7 ms·
"Supreme Being is not only imaginary" I was immensely proud when my son at 4 years old decided to stand up in his pre-school class and point this out to everyo
by arethuza 10y ago
"Supreme Being is not only imaginary"
I was immensely proud when my son at 4 years old decided to stand up in his pre-school class and point this out to everyone.
- crististm 10y agoBy the same account, electrons are imaginary as well. Edit for the naysayers: quantum effects too...
- erelde 10y agoThere's proof of electrons... Your screen. edit: there's also proof of quantum effect in the real world.
- tankenmate 10y agoMy favourite one is that Mercury is a liquid at room temperature. It should be a solid, it doesn't form diatomic molecules in gas form, and it has far lower melting points and electrical conductivity; largely because it doesn't share it's valence electrons easily due to a mixture of relativity and quantum effects.
- waqf 10y agoI think you'll find Mercury is a solid at room temperature. You're probably thinking of mercury.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoYou say "your screen" like you imagine that there's more than one mind here .. and you imagine that mind isn't being fed sense-data from a malevolent aliens laptop for entertainment purposes. Being a bit more grounded there's a possibility that it's electron, not electrons too.
- wtbob 10y ago> There's proof of electrons There's also proof of God: to borrow Sir Christopher Wren's epitaph, si monumentum requiris, circumspice. I don't mind a little atheist boy proclaiming his disbelief in preschool, but I wonder how his father would feel about a little religious boy proclaiming his belief in that same school.
- erelde 10y ago> If you seek his monument, look around you This, is no proof. At best it's an argument from authority. You need a little leg up in rhetoric arguments. It has long been decided, by better logicians and theologists than us, that either there's no proof of a supreme being or that it doesn't exist. To borrow vocabulary from another domain, it's a closed issue. Either way is fine, and I've been careful not to disclose my beliefs. edit: I used an argument from authority, partly by sarcasm pedit: musing about languages and brains: I did 3 years of latin classes and was good at it, and although I could roughly understand the latin quote, translating it in English through my native tongue made my brain feel weird, so I took the translation found on wikipedia...
- dagw 10y agoWhy? Should he also be telling them that Santa Clause and the tooth fairy are imaginary? Why can't kids be kids and believe in whatever makes them happy? They'll have plenty of time later to be old and cynical.
- nitrogen 10y agoBecause false beliefs that are later dashed make kids cynical? Being prepared to distinguish reality from fanatasy is an essential skill needed to rise above the whims of crowds. However, if I had a kid in a similar situation as the OP, I might have tried to teach them about the dangers of confronting other kids' parents when those kids stop believing in Santa at four instead of whatever age they'd hoped.
- ganzuul 10y agoThe premise is unfalsifiable, so claims of falsehood are unscientific. Doing this is just as bad as preaching from a book if you care about truth.
- akiselev 10y agoThat's ridiculous. The claim that unicorns and hobgoblins don't exist is also unfalsifiable but we human beings aren't purely rational automatons that can't tell the difference between fantasy and reality. In the absence of falsifiable claims, the burden of proof lies exclusively on the person making a positive statement of existence (that there is a supreme being). If you care about truth, preaching from a book is so much worse.
- ganzuul 10y agoDo you always downvote people you disagree with?
- pessimizer 10y agoKids don't choose to believe in any of that stuff. It's a game for adults that involves extensive lying and often elaborate staging. You're explicitly equivocating between cynical and realistic, here. Everything true is not bad, and the adult world is not all terrible.
- lintiness 10y agoi've never met a more evangelical (from the greek) crowd than atheists.
- nitrogen 10y agoYou really ought to get to know some Mormons ;) (spoken as a former believer). One reason some groups, like atheists or evangelicals, are so vocal is because they believe that the damage done to society by others not sharing their beliefs will be irreparable. This is why beliefs and decisions need to be rooted in reproducible evidence, rather than the reverse.
- sverige 10y agoThere are many kinds of evidence that are not reproducible.
- justinjlynn 10y agoEvidence refers to that which can be evidenced on demand, or rather more apropos, produced upon demand. Therefore, unless you mean something other than the commonly accepted meaning of the term 'evidence', then evidence must be reproducible. Perhaps if you could share some examples, we could explore your definition more fully?
- sverige 10y agoI disagree that all evidence must be reproducible, which is the standard for experimental evidence (simple physics comes to mind). Just off the top of my head, there is historical evidence and geological evidence, for example. Historical evidence (whether documentary or archaeological or otherwise) is certainly producible, but not reproducible in the sense that you can provide the exact same thing again. Geological evidence (again, very simply, like rock strata) is not reproducible. Even saying that this kind of formation always accompanies another kind isn't reproducible. (The "all ravens are black" problem.") There are other logical kinds of evidence that don't meet the "scientific" standard, and yet are quite valid. My objection really is that the original statement was far too narrow.
- nsxwolf 10y agoCan your 4 year old refute Aquinas? It's a little condescending to say he "pointed it out" to everyone, as though it's some trivial subject.
- arethuza 10y agoI was proud of him for stating his beliefs in a context where that would have been difficult to do. The fact that his own beliefs happened to coincide with my own even though I'd never explicitly communicated them to him was a secondary thing.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Retra 10y agoIt is a trivial subject.
- pluma 10y agoEveryone can refute Aquinas.
- sctb 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12274765 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12274765 and marked it off-topic. This is a classic flamewar topic and the guidelines ask us to resist introducing it: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- nitrogen 10y agoI've made this comment in response to this type of moderation before: if comments expressing skepticism (or even cute stories about kids being kids) are detached, but comments lacking skepticism it are not, then a bias is created in which it becomes okay for the religious to discuss those intellectual aspects of their beliefs suitable for HN, but not anyone else. And FWIW, I thought the commenters in this thread did a decent job of not turning it into a flamewar. So if this comment was detached because it received a lot of flags, consider that it may be effectively suppressing an interesting intellectual viewpoint because of one group's disproportionate taking of offense at disagreement, to the point of feeling the need to flag this comment but not other, similar comments that support that group.
- gedy 10y agoWhich is why he did it, and sounds a lot like you posting this here.