3 ms·
Praise intelligence -> makes them give up easier. Praise hard work -> could be a subtle attempt at manipulation. Maybe instead we should ask them what they wa
by visarga 10y ago
Praise intelligence -> makes them give up easier.
Praise hard work -> could be a subtle attempt at manipulation.
Maybe instead we should ask them what they want to do, and support their creative activities.
- sverige 10y agoThey are children. The are a big mess of potential without experience. They need guidance from people with experience because they don't know much, even if they have a lot of native intelligence. It's kind of like pruning plants. Some things you encourage, some things you cut off without hesitation. Sounds cold to some, I understand, but once you've raised a few, you'll know what you did right and what you did wrong. That's still better than letting them decide everything.
- erikb 10y agoI don't like this. As a 5 year old you can't even know what you want in 10 minutes.
- GrinningFool 10y agoWhat a child wants to do is what a child wants to do right now. If you ask the same question a few minutes later, you could get an entirely different answer. As adults who have lived through being children, a surprising percentage of us actually do know better than a small child what's best for the small child for a surprising percentage of their lives.
- visarga 10y agoI read once about a highschool boy, a good student, who was shocked when a teacher asked him "What do YOU want to do?". What? he thought. This question has never crossed my mind. Nobody told me I can make my own mind. It was always "teacher knows best" and "parent knows best" and "be a good student and learn what we teach you, do what we tell you". I wrote from this point of view, but I agree that parents and teachers know better most of the time, I just don't know if it is good to try so hard to make sure the child doesn't make any "wrong" choices.
- GrinningFool 10y agoSorry, I missed this reply. I think I was considering a younger age range - and even so, I agree. They need to be allowed to make their mistakes.