4 ms·
Can't quantum physics on its own predict proton radius?
by lostmsu 10y ago
Can't quantum physics on its own predict proton radius?
- gus_massa 10y agoQuantum Physics is a very wide term. To calculate the size of a proton you must consider also all the details about the particles and the forces about the particles. In particular how strong is the strong force between the quarks inside the proton (and the gluons inside the proton). (To use a very bad analogy, you can use Classic Newtonian Mechanics to predict the maximal speed of a car, but you must consider the details of the car, like the size, weight, the size and position of the gears in the transmission, ...)
- akiselev 10y agoAny such prediction would be bound by the least precise constant involved in the calculation. This experiment is truly pushing the boundaries of distance measurement (to the tens of femtometers) so I doubt the rest of our measurements of universal constants are anywhere near precise enough to pull it off. If we could measure all of those constants as precisely as, say, LIGO can measure optical interference spread over many kilometers then it would be possible, but if we could do that we'd probably have already measured the proton's size to within femtometers.
- lordnacho 10y agoPredictions mean nothing without measurement.