13 ms·
To Cut Down Poverty, Cut Down the Cost of Living
- chubs 10y agoSounds like 'supply side economics' to me. Great to see Hayek relevant again!
- fsaneq2 10y agoThis reads like a huge tautology. If you cut down bills people have to pay, they'll have to pay less. Brilliant..? > The good news is that reducing poverty by cutting monthly expenses would be a big boost for people on the lower end of the economic spectrum, without hurting the middle or the top Oh, well if you also assume you have a source of money appearing out of thin air (!), then, well, this is just pure genius.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoNotice how one of the largest expenses for the poor are energy and transportation. Then note the cost of renewables driving down the cost of energy, and electric cars on a steep cost curve decline. Technology is deflating costs (to the chagrin of central banks trying to stoke inflation). We must continue to innovate. Remember, there is no need for poverty if clean energy and automation can provide for everyone's basic needs. We are almost there.
- fsaneq2 10y agoOkay, but what does that have to do with the article? It brings nothing to the table. Of course we should innovate and keep bringing costs of everything down; this will happen with or without city planning.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoBut it does! If you're performing city planning, you should be requiring the installation of solar panels on low income housing. You should be ensuring electric vehicles can be supported (as simple as making a weather proof NEMA dryer plug available for each vehicle parking spot). You must ensure that low income citizens can directly benefit from these cost-reduction technologies. EDIT: The only three resources that have been inflating in cost are real estate (can be fixed with policy), education, and healthcare. Those last two can also have their costs driven down with technology. It's first principles all the way down.
- stuaxo 10y agoI guess having denser cities where cars aren't needed would help too.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fsaneq2 10y agoI agree with you, I'm just disappointed with the article I guess -- it seems to dress up completely banal information as research/news. For instance it basically says that a largely fixed dollar amount that doesn't vary that much by house, electricity consumption, looks large if you make $10,000 a year but looks tiny if you make $100,000 a year.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ruste 10y agoIf you do that then they'll just build less low income housing...
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThen we build low income housing ourselves: http://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/these-tiny-houses-can-make-big-difference-austin-s-homeless-n563521 http://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/these-tiny-hou...
- ThomPete 10y agoI think the point is that the cost of living is exceeding the income of working for most Americans. The claim have always been that the market makes things cheaper which I would hold is still true. Yet more and more people become working poor because their income doesn't follow the increase in cost of basic necessities. So something is out of sync and it's worth investigating what that might be.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- _andromeda_ 10y ago> This reads like a huge tautology. If you cut down bills people have to pay, they'll have to pay less. Brilliant..? Au contraire; this is the very essence of what capitalism is. If you employ time preference and amalgamate CAPITAL through savings, chances are that you will be able to use that capital to invest in something – yourself (through skill acquisition), a business, your children, etc. When this is done iteratively, one outcome is often guaranteed; wealth creation. As a millennial myself, I'll be the first to admit that when I learnt of Adam Smith's philosophy on free markets and how self-interest is the best way to fuel an economy, I was irked as many others are. However, I've come to agree that economically you'll have a better outcome if you go with praxeology. A rarity is when you come across an article advocating for forms of laissez faire and fiscal responsibility especially on hacker news. It's refreshing.
- djrobstep 10y agoWe already know how to cut poverty, based on other countries like the Nordics where poverty is lower: Take more from the rich and give more to the poor. Unfortunately, rich people love money too much, so we're not allowed to talk about the real solution, and have to talk about all these fake solutions instead.
- programminggeek 10y agoThat's all well and good, unless you are the one being taken from. Why should someone's effort be rewarded with thievery?
- djrobstep 10y agoQuite. Owners of capital and land must stop their ongoing thievery from workers.
- jgh 10y agoIt's not thievery, it's taxation. If you advantage from the system you should pay back into it.
- stevendhansen 10y agoIt can be both.
- ThomPete 10y agoTaxation is neither moral nor amoral. It's just tax which depending on it's size and how it's used and where have consequences good and bad depending on who you ask. There isn't some objective version of tax or non-tax.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- themartorana 10y agoThis is where shit goes off the rails before it's even begun. "Take" needs to be so much more well explained, because on its face, I agree with you! But, when looked at on balance, simple things like fair working wages also help redistribute wealth down the ladder but aren't burdened with the hyperbole of the rich being mugged by the poor. The argument is forever framed as three sets of hands - one with cash, one in the middle that pries the cash from the first set and hands it to the third. We don't need to talk about direct redistribution by force. Fair market practices and regulations that prevent one from taking unfair advantage of another do the trick just fine.
- vertis 10y agoThis week is national homelessness week in Australia. I attended a panel by a bunch of charities here in Melbourne earlier in the week, and one of the things that kept coming up was the need to do more about affordable housing. In Australia at least the major population centres are very expensive to live in (and there isn't much in the way of regional centres to offer alternatives). It's such a risk for lower socio-economic groups that a bad run of luck can put them into a position of losing their accommodation. Interestingly, some of the stats being shared by the panel indicated that the amount of money expended on dealing with the problems surrounding a given homeless individual are actually more than it would theoretically take to remove them from homelessness more directly (don't know how accurate that is).
- empressplay 10y agoThere's plenty of work in the regional centres (for example Bendigo) for people who have mid-level skills and salary expectations. These cities are hardly the sticks. The truth is people like living in the capital cities because of the amenities, but the amenities are what drives up the housing prices! So, while I agree that the housing prices in Melbourne and Sydney are insane, currently, they would still be quite expensive even in an ideal situation, so wouldn't it make more sense to make regional centres better able to handle / more attractive to lower socio-economic groups / homeless people who can't afford to live in the capital cities? Bendigo, for example, is two hours from Melbourne on the train (which costs less than $20). Seems to me like an ideal place to offer low-cost housing...
- jacalata 10y ago> people who have mid-level skills and salary expectations. The really difficult homeless population doesn't have either of those. That aside, to make Bendigo attractive, you need to move/duplicate all of the social services infrastructure and family connections that people have in Melbourne (which are the 'amenities' that are important to the borderline homeless group). If their kids are in high school in Frankston then many people would rather stay homeless in Melbourne than move to Bendigo. Then if they have existing food bank connections, court dates, legal clinics, etc - it's a big risk to leave this for some temporary housing and a theoretical job.
- eggy 10y agoI think the idea of focusing on reductions in expenses is the right thinking. I am not sure disguising it as increasing social welfare is the answer. I have been teaching all of my children, and ranting about it online occasionally, that a lot of younger people are financially illiterate, including so-called smart or tech people. I was taught live within your means. I grew up below the poverty line in a crime-ridden neighborhood in Brooklyn in the late 60s, early 70s, and now I am living in the impoverished rice fields of East Java, Indonesia by choice. My son bought his own first used car by shoveling driveways, tutoring, working for a tree company all the while maintaining an A+ average at school. Financial literacy is not just being able to balance a checkbook. It is about being able to keep a 3 month to a full year of cash flow right in front of you, whether on a piece of paper or a spreadsheet. And don't tell me it is unrealistic. I did this when I had nothing. I recieved a shoeshine stand and kit when I was eight, and did newspaper routes, sweeping floors for supermarkets part time and a bunch of other fun jobs. Yes, they were fun for me. I smiled and whistled while I did them. I didn't see them as holdovers until I could be a real scientist or write my novel or make my art. Rather I saw them as another day towards buying that telescope on a fire sale at the local hobby store, or a book I really wanted to own, not borrow from the library. Besides, I met some really interesting people while doing them, and some led to better opportunities. Teach your kids the value of a dollar, and have them know what it really means in their gut. That is how poverty will be eliminated eventually in spite of any obstacles societal or otherwise.
- RangerScience 10y agoI live within my means but am not financially literate. It sounds like a good practice for me would be writing down my in/out cash flow - like you say, "It is about being able to keep a 3 month to a full year of cash flow right in front of you, whether on a piece of paper or a spreadsheet". Is starting out really that simple? Writing down what comes in, and what goes out, and what you know will come in and go out?
- toomuchtodo 10y agohttps://i.imgur.com/1rPEkGQ.png https://i.imgur.com/1rPEkGQ.png
- bryanlarsen 10y agoNo discussion about the biggest cost for poor people: rent. And the fix is simple (not easy): eliminate rent control and zoning laws. The rent in Tokyo has gone down despite an increasing population in a very dense city with scarce land availability. Why? No rent control and very lax zoning laws.
- ThomPete 10y agoThats hardly the reason since the exact opposite happens in NY where rent has gone way up at places which doesn't have rent control.
- enraged_camel 10y agoThat's because some places have rent control and others don't. You have to make it like Tokyo where nowhere in the whole city had them.
- ThomPete 10y agoPlease point to any evidence of that claim.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoI'm sorry I mentioned rent control, that's a minor effect. The big factor is the lax zoning.
- 1anh2kqowg 10y agoI think rent control is not very relevant to this discussion of poverty. Most cities in the US do not have rent control. This includes high-rent cities like Boston and Seattle. Getting rid of rent control in SF would decrease market rates, but market rates are so high it's hard to see how they could go down enough that anyone near what we define as "poverty" could afford to live there. I think current low-income residents would be evicted en-masse (because their rent just went from $1000 to $3000), while medium-income and more frugal high-income people would relocate from the suburbs to the city (because market rate went from $4000 to $3000). As a software developer I could afford a better house but you might not be able to get the world's best burrito in the Mission anymore. Obviously there is an ideological split over whether that would be a good change or a bad one. The living expenses of current residents are currently subsidized at the expense of landlords. It's a microcosm of wealth redistribution in general and pretty much zero-sum. However, increasing supply is not zero sum. It increases the total number of people that get a place to live. It's more attachment vs. progress than poor vs. rich. I think we have a chance to build a winning coallition on this issue. Rent control does not prevent development, at least in SF, because it does not apply to new construction. If we can get enough construction going that market rates are decreasing, maybe then it will be time to figure out how to keep Mr. "I've lived in this apartment in the Pacific Heights since I graduated from law school and am richer than my landlord" (Esq.) from saving fat stacks of cash for the rest of his life, without screwing that family who runs a tacqueria in the Mission.
- kazinator 10y ago"A city cannot just give every resident more money” So the answer then is some sort of "rebates", which are basically stamps under a different name (food stamps, "energy stamps", "transportation stamps").
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fma 10y ago"For Philadelphia, the biggest-ticket poverty-reduction item is expanding transportation access" It looks like cities need to focus more on subsidized mass transportation. I live in Atlanta where the bottom line is ALWAYS scrutinized. Our mass transportation system, MARTA, must be profitable. When it's not profitable, a certain segment of society always criticizes it. They don't think of the impacts to society of providing cheap, reliable and convenient transportation. The only impact they think when MARTA is up and running, or expanded, is that the 'unwanted' (of certain skin color) have the opportunity to come to their neighborhood to loot and plunder. I had just read an article that my county is adding more toll lanes (http://www.ajc.com/news/news/local/work-begins-i-85-express-lane-extension-gwinnett/nr9ZT/ http://www.ajc.com/news/news/local/work-begins-i-85-express-...). That is exactly the opposite of what this proposal is recommending. My county is charging money for express lanes to bypass traffic - essentially a privilege of the wealthy - rather than create a long term solution for everyone (and the construction is using tax payer money!)
- wutbrodo 10y ago> Our mass transportation system, MARTA, must be profitable. When it's not profitable, a certain segment of society always criticizes it. They don't think of the impacts to society of providing cheap, reliable and convenient transportation. An easy way to shut up the idiots like these is to point out the extent to which miles traveled are subsidized for car drivers (invariably more than for transit, due to how horribly inefficient cars are). When they're forced to imagine a society without transport subsidies instead of one with only _their_ favored transport subsidies, they tend to quickly shut up. Though of course this only works for people you know: the voting public is allowed to be as dumb and contradictory as it wants to be.
- fma 10y agoActually the polls show the citizens want the railway expanded, but the politicians are the absent minded bigots. They need to be voted out and find a job picking up trash. http://www.myajc.com/news/news/local-govt-politics/poll-gwinnett-residents-in-favor-of-marta/nkwrQ/ http://www.myajc.com/news/news/local-govt-politics/poll-gwin...
- pnathan 10y agoAdd mass transit infrastructure. Strip rent control. Strip zoning that limits density. This dramatically increases supply over a wide geographical range, giving broad choice. Stop focusing on social programs, let market competition itself drive down prices. These things are pretty well understood at this point.
- 0xfaded 10y agoIn Sydney where the cost of living is high, a typical non-skilled wage is ~$20. The result is all service based industries, cafes to full service laundromats, are relatively expensive. However if one is willing to forego the luxuries, it is a livable wage. In this way, a higher minimum wage ultimately leads to a fairer redistribution of income and is in my opinion a possible solution. Reducing the cost of living implies downward wage pressures, which has the opposite effect.
- known 10y agoPrevent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_avoidance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_avoidance and https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_evasion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_evasion
- didibus 10y agoThe best thing I heard about dealing with poverty, is to half the maximum allowed work week. If you made full time 20h a week for a lot more jobs, forcing employers to pay double or triple for extra, then you'd inevitably force people to share jobs. Employers would need to employ twice as many employees, but it would not cost them more. It's an easier sell then higher tax, since people get to have more free time. It also adapts better, since all the offer and demand and market laws would apply. No unjust or artificial taking more from some but not others.
- Qantourisc 10y agoI wish this was try, but for my country and I suspect most, hiring 2 employees is more expensive, even before mentioning any overhead. Maybe we should pay companies for each person they employ ?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- keithpeter 10y ago'Consumer confidence' and growth rates currently big news in UK. Basically, the economy, or at least the numbers used to measure it at present, depends on people borrowing money to buy stuff. "Living within your means" is almost impossible (housing) and regarded as somewhat unpatriotic. Strange times. Back to OA specifically: I take it that the emphasis on transport access implies long commutes to jobs? Any research on the impact of commute time on social factors?
- pitay 10y agoThis article: http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2011/06/perils-commuting http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2011/06/perils-commu... One of the standouts is a 40% greater divorce rate for couples, although that statistic is slightly misleading. 14% of couples with at least a 45 minute a day commute divorced in 5 years of the study, 10% of couples divorced that had a commute less than 45 minutes.
- swframe 10y ago"Applied" education is the best path for the poor. Don't teach the 3-Rs. Teach them how to fix their problems: 1) fight the cycle of poverty 2) weaken gangs 3) reduce crime and drug usage 4) renovate local housing, schools, and infrastructure 5) create and run local businesses 6) employee all teenagers after school and during the summers, etc. Once they have pass those classes, they can learn the other stuff. And this is how we should pay for it. Sell treasury bonds like we would to raise funds to improve our national infrastructure. In other words, invest in poor people in such a way that you can repay the investment from their future taxes. Specifically, pay poor people to work their ass off to fight poverty. (No person should be paid to do nothing; that is a horrible idea.) Allow the wealthy who want to reduce their taxes to keep $x in taxes for every $y they invest in hiring poor people to fight the causes of poverty. In fact, we should create poverty fighting companies who complete and measure their success by the quality of life improvements they cause. The higher performing companies lower the taxes of their investors. (This isn't even expensive. Paying a teenager to avoid a life of crime costs $1000s/year and putting them in jail costs $10,000s/year. Furthermore, providing teenagers with IUDs costs $100s and saves $1000s.)
- matt4077 10y agoJust pointing out some assumptions you're making in your post: 1. Poor people are stupid/uneducated ("Applied education is the best path for the poor") 2. Poor people are lazy ("pay poor people to work their ass off") 3. Poor people are criminals ("reduce crime...") 4. ...and junkies ("...and drug usage") 5. The broken window theory is right ("renovate ...")
- swframe 10y agoAgreed, I made gross assumptions based on my crazy background and experiences. I grew up in public housing (80% welfare families) in East New York (Brooklyn) during the 80s when that tiny (crack infested) neighborhood had the highest murder rate in all of NYC. For the last 3 years, I currently fund the education, teach and mentor several people in the 3rd world who make less than $10/day. The poor people I grew with and I now try to help are ... 1. Smarter than me but don't know how to end the cycle of poverty (one had a baby recently at age of 19 and both parents are unemployed). 2. Are not lazy but work in dead-end 60-hour/week jobs where they are not learning the skills that allow them to make enough to escape poverty and have no time to learn new skills. 3. Are not criminals but have accepted their fate and are not working to change their neighborhoods to reduce the temptation of their kids to enter a life of crime. 4. Are not drug users but drug related crime and extreme violence surrounds them (they have seen dead bodies in the streets on their way to work). Other kinds of poverty exists. My proposal should be adapted to work in the situations I've not experienced.
- member221 10y agoMy name is Charlotte Wilson, from California USA, i was in search a construction loan and a car Loan of $600,000 on the month of April 2015, I tried seeking loans from various loan firms both private and corporate and banks but never with success, and most banks declined my credit because at that time i was down financially, and i tried all means of getting a loan, and all i got was group of scams who made me to trust them and at the end of the day, they ripped me of off my hard earned money without giving anything in return at that point all my hope was lost, i got confused and frustrated, and i sworn never to have anything to do with online Lender's, Till this faithful month of June, i was going through a research on the internet, then i saw a Testimony of a lady called Cathrin Adams, who once had same problem with me, she testified how she finally got her Loan of $210,000 from fidelityloanfinancial@gmail.com When i saw the Testimony, it was so encouraging, then i decided to contact the email, and to my surprise, they responded back to me, then gave me a website, i filled out the form, then i was approved of the Loan that same day, and 48 hours after approval, my Loan was deposited into my account. I still can't believe that good lender's like Rev Jones still exist. Please i advise everyone out there who are in need of Construction Loan or any type of Loan to contact fidelityloanfinancial@gmail.com
- surfmike 10y agoThis study (and they are quite transparent about it) doesn't focus on the number one cost, housing. There is some room for technological innovation there but it's mostly a policy issue. The best-paying jobs in the US are highly concentrated in a few areas, and at the same time cost of housing is skyrocketing in those areas. We could do a lot to improve people's wellbeing by figuring out how to make housing much more affordable. (Technology can help with transit, building techniques, and better remote collaboration software; but policy is required for zoning/planning, and for transit as well).