7 ms·
It certainly was interesting to see reactions to Tesla's announcement of last quarter's production and sales numbers. They had the best production numbers yet,
by mikeash 10y ago
It certainly was interesting to see reactions to Tesla's announcement of last quarter's production and sales numbers. They had the best production numbers yet, thanks to massively accelerated production in the last few weeks of the quarter. But that meant that many cars were in still in transit at the end of the quarter, which don't count as sales yet, even though they pretty much all had a customer's name on them. Thus sales were down for the quarter, and even though it's obvious that this was just because of when the end of the quarter happened to be, the press was full of "Tesla sales are down, they're so doomed" stories.
I can never decide whether the people who write these stories can't be bothered to do even the most minimal digging past the first number they see, or if they're doing this on purpose. Probably a mix, I guess.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoTesla forecasted the production of 17,000 cars. They fell short by about 20%. I think the market was reacting to that more than GAAP figures.
- _ph_ 10y agoBut the production was 18400 cars, which exceeds the 17000.
- mikeash 10y agoTesla produced over 18,000 cars. They had around 4,000 in transit at the end of the quarter, so they only sold about 14,000. Which is to say, they didn't fall short on production, their production numbers were just biased toward the end of the period in question, making for a large difference between production and sales numbers. Edit: see below for slightly more accurate numbers, 4,000 in transit is not entirely correct.
- KallDrexx 10y agoBut that only assumes they had 0 cars in transit at the end of the previous quarter right? Otherwise any cars that were in transit at the end of last quarter are considered in this quarter's 14k sold.
- mikeash 10y agoWikipedia has more accurate numbers, mine were a not entirely great summary: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Motors#Production_and_sales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Motors#Production_and_sa... The delta was about 2,500 cars. Adding cars in transit from Q1 to the Q2 production numbers, then subtracting sales and cars in transit, there are about 1,400 missing cars. I'm not sure exactly what those would be, perhaps filling out their Model X loaner and showroom fleet or something.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>Tesla forecasted the production of 17,000 cars. Tesla can do no wrong with the SV crowd, as evidenced by your statement of fact being down-voted. If you step away from the hype for a second, Tesla are building some great products, but they play a little fast and loose with their numbers. That's why the Street is skeptical. First it's all about deliveries. Then deliveries falter a bit, so the focus moves to production. Then those numbers are low, so the focus moves to the fact that cars are in transit. If there was some consistency with how Tesla represented their financials maybe there would be less scrutiny and skepticism. We hear about things (battery swamp, PowerWall), then they are hardly mentioned. But I think the Tesla fans consider this "sticking it to the man" (Wall Street), even though Tesla and some major banks are tight.
- mikeash 10y agoThey produced over 18,000 cars. If they forecasted 17,000, then the statement that "they fell short" surely isn't a statement of "fact."
- forgetsusername 10y agoThey projected 17,000 deliveries, but in fact delivered 14,000. Up to this point their emphasis has always been on deliveries. But, since that missed, the focus turns to production numbers, which they just happened to outperform on (after a big miss in Q1 on the same metric). What numbers matter, then? They promote whatever "looks best". It's not unusual, but it induces skepticism.
- mikeash 10y agoThat's not what the comment above said. So, again, characterizing it as a "statement of fact" does not seem entirely accurate. They roughly doubled their production rate near the end of the quarter. They have a product that takes weeks or months to ship to the customer. What happened is exactly what you'd expect. Historically, Tesla has been constrained by production, not demand. The numbers show that production has substantially improved, and demand has not weakened, so it's good news all around. Why should that induce skepticism? Just because of what they "promote"? If you're skeptical just based on what they emphasize, are you not allowing your thinking to be controlled by them just as much as the mindless fanboy who parrots their lines without thinking?
- te 10y agoNo, they forecasted production of 20,000 cars. They forecasted deliveries of 17,000 cars. Substantial miss on both counts. Source: http://ir.tesla.com/common/download/download.cfm?companyid=ABEA-4CW8X0&fileid=889927&filekey=27EE2FDA-9C77-4D6A-8CEE-E8DFE45227BA&filename=Q1_2016_Tesla_Shareholder_Letter.pdf http://ir.tesla.com/common/download/download.cfm?companyid=A... Edit: fixed link to correct source, as pointed out below. In this pdf, it's on bottom of page 3, under "Outlook".
- mikeash 10y agoWhere is that info in that PDF? Edit: I guess you mean this one: http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ABEA-4CW8X0/2007076272x0x889927/27EE2FDA-9C77-4D6A-8CEE-E8DFE45227BA/Q1_2016_Tesla_Shareholder_Letter.pdf http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ABEA-4CW8X0/200707627... That does indeed say 20,000. They actually produced 18,345, for a miss of about 8%. They ramped up production from about 1,000 cars/week to 2,000 cars/week, so being short 1,655 indicates that their production ramp-up was delayed by about 10 days. Doesn't seem like a very big deal to me, and a slight miss of estimated production increases is way different from the "sales are down, Tesla is doomed" that got reported.
- Animats 10y agoTesla added an additional assembly line at the Fremont plant.[1] This doubled production capacity. Cost about $100M. They already run two 9-hour shifts and six days a week. [1] http://insideevs.com/teslas-2nd-production-line-capable-pumping-3000-tesla-per-week/ http://insideevs.com/teslas-2nd-production-line-capable-pump...
- te 10y agoThat article is two years old.
- Animats 10y agoGood point. Do they have more final assembly lines now, or what? The info two years ago indicates the final assembly lines were maxed out. Here's a long video of the assembly process in 2015.[1] This is useful, rather than the usual quick montage of cool robot scenes. There was a surprising amount of manual assembly in areas where other manufacturers are automated. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVCCroN7vS0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVCCroN7vS0
- dmode 10y agoJust to clarify, and this mistake is repeated by almost every publication, sales are up by 67%. It is deliveries that "fell short of expectations". There are no demand issues, but rather manufacturing issues. The key thing to look for is cars produced by week, and it seems that they are up to 2000 cars/week by end of the quarter.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tcoppi 10y agoA lot of it is that many investors and media covering the market only care about the fundamentals of the company and quarterly earnings, and can't understand how a company that constantly dilutes its stock and mostly misses expectations/predictions and isn't turning a profit has such a high valuation.
- _ph_ 10y agoBecause its sales volume is constantly raising. About 50% year to year. Also, a lot of the money gets used for building the production infrastructure. Tesla owns now a car manufacturing plant in Freemont and the Gigafactory in Nevada just had its opening party. These are real values Tesla owns. But then, I cannot understand how Whats App could be valued 19 billion...
- tcoppi 10y agoRight, investors won't bat an eye at Instagram, Whatsapp, Airbnb, or Pintrest valuations, but can't possibly see how Tesla is worth $30b. I suppose that is slightly unfair since I happen to think Tesla is fairly well valued, maybe slightly undervalued currently, and obviously investors are the ones supporting that price. It seems like it is mostly a few institutional investors and the general public propping them up right now though, not the sell side firms that can dominate coverage and mentality sometimes.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoThe companies you name receive a lot of eye-batting.
- tcoppi 10y agoMostly by the tech community itself, not the financial or venture capital world.
- pakitan 10y agoAll those companies can pretend that they are part of the "new economy" where valuations are not bound by mere fundamentals like revenue and profit. Tesla, on the other hand, can't do that. They manufacture a tangible product and have a lot of established competition to which they can be easily compared. Currently Tesla's market cap is 150% that of Renault's. A company that sells millions of vehicles, has factories all around the world and makes a very healthy profit for its shareholders. So, Tesla, instead of trading at a discount to reflect the risk involved, is traded as if it's already a successful company 1.5 times the size of Renault. So, if you think Tesla is valued "fairly" now, please, tell me what should be its market cap when it actually starts making profit? $300B? $3T?
- jusben1369 10y agoTo give the other perspective, I think investors and writers fairly expect that Tesla should be able to give accurate predictions 90 days ahead of time. Tesla tells the market how many cars they will deliver to customers. And they get it wrong. It's not really about whether or not their reasons are legitimate. All of their reasons are within their control, vs say an outside shock. I don't know if they're being lazy or just saying "Yeah, but what does it tell us about your business acumen that you can't hit your own numbers?"
- mikeash 10y agoIf the stories were "Tesla missed expectations" then I wouldn't bat an eye. But the stories I saw were, "Tesla sales are down, Tesla demand is falling off, Tesla is dying." Which is not remotely supported by the numbers, missed expectations or not.
- taf2 10y agoNot batting an eye is why the headlines where doom and gloom - they got your attention, mission accomplished.
- jusben1369 10y agoTo be clear, they missed their sales goal. So sales were down. The challenge with Tesla is they do not have a good history of being open and honest about what his happening inside Tesla. So perhaps they missed their sales goals because it was all operational as they say. Or perhaps sales are softening. They have been reducing pricing from what I've heard. But either way, stop lamenting the press when it really starts and stops with Tesla doing what they say they will do or not. Every public company has the same parameters. why don't they just under promise and over achieve if they have uncertainty in exactly how well they control their production?
- mikeash 10y agoIt's not the "sales were down" part that I object to, it's the incorrect conclusions they draw from it. Tesla explicitly stated the reason for the missed deliveries. The published production and delivery numbers match the explanation. I suppose they could be lying, but I haven't seen anybody go so far as to accuse them of that here. I'm not lamenting the press for criticizing Tesla for missing expectations. I'm lamenting the press for taking a number that clearly indicated a slightly delayed production ramp and publishing articles talking about how the company is doomed because people aren't buying their product anymore.
- AYBABTME 10y agoPretty sure they're doing it on purpose. There's so much short going on, it's to lots of people's benefit to create FUD.
- cel1ne 10y agoJournalists often know the story they'd like to write in advance and show a terrible confirmation bias thereafter.