7 ms·
The bandwidth bottleneck that is throttling the Internet
- joeblau 10y agoFirst thing I did was open the page and try to find the word "Comcast".
- IAmGarrett 10y agoGoogle, FB, and Microsoft own cables. So I can see that it's data-intensive companies. What does owning the cable do for them? They get to rent it out to other companies?
- KaiserPro 10y agoIts a lot cheaper, and you can do fancy things at little to no extra cost. For example, In the UK if you order a leased line for say 100megs, you'll get some geenric fibre blown into the building. That fibre, and the equipment to run it are all capable of at least 1gig, if not more. However you ISP will charge you a lot more for the full line speed. Why? because they can, that and upstream bandwidth costs more. If you are interested in point to point, then getting semi decent dark fibre allows you to do DWDM to get 40 gig per strand (most fibre cables are more than on strand.) a 32 fibre cable (Most of the cost is the physical laying, not the fibre it's self) would give you 1.2tbps theoretical. All for the cost of installing one cable. Also owning your own cables means you can peer directly with other networks without having to go through a third party. (In the EU, and rest of the world at least, The US have some horrid monopoly system.) This means that the cost of buying bandwidth drops dramatically.
- obrienmd 10y agoNote, I haven't been in this world for a few years, so this info may be out of date Actually, a heck of a lot more than that - WDM (wavelength division multiplexing) can give you 40Gbps (or more, though cost per bit per second starts to increase substantially) _per wavelength_, with 40 waves per strand (again, more possible, but cost-effectiveness not as good). So, 1.6Tbps per strand fairly cost-effectively, with more physically possible. That 32-strand cable could carry 48Tbps with a config like this. Upstream bandwidth isn't really expensive if you're selling to eyeballs (i.e. those who primarily consume services rather than provide them). However, as you said the fixed cost of laying fiber is non-trivial, as is the endpoint equipment to terminate all these waves and do something (route, etc.) with the transported data.
- virtuallynathan 10y agoDWDM on commercial equipment is up to >24Tbps per fiber, long haul is about 8-12Tbps (trans-oceanic). I haven't looked into the details yet, but earlier this year Nokia announced a system that can do 70Tbps per fiber. New Sub-sea builds are usually 6 fibers, some large-scale terrestrial builds are up to almost 8000 fibers (euNetworks did this across europe).
- dzdt 10y agoWhy not more fibers sub-sea? I would have guessed when you are going to the expense to lay fiber across an ocean, including a fair amount of dark fiber looks like a good investment.
- virtuallynathan 10y agoThere is a limit to the amount of power that can be pushed through the cable on each end, and each strand of fiber needs a number of Erbium-doped fiber amplifiers, which consume a lot of power. This isn't a problem on land, as you can add power at each regen site.
- kornholi 10y agoRepeaters and equalizers. They go up to 8 fiber pairs, and are probably the most expensive single component for long cables. You need separate amplifiers/equalizers for each single fiber, so the cost strongly depends on the number of strands. Since these repeaters are typically placed every 50-80km, there's a significant number of them in long systems and powering them becomes a challenge. These cables usually operate around 10kV DC at 1-2 amps, and I'm not sure how realistic it would be to go higher. The wire resistance losses are probably already more than 70% of the voltage budget, so you can't really use more current (voltage drop = I^2 R). Higher voltages cause other issues such as dielectric breakdown. Deep ocean cables are actually pretty thin, about as thick as a garden hose, and I doubt you could easily pass more than 15kV. You also have to account for ground voltage shift between the continents which may be as high as 1kV and depends on the weather.
- virtuallynathan 10y agoGoogle, FB, and MSFT all essentially migrate huge parts of the internet between continents (Google Search Index, Gmail Inboxes, YouTube Videos, Bing Search Index, Outlook Inbox, Facebook Profiles, Photos, Videos, etc). This is a ton of data, and they want to keep cost low and bandwidth high. Getting in on the construction keeps the long-term costs down.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- di 10y ago> the Internet is still a global patchwork built on top of a century-old telephone system. No, it's not.
- snw 10y agoit is in germany.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- runeks 10y agoAnd Denmark. Of course, the core internet nodes are not connected by old phone lines, but most of the edge nodes (consumers) are.
- Symbiote 10y agoMost edge nodes in Denmark (6.6 million) are mobile phones, 2.4M are fixed lines. Worldwide, DSL is less than half of all fixed lines. Denmark has decent fibre networks, and cable TV, but i haven't found any numbers for usage. Statistics from http://www.oecd.org/sti/broadband/oecdbroadbandportal.htm http://www.oecd.org/sti/broadband/oecdbroadbandportal.htm
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- k__ 10y agoWhat about the cable networks? Unity Media advertises fiber connections.
- PebblesHD 10y agoAustralias newest, most high-end infrastructure for internet access, the NBN, is based on a mix of 100 year old Telstra copper for last mile (in reality last 4 or 5 mile) connections, 40 year old HFC cable if you're lucky, and if you happened to be really lucky and in an opposition party area when it was originally planned, a little bit of fibre in neighbourhoods. Its an abysmal abuse of the phrase 'cost-savings' as its crippling any attempt to introduce new, more advanced services that need more than about 20mbit continuously...
- excalibur 10y agoThis seems like as good a place as any to complain that auctioning off radio frequencies to the highest bidder is unlikely to result in optimal (or nearly optimal) utilization of scarce resources, and is therefore working against the public interest.
- tw04 10y agoPardon my ignorance, is there a reason we couldn't theoretically just build out a state owned network, then lease back access to the operators? I would it would cut down significantly on infrastructure required, and create better competition.
- runeks 10y agoI agree. I wonder if it would be sufficient to just allow companies to sue each other in case of intentional interference, and otherwise just allow free play. I suspect there is so much value in everyone cooperating that we would more or less sort it out, without needing restrictions on who can operate at which frequencies, by handing out frequency band monopolies to the three highest paying bidders.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- abecedarius 10y agoThat was roughly how things were developing until sometime in the 1920s, according to an old paper in Law & Economics. By my quarter-century-old memory it claimed that kind of approach worked all right and got replaced after a scare campaign and power grab by Herbert Hoover and friends.
- hyperion2010 10y agoFor a fun look at current fundamental limits on bandwidth I found this wikipedia page [0]. Really puts things in perspective. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_device_bit_rates#Bandwidths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_device_bit_rates#Bandw...
- Animats 10y agoMost bandwidth usage is ads and video. And bloated apps and web pages. What else needs much bandwidth? Even HDTV only needs about 20mb/s, and can be compressed down to 8mb/s or so without much visible loss.
- badsock 10y agoSending streaming lightfields for viewing in VR (for live sports etc.) Is going to take every bit of bandwidth we can throw at it.
- flukus 10y agoYep, video/audio aside, most of the textual content and data we deal with is manageable on 56k or less.
- silverforgotapw 10y ago3d
- dzdt 10y agoHolographic video is about 1000000 times as bandwidth intensive as flat images. If we had a million times the bandwidth we would use it!
- Animats 10y agoI suspect that much of the demand for more bandwidth is really a demand for lower latency. It's not that there's a real need for 1Gb/s to the user. It's that the latency is too long under load. Some delay is being inserted by middle boxes near the end user with dumb FIFO queuing. This is sometimes called "bufferbloat", but it's not about how much RAM you have in the router, it's about big FIFO queues. Just prioritizing empty ACKs in the upstream direction can help a lot. If you can't watch video while uploading a file, that's the problem.
- mwsherman 10y agoGood point. The utility of incremental bandwidth diminishes quickly. https://www.igvita.com/2012/07/19/latency-the-new-web-performance-bottleneck/ https://www.igvita.com/2012/07/19/latency-the-new-web-perfor...
- jwatte 10y agoGiven the headline, I thought it was going to say "Comcast."
- ldehaan 10y agothe size of your pipe is not the speed of your pipe. something I think few people understand. better compression and less chatty protocols would certainly help with this issue but the overall solution is using superconductors instead of plain wires. I raise my glass in salute to the day we all have hydrogen superconductors as our pop.