9 ms·
FCC loses court battle to let cities build their own broadband
- ruffrey 10y agoSerious question - are there other ways to make competition "legal" again? State and local law on this matter favors monopolies.
- jessaustin 10y agoI think a few state legislators have to be caught enjoying excessive telco/cableco bribery (e.g. "factfinding" junkets, jobs for relatives, etc.), and then they have to lose reelection over those misdeeds, in order for their legislative colleagues to perceive the opportunity that exists to help their constituents.
- socialist_coder 10y agoMore and more unlikely to happen now that local newspapers and tv are no longer paying for investigative journalism. It's click bait all the way, and a story about local bribery is just not bringing in the clicks. As the creator of The Wire recently said, it's a great time to be a corrupt state or city politician.
- ethbro 10y agoI feel like pre-1870s America would have been pretty good too, considering you could flat out buy an NYPD position, among other things. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Civil_Service_Reform https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Civil_Service_Reform
- ryao 10y agoGet the laws overturned through the democratic process. It is easier than trying to get the unelected bureaucrats at the FCC to stop doing stupid things like requiring radios use proprietary microcode (this is why ath10k's radios require microcode) or more recently, tightening rules on how people can adjust radio parameters due to a few people who did stupid things. They are the reason why Asus, TP-Link and others were locking down routers and rather than reverse their mistake, they are playing whack a mole trying to coerce companies to not take the easy road in complying with their requirements. It is easier to elect someone else into the local and state governments than to convince the FCC to fix things when it messes up.
- koolba 10y agoMaybe offer broadband to people in the state next to yours. An "internet swap" between towns. Then it'd be under federal jurisdiction rather than state. This would probably only work for towns close to the border and at best would demonstrate how stupid the legal landscape for competitive internet access has become.
- rayiner 10y agoPass a federal ban on municipalities imposing build-out requirements. That's the #1 thing preventing the 1996 deregulation from being effective. If a fiber provider could walk into New York, Philadelphia, or San Francisco, and wire-up lucrative pockets of the city and steal the local incumbent's lunch, the whole industry would look totally different. It would also help to ban municipalities from requiring franchise licenses to offer video service over their wires. At least until cord-cutting is more advanced, double-play packages are critical to the profitability of services like Google Fiber and FiOS. Municipalities tend to impose onerous terms on the acquisition of video licenses which make it unattractive for competitors to enter a market. It's not like competition doesn't exist anywhere. Low-regulation southern cities like Atlanta and Austin are enjoying multiple providers offering gigabit service.[1] The only reason the same isn't happening in New York or San Francisco is the local government. [1] I mean, just look at the map of Google Fiber cities: https://fiber.google.com/newcities https://fiber.google.com/newcities.
- mjevans 10y agoThe most apt comparison isn't actually possible. The 'last mile' networks are similar in nature to roadways; a service that is a natural monopoly and best supported through government and local community working together. Meanwhile, cars (computers) and gas ('long distance' interconnect) are things that best compete on top of that local natural monopoly network. You should have your choice of ISPs and other data services selling you their content across the local mesh network.
- rayiner 10y agoIt's not actually that much work to run a few sets of fiber along existing utility poles or conduits (which are mostly owned by electric utilities). We're not talking about nuclear reactors here.
- tgb 10y agoAre they run on utility poles? I always think of them as buried, but can't find any information either way.
- mannykannot 10y agoIf all else fails, there is the ballot box (figuratively speaking, these days.)
- choko 10y agoA less sensational and more accurate headline might be: "FCC Losses Battle to Preempt State Law"
- eutropia 10y agoOr: 'Yet again, cable lobbies succeed in legislating the market out of their way'
- goda90 10y agoI agree that the existing state laws are bad and clearly a product of cable lobbies, but the FCC not being able to preempt state laws is a good thing.
- balabaster 10y agoAgreed, nobody should be able to preempt the law... however, what's crazy is that there are many anti-monopoly laws that exist for exactly the reason of increasing competition in favour of the consumer... what I don't understand is how none of these laws appear to apply to cable and telecoms providers. It's the same up here in Canada. Anti-monopoly laws prevent you from establishing a monopoloy, but it still appears to be fine for cable and telecom providers... and Government run businesses such as the LCBO... and in BC, ICBC and I'm sure a wealth of other monopolies that don't appear to fall inside the jurisdiction of anti-monopoly laws that literally apply to everyone else. One law for one, one law for everyone else doesn't appear to be the way the law is supposed to work, I can't fathom why it works this way in this case.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Bluestrike2 10y agoThere are a few reasons, but one of the most difficult is that federal legislators and bureaucrats (hell, we could even include those at the state level) are in a position where they don't actually see that there's a problem. There are a number of telecom companies. Not a lot, but we're certainly not talking about the situation with Standard Oil. At a macro level, there's clearly competition: Comcast, Verizon, Google Fiber, etc. No one can deny that, and that's the level where legislators interact with them. But the problem is that consumers don't actually get to choose between companies; they're largely locked into a particular provider based on geographic location. Franchise agreements, high barriers to entry, etc. all see to that. That's not really an antitrust issue. Utilities, by definition, are functional monopolies. The problem is that broadband is a utility, but a unique one. You can't really differentiate water service or sewage, for instance. But there can be a drastic difference between ISPs and the type of broadband service they provide. At the same time, it's still subject to the same economic factors as any other utility service, making new competition very unlikely. So you wind up with a very dysfunctional market, despite the competition at the macro level. It's a somewhat counterintuitive distinction, but what you wind up with is basically an industry with multiple competitors that don't actually compete with one another at the consumer level because they're just like any other utility at that level. You don't get a choice in water providers, sewage, etc. Everyone is locked within the confines of their particular borders, and while those borders can and do shift, when they do it's more like the trading of pieces of territory than encroachment via competition. And all of this is made worse by the sheer scale of the barriers to entry. As Verizon FiOS and Google Fiber both learned, fiber rollouts are a capital-intensive proposition.
- binarymax 10y agoThe ruling makes sense. FCC is about federal regulations, and municipal broadband is about local law. If a city wants to build its own infrastructure, then it should challenge those laws itself, not through a federal proxy. However, since the FCC controls the airwaves, I could see localities getting started by using a wireless mesh with their help, and then once established branch into fiber.
- mhurron 10y ago"The Federal Communications Commission regulates interstate and international communications by radio, television, wire, satellite, and cable in all 50 states, the District of Columbia and U.S. territories. An independent U.S. government agency overseen by Congress, the commission is the United States' primary authority for communications laws, regulation and technological innovation." Exactly what part of that means the FCC has no place in regulating internet access? > I could see localities getting started by using a wireless mesh with their help That would be illegal in NC, the law the FCC was challenging explicitly states "it is against the public policy of this State for any unit, department, or agency of the State, or any division or subdivision of a unit, department, or agency of the State to engage directly or indirectly in the sale of goods, wares or merchandise in competition with citizens of the State and Whereas, to protect jobs and to promote investment, it is necessary to ensure that the State does not indirectly subsidize competition with private industry through actions by cities and to ensure that where there is competition between the private sector and the State, directly or through its subdivisions, it exists under a framework that does not discourage private investment and job creation" The fact that Time Warner wrote the law and got it passed would be hilarious if it wasn't so disgusting.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 10y agoThere are states that have that type of law far before Time Warner. The original purpose was to keep corrupt politicians from using the power of the state to destroy opponents. Some states actually have specific businesses the state can engage in their constitutions. Allowing a business owned by someone who can regulate / inspect every competitor out of business isn't seen as very fair.
- clavalle 10y agoWhat justification do the states give for forbidding municipal broadband?
- doppelganger27 10y agoI'm not a lawyer, but as I understand it, the states' justifications aren't important to this appeal. The decision that "the FCC is not able to, essentially, remove state laws that prevent the construction of municipal broadband networks" (from the article) doesn't say anything about the legality of the state laws, just that the FCC doesn't have the authority to change them.
- clavalle 10y agoFair enough. I wasn't suggesting it was relevant to the decision. Just, considering the democratic ideal of the government serving the people, I struggle to come up with a plausible justification that the states might give for denying municipalities and I'm hoping someone more familiar with the matter here at HN can shed some light.
- crymer11 10y agoI live in Chattanooga, home of EPB, which was one of the municipally owned ISPs that was hoping this case went the other way. The common argument we hear for the laws that restrict EPB from expanding is that it's "anti-competitive," since they aren't a private business.
- Cshelton 10y agoI'm torn. On one side, I think every community should have the right to build whatever infrastructure they please. On the other, I agree that the FCC is a federal governmental organisation that should not have precedent over a State's rights. Something which has been abused by the courts for the last 50 or so years. However I think everyone can agree that what is happening is corrupt. State/municipality legislatures are taking money and setting rules. It's a tough thing to stop. Can you remember a time when you voted that you were familiar with all the candidates for both state and city positions? I know I can't. Not even close. I usually just vote a ticket. Another question is...why do we need representatives at the city level? Can we not design a system to allow citizens to govern themselves? City councils' are probably the most corrupt governing bodies today. Yet everyone is so concerned with Republican/Democrat and the presidential race that we forget what affects us the most, elected city officials. The whole thing is backwards. There are some improvements to local governments, like [OpenGov.com][1], but that is only the first step. The people of a community should get to decide directly if they want to build their own broadband system, or only allow a select few, large corporations, own it. [1]: http://opengov.com/ http://opengov.com/
- rayiner 10y agoIt's a hairy issue. On one hand, municipalities are purely organs of the state governments. The states should be able to tell them what to do without interference from the federal government. On the other hand, the whole point of the federal government is to preempt state action when it comes to interstate infrastructure like the Internet and the wires that carry it.
- peeters 10y agoHonest question from a foreigner with a slightly less federal form of government: Why is the autonomy of the States so worth protecting? It seems like every time I see a state government clash with the federal government, it's always the state trying to protect some backward law. What are the counterpoints...I know they must exist!
- sinatra 10y agoBalance of power. You don't want one entity to get too much power. One can also argue that a state can be a better/closer representative of its people than a distant federal government formed out of many other states which may have different needs from this one state.
- drewg123 10y agoThis was submitted yesterday as: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12264581 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12264581
- massysett 10y ago"Court stops unelected FCC bureaucrats from lawlessly exceeding the statutory authority granted to it by the people's elected representatives" Fixed that for you
- jessaustin 10y agoWhat about the elected bureaucrats?