11 ms·
I have a lidar question that maybe HN can answer. So this work is super cool and in the future I'm sure we'll have lots of lidar-based devices driving around. B
by azinman2 10y ago
I have a lidar question that maybe HN can answer. So this work is super cool and in the future I'm sure we'll have lots of lidar-based devices driving around. But if we do, won't they interfere with each other and thus render the lidars very inaccurate?
- Aelinsaar 10y agoIANAE but I would guess that it's the same for laser light as any other EM spectrum comms, in that modulation and some kind of packet system would work in tandem with limited range. It's probably not even as hard to manage as Bluetooth or WiFi, being far more directional as it is.
- IshKebab 10y agoI think not, because they rely on sending laser light in a specific directly, but also on receiving it from the same direction. The chances that another LIDAR system is looking at the exact same point a the exact same time is really low. At worst it would cause some outliers that you can filter.
- gene-h 10y agoNo, but the bigger issue may be from laser jammers[0]. Laser jammers are used to jam police speed lidars to prevent them from obtaining a reading on vehicles. Such devices are legal in most places, because the optical spectrum does not fall under the FCC's control. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_jammer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_jammer
- Animats 10y agoThere are easy ways to protect a LIDAR against that, but I don't think Velodyne is doing them yet. The duty cycle is low; a ranging operation takes under 1us, and typical cycle rates are 100Hz. So each beam is live only about 1/10,000the of the time. A simple denial jammer thus needs far more power than the pulsed laser used for ranging. A simple denial jammer looks like a target at zero range, so you know you're being jammed. Note that jamming must the same color as the ranging laser; everybody has narrow-band interference filters that only pass a very narrow color band. That's why this works in sunlight. To defeat a synchronous jammer, the LIDAR only needs to add some random variation in the transmit timing. Then the jammer won't know when to be on. With some random variation, synchronous jamming looks like noise, rather than a solid false reading. This new MIT system requires that the received light be in phase with the laser beam at the light coherency level. That makes it reasonably immune to anything other than a laser that can sync to a narrow light pulse. Not sure that's even possible.
- drewm1980 10y agoEven if each ranging operation is fast, they will be scanning it around, so I suspect the effective duty cycle will be higher. Light bounces all over the place, so two sensors could still interfer even if they are measuring two different paths in space. It can probably be resolved with careful, expensive, and coordinated engineering, but I would expect the first gen sensors to interfere with each other just as primesense cameras do unless the authors explicitly claim otherwise.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]