7 ms·
The boss, not the workload, causes workplace depression
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 10y agoIt is funny to see this on the same day as the Amazon story, especially with the comment about how Bezos, in the wake of the negative press, encouraged people to come forward and report issues they see. People did, and he fired those who complained. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12260891 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12260891
- clock_tower 10y agoI was going to reference the Hundred Flowers Campaign, but it looks like a lot of people got there before me.
- doug1001 10y agoJB: if you observe a serious problem w/in Amazon, you are welcome to bring it to my attention and i will take immediate action well it looks like mr Bezos was at least telling the truth when he made this offer.
- 0xmohit 10y agoTo elaborate, the things that often lead to unhappy workers also include: - Unknown expectations from the job - Little or no control over decisions that affect your job - Missing feeling of involvement The fair treatment bit is mentioned in the article. The reality is that people tend to be more irrational than they probably ought to be which usually has significant (negative) side-effects.
- brianvan5155 10y agoThese factors indeed would stress people out. Put poor compensation and poor quality-of-living on this list as well, since we now live in a race-to-the-bottom global labor marketplace, and companies are aiming for absolute low payroll costs rather than location-adjusted costs. People will take a job at a unsustainable salary in the hopes of proving themselves and eventually receiving a compensation upgrade; there is a non-zero number of companies out there who have the exact opposite plan as a rule. We can also say that not-every-boss is the irritant in a bad workplace situation, but that's a nitpick. Yes, I've had the bad-boss-in-a-good-organization and I've had the great-boss-in-a-rotten-job scenarios. In the latter type of situation, at least one human in a management or executive role made decisions that adversely affected my personal growth, workplace conditions, or feedback relationship with the company. It was often many humans up-the-chain making these kinds of decisions, in a loosely (sadistically) coordinated fashion, fully aware that their handling of resources was resulting in human suffering. If you have a great boss, both your job and his/her job can still be very, very stressful and limiting. Since we know that it's possible to run companies that don't have chronic worker stress issues, it's very much immoral to put people through this in the service of any business or organizational goals. (This applies to not-for-profit orgs, too)
- 0xmohit 10y agoThe following image sums up the stress/burnout part rather well: http://imgur.com/a/k6MPj http://imgur.com/a/k6MPj
- fallingfrog 10y agoThis is why we need workplace democracy and worker ownership of businesses.. It's no big surprise that the places where there is the least amount of personal agency and the most hierarchical control of employees are the places that are highest in alienation, suicide, and burnout. Whereas the first few founders of a new company work harder and work better than the ones who come later. Because they are free to make decisions and they own what they are creating.
- fallingfrog 10y agoThis is why we need workplace democracy and worker ownership of businesses.. It's no big surprise that the places where there is the least amount of personal agency and the most hierarchical control of employees are the places that are highest in alienation, suicide, and burnout. Whereas the first few founders of a new company work harder and work better than the ones who come later. Because they are free to make decisions and they own what they are creating.
- LeozMaxwell 10y agoThere's also this very real phenomenon: "Retaliation: A Guide for Vindictive Bosses" - http://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffschmitt/2012/12/10/retaliation-a-guide-for-vindictive-bosses/#6fe16402461d http://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffschmitt/2012/12/10/retaliati...
- brianvan5155 10y agoTrue and frightening. There isn't a particularly good reason why a modern middle manager has that much power over their direct reports.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vkat 10y agoEmployees quit their bosses not the company.
- VikingCoder 10y agoMaybe sometimes, not always. I quit to go to a new company, but I would have gladly kept my boss. Actually that's happened to me a couple times.
- Noseshine 10y agoI've got a "me too" comment. In my first job post university, after about two years, the moment I realized "I don't belong here" was when a coworker in the 80% underground open plan office stood up and asked in a loud voice to be heard by everybody "Does anybody need a few project hours for billing? I've got some hours left in my project that you can have." My boss responded "Yes! I'll take whatever hours you can spare for myself and for [Noseshine (me)]". We had to have a billable customer project for each and every hour of our time at work. My boss was great, the "system" sucked.
- T-hawk 10y agoI'll me-too your me-too. I had that exact same situation on a job and left because of it. The only question I ever heard from my boss was "Are you billable?" She didn't care anything about technical quality, career development, tooling, architecture, morale; the only thing that mattered was billable billable billable. It wasn't entirely her fault, it came transitively through her from upper management, the entire division only cared about billable hours, but she sure didn't do anything to help either. Classic "shit pipe" rather than "shit umbrella". The product had a hideous installation process involving hundreds of manual edits to settings in IIS and configuration files. I was deliberately told not to try to improve that via scripting, because they wanted to keep being able to charge customers dozens of billable hours for each installation.
- mgkimsal 10y ago
- greenspot 10y agoThis is content which the typical bullied and vulnerable employee loves to read: 'Yes of course. It's my boss who drove me into depression.' Don't want to sound too cynical but a job is a job at the end of the day and life is more complex. Just blaming the boss for all the misery is a bit too easy. I expect to get downvoted because more people reading here have a boss than the other way round (I guess).
- pionar 10y agoI'm both a boss and have a boss. I've seen from people who work for other bosses that yes, the biggest effect on employee happiness comes from their boss. There's no magic bullet; each employee is different. Sure, it's not always the boss, but a good boss does what they can to help improve that. There's two things a manager needs to do to be successful - achieve the goals you and the company have set for your team, and keep your good people. If you achieve goals but your team leaves, you haven't done shit. You've lost the game and played yourself.
- johnward 10y agoHaving been through a handful of managers in the past few years I know that your direct manager can make a huge difference. My work itself doesn't change but my stress load is way less under my current manager. Just knowing that she has my back makes a world of difference. For example I've never actually had any "career development" type discussion with a past manager. This manager makes sure we have those discussions and then actually tries to put me on project where I can learn skills to help me advance. On top of that I found out she actually gets reprimanded for having these meetings but she fights back saying that it's necessary, and it really is. We have huge turnover and her manager wants her to put less effort on employee satisfaction and career development.
- mfringel 10y agoI suggest taking another guess at why you were downvoted.
- EliRivers 10y agoJust because it's easy doesn't mean it's not true. Are you saying it's not true, or are you just saying it's easy?
- jkot 10y ago> concludes an extensive new Danish study. > A study of 4,500 public employees... at Danish schools, hospitals, nurseries, offices, etc. Public employees in Denmark work 35 hours a week, with 8 weeks holiday for teachers and 5 weeks holiday for others. I really do not think this study applies to people who work 12 hours a day with no holidays. Also it was published in 2013
- throwawayReply 10y agoIt's banal to say "this was 2013" as if such results age so quickly. It amazes me how on one hand "Peopleware" (1987) and "The mythical man-month" (1975) are held up as ground-breaking ideals here but a published academic study is dismissed because "it was published in 2013". As for "Well it's not transferable to 12 hours a day with no holidays", what you're describing isn't reality for most people in most countries. It is not even legal to work 12 hours a day for 5 days a week in any of Europe+. If you are doing 12 hour days and don't have holidays then you are a slave not a worker. + Except UK, but only if you have specifically opted out of the law, otherwise the 48 hour week maximum still applies.
- jkot 10y agoI think mods should add (2013) into title. 12 hours a day is not uncommon. Even in EU and public sector, for example doctors in some eastern countries have to work this way. Anyway, my point is: this study should not be miss represented.
- jeremiep 10y agoI'm pretty sure the results would be even more true for 12 hours workdays. I recently switched jobs and dropped from 40 hours to 35 hours a week and only feel much more productive from it. Working 70 hours week is a guaranteed way to have a mediocre productivity and quality of life. In the end you spend half your time fixing your own mistakes and waste the other half writing said mistakes. You're then much more vulnerable to anything listed in the article.
- HenryTheHorse 10y agoSerious question: how would a psychiatrist distinguish "workplace depression" from your garden-variety depression that strikes people outside the workplace?
- johnward 10y agoI've been to a psych and he has never actually suggested that my issues are caused by my work place but he has suggested I take short-term leave on several occasions. I have refused to do it thus far but that seem obvious that he thinks work is causing or increasing my issues. I've also talked to a therapist's but in general have no other major causes of stress in my life. I make more than double the median income in my area, my family is all healthy and close, etc. Work seems to be a major cause of stress. I've tried to find another job but the interview process in tech is more stressful than the actual work. So many rejections just wear you out over time. To your point I would say the only way they could really tell if it was job related would be talking to each person and ruling out other causes.
- HenryTheHorse 10y agoThank you. So what you are saying is, the psychs view the workplace issues as exacerbating factors.
- 46Bit 10y agoAn abusive work environment is akin to an abusive home environment. Given that at work you don't even have the option of standing your ground, it's at least as bad.
- lormayna 10y agoI had a problem of burnout in the past. My boss was an asshole, he lacked any planning or technical skills, he want impose his point of view without listen anyone opinions. He change assigned priority every seconds and want to take technical decisions without any knowledge. He was crusty when someone try to reply to him and explain a different point of view. He changed position during the time trying to earn merits and charge others to his own faults. He ever defend one of two employees who he like, even if they are completely wrong. Also holiday planning was a nightmare: he pretend to stay one month in holiday and we have to cover this period (I come from Italy where everyone usually go in holiday in August). Unfortunately he was one of the founder and of the owner of the company. When he decided to sell his share, we opened a big bottle of champagne. Now, with a democratic, polite boss (that is also a technical guru) the climate in the office is great and no one want to leave.
- dvtv75 10y agoLucky. My boss, who was very much like that, got a promotion in the owning organisation, and now has more power (and pay), and still runs our place into the ground.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y agoIn my experience this is a common problem in tech startups, often because "the boss" is a "business" guy who is imposing unfair things on engineering. For example, instead of following a lean startup or customer discovery method of determining the product, he is imposing feature-of-the-week management based on whatever random thing a "potential" customer wanted that week, and never changing the delivery date even though the spec (spec? No he just requests a feature, never integrates it with he product design) ... is constantly changing. And this isn't a specific example, this is just something that has happened so often that it seems to be an epidemic. I think Agile is partly to blame for this. Sure, changing direction every 2 weeks is ok, but you have to leave room for designing the new features, you can't just add them to the workload for the next sprint.
- keeringplastik 10y agoYup, I'll buy that sauce. Been there, done that, not again. Testify, brothers!