7 ms·
The Most Intolerant Wins: The Dictatorship of the Small Minority
- r-w 10y ago> Aramaic is a Semitic language which succeeded Canaanite (that is, Phoenician-Hebrew) in the Levant and resembles Arabic; it was the language Jesus Christ spoke. The reason it came to dominate the Levant and Egypt isn’t because of any particular imperial Semitic power or the fact that they have interesting noses. Well then.
- golergka 10y agoThe author is from Lebanon himself and is probably referring to his own interesting nose in that passage.
- sitkack 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nassim_Nicholas_Taleb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nassim_Nicholas_Taleb is freak'n hilarious. If you have a chance to see him in person, I highly recommend it. [0] Preprints https://arxiv.org/a/taleb_n_1.html https://arxiv.org/a/taleb_n_1.html [0] http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/scheduledseminars.htm http://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/scheduledseminars.htm
- sremani 10y agoHe is one of my favorite authors, who does not feed you pop-psychology or some feel good narrative. I understand people here are turned off by his seeming arrogance, but I like one quote (probably by someone else), "Character trumps reputation." and Reputation is fragile. This one quote gives me more courage than any to speak my mind.
- mcguire 10y agoBut there is nothing but pop psychology in this article. Well, and some paranoia and grammar errors. And did you check the end? I think he decided that it didn't feel good enough.
- throwaway814 10y agoFantastic article. Great examples, some of which I benefit from (English as a lingua franca for example) and some that are pretty horrifying. The realm that I most notice this happening every day is "political correctness". My Facebook feed is dominated by people tripping over themselves to attack racists, sexists, religious bigots, etc. Great. But many times they go way too far IMO and crucify innocents. However, there's no way I care enough to stake my reputation on defending innocent strangers. So they continue to rack up positive feedback on their campaigns. For example, this article is popular right now: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/top-10-most-sexist-things-to-occur-at-the-2016-rio_us_57a88bfce4b0c94bd3c9fb86 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/top-10-most-sexist-thing... Most of those remarks are totally fine in my book and are only sexist by willful misinterpretation. For example, how is it not newsworthy that a recent mom is competing? Even the article calls it "an incredible feat!" Then Ledecky, who "swims like a man" because she is strong enough to use the traditionally male stroke, unlike all of the other women. Girls "standing around as if they're at the mall" was just an old commentator picking the most casual place he could think of. And when he tried to defend himself by pointing out the Cherry-Picking Fallacy (he has covered women's sports for many years, so they picked one sentence online that might be misconstrued as sexist to crucify him online when his body of work is totally fine) they actually cropped his defense and cherry-picked from it as well. Anyways. Things like that annoy me because I can't say them with my name attached or I'll end up cast aside. Nobody is interested in rational discussion, the Most Intolerant does always win.
- tomp 10y agoThat's a really terrible article. Sure, certain complaints are kind-of legitimate (e.g. mentioning someone is someone's wife - although I'm sure same is also often said of men married to famous women), but most just seem to be petty denials of the fact that (the best) men are almost universally better at a given sport than (the best) women.
- throwaway814 10y agoFor sure, and even the follow-up on that issue has the IMO totally reasonable explanation + apology for how something that ridiculous came out: http://www.wbur.org/onlyagame/2016/08/12/cogdell-unrein-twitter-olympics-trapshooting http://www.wbur.org/onlyagame/2016/08/12/cogdell-unrein-twit... The Chicago-based newspaper was trying to emphasize her connection to Chicago (she's from Alaska) and overdid it. Then apologized. Woo, makes sense, no harm no foul.
- tumbas 10y agois this about when free masons the small genocidical intolerant criminal minority enslaved russia in communist revolution and commited genocides?
- skybrian 10y agoThis is just a rant. Why is it here? It's very easy to advertise what's not in food if it never had it anyway. This is just good marketing. Many foods are kosher or halal or vegan or whatever because as far as the majority is concerned it's a checkbox feature that doesn't affect you and maybe even works as a signal of quality. I'm having a hard time seeing the issue. On the other hand it seems like nearly everything having to do with nuts is labelled as processed on machines that also process peanuts so apparently economics wins much of the time.
- throwaway814 10y agoAs far as I can tell, this article isn't even angry. It's just explaining the mechanics behind some changes. How is that a rant?
- skybrian 10y agoYou can't really call it "explaining the mechanics" when there's no evidence he actually talked to anyone or did any research to see if his theorizing holds up.
- Anon1096 10y agoSo can nothing be published unless it's cleared by experts in the field? This isn't even in a scientific journal - it's a Medium blog post. I'm not sure why you're attempting to hold it to the rigor of a journal (which he'd have to pay for to apply to, I might add). And on the accusation of having "no research", his research is all the things he observed happening in the world in the first half of the essay.
- skybrian 10y agoSpeculation is fine - everyone does it. But usually you admit that right up front. "I've done no research but here's my half-baked theory of how this works." You show a bit of humility, some understanding that you might not have it right the first time, and invite corrections. (Also, if it's based on what other people wrote, links help.)
- tomp 10y agoI doubt the whole of Europe will ever eat Halal. Or, at least, I hope not. Personally, I find the method of slaughter cruel (slicing the throat and waiting for the blood to drain - granted, the animal can be stunned, but there were plenty of footages of animals being tortured instead), and discriminatory (has to be performed by a Muslim, Jew or Christian). I actively avoid eating Halal meat.
- Reason077 10y agoIn the UK, the law requires all animals to be stunned before slaughter - except in the case of religious slaughter (Kosher and Halal), where stunning may be contrary to religious practice. It can be hard to avoid eating Halal meat, because there is no requirement that Halal meat is labeled as such. Meat from Halal slaughter ends up in the regular supply chain. The vast majority of New Zealand lamb, for example, is Halal - but isn't typically labeled as such. https://www.rspca.org.uk/ImageLocator/LocateAsset?asset=document&assetId=1232719611043&mode=prd https://www.rspca.org.uk/ImageLocator/LocateAsset?asset=docu...
- omginternets 10y agoSame in France, sadly. I suspect much of the EU works in this way.
- SyneRyder 10y agoI think there are other reasons that will also stop it happening. We used to be frequent customers of a fast food store near us, who switched to sourcing Halal chicken for their product. Seems like a good idea (increase marketshare, provide a new service to an unserved community), but the Halal chicken was extremely dry & flavourless. It ruined our enjoyment of the food and we stopped going (after being customers for almost a decade), especially as new competitors with tastier non-Halal offerings started opening. The store closed some months afterwards.
- g8oz 10y agoSounds like there is a bad competitive situation in the halal wholesale market in your area. The store owner should have taken that in to account.
- mcguire 10y agoFascinating article, although probably not for the reasons Taleb would like. He's signaling something, but I am too much of a plebe to know what: "a glass of that type of yellow sugared water with citric acid people sometimes call lemonade" This reverses his majority/minority argument: "Let us apply the rule to domains where it can get entertaining: "An honest person will never commit criminal acts but a criminal will readily engage in legal acts." This argument is pretty nonsensical; if the majority is flexible, then in what sense does it make sense to say "submit"? "...then the (flexible) majority will have to submit to the minority rule." Taleb seems to need to work on his cut-n-paste skills: "Note that these slaughter rules [for halal/kosher meat] are skin-in-the-game driven, inherited from the ancient Eastern Mediterranean [discussed in Chapter] Greek and Semitic practice to only worship the gods if one has skin in the game, sacrifice meat to the divinity, and eat what’s left." I'll just note this in passing: "In promoting genetically modified food via all manner of lobbying, purchasing of congressmen, and overt scientific propaganda (with smear campaigns against such persons as yours truly), the big agricultural companies foolishly believed that all they needed was to win the majority. No, you idiots. As I said, your snap “scientific” judgment is too naive in these type of decisions...It is strange, once again, to see Big Ag who spent hundreds of millions of dollars on research cum smear campaigns, with hundreds of these scientists who think of themselves as more intelligent than the rest of the population, miss such an elementary point about asymmetric choices." Could someone run through this with the math? This is not a use of renormalization I am familiar with. "The method of analysis employed here is called renormalization group, a powerful apparatus in mathematical physics that allows us to see how things scale up (or down). Let us examine it next –without mathematics." Signaling again: "flâneur". Are we talking about the same French language? "...the prestige of France or the efforts of their civil servants in promoting their more or less beautiful Latinized and logically spelled language over the orthographically confusing one of trans-Channel meat-pie eaters."
- zby 10y agoI actually found the article interesting, but you are right that it would improve much if he worked a bit more on these parts. I stopped at exactly the same points. As to the last point French is a bit more logically spelled than English - even if it is still horrendous.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- triplesec 10y agoPreviously on HN https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10567630 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10567630 Edit: as a pdf with a marginally different title but the same content.
- rayiner 10y agoHis use of the intolerant-minority principle to address the challenge faced by tolerant societies is very interesting.
- mcguire 10y agoCertainly. But if you’re preparing to decide to be intolerant, you may want to ensure you aren't going to be on the receiving end.
- g8oz 10y agoI'm a little confused as to how the West is committing suicide as he puts it. Allowing the sale of halal meat? What a joke compared to the old communist threat.
- iofj 10y agoHere is one thing happened in Brussels when people announced an anti-islam demonstration: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7rcb6iK0EHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7rcb6iK0EHQ Note that the protesters in that video are the "local youth". And that police force is there to prevent the situation from blowing up. There are about 5 anti-islam protestors who turned up and didn't immediately walk off. Local businesses destroyed, wounded with the police, ... the works. But even that is a mere blip on the radar. I've heard about women without islamic headdress being routinely attacked in neighborhoods in at least 3 Belgian cities (Brussels, Antwerp and Mechelen), with constant stories from colleagues that Paris and French cities in general are worse. Constant violence perpetrated by muslims for mostly imagined offenses, things like a school accused of serving pork. The attacks, obviously. The demonstrations and attacks on the police whenever they go looking for terror suspects (I don't know how much more supportive of terror you can call these muslims. They are willing to use violence to defend jihadists, on TV. But of course it is still not acceptable to say there are large amounts of muslims in Europe that support these attacks, not even when a video of hundreds of them doing just that is readily available on youtube here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8DlYB2qw3jI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8DlYB2qw3jI). And of course the political correctness constantly hiding these facts. For instance, the video above is from a news report by the state TV, but it was never sent out like that, and even the shortened version was only displayed once, despite a very slow news day. All other news of the day made no mention of it, and it was gone from the website 30 minutes or so after it aired. This in an organisation that normally leaves those things online for years. The blatantly obvious fact when walking around in those neighborhoods in Brussels is that the muslim population utterly and completely rejects western european values. Stories from people running away from Brussels because criminals focus down non-muslims, with one friend in medicine saying that their apartment was broken in 3 times in a single day and the police attacked when they came to check it out. A week later they moved, making a huge loss on the apartment they bought there. Female colleagues at the companies I go in Brussels complaining about harassment with people shouting "putin" (French for whore/prostitute) after them just for not wearing headscarves (these are colleagues working in companies in central Brussels, it's not everywhere, certain neighborhoods have this). None of this ever getting a single mention on TV. When something does get through (e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKg2UsfnxHc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKg2UsfnxHc in which a muslim convert matter-of-factly discusses his "right" and "moral duty" to kill everyone who isn't a muslim was completely and publicly suppressed from the state broadcasters website and never discussed again, with one message saying the journalist was told that if anything like that happened again, he'd be more than just fired (by his boss, a state employee, not by muslims). At what point does one start making conclusions ?
- bambax 10y ago> Should a society that has elected to be tolerant be intolerant about intolerance? (...) Yes, an intolerant minority can control and destroy democracy. (...) So, we need to be more than intolerant with some intolerant minorities. This has been tried during the French Revolution, one of its slogans being "pas de liberté pour les ennemis de la liberté" (no freedom for the enemies of freedom). It led to Terror and mass executions, so I'm really not sure it's the right path.
- omginternets 10y agoProvocative counter-argument: the revolution undoubtedly benefited future French generations immensely, and led to (arguably) one of the most successful and tolerant nations in the West. Maybe it was necessary to purge the enemies of freedom? French revolution aside (the Terror was, indeed, a dark period I would not like to see repeated), there is an argument to be made for: - the lesser of two evils - the necessity of cracking eggs to make an omelet
- golergka 10y agoQuestion to moderator. I thought HN allowed dupes as long as community found them interesting. Now the post is marked "[dupe]". Did it change?
- DanBC 10y agoIt's always better to email the mods, because they often don't see these questions if they're posted in threads. I'm guessing the [dupe] tag is a mistake.
- bobthechef 10y agoWhy aren't the LGBTQXYZ movements given as a recent example? A tiny group of people (that is disproportionately wealthy and powerful) managed to slide the West from something unthinkable (gay marriage, same sex attraction) into legalization and acceptance of the phenomenon as normal. Granted, we should distinguish between those with persistent same sex attraction and gays i.e. those who embrace the so-called "gay lifestyle" and express support for its acceptance and legal recognition. The left has a history of such manipulation. Saul Alinsky is famous for it. Soros is a contemporary symbol of it.
- taserian 10y agoRegarding same sex attraction, the fact that you never thought of it before doesn't make the concept "unthinkable". History begs to differ with that label. Also, you shouldn't use "i.e." to equate those who are LGBT to those who support their being accepted into society and legally recognized despite not being LGBT themselves.
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoSo the article talks about intolerant minorities taking over and we have the comments section here taken over by intolerant minorities pushing their agendas. I feel like this is an elaborate joke.