3 ms·
I'm going to start calling this claim that "its-the-computer-for-most-people-since-most-people-don't-seriously-use-computers" fallacy. Even if what most people
by joe_the_user 17y ago
I'm going to start calling this claim that "its-the-computer-for-most-people-since-most-people-don't-seriously-use-computers" fallacy.
Even if what most people use a computer for doesn't seem serious, they do it seriously and don't want to have to stop doing it after ten minutes because their machine is completely unergonomic (the Ipad is 1.5 pounds, trying holding that with one hand http://www.apple.com/ipad/specs/ http://www.apple.com/ipad/specs/)
Just as much, if you peel students, office workers, tech professionals and artists away from "everyone", you've got a smaller "everyone" than you'd think (especially office workers). A lot of people don't do that much word processing on their machines. But a lot of people would unhappy if they couldn't do any word processing on their machine.
The Internet has been more successful than any walled garden because people's needs are actually more varied than concept "consumer-end" allows for. I expect the Ipad's failure to reinforce this concept.
- greendestiny 17y agoOk but if we're inventing fallacies then I'm going for "every-device-must-fulfil-all-your-needs" fallacy. I don't think iPad like devices are for average people, I think they're for just about everyone. It won't replace every computer usage, but rather than people rueing having to use these simple limited devices they'll be rueing having to boot up their big ugly expensive machines.
- jnoller 17y agoThat's relatively close for why I'm buying one - I don't want a laptop replacement. I want something more portable that does "just enough" of what I need and want to do on the go.
- jnoller 17y agoTo quote someone else in the thread later on: "Because no one ever held a book steady in their hand for more than 15-20 minutes without getting tired..." I will be very interested to hear real-world feedback about the usage patterns and ergonomics of it as people really use it - and people will, including tech people, writers, bloggers, etc.
- Qz 17y agoI'm always re-adjusting when I do long-term reading, every 15-20 minutes at least. My arms do get tired, I start laying down, rest the book on the mattress/couch and just hold the page open, but then the arm gets tired and you have to roll over and do the same with the other arm. It's arduous work, reading is. And that's with paperbacks. This thing is 1.5 pounds.
- joe_the_user 17y agoI was tossing this question around with a friend. A thick paperback can easily be two pounds. But paperback can folded or even dropped. You don't need to free one hand to interact with it. Amazon Kindle is 10 onces. The controls are to the bottom and the side. It's specifically limited to reading. If a iPad user has to select an icon in the middle of screen on a regular basis, it will be an ergonomic challenge. Remember, a standard desktop or lap is actually already hard on the body.