6 ms·
A Prayer for Archimedes (2007)
- noobermin 10y agoI'll say what's probably on everyone else's mind: if this had not been lost and/or had been taken seriously, we'd probably be in space by now. At the very least, we'd be nearer to a theory of everything, figured out fusion, etc...
- ch4s3 10y agoMaybe, but probably not. I don't think math alone get you all the way there. Think about some of the non or less mathy things that are required for large technological leaps. First, I would argue that prolonged periods of political stability are required in order for resources to be put towards something other than conflict. That took Westphalian sovereignty, not a treatise on fluid dynamics or even a theory of economics. Consider also trade, a necessary framework accumulating the necessary ingredients to build new technology. Sure, Archimedes or his successors could have likely worked out optics mathematically, but could they have come by the necessary raw materials and put together a large enough cohort of glass workers to develop sufficient lenses to build telescopes? Probably not. The idea that trade is not zero sum, and should be open didn't come about until the 1700s. Once this ideas was in place, prices fell and it became cheaper to develop new types of goods. I could go on, but my point is that it's far too tempting as a technologist to assume that people in the past were more backwards than us, and if only they had been enlightened enough to follow (insert name of really smart dead person) society today would be so much more advanced. It is easy to forget about all of the social, political, and cultural constructs that allow us to go to the Moon, build power plants, and microwave frozen burritos.
- atmosx 10y ago> Maybe, but probably not. I don't think math alone get you all the way there. Hm, I'm not so sure. When I was studying anti-coagulants, I came across a wikipedia excerpt. Apparently until 1700 AD the most advanced information about blood circulation came from Egyptian texts written in 200 BC. This knowledge came from mummification techniques. Egyptians knew the difference between veins, arteries, amongst other things. So for nearly 2000 years no advancement has been made on the topic, because religion. Indeed, if I'm not mistaken the period is called "the dark ages" and "the middle ages" to signify the lack of any advancement in science - or at least that's how I've always perceived that period. Aristotle had described a sort of scientific method but we had to wait for the Royal Society and Newton to establish what the actual scientific method is. It would have taken only one step between the two in my mind, 100 years should/could suffice. I think parent comment has a valid point. Of course I reckon that all this is pure speculation.
- Swizec 10y agoThe Arab world continued to have great mathematicians and doctors. Advances in science aplenty. But the current world is dominated by Christian societies, so we paint history through our eyes.
- riffraff 10y ago> Indeed, if I'm not mistaken the period is called "the dark ages" and "the middle ages" to signify the lack of any advancement in science - or at least that's how I've always perceived that period. and that is how most people perceive it, but it's a lie :) Basically, they are called the dark ages, because the people who came just after them (i.e. renaissance) wanted to show themselves as "better than the old guys". The middle ages in europe saw the adoption of spectacles, arabic numbers, mechanical clocks, universities, paper and a bunch of other stuff. The muslim word, arguably more religious, had it's golden age during this period too and vast advancements in a ton of scientific fields.
- acqq 10y agoActually, in the field of medicine, in the Western world, really nothing good happened at the times between the Christians came to the power and until the Italian Renaissance, check any good history of medicine. And it was really only because of the dogmatic approach that Christians had. Also, for professional historians, "dark ages" don't mean something "bad" but is a term used to refer to some historical period of some observed area where there's significantly less information on which history can rely to. It's not judgemental, it reflects the facts. And yes, there were periods when the most cities or the infrastructure of some region broke completely. Here's one look at the fact that for almost 200 years there were no coins in England: http://www.numsoc.net/darkages.html http://www.numsoc.net/darkages.html And of course it's a local effect, the Eastern Roman Empire at the same time functioned as a real state and produced new money. And some periods can "go dark" for us not because of something occurring during some time but because something later destroyed most of the evidence.
- foldr 10y ago
- wtbob 10y ago> First, I would argue that prolonged periods of political stability are required in order for resources to be put towards something other than conflict. That took Westphalian sovereignty, not a treatise on fluid dynamics or even a theory of economics. But one also needs conflict (or the threat of conflict) to spur innovation and prevent a lapse into stasis, as occurred with China. One shudders to think how if a few historical events had occurred differently, we might still be living a mediæval lifestyle.
- ch4s3 10y agoI'm not sure I buy that. I think conflict clearly pushes some types of innovation, e.g. antibiotics, but you don't get things like telescopes because the duke of Milan needs to see onto the far hill top. You get those bigs leaps often because educated people are free to sit and wonder or tinker for long months and years with no pressure to produce anything. However one interesting conflict that was quite useful was of a more philosophical nature. Trying to square Christian/Catholic dogma about the nature of the world with the observable world led to some interesting insights by Tycho, Newton, and so on.
- larsiusprime 10y agoThe counterpoint to the conflict bit is that Archimedes was killed during the Roman invasion. We talk a lot about if this or that book hadn't been lost, but if you're gonna take that tack, why not ponder on what would have happened if the man himself had not literally been murdered? If it hadn't been for the Roman invasion, he'd have lived. Sure, like Da Vinci, military applications was a driver of his patrons and thus his innovations. But war was also the very thing that cut his life -- and thus his innovations -- short.
- ch4s3 10y agoI agree completely.
- mathgenius 10y agoThe methods of Archimedes were well known and being built upon up until around the renaissance. Around that time (early 17th century) the Jesuits stepped in and banned all use of "infinitesimals" because... well because no-one could make any sense of it and it threatened the seeming perfection of constructive geometry, which was held up to be the language of the gods. So anyway, if you want to blame someone blame the jesuits, they sent european mathematicians (especially italian) back to the stone age. More here: "Infinitesimal: How a Dangerous Mathematical Theory Shaped the Modern World" By Amir Alexander
- tragomaskhalos 10y agoOld farts like me will remember Carl Sagan's seminal TV series "Cosmos", wherein he waxes lyrical about how disastrous to human progress was the loss of the Library of Alexandria and the scientific and academic culture that it represented. And indeed there's an animated sequence showing a spacecraft with a dodecahedron emblem and Greek text, the idea being that had that culture survived and flourished it would have reached space centuries ago.
- hermannj314 10y agoWhile it sucks the original work was erased to be overwritten by prayers, I wonder if the book only survived this long on account of being an heirloom prayer book rather than a dusty old math tome.
- idobai 10y ago> Archimedes wrote his manuscript on a PAPYRUS scroll 2,200 years ago. At an unknown later time, someone COPIED the text from papyrus to ANIMAL-SKIN parchment. Then, 700 years ago, a monk needed parchment for a new prayer book. He pulled THE COPY of Archimedes' book off the shelf...
- ajdlinux 10y ago"(2007)" in the title, please.
- Fej 10y agoSo - are we going to blame religion for setting us back? That's not a rhetorical question.
- wodenokoto 10y agoI would say no. The book had been around for 1700 years without anyone picking up on its ideas. For a book full of ideas nobody seems to have cared about or understood, that's a long time. Had it not been erased chances, Newton would probably still have invented calculus.
- rimantas 10y agoI would. It does spoil everything.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoBlaming religion for setting back science is lazy. It's a nuanced topic - for each instance of antiscientific pressure you can find instances of e.g. the Catholic Church supporting scientific advances.
- MichaelMoser123 10y agothere were some interesting talks on youtube that covered the Archimedes Palimpsest google tech talk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xe9uQVGkz9k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xe9uQVGkz9k The Story of the Archimedes Palimpsest to 2000 (three parts) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_rHv3OiaVC8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_rHv3OiaVC8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=po-ueHf-mDU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=po-ueHf-mDU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDPvAOLNXH8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDPvAOLNXH8 there was an excellent BBC documentary on the subject, but the video was taken down; at least there is the transcript http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/horizon/2001/archimedestrans.shtml http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/horizon/2001/archimedestrans.sh...
- Noseshine 10y agoI think this comment from the reddit discussion nails it (https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/4wxm2b/til_700_years_ago_a_monk_scraped_off_the_ink_of/d6as8le https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/4wxm2b/til_7...) Comment included below: ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I don't think the invention of calculus was hard. Yes of course it takes a "great person", but there always are some of those around at any one time. What made calculus possible and the reason why it wasn't invented earlier was that it just wasn't needed. All inventions are part of a context. In support of my assertion: When it was needed it was promptly developed twice on the same continent and at the same time. Which has implications for learning calculus: I guess it's especially hard to learn this, or anything, if you don't see a need for it (in your life). I - now pretty old - found out that while I had always been good at school I had forgotten almost everything even slightly advanced in biology, chemistry, and other fields. When I had to learn it I learned only that particular knowledge and only for the exam since that was the only use I had for it. Recently, a few years ago, I suddenly became interested in medical topics - only to understand how the body works, the pathologies don't interest me. Anyway, I had to learn a lot of chemistry, org. chemistry, biochemistry (citric acid cycle is fun, but understanding how mitochondria create energy using that cycle is even more so), and it took me very little time, and this time I won't forget any of it. That's because it now is embedded into a big subject that I actually care about. If I had just to learn the citric acid cycle and only to pass some exam I would learn it - and afterwards promptly forget. Now it's part of a larger "story" that interests me and I actually think about it occasionally while walking around town because it matters to me, and I explain to my inner self whole physiological processes just because I find it so interesting. Same with calculus, if you are an engineer and care about e.g. building a chemical plant to produce XYZ you will care about calculus so much you will learn it in no time. Simply because it helps you. You don't care about the calculus - you care about what it can do for you. Did you ever wonder what language the wizards in the fantasies movies speak to invoke magic? It must be math. It is the language of miracles. You can move mountains, you can put stuff into orbit, you can hit the moon circling around a planet hundreds or even thousands of millions of miles away. Or you can simulate ecosystems on earth. Or pretty much any somewhat advanced simulation of anything, like the weather, or airflow, etc. So the best way to learn calculus is to not care about calculus - but to care very much about a subject where calculus is the magic language to get stuff done. By the way, the wizard/fantasy analogy can be taken further. The "magical items" that they have are actually pretty much exactly how we use technology: Somebody else made it and the person using it has no idea how. Basically, the knowledge of many, in our time often millions of people working together in both space and time, is poured into "magical items". That can be electronics, but even a piece of concrete or steel is a high-tech "magical" product these days. So next time you watch a fantasy movie remember it is actually real, they only got the language and the symbolism wrong. We do live in a world of exactly such magic, but the language is math and we don't wave wands around, wear different clothing than in the movies, and use labs, computers, robots and industrial processes. And boring team meetings to coordinate everybody :) - And a few words about the religion of Europe at the time - from an atheist. I recommend reading up on European history. It seems to me from the things I did read, although I'm definitely nobody who would be allowed to post in /r/AskHistorians, that Europeans owe a lot to Christianity. It seems to me it was what kept Europe at least somewhat together, a unifying force spanning all peoples and kingdoms. Also, the tension between worldly and religious leaders seemed to have been advantageous because it didn't allow one party to get all the power. Since it was a somewhat "orthogonal" force and not directly competing like other kings it could exist in parallel. Also, from what I read it does seem to be true that the monks were chiefly responsible from getting knowledge saved for when it was again needed centuries later, from old Greece and Rome. As for the example of Galileo, I remember that it was in /r/AskHistorians, the actual story is far more complicated and the simple story "church evil, Galileo good" not even close to true. [Here is one thread](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/42bbfx/what_precisely_was_galileo_put_on_trial_by_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/42bbfx/what_...), it was not the only one. (End of included comment.) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The only thing I would like to add to the end is to point out another thing that set organized religion positively apart: No inheritance. Today we perceive the "no family" rule for priests as backwards, but it served an IMHO good purpose. Even today we have the problem of wealth and power being concentrated in families. That aspect of the Catholic Roman church was incredibly advanced IMHO.