10 ms·
Too Poor to Afford the Internet
- kyleblarson 10y agoIn Seattle you can borrow a 4g hotspot from the library: http://www.spl.org/library-collection/spl-hotspot http://www.spl.org/library-collection/spl-hotspot
- droopyEyelids 10y agoWhat they don't talk about is the real struggle the less-literate face, even when they have access to computers. I tried to teach a class on computers in my local library and that was often the hurdle. Adults who want 'computer training' are most excited about getting a job. But while it's easy to teach them to move the cursor and click on the browser, that doesn't do any good when they can't write enough to search, or read job descriptions, or write their resume.
- virtuexru 10y agoWhen TWC stops providing horrible internet service for astronomical prices then maybe things will change.
- randyrand 10y agoWhat incentive do they have to do that?
- hbcondo714 10y agoThat will hopefully come soon enough - https://www.charter.com/merger-twc https://www.charter.com/merger-twc
- leereeves 10y agoDoesn't reducing the number of suppliers of a product tend to reduce competition and increase prices?
- DiabloD3 10y agoCharter was the only cable company allowed to buy TWC because of their track record. Both Comcast and Cox considered it, and the FCC straight up said no, they would never approve it. The former Adelphia areas that went to Comcast got marginally better (more uniform towards product offerings in line with existing Comcast), but are still overpriced shit, and the areas that TWC got worse to match TWC's existing shittyness. Given how TWC is a toxic shithole of a company, and Comcast is barely any different, Charter has actually made a name for themselves for being customer oriented, not short term anti-profit like the other two, and the FCC happily allowed the merger. Charter's pricing is generally lower, their customer support is generally better, and they actually rebuild areas they buy instead of letting them rot like TWC (and also Verizon, on the teleco side). tl;dr if the companies refuse to compete, how is any of it considered "competition"?
- lumberjack 10y agoRather than home internet access. I'd create safe study places for these kids to do their homework and even just hang around in. Children in poverty often suffer from dysfunctional families that disrupt their studying and lack of life mentors to motivate them to pay attention in school. If you could have supervised after school hours just for these kids to do their homework and maybe engage in a bit of self learning it would be much more useful than having home internet access.
- iqisracist 10y agoLibraries?
- stcredzero 10y agoMy Librarian friend did indeed do a lot of social work while working for Houston area Public Libraries. If you want to engage in outreach in a location like that, then provide internet, clean bathrooms, air conditioning, and entertainment/activities.
- cylinder 10y agoMany / most schools have after school programs for this reason.
- superuser2 10y agoI have limited experience with these, but don't they tend to be like 45 minutes to an hour? You need to go at least as far as dinner time if you want kids to actually complete assignments there, not just start them.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoI'm torn about this. On the one hand it's clear that access to the Internet is almost as important as other utilies, such as clean water and heating oil. On the other hand regulation is exactly how broadband rollout has been stifled in the past and present by incumbents, and is at least partly to blame why it's so expensive right now. I want it deregulated and opened up to very serious competition. I also want our government to build reliable infrastructure (fiber) as much as is possible.
- __jal 10y ago> I want it deregulated and opened up to very serious competition. I also want our government to build reliable infrastructure (fiber) as much as is possible. I'm not surprised that you feel torn. Those desires are in direct contradiction with each other. Even if you're referring to splitting infra from service, there will still be regulation. You'll also see law enforcement becoming very interested in the fact that interconnects and the last mile are now government property.
- randyrand 10y agoI wish we could have more separation of government entities. Community internet could/should be owned by the community, separate from the government. It could be structured as a private company, where shares are only owned by people within the community and then they have voting rights. Still community owned, but very separate from the more general government. Interestingly this would also allow community members to invest in their own internet infrastructure directly.
- stinkytaco 10y agoThis is how many municipal electrical utilities are operated. Essentially as independently run entities. It's actually worth pointing out that many government bodies are overseen by politically appointees (library boards, parking commissions, liquor control boards, etc.) creating a space in which civil servants are working with much more direct civilian oversight. As lampooned as this is in comedy (see Parks and Rec or Yes Minister), it's generally a fairly effective check against what you are speaking of. My library, for example, has a fairly robust law enforcement inquiry policy set by its board.
- FussyZeus 10y agoI have a weird question: How come the kids congregate outside the library for the wifi? Is there a thing that you can't go in just to use the wifi? I used to do that all the time in college, didn't even have a card.
- jawns 10y agoCan I just say how much I love the way public libraries have navigated themselves into the digital age? They are, as this piece points out, very popular places to access computers and the Internet, and many libraries offer a wealth of digital content. I can check out and instantly download e-books and audiobooks and movies from my library. It's certainly conceivable that they might have transitioned less well. There is, after all, a healthy amount of government bureaucracy in the public library system, and that tends to stymie innovation. And then there's just the pain of transition. Bookstores have felt those pains hard; it's not that people don't want content, but they want content in different forms, and a lot of bookstores just couldn't move fast enough. But I'm really glad to see libraries continue to be generally healthy, and important community resources.
- chatmasta 10y agoPublic libraries are amazingly accessible, but university libraries remain complicit in the ongoing racket of pay-to-read academic literature. Although many university libraries allow guest access during the day, you cannot access their academic subscriptions unless you're on the secure wifi.
- Cyph0n 10y agoMost universities have a proxy service that allows you to access journals and other digital databases from anywhere in the world. My previous university has one that I have lifetime access to (UAE University) and my current university has an even better collection (GATech).
- superuser2 10y agoThey have to be, as a condition of their journal subscriptions. Librarians generally want to extend access as far as possible, but they are terrified of pissing off a publisher and getting a journal taken away from their entire university's community of researchers who need it to do their work.
- chatmasta 10y ago
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoIs it really $50 per month for basic internet in New York? In the UK https://www.uswitch.com/broadband/packages/ https://www.uswitch.com/broadband/packages/ shows the cheapest broadband package - which includes telephone line rental - to be £18 per month (average across the contract when delivered router is included). That's around $25 (you can get "free" with a telephone service). What struck me was the kid in the header image has a swanky new laptop, the story confirms the kids bring their laptops with them. Could they pay their neighbour $10 to leech the neighbours wifi? Do they need swanky laptops or just an internet appliance (my work computer is a 3rd hand toshiba on WinXP! - good enough for net+email)? Do people in the USA tend to go to libraries for wifi rather than [near] to a cafe or other private business leaking free wifi?
- Spooky23 10y agoI live in Albany, NY and pay TWC $80 for a 50/5 connection. $50 gets you 25/1. Our stupid state government gave them more money to make 50/5 100/7. Our library gets a lot of Internet patronage. In our city the library has done a great job of transitioning into a third place. People like to use the "think of the poor children" card, but I see all walks of life there. It's a great place.
- jitix 10y agoDoes TWC have different prices in different places?!! This seems so wrong. I'm paying $45 for 50/5 TWC connection in Raleigh, NC.
- Spooky23 10y agoTotally. My brother in law lives in the burbs where Verizon deploys FIOS 5 miles away (they don't like cities). He can pay $39.99 for my service from TW, or $69 for 100/100 from VZ. TWC is less noxious than Verizon though -- they don't block Netflix, etc in my area.
- freditup 10y agoI live in NYC and pay $35/month from TWC for 50/5. It's an introductory yearlong rate, and goes up to $45/month after a year. But if you ask really really nicely, they'll let you keep the $35/month rate :)
- drops 10y agoInteresting. I live in a country with a minimum wage of $58 a month (Ukraine) and yet the internet is one of the few things that pretty much anyone can afford: high speed connections (50-100mbps) cost about $2-4; rarely more. Are american high prices the result of scummy pricing on the corporations' side or is it an actual infrastructural issue that prevents the ISPs from providing cheap connections to everyone?
- walrus01 10y ago1) it costs a great deal less in salary to pay construction workers to install aerial or buried fiber in ukraine. Or to aim point to point microwave. 2) A network engineeering position that might cost a company $115,000/year in the US could be filled for $35,000/year in Ukraine. 3) Eastern european ISPs are much more "Adventurous" in terms of the low cost network equipment they use for core infrastructure. $1500 Mikrotiks in the same role where a US ISP would use a $15,000 Ciscos or Juniper. Building five to six nines uptime core router POPs with fully redundant -48VDC A and B power is not cheap.
- qaq 10y agoBe it as it may the quality of service is way better then what I can get with Comcast at about 1/10th the price :)
- walrus01 10y agoYour shitty last mile DOCSIS3 connection over 20+ year old coaxial copper is not a reflection of the quality of an ISP backbone... I realize that from a customer perspective the two are indistinguishable, but if you look at the quality of the router/switch equipment used by the top 50 ASNs (ordered by CAIDA ASRank) for major north american ISPs, it's vastly more expensive than what's used in countries where ISPs don't have the budget luxuries for $100,000 routers.
- qaq 10y agoWhat benefit is it to me :)? In all seriousness we run things in US and Ukraine and while in theory you would expect there would be some tangible differences given the concerns you outline in reality they are not there. Major backbone providers also use cisco and juniper gear and are about as reliable as stateside providers. Residential providers due to intense competition offer way better service at a small fraction of the cost.
- gumby 10y agoAnother huge aspect of poverty and internet access is the increasing number of households who don't have wifi but use only their phones for internet access. ("one-quarter of those earning below the median income and one-third of those living below poverty level accessed the Internet only through their mobile devices." https://theconversation.com/many-low-income-students-use-only-their-phone-to-get-online-what-are-they-missing-54213 https://theconversation.com/many-low-income-students-use-onl... and if you want more http://qz.com/580024/more-americans-are-relying-exclusively-on-their-phones-for-internet-access/ http://qz.com/580024/more-americans-are-relying-exclusively-... ) The world really looks different if you only have a handheld device -- it's more read-only and because of caps and expensive mobile plans, you will use it less. In cities there's a chance that libraries can help, but with rural poverty it's really a trap!
- justinph 10y agoKaren McGrane gave a great talk about just this issue. She made the very valid point that many employment portals are neglected backwaters and don't have mobile friendly or responsive designs, making them unusable on phones. That effectively cuts off employers from huge chunks of potential employees and verges on not being equal-opportunity employers.
- wolfgke 10y agoI'm a little bit surprised: Raspberry Pi 3, say, 40$ (current price on Adafruit). Let's say 70$ for RPi + power adapter + enclosure + mouse + keyboard + SD card. You surely have a TV. Use your mobile phone to set up a hotspot - problem solved. If this is still too expensive: There are lots of hobbyists having old RPi lying around. Or companies that have old mouses and keyboards lying around that aren't used anymore and are happy to give them away for a symbolic sum.
- kingnothing 10y agoLearning how to set all of that up is a massive barrier to entry for the technically average or below-average person. With a modern phone, all you have to do is turn it on and you're good to go.
- niftich 10y agoYou need water to be a productive member of society. (Or to survive at all, but that's a prerequisite.) You need food to be a productive member of society. (Or to survive at all, but that's a prerequisite.) You need shelter to be a productive member of society. More often that not, you need electricity to be a productive member of society. Increasingly so, you need internet to be a productive member of society. In every case, the person consuming these resources either: [a] pays for them on their own [b] is provided them but paid by someone else, possibly in aggregate (family, government services, charity) [c] not provided them at all, in which case they are no longer a productive member of society (or worse, near-starving, starving, or dead) Ethics and economic systems notwithstanding, the first few are 'hard problems' that humanity has struggled with for millennia. Internet access is comparatively easy, because the marginal costs of distribution are low, but just like other 'utilities' and 'necessities', the capital cost is high. One way to offset this is to create a market like for electricity, where multiple players, some private, some government-owned, compete at the supply-side and distribution-side, to provide capacity at prices that are close to the cost of (production+transmission) for the area. Luckily, unlike electricity, water, food, or shelter, information can be duplicated, format-shifted, batched, compressed, time-delayed, and the like. If fixed-fiber-based Internet to arbitrary endpoints is too expensive despite the presence of a market, cache or store more content closer to the consumer on CDNs. If last-mile distribution is too expensive, switch to a different last-mile distribution paradigm -- this latter one is what public libraries (and public hotspots) currently accomplish. If bi-directional communication is desired, investigate peer-to-peer solutions. There's so much potential in LANs, WANs, sneakernet, (TV/radio/data) broadcast that goes untapped. We're stuck here because right now telcos are a terrible market and the monopolies are granted at the wrong level; but also because we're assuming that getting direct, end-to-end connection from one of the big telcos is the only way to digitally communicate.
- hnburnsy 10y agoMost providers offer low income broadband which offers service for $9.95 per month with no installation/activation or modem rental fees. Cox even includes access to its Wi-Fi hotspot network.
- Cyph0n 10y agoComcast charges $20 for its cheapest plan (10 Mbps), which increases to $50 after the first year. It's the only option on my area.
- hnburnsy 10y agoComcast Internet Essentials - 10 Mbps Internet service for just $9.95 a month + tax - No activation fees and no equipment rental fees - Option to purchase a computer for just $149.99 + tax - Access to free Internet training online, in print and in person - A wireless gateway, delivering in-home WiFi at no additional cost https://customer.xfinity.com/help-and-support/internet/comcast-broadband-opportunity-program/ https://customer.xfinity.com/help-and-support/internet/comca...
- Cyph0n 10y agoOh yep, you are right. Thanks for linking.
- koolba 10y ago> They’re there during the school year, too, even during the winter — it’s the only way they can complete their online math homework. Why is there homework online? Has this been shown to be better in any way for children learning math or just a cop out by lazy teachers to be able to automatically grade the assignments? I can't imagine learning math with anything besides a pencil and paper (yes even calculators are mostly bullshit).
- mathrawka 10y agoIt allows the teachers to utilize online services built for education, which allow other "features" that online grading does not do. - It provides feedback on how long students are doing each section, so they can identify if students are spending too much time on homework. - It makes it interactive, which for primary school children helps keep education fun. They can even receive awards (gold medals, virtual stickers in their collection, etc) to keep them motivated. But yes, pencil and paper are used for these as you can see the problem and write the answer, but do the work on your own, as needed.
- TheGRS 10y agoI can see the huge cost savings from doing it this way, you can print far smaller textbooks that aren't loaded with questions, you can grade assignments much more quickly and have one teacher do more subjects or classes. I don't know if that's any better on an academic level as I personally loved puzzling out math problems on pen & paper (which I suppose you could still do in your notebook), but I definitely see the cost savings.
- jcrawfordor 10y agoSchool systems and colleges love these online services because they do most of the legwork (grading and grade management) completely automatically, which allows the instructor to have much larger section sizes (without having to hire grading staff). Pearson, the leading provider of these, likes to market them as better for teaching but everyone in education understands that what they're actually better for is bottom-line cost. It's an extremely frustrating trend, particularly since on the whole students seem to uniformly despise these services, but education is highly budget-constrained and this is one of the areas where it really shows. It's either online homework or pay more in taxes/tuition. Edit: while I'm making Pearson sound vaguely evil, I should mention that the cost of these services is usually mostly offset onto the students, as the textbooks come with a one-time-use activation code for the online service that effectively eliminates the used textbook market. Of course in K-12 public school systems, the taxpayers still end up footing the bill.
- clumsysmurf 10y agoI relied on my public library for internet access for years ... luckily though, I had my own computer. Do any libraries have some kind of persisted 'virtualized' environment that migrated between public-use machines? For example, at the library I was at, you could not install software you needed - things were pretty locked down. And one day you may use machine #5, another day it might be machine #10. Imagine you wanted to teach yourself programming. A few tools would need to be installed. I don't see how this would be possible in the library I was in (using public computers).
- Jach 10y agoPresumably the computers had a browser, that's all you need for learning JS programming.
- pimlottc 10y agoI don't recall the details, but the last time I was at the main library in Cleveland, there was a sticker advising everyone how to save to a "cloud drive" so all their files would be there the next time they came back. They had some sort of similar system for the tablets they let you use as well, pretty nifty.
- obihill 10y agoWould it make sense to give libraries a new lease on life and turn them into mini-coworking spaces with micro-finance credit? Apart from how they serve as a conduit for free internet, there could be opportunities to use them to encourage entrepreneurship in those areas that are currently under-represented. Maybe even something worth replicating in other locales.
- tim333 10y agoIt's because of stuff like this that I thought facebook free basics in India wasn't such a bad idea. At least the kids there would have been able to get Wikipedia which you can learn most stuff from.
- shardinator 10y agoToo poor for a NYT subscription :( ... actually just checked their prices, quite reasonable.
- rmason 10y agoThe road to Internet connectivity for the nation's poor originates in Detroit. I know that I've posted this before so forgive me. https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp/digitalstewards https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp/digitalstewards A group of volunteers in Detroit are the pioneers in setting up mesh networks to provide connectivity to the poor. The recipe is to get some benefactors to sponsor one or two fiber connections, campaign with local businesses to open their connectivity and build a mesh network throughout the neighborhood. I've met these people and have come away impressed and a little in awe of what they've done on - little or no money. They've also got some mean technical chops and have setup networks in other cities around the world like Brooklyn, Washington D.C. and India.
- ams6110 10y agoI question the premise. I cannot think of anything I do online at home that is essential to my being a productive member of society. 90% of my internet use at home is for entertainment. It's today's cable TV. It's not essential.
- darpa_escapee 10y agoI'll counter your anecdote with my own: internet access allows me to be paid handsomely for being a productive member of society.
- massysett 10y agoMany government services are offered over the Internet. My county government has an app I use to request services. I find information about state government services such as motor vehicles. The school system has an extensive online portal for parents. They post grades there. Sure you can do all this with no Internet. But it will take much longer, requiring phone calls or in person visits. Plus, want to try applying for a job with no Internet? A person with no Internet at home (or on a phone, etc.) is doomed to be much less productive.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoHow do you think your life would be if you couldn't access the 10% that is not entertainment? I'll argue this stuff will at times be a large quality of life issue especially if you are poor. Like others have said, governments are moving things online. Some things, though available in person, are too far for travel and telephone hours are short. If you are working a couple of jobs, you might miss some work just to do basic things, which is really detrimental. Even simple tax returns give money sooner, which might be the difference between someone having housing and not. Utility companies have started to charge people more if they get a physical bill instead of online billing. Reduced or witholding installation charges if you sign up for internet, cable, or whatnot online. Maybe you just need a phone number. Increasingly phone books are becoming rarer, so you might not have access. Or the number changed, or you need some governement phone number that isn't listed. Maybe you simply need hours or a doctor's phone number. Internet provides this more readily. More and more companies are using online only applications. I worked for a pharmacy that simply did not take paper applications or CVs. They did not have a kiosk in the store. Libraries are great for access, until they are out of your range or you don't have one in your township and have to pay for a card. Many smaller libraries have too few computers, a short time limit (30 minutes), and a lack of privacy. Plus there are transportation costs. Such transportation costs actually are most detrimental to the poor. Now, most folks will have the biggest gain in entertainment. But really, this helps you be more productive as well. You can make small talk at work, you can relax after the day, interact with family, and other such things. It is good for mental health in some respects.
- VonGuard 10y agoIf you know anyone who is too poor for the Internet, if they live in public housing, please let them know about http://everyoneon.org/ http://everyoneon.org/ This is a program that gives people in subsidized section 8 housing super cheap broadband. It's a bout $5 per month and gets you top quality broadband, such as a cable modem. Very similar to the old lifeline phone lines.
- mankash666 10y agoI'm genuinely curious as to why the kids aren't availing the FCC lifeline program. Can someone explain how and why a mechanism built to solve this exact problem isn't working, given that $7B was attributed to 3 communications related welfare programs by the FCC.
- compil3r 10y ago"Today’s technology revolution promises to provide more information, more widely than ever. Yet we have left almost two million New Yorkers in the digital dark." - That is NYC, imagine Detroit, or Athens..
- kwhitefoot 10y agoWhy should one need a library card to use a library internet connection? Last time I used a public computer in the UK they were free for everyone with a time limit. But in Raleigh, NC, only registered card holders can use them.
- lllorddino 10y agoJust steal your neighbors wifi..
- Mister_Snuggles 10y agoMy local library is trying out a pilot program to loan out hotspots[0] the same way they loan out books. The hotspots have unlimited data and it looks like the only real restriction on them, beyond the usual stuff you'd get from a normal ISP, is that you bring them back after the loan period is up. Hopefully the pilot project results in a permanent program. Library cards are now free, so cost isn't a barrier anymore. The City of Edmonton provides free WiFi[1] in a number of places[2], albeit with more restrictions. These mainly seem to be at rec centres and LRT stations, but there are also some parks included. If someone in Edmonton didn't have internet access and needed it, it's available without too much trouble. [0] http://www.epl.ca/hotspots/ http://www.epl.ca/hotspots/ [1] http://www.edmonton.ca/programs_services/open-wifi.aspx http://www.edmonton.ca/programs_services/open-wifi.aspx [2] https://data.edmonton.ca/Facilities-and-Structures/Open-City-Wi-Fi-Locations-Map-View/mhj4-e4bq/data https://data.edmonton.ca/Facilities-and-Structures/Open-City...