5 ms·
Microsoft, Sony, and others still use illegal warranty-void-if-removed stickers
- Can_Not 10y agoTo anyone more familiar with the subject: if a company illegally denied your warranty, is there any reason why small claims court wouldn't resolve the issue?
- inputjoker 10y agoNot exactly same, there was a case in India where the user has complaint about company not repairing his purchased hardware saying they don't have the parts anymore and the user has to buy new product for full cost. This was within 3 years of selling the product. Consumer court asked the company to either repair the hardware or give the new product free of charge.
- RileyKyeden 10y agoArbitration clauses. I don't know if those have been tested in court.
- pdkl95 10y agoClauses? Buying a game console at retail doesn't involve a contract. No arbitration clause has been agreed to. (demanding agreement to new terms after consideration has changed hands (such as an EULA inside the shrinkwrap or on first-boot) is not how contracts work)
- monocasa 10y agoA few years ago I would have said that requiring millions of people to give up the ability to collectively sue in a class action via an obviously asymmetric contract wasn't how contracts worked either. I would not be surprised to see EULAs get more legal teeth at some point here.
- edoceo 10y agoIn USA small claims cannot be used for a person suing a company. Its why there are not 1000s of small claims against Comcast
- noxryan 10y agoI've never heard of any restrictions suing a company in small claims. It looks like it does happen from time to time: https://consumerist.com/2010/04/09/judge-forces-comcast-to-pay-customer-5087/ https://consumerist.com/2010/04/09/judge-forces-comcast-to-p...
- gruez 10y agoEmphasis on the last paragraph Most people don’t realize how easy it is to file a small claims court, and how good your odds are. You don’t even need a lawyer and it could cost only $50 in filing fees. To learn more about how to file in small claims, check out our posts, “How To File A Lawsuit” and “Suing Big Companies In Small Claims Court Is Fun And Easy.”
- nommm-nommm 10y agoHuh? What? This isn't remotely true at all, not in the least. You can sue a company in small claims court all you want, a company can and does also sue you in small claims court as well. My sister in law was sued in small claims court by a large company. If that were true nobody would be allowed to sue their landlord since many (most?) landlords operate as LLCs. Small claims court is the primary way landlord-tenant laws are enforced. Even if it was, nobody brings a small claims case in federal court, even if that was allowed. You bring a case in your State court and every single State has different rules and procedures for small claims court. There are plenty of small claims against Comcast. https://consumerist.com/2008/01/21/suing-big-companies-in-small-claims-court-is-fun-and-easy/ https://consumerist.com/2008/01/21/suing-big-companies-in-sm...
- edoceo 10y agoThank you! I had bad data.
- tombrossman 10y agoTL;DR - The possibility of Small Claims + attention to detail is all it takes, you rarely have to actually file and appear. I've done this with Sprint in the USA, and later with LG and HTC in the UK (they call it 'Petty Debts' but it's basically like Small Claims in the USA). Bottom line is that these stickers are effective - much like the parking lot signs that say how the lot owners 'accept no liability' for damage to your car. Whether they accept liability is irrelevant, you can still sue and a court may assign liability whether they like it or accept it or not. This point is overlooked by many who don't want the hassle and that's why such signs (and stickers) are effective. They are just part of a layered defense, and anyone with the will to pursue a claim can still prevail. It's not as if you show up in court and they point to the damaged sticker on your laptop and the judge says 'case dismissed' or whatever. They have to actually defend their point that their warranty does not apply because of some silly sticker (it almost certainly does). LG, Sprint, and HTC all did the right thing ultimately when I sent a properly formatted business letter demanding that they uphold their end of the warranty terms, and giving them a deadline of ten days to comply or they were going to be sued in Small Claims. I kept it short and sweet, and attached a comprehensive time-line with exact times, dates, and names of everyone involved's correspondence and what they said. It was a bit of a hassle but still cheaper than repairing or replacing an expensive handset off-contract. They'll usually send an NDA that they want signed before they pay out, and you can ignore that and let them know the ten-day clock is still ticking. They may also ask you to log in to their support website which subjects you to additional T&C's more restrictive than your legal rights - avoid that, it's a minefield! Stick to registered postal mail sent to the companies registered business address. I think they assess what it will cost to repair versus what it will cost them to show up in some random county court, and cut their losses when it becomes clear a customer has no intention of giving up. Having complete documentation plus a time-line with everyone's names that you spoke to is the single most effective tool to win when you are up against a big company, so always plan offensively from the start of any trouble with a device and keep a simple text file that you maintain for reference. You shouldn't do any of the above if you really did break the device by doing something stupid, just take the loss and buy a cheap or refurb replacement. Don't try to lie and plan on them not showing up and you winning a default judgement. But if the company is doing you wrong, by all means go after those bastards.
- benologist 10y agoAnother area like this is refund policies, Australia recently found Steam was violating consumer protection laws for their former refund policy that was designed to deny refunds. Lots of sites/services continue to have similar policies. http://www.smh.com.au/business/consumer-affairs/online-games-giant-valve-found-to-have-breached-australian-consumer-law-20160329-gnt2wd.html http://www.smh.com.au/business/consumer-affairs/online-games...
- Kenji 10y agoSo, does that mean I am allowed to open up my Xbox One once in a while to maintain and/or clean it (the dust that accumulates in fan-cooled systems is insane, expecially over a timespan of years)? I feel like it would cost me more money and trouble if it breaks and they refuse warranty.
- messe 10y agoIt likely depends on your country's, state's or local area's laws.
- etatoby 10y ago> expecially over a timespan of years The warranty for most products is limited to one year (two in the EU by law, sometimes three if you pay more.) After that period, no company will repair or refund anything, even if it fails spectacularly. As soon as that time expires the maintenance is in your hands, so it's a good habit to start by taking it apart, give it a good cleaning, check for corrosion and for faulty capacitors, maybe upgrade the RAM or the disk if you like.
- monocasa 10y agoMaybe, maybe not. For systemic issues (like the 360's RRoD, and the Wii had dirty laser lens that kept them from reading dual layer discs) they generally fix them past the warranty to stave off a class action suit.
- striking 10y agoIt wasn't that they were dirty, just that a particular potentiometer had the wrong setting on 1% of drives released before SSBB.
- matthjensen 10y agoWarranty-void-if-removed stickers reduce the cost to the company of providing the warranty, among other effects. Outlawing these stickers increases the cost of warranties to consumers who have no interest in opening the hardware. In this situation, it is unclear whether the use of government rule making -- and the use of government force to uphold those rules -- enhances overall welfare. I would be interested to hear from the regulators what assumptions were necessary to justify the policy.
- ghusbands 10y agoThere are many ways one can mislead consumers in order to make more money. Governments typically try to combat this. In this case, by outlawing this particular lie.
- nxzero 10y ago>> "Warranty-void-if-removed stickers reduce the cost to the company of providing the warranty" Yes and no, it's not black & white. I've personally repaired a lot of hardware myself and a lot of the hardware that's "voided" if opened gets returned by me instead of me fixing it myself. While I can't speak for any random person opening hardware, if I break something trying to repair hardware, I accept responsibility for it.
- RainCloud 10y agoSo companies should be allowed to falsely advertise to lower prices? I don't follow the logic here.
- csydas 10y agoI disagree and would like to see evidence to support this claim. I admit my evidence is anecdotal, but when I assisted with computer repairs at a University, regardless of whether or not a user had broken the warranty sticker companies would do whatever was in their power to refuse service or provide improper/inadequate service on machines. As I often worked with foreign exchange students who really needed their machines repair as opposed to buying new ones, I would often act as an authorized intermediary for the students and would work with the manufacturer warranties directly. Numerous times consumers would be accused of having violated the warranty because of "broken warranty stickers" when we hadn't so much as removed the battery on laptops that still had detachable batteries. The machines would be returned to the student having been opened by the manufacturer and then the blame would be put on the student. Combine this with the fact that standard warranties are very short and even a paid for warranty often won't cover the most common damage to portable electronics (water damage), and I guess I'm wondering what you're even paying for. Warranty support is a sham for many companies, and often times the focus of warranty support is to find a way to dismiss the claim rather than honor it. There are some that are very good with their warranty support, but also quite a few that are horrible. Apple, for as controlling and mean as people make them out to be, only have moisture damage stickers inside their products, and their exclusions only include mistreatment of the device and non-certified third party service that causes damage (third party service itself isn't forbidden, just if they wreck the machine, Apple eschews their responsibility). Other companies put warranty stickers right atop screw heads, preventing things like swapping hard drives, RAM, or other easily replaceable components without voiding the warranty, quite illegally as the article demonstrated. So even if there is a cost reduction that can be demonstrated, if it comes at the cost that I can't swap out HDDs on my own without voiding my warranty, I think the extra cost is better, since you're paying far more than the extra few $$$ in order to get the largely non-usable warranty.
- davidgerard 10y agoSomewhat amused in context to see "By using the Ziff Davis site, you agree with our use of cookies." immediately on the page.
- falcolas 10y agoI'm curious to see how these laws will end up applying to Tesla cars, given all of the restrictions Tesla has been throwing up in front of consumers who want to fix their own cars (or buy salvage title Teslas).
- franciscop 10y agoI was exactly thinking about this, more specifically how it affects to the software or battery packs in them.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoI'd imagine the DMCA's anti-DRM circumvention provisions make their software rules airtight, unfortunately.
- acd 10y agoI tend to think about the household equipment my grandma bought that where made of sturdy iron parts and lasted a life time vs the current cheap plastic buy and throw. Examples http://www.antiquesingersewingmachinevalue.com/img/1.jpg http://www.antiquesingersewingmachinevalue.com/img/1.jpg vs http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/71WYLMoKDDS._SL1500_.jpg http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/71WYLMoKDDS._SL1500_.j... old machine http://img.tradera.net/medium/375/231691375_31cc85f8-542b-44ab-a128-8b96230e028d.jpg http://img.tradera.net/medium/375/231691375_31cc85f8-542b-44... vs http://www.xn--grcia-csa.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/10.jpg http://www.xn--grcia-csa.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/10.j... Its like economics and the environment with global warming is running two opposite agendas. The economists wants us to produce and consume more "stuff" because that is good for jobs and the economy. For the environment and global warming we should consume less stuff and repair more of the things we own. If we baugt things that lasts a life time we can stop global warming. I would like to have changed laws which says being to repair the equipment you own is mandatory. There should also be some kind of label which says how long the device is expected to last. Hard drive manufacturers do accelerated MTBF testing so it should be possible for other equipment too. How do we address the economics vs environment issue?
- dTal 10y ago>The economists wants us to produce and consume more "stuff" because that is good for jobs and the economy. Isn't this just the Broken Window Fallacy? All the effort spent making ten shitty products instead of one good one could have been better spent improving our lives elsewhere. If economists want this, they're bad economists. I do see a problem in that the efficiency of manufacturing has far outstripped the efficiency of repair. If you have a fully automated assembly line and you've already put in the capital outlay, it's way cheaper to tell the machines to make another one than it is to pay someone to spend time diagnosing and fixing a faulty unit. This must surely lead to massive materials waste if nothing else. But then you have to ask yourself, is that bad? And if it really is, why isn't that reflected in the price of the materials? Are there unaccounted externalities? If so, then we need to impose those through tax and regulation.
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y ago
- DocG 10y agoSoes anyoneone know,is it the same in EU?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]