7 ms·
"...operating at a level of stealth unusual even for the normally secretive firm." I chuckled at that. When I worked there I participated in no less than a doz
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
"...operating at a level of stealth unusual even for the normally secretive firm."
I chuckled at that. When I worked there I participated in no less than a dozen "super secret" projects. Stealth was the standard operating mode. In engineering I attributed it to the somewhat interesting way in which recognition and promotions were handed out, which was to say if someone else got word of your idea/project and executed on it more quickly they could declare victory and take the glory. So keeping things secret until success was assured was the "smart" play. And it didn't hurt than when things went south you didn't have to take the blame since nobody knew you were working on it. A win-win situation as they say.
Levy makes it sound like a big deal they were being super secret but really? I suspect it was keeping things that might, or might not, happen in the future from becoming part of the questions at a TGIF meeting.
What the re-organization has done has put a spotlight on how much Alphabet is a one trick pony. It's a good trick, and a strong pony, but it doesn't translate into other markets. And several other organizations have been training their ponies hard and are taking away that specialness.
The current road Alphabet is on doesn't seem to me to end in a happy place, so I continue to watch them to see if they will find a way to turn off it.
- marcofloriano 10y ago"The current road Alphabet is on doesn't seem to me to end in a happy place" I think it's a natural (good) road. Alphabet should be a good opportunity for Google owners to invest in outside business with a lot of potencial, like Space X. When you are "just" Google, it's hard from a business view point to invest in outside business. It's more like acquisitions and fusions. But with a strong group like that, you can make more moves with investors money. And Alphabet have a lot. If your bets isn't giving you good results, let's start put some coins outside. But it's just a teory (don't have actual facts to support).
- samfisher83 10y agoIn finance class we learned it should be investors who make that decision not google. Therefore they could just break it into google and all its other companies so the investor can invest what they chose to. If they want to invest in risky bets they can. If they want to invest in core google assets they can. The issue is other than ad words their other bets are not nearly as profitable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- linkregister 10y agoI think that a "should" statement is a bit inapplicable. Investors may choose a different stock if they don't like the particulars of Alphabet. It has some significant downsides: founders owning 10% of equity but having a majority of votes; large investments in ventures unlikely to succeed (Fiber, Calico).
- hueving 10y ago"should" from a market efficiency standpoint. By being an all or nothing proposition, it makes it hard for investors to buy in if they are fundamentally against one technology (e.g. user data mining) but want to support another (e.g. self driving cars). It ultimately results in the entire company being less valuable than the sum of its parts (think Yahoo where it's Alibaba holdings alone were worth more than its market cap). In other words, by having so many diverse bets, investors in Alphabet have to buy into all of those bets. So the number of investors that believe in all of those bets is smaller than the sum of all investors that would invest in each one individually.
- waqf 10y agoI guess nobody ever invests in index funds, then.
- goldfeld 10y agoThe members of an index fund are supposed to have little correlation; not the same goes for Alphabet's divisions.
- twblalock 10y agoQuite a few index funds comprise members that have very high correlation with each other, e.g. funds that track sector-specific indexes in health care, natural resources, etc.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoVery interesting to read your "one trick pony...strong pony" perspective, because it has always been the one constant 'red flag' about watching their growth and expansion into new and cool things. The up-and-down, perfectly natural pattern of experimenting and killing off bits here and there that don't work makes sense for any business. It's just that I don't have an easy time with, um, I guess 'aura' is the right word, of crazy-wild-future-whoa sentiment. I think they can do great things, but growing pains are real in all sorts of businesses, not just the tech sector.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWhat gives me pause is that if "the smartest engineers on the planet"[1] are working at Google, why aren't we reading about Alphabet Space Ventures, or The Alphabet Social Network, or the Alphabet Smartphone company, or the Alphabet Casual Hotel company, or the Alphabet Movies and TV on Demand company, or the Alphabet Electric Car Company. It goes on of course. And the pat answer is that innovation can happen anywhere. But I don't accept that. Google has tried and failed to make phones (Motorola/Android), tried and failed to make social networks (Orkut/Plus/...), tried to make a video business (Youtube Red), Etc and they have been miserable at it. It hasn't been for lack of spending money, and it hasn't been for lack of "brand reach" or customer acquisition. It reminds me Sun's inability to make anything other than a Workstation when it needed to fight Microsoft on the engineering desktop. Sun was organizationally incapable of winning that fight, and Scott McNealy was unwilling or unable to see the changes that needed to be made to empower the company to do that. How? I think you have to look to companies that have been able to make profitable businesses out of new technologies or products that were distinctly different than their initial success. I don't see Google doing that effectively, and the people who I think were on track to make the changes that would have done that, people like Chris Urmson, leave the company (as the article points out). How is it the organization expells the very people it needs to retain in order to survive? There is an apocryphal story of the #1 traveling circus that the author saw as a child, and when he finds it again as an adult it is bankrupt. He asks how that could be and the ringmaster tells him that the star of the show would never let any acts exist that would steal any part of the limelight or glory from his act, and then when the star died and there were no other acts and no reason for people to attend the circus. [1] From some recruiting hyperbole that they spammed out a while ago on LinkedIn.
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoMy wife used to work at Apple. I work at Google now. Compared to the former, secrecy at Google is nothing. Apple takes it to a whole other level.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThey even have a Gestapo. I said screw that and never even applied. http://gizmodo.com/5427058/apple-gestapo-how-apple-hunts-down-leaks http://gizmodo.com/5427058/apple-gestapo-how-apple-hunts-dow...
- rdtsc 10y agoI think one of the underestimated functions of this kind of secrecy is to make participants feels important and better about themselves. "This is super-secret, therefore important. I was picked to work on important stuff, so I must be important". This goes for everyone in the chain including managers "I am managing a team working on a super-secret project, I can't tell you about". That sounds a lot better than "I am managing a team which makes Uber but for dogs". I suspect this is partly also why governments like to classify everything, even stuff that doesn't need to be -- it provides a level of importance and adds ceremony to everything. Which, in turns makes everyone involved feel important.
- nostrademons 10y agoAlso, to avoid making them feel worse about themselves when what they're working on doesn't work out, or when their coworkers are skeptics. My experience was a bit different than ChuckMcM's; I was at Google a couple years later, and my perception was that it was a lot more open internally than any other company I've seen. But when projects were secret or semi-secret, it usually seemed like it was so that the team members could take risks without fear of criticism or ridicule. It's been my observation that for each famous product Google has released, there is some famous person inside Google who tried to kill it. Secrecy is a form of corporate anti-inflammatory, where it's a way of overcoming the natural immune response against any idea that is new and different.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI really like the corporate any-inflammatory idea. I think that really captures it.
- Roritharr 10y agoI will most definitely steal your last sentence as a word of wisdom in our company. We don't need to make things secret, but I sometimes fear our engineers don't try to add new things on their own because they fear the discussion before they've built it...
- danbolt 10y ago
- guelo 10y agoI wonder how many hundreds of billions of dollars all those worthless ponies like Youtube, Maps, Gmail, Android, Chrome, Docs, etc. would fetch if they were sold on the open market.
- blahi 10y agoNot much because none of them are profitable separated from Google.
- devdoomari 10y agobut aren't docs/mail/etc. somewhat profitable from enterprise offerings?
- e40 10y agoI attributed it to the somewhat interesting way in which recognition and promotions were handed out, which was to say if someone else got word of your idea/project and executed on it more quickly they could declare victory and take the glory. Wow, that sounds like a toxic environment, and I would hate to work at a place like that.
- kbenson 10y agoI don't think he necessarily meant within the same company. If Apple or Amazon or some startup do it first, then your project is no longer something new, it's following what's been done already.
- bane 10y agoI think part of the problem was the unclear and frankly, half-assed way it distributed itself. Some of Google's subsidiaries became Alphabet holdings, but very little of Google broke up into separate companies. When it was first announced many people were thinking "oh, okay, S is for Search, Y it for Youtube, X is for X-Labs, M is for Maps, okay maybe each of those should be separate concerns". But instead it's just Google, and a bunch of highly experimental, low return, high risk other random companies with no particular strategy. How many labs are separate Alphabet companies? Why not just 1 lab that's supported by R&D concerns from the rest of the conglomerate? What isn't L for "Labs"? Does GV really need to be a separate company? Why isn't it just part of Google? Or why isn't GV "V for Venture?" That's okay, they also have Jigsaw, Google Capital and probably a bunch of internal investment arms. Do they really need two genomics/life sciences companies? Why are there so many different video companies, but youtube stays part of Google? The approach is entirely disorganized and without any seeming strategy.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Do they really need two genomics/life sciences companies? Presumably this is a reference to Verily vs. Calico. AFAICT, yes; or at least the two have distinct enough missions that it makes sense for them to be separate efforts. Calico is a very long payoff window effort starting with basic research aimed at lifespan enhancements, Verily is a shorter payoff timeline (but still fairly long window, given medical device, etc., commercialization timelines) medical device and treatment development effort.