6 ms·
As an aside, this is something that's always bothered me. A good car/truck should last decades with proper upkeep but somehow manufacturers have talked us into
by HeyLaughingBoy 10y ago
As an aside, this is something that's always bothered me. A good car/truck should last decades with proper upkeep but somehow manufacturers have talked us into thinking we need to keep buying new ones instead of repairing the old ones.
- viraptor 10y agoFor a specialised work vehicle... maybe. But for a personal car, even if a 20yo one still works perfectly, I'd still replace it with a new one for fuel economy and safety features. We made some serious improvements in that time. 1970s cars are deathtraps in comparison. I mean, in the US ABS wasn't even enforced until 2013!
- mikeash 10y agoThe "somehow" is that they sell us brand-new cars for relatively little money. If new cars cost a million bucks, we'd be keeping ancient cars on the road with gusto, just like we do with airplanes. But since cars are so much cheaper, the point where continuing maintenance efforts stop paying off is reached much sooner.
- mgkimsal 10y agoYour comment reminded me of Cuba's car situation - all they have the option to do is continue to rebuild/repair existing cars.
- anexprogrammer 10y agoIt's rather different in aviation though. There's countless mandatory checks and services along with mandatory engine rebuilds required to keep cert of airworthiness. You also get pretty strict type approval of what you can fit, where, and when. The regs get stricter if it's being used for commercial flying as opposed to private, also if turbine engined. So you get an awful lot of Pipers and Cessnas from the 60s and 70s still flying around with 40s technology carburetor Lycoming engines that are still being made for new aircraft. Just the same for the countless Bell 205 copters flying around with 50s Lycoming turbines. Cars have moved along far more by comparison and stop passing tightening emmissions regs, so they stop making a model or engine. Aviation emissions are often horrifying, though newer aero engines are getting much better. They've even started using fuel injection! edit: e.g. Buy a $700,000 2016 Piper Seminole twin, lift an engine cowl and it'll be a 6L carburetted, air cooled 4, magneto 50s engine, with 50s noise (probably open pipes still) and emissions. Far more 50s station wagon than Ford Taurus. Cockpit will have GPS and some toys though. Probably much nicer seats.
- bdamm 10y agoFuel injection was available on aircraft sold in the 60's. It's complexity is what prevents it from being dominant in aircraft, so you're quite right that a 2016 Seminole does in fact ship with carburetted engines (O-360-A1H6). The fact is that carburetted engines are cheaper to build and maintain, and their simplicity arguably makes then safer (due to fewer equipment failures). Aviation emissions could be reduced through legislation, but people will die as a direct result.
- hueving 10y ago>Aviation emissions could be reduced through legislation, but people will die as a direct result. Or they will stop flying until manufacturers can put out reliable engines. I thought aviation safety was very high because of strict regulations around durability. Surely nobody would be allowed to fly if they were so unsafe?
- anexprogrammer 10y agoCombination of both. There's a reason aviation is many times safer than driving and an expensive field to play in. It came slowly though. An old engine or airframe means they're well understood and don't trigger need for re-certifying. Every time an issue is found or production improvement is made it'll show up in EASA or FAA revised certification, maintenance schedules, time between checks, or even how you're allowed to operate it. Every identified accident cause filters into the system similarly. A famous case came when jet liners were new, in the early 50s. The ground breaking DH Comet, and the world's first jetliner, was mysteriously falling out of the sky [1] with loss of all on board after around a year in service. That was when the world learned about metal fatigue in airframes and stress points. If it hadn't been DH it would have happened to Boeing or someone else [2]. The legacy was such that DH lost commercial opportunity for half a decade, and the world started along the track to a recognisably modern accident investigation and aircraft certification regime. Histories of that period in aviation are fascinating as it was also a particularly vibrant period as all the wartime progress was applied to lots of new designs of civil aircraft. I'm not sure the thresholds differentiating between "it's a new engine now, full prototype testing and certification please", and the aviation equivalent of a revision note, but it seems incredibly low. Those Lycoming engines don't even put out a few more bhp than they did when newly designed back in 1950-something. A simple improvement in say carburettor design that would see a car maker just add the change doesn't happen easily in aviation. That's so some vanishingly rare circumstance doesn't cause it to fail in service with associated loss of life. I dread to think what GA or Transport certification runs in at, but plenty have gone bust trying to make better GA planes or engines. Microlight, Light Sport and homebuilt (lightly certified) sectors have dozens of interesting weird designs and ideas, and experiments with new materials. Even with all that mistakes are made, and people die, especially with new designs. The deaths stop much more quickly than in many other fields. When a helicopter like a Super Puma, favourite of offshore operators, a 40 year old relatively simple airframe and engine has a $15m price tag faster progress becomes prohibitive. It's the aviation equivalent of a minibus. Just it's a very safe minibus with bookshelves full of accident history and safety revisions. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Havilland_Comet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Havilland_Comet [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Havilland_Comet#Legacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Havilland_Comet#Legacy (relevant section)
- ChuckMcM 10y agoSome people have considered building "life cars" which are vehicles designed to run forever because all of their parts can be replaced. On the plus side you only need new tooling when the old tooling starts getting out of tolerance, on the negative side your car looks the same as it did in the 60s. So go back and look at cars in the 60's and ask yourself if the asthetic works for you. So the next step is car chassis that last forever but the body can be replaced. Prior to unibody construction this is how a lot of cars were built. And the 1970's VW beetle chassis was used by lots of people as the starting point for a fiberglass re-make (look for 'VW kit car' in images and see what I mean) That fixes the "look" (sort of) but the body work and interior work is over half the cost of the car. So you don't save too much and do you keep tooling for the 10 year old bodies?
- antoniuschan99 10y agoWhat about safety?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWhat about it? Such a car would always be just as safe as the day you bought it. One would have to sell new cars with the required level of safety equipment but it doesn't change the value proposition of a car that you can always get parts for. What are your thoughts about safety?
- notahacker 10y agoI presume the user meant that vehicle safety tends to improve over time: a modern car is substantially safer than a 1960s model can readily be modified to be, thanks to radical body redesigns as well as innovations like ABS that might be possible to retrofit. I'm not sure the rate of improvement in safety has been quite so large since the mid 90s, but certainly wouldn't rule out significant safety innovations over the next 30 or 40 years that couldn't be retrofitted to a chassis built this decade.
- ChuckMcM 10y ago
- Johnny555 10y agoFew people want to spend the same kind of money on maintenance for their $10,000 car as they do on their $200,000 aircraft. My last car had 150,000 miles on it, and needed around $3000 of engine work (timing chain, head gasket). The car was only worth around $4000, so I traded it in on a new car. But when you have a $200,000 aircraft, a $15K overhaul every 1500 - 2000 hours is worth it to keep it in the air. 1800 hours is equivalen to 80,000 miles of driving at 45mph. Who wants to pay thousands of dollars to overhaul their car's engine after 80,000 miles even if it means that the car will run fine for another 80,000 miles?
- hueving 10y ago>My last car had 150,000 miles on it, and needed around $3000 of engine work (timing chain, head gasket). The car was only worth around $4000, so I traded it in on a new car. I don't understand this logic. You had to put up way more money to buy a new car. Unless you really want a new car, there is no cost justification for buying something brand new that will lose more than the value of your old car in less than a year.
- robryan 10y agoTypically though once you get to that stage the continued maintenance of keeping it on the road is going to quickly run more than the value of the car. If that work would get you another 5 years it would be worth it, usually though something else will be close to failure.
- creshal 10y agoAt some point cars are so old and worn down that you're going to have to replace something every few months, and the maintenance costs explode – sure, you can completely refurbish the car, if you want to, but that's easily in the magnitude of a new car. Labour costs to produce a new car on an assembly line are much lower than those of having two or three (skilled, but not necessarily familiar with your particular model) mechanics take your old car apart and test and reassemble it again. That manufacturers sell spares at a premium and aren't interested in long-lived products doesn't help, but the basic problem remains.
- HNSucksAss 10y ago"manufacturers have talked us into thinking we need to keep buying new ones" Not all of us.
- beachstartup 10y agothe difference is cars are expected to crash and a decades-old vehicle is a safety hazard. it will literally cut you in half if it crashes.
- nradov 10y agoA car will last for decades if you're willing to pay for proper upkeep. But new cars are tremendously safer than those built 10+ years ago. Look at recent crash test videos. If you were going to be hit by a drunk driver which vehicle would you rather be in? The safety factor alone makes new cars more cost effective for many of us (depending on the value you place on your life and health). Safety improvements in light aircraft have been far slower and more limited.
- cylinder 10y agoCheap and readily available finance lures consumers into spending more than they need. Bigger newer houses, more medical tests than necessary, more expensive university, graduate degrees, etc. And then others want to keep up with peers so they get lured in too. If you go outside the US cars will be noticeably older, even rich countries, but still serving their purpose just fine.