4 ms·
>Exploitation of the public's fear, >promises to make the country great again, So any politician running for an election? > rejection by their own party once
by matwood 10y ago
>Exploitation of the public's fear,
>promises to make the country great again,
So any politician running for an election?
> rejection by their own party once they figured out that they might come to power.
You mean, the basic reason the democrats invented the super delegate to begin with?
Not sure how old you are, but when Bush 2 was in power the same comments were made. I guess Bush didn't turn into Hitler so now it's Trumps turn.
- cyphar 10y agoI didn't say that I _agreed_ with the original comment, I was giving examples of why people might draw parallels. Personally (as someone from a non-US country) I think the US's system of government is quite flawed in how much power it gives to presidents -- in Australia nobody gives a shit about the Prime Minister. All that matters is what the party in power is pushing for (and what the representatives vote for). So, while I think Trump in power won't end well, I feel like this is not a problem with Trump but rather with a system of government that allows individuals to have that much power. Just because Trump is the threat _today_ doesn't mean that he is where our attention should be directed.
- bko 10y ago>Exploitation of the public's fear, >promises to make the country great again, Xenophobia. Us versus them. Rejection of internationalism. Lack of empathy towards others (e.g. pro torture, pro going after the families of suspected terrorists, etc). Blatant dishonest and a disregard for facts, even when presented with proof. Yes, when people are caught up in an election, every slight disagreement or preference seems pressing, but this time I think Trump is actually a first in so many regards and has created an alternative to the regular left-right heterodoxy that has controlled America for the better part of the century. This is cult personality nationalism that hasn't made its way to the modern US in any meaningful way until now
- morgante 10y ago> Not sure how old you are, but when Bush 2 was in power the same comments were made. I'm sure there are some who complained of that, but nobody I know did. There is a categorical difference between merely having a different policy agenda (most Republicans) and outright rejecting basic Constitutional principles (ex. religious equality, free press, no torture). I didn't vote for Romney in 2012, but I certainly didn't think he was a fascist. Pretending that all politicians are equivalent is rather ignorant. After all, Hitler was also a politician and clearly he was in fact different, as were dozens of other leaders who around the world who have shared his approach.
- ktRolster 10y agoI'm sure there are some who complained of that, but nobody I know did. Look up "Bush Hitler" and you'll see plenty of images. It's the American national past-time to compare our president to either Hitler or the Antichrist, depending on your persuasion.
- morgante 10y agoAs I said, I'm sure that plenty of people did. Fringe groups will always have extreme opinions. That's different than mainstream news sources and even multiple historians making the comparison. No credible argument could be made for Bush (or any other Republican) being a fascist, but Trump's campaign follows many fascist criteria. Compare the results, to see for yourself that it's obviously a whole different degree: - http://query.nytimes.com/search/sitesearch/#/trump+hitler/ http://query.nytimes.com/search/sitesearch/#/trump+hitler/ - http://query.nytimes.com/search/sitesearch/#/bush+hitler/ http://query.nytimes.com/search/sitesearch/#/bush+hitler/ Or just look at the facts. Bush never campaigned on an explicit central theme of xenophobia and fear of foreigners. Heck, immigration reform was actually one of the stronger aspects of his policy proposals. Yet Trump's most consistent message, by far, is that we need to be afraid of foreigners and minorities—something straight out of the fascist playbook.
- matwood 10y ago>As I said, I'm sure that plenty of people did. Fringe groups will always have extreme opinions. If you consider MSNBC a fringe group: http://www.mrc.org/biasalerts/chris-matthews-compares-bushs-aggressive-iraq-war-nazis-trial-nuremberg http://www.mrc.org/biasalerts/chris-matthews-compares-bushs-...
- ktRolster 10y agoNo credible argument could be made for Bush (or any other Republican) being a fascist, but Trump's campaign follows many fascist criteria. You must be young, or lack memory, because plenty of people said the exact same thing about Bush a decade ago. If Trump wins, lame as that will be, he won't become Hitler. "Many fascist criteria" is not the same as fascist.
- Lordarminius 10y agoIf Bush 2 did not turn out to be Hitler it wasnt for lack of trying on the part of his associates. Americans I find are amongst the most conceited and deluded people in the world. GB2 ran a very bad presidency perhaps the worst in American history; but flag waving idealism prevents Americans from coming to that conclusion.