, I have followed the metal's fundamentals but not owned it. In recent years, bullion inventories have fallen materially, and last summer Charlie and I concluded that a higher price would be needed to establish equilibrium between supply and demand. Inflation expectations, it should be noted, play no part in our calculation of silver's value. [0] [0]: http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1997.html http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1997.html
- tomcam 10y agoThis happened when I was a kid, and I took note of the wild swings commodities market could take. I like silver, so when it went down to five dollars in the late 1990s, I bought a couple of thousand ounces.starting at that level, it becomes logistically a little interesting to store it.