10 ms·
Singapore Is the Perfect Place to Test Self-Driving Cars
- jasonjei 10y agoSingapore also has a political framework that could force self-driving car adoption if the powers that be want it. Things that could be mandated such as self-driving only car lanes and motorways could be possible given the small size of Singapore and the powerful nature of the government. It would be unthinkable at present in America to force all cars on certain roads to be self-driving only. Singapore has the sort of culture that values "safety" over freedom. In America, for better or worse, it would take a long time to mandate these things if they were even possible (considering that the same laws would need to be passed at least 52 times for states and territories). America has checks and balances--everybody gets their say.
- ktRolster 10y ago>It would be unthinkable in America to force all cars on certain roads to be self-driving only. We have carpool lanes
- chris_va 10y agoAnd private tollways
- jasonjei 10y agoThat's only one lane that is enforced to a varying degree (hardly in CA), and subject to cheating. I think in order for cars to become safer we need to force the human out of the driver's seat. Even if we had a hybrid system, self-driving is still subject to other human drivers. Try taking away the keys of Americans. I ride a motorcycle and I would miss riding if it came to forcing people to adopt self-driving, but that's how we reduce highway deaths. Edit: now that I think about it, cheating could be enforced by camera. Assuming the road had a computer network (like a much more reliable Bluetooth), I am sure cars could identify an unauthorized manually-driven vehicle and alert authorities.
- superuser2 10y agoI suspect there'd be a strong selection bias where the only people who'd continue to drive manually would be the better (or at least more attentive) drivers. To enforce that, you could make the licensing regime more like an FAA private pilot rating and less like a token ritual for access to your God-given right to drive no matter how incompetent.
- mikerichards 10y agoyes, it'll be a slow slog, but Americans aren't stupid and understand that fully autonomous roads are controlled by government and bad.
- dxbydt 10y ago>It would be unthinkable in America to force all cars on certain roads to be self-driving only. There are private cities (Celebration, FL), private housing communities (1000s of them), private large corporate campuses, private shipping yards, private military complexes, private airports, industrial hangars - lots of places where you could safely force all cars to be self-driving without any governmental interference.
- jasonjei 10y agoBut I think for it to have meaningful impact we need interstate public roads to have self-driving. I haven't looked at the statistics, but most deadly accidents I read of late happen on interstate roads. Edit: It's unthinkable at present but I believe if a city-state like Singapore undertook the experiment and it was successful it could eventually spread around the world like HD adoption. (That's why I said it would take a long time to happen in America.)
- jessriedel 10y agoBut Singapore doesn't help much with that because its only 20 miles across.
- lokedhs 10y agoSingapore may be small, but within that space (a bit over 700 square km) it has everything larger countries have. Towns, expressways, nature reserves, military bases, airports, etc. Thus, it is an excellent place for testing such things as self driving cars.
- jessriedel 10y agoThe amount of miles driven per year on highway, which is the issue I'm addressing, is much too low. Just need higher throughput.
- lokedhs 10y ago
- CyberDildonics 10y ago> the powers that be That is the long and short of their political framework
- mikerichards 10y agoThat's a good point. Singapore is an autocratic state and very small. It'll be decades (maybe a century) before Americans give up their right to freely drive their cars. The are huge individual american rights to move around freely that can't be denied.
- L_Rahman 10y agoFrom a product development and deployment perspective, it also makes a lot sense to start in Singapore. Unless a product is completely risk-free, it makes sense to validate outside of the largest and most valuable market.
- mark_l_watson 10y ago+1 I think you have it right, the political/social frameworks of Singapore could 'make this happen.' I worked in Singapore in April and I loved the place. I felt very safe walking around at night for exercise, and the whole place was well run. I have read some criticisms of the government but people there seem happy, seemed to be employed, etc. A nice place and I would love to go back there!
- limeyy 10y agoAll this attention to "self driving cars" makes news look pretty poor. It'll take years for them to become reliable.
- ma2rten 10y agoDo you have a source for that claim? I might have fallen victim to Google's PR here, but I was under the impression that they are reliable already - at least in controlled conditions (low speed, good weather, well mapped area).
- adrianm 10y agoYou don't need a source for common sense. It will take years for self driving cars to become reliable. There are many adverse conditions the car will need to be able to deal with in the real world. Weather and all other chaotic systems are not to be dismissed casually if we want self driving cars to become a reality in our lifetime. Just because something will take a long time to reliably engineer doesn't mean it's not a worthy problem to solve.
- Dylan16807 10y agoI guess it depends on what you mean by "reliable". If you mean it won't crash more than a human, then we can pretty much do that under certain conditions. If you mean it will accept a trip 24/7 no matter the weather or road, it will take a while.
- 1_2__3 10y agoDo you have a source for this? Everything I can find is not apples-to-apples - they compare the reliability of a self-driving car under extremely careful and limited conditions, specifically by people who are developing, testing or evaluating the car... To the reliability of cars driving in snow, rain, glare, and operated by people with limited cognitive abilities and reflexes. I don't think that's a fair comparison at all.
- upgraded 10y agoI love the Autonomous trend. When will the government put in actual firm consumer policy to encourage Tesla and other electric car makers to return ?
- startupdiscuss 10y agoSeems like the correct title of this piece should be the less dramatic: "Singapore will also get self-driving cars."
- serg_chernata 10y agoI don't know, there's nothing groundbreaking here but they do explain why.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoI didn't see that. They're not arguing that the US doesn't have places with "flat terrain" or "good weather" or many of the other things. Just that Singapore also has it. Now they are not evenly distributed in the US, so surely in the US it will happen in certain pockets first.
- devnonymous 10y agoI think the important bit is the government buy in and support for this. As far as autonomous driving is concerned, legislation might end up being the bottle neck in most nations.
- czahedi 10y agoAlso don't forget the lack of driving & car ownership by the population. That's hugely important. In the States, the plethora of drivers & traffic creates countless more variables for an autonomous vehicle to deal with.
- startupdiscuss 10y agoI agree with your view on the matter, and the article did suggest that this was the case, however, they didn't show it. In the very same paragraph that the article made note of the government's support, it also conceded that the Delphi already had pilot programs in the US. I would expect to see some concrete examples of laws being passed. I am not, by the way, saying that Singapore is not auto-car friendly or that they won't have them earlier or anything like that. Just that this article doesn't argue that fact. (Edit: Not to be coy with my view: I think all the rich countries will get them at approximately the same time.)
- Someone1234 10y ago> Singapore makes a particularly good testing ground for automated vehicles. Its manageable size (it’s about three-and-a-half Districts of Columbia), flat terrain, warm weather, and well-kept roads provide about as simple of an urban landscape as one could ask for. And its government is supportive of such technology, having formed an Autonomous Vehicle Initiative to oversee research in 2014. I'd argue we already have too much testing under "ideal conditions." I want to see self-driving vehicles tested in snow, in rain, in strong winds, in fog, and on mountain roads. Don't get me wrong, you absolutely want to start developing it under best conditions, but if they legitimately want to get this live by 2020 then we need to expand the scope to less idealised situations.
- czahedi 10y ago>I'd argue we already have too much testing under "ideal conditions." I want to see self-driving vehicles tested in snow, in rain, in strong winds, in fog, and on mountain roads. Unfortunately, the vehicles don't yet work perfectly under "ideal conditions". I think this ought to be the first step. There's no need to have a "blanket" rollout of autonomous vehicles - start in ideal cities and then spread further. Granted, I DO think that they'll find driving in snow/rain/winds to be fundamentally different enough from ideal urban driving that the exact methods the vehicle AI has "learned" may not directly apply. So, it may merit testing in parallel, because as you've said we need to stop ignoring these cases. I guess my point is a long-winded way of saying "Yes we need to test those cases, but in addition to ideal urban conditions, not instead of."
- gpvos 10y agoSingapore is a city, and therefore already quite challenging. I've never been there, but I suspect there will be streets with playing children, scooters, etc.
- notahacker 10y agoCompared with most cities, there really aren't many playing children or other people in the road (you'd set autonomous vehicles to avoid Little India :-) ), the roads are impeccably maintained and there's virtually no traffic.
- uberstuber 10y ago>Perhaps they’ll also help with the Singaporean phenomenon of the seeming complete disappearance of taxis when it rains Are self-driving cars able to handle rainy conditions? I'm not in the industry but thought this was still an issue.
- 1_2__3 10y agoThe very fact that these manufacturers are being extraordinarily cagey about the circumstances under which their automation works and where it doesn't should tell everyone everything they need to know about how 'around the corner' this tech is. Think of it this way: non-optimal driving conditions is nowhere near the last hurdle for full autonomy. We're a long ways off.
- jimjimjim 10y agoThis is a good question. The times I've seen it rain in Singapore or kuala Lumpur it's all or nothing. Fine weather -> 2 foot of water on the road -> Fine weather. I somehow don't think that scenario is in the test plan.
- clock_tower 10y agoAt least it means that you can model RainIntensity as a bool... :)
- up_and_up 10y ago> Are self-driving cars able to handle rainy conditions? Seriously? I pretty sure all current vehicles need to go through extreme weather testing before they can be brought to market. For example my dad worked on a project testing Ford vehicles in extreme cold and snow conditions in northern MN.
- Qworg 10y agoSeriously. All self driving systems currently cannot cope with heavy rain or snow very well at all.
- samfisher83 10y agoSingapore is a country that is less than half the size of houston,tx. It might be more manageable there compared to many other places.
- projectramo 10y agoOnly if there is a particular value in getting the whole country to shift at exactly the same time. What harm is there in, say, letting a suburb of Pittsburgh try it out. Then extend it to Detroit and so on.
- squozzer 10y agoI can foresee several phases in the development of "robocars". Phase 1 - dedicated lanes for robocars, to mitigate problems with the still-dominant human-piloted cars. Robocars capabilities at primitive level, will likely have human-usable controls. Phase 2 - once their safety and compatibility have been established, robocars will freely mix with human-piloted cars. Robocars will accommodate errors committed by human-piloted cars, and will no longer need human control. Phase 3 - robocars dominate the roads, while laws and economic structures (e.g. insurance) will favor robocars. Robocars will have localized coordination capability. Phase 4 - robocars will act in concert over large (metropolitan) distances to smooth traffic flows. Human-piloted cars will become as horses are today - a hobby for the rich. Admittedly, I am mixing adoption phases with technological ones.
- jefe_ 10y agoTest in Thailand... if you can dodge a tuk-tuk, you can dodge a toddler.
- hellofunk 10y agoSingapore definitely has some of the worst driving standards of any major city I've lived in around the world, so if you can stand up against them with a self-driving car, that is definitely promising.
- keldlundgaard 10y agoPlease elaborate.
- Gigablah 10y agoIn other words, the poster hasn't lived anywhere else in Asia.
- hellofunk 10y agoI'm comparing Singapore to other first-world big cities, but there are other places in Asia where you could make a similar claim. One of the most surprising discoveries upon moving there was that, unlike nearly everywhere in the West, in Singapore a pedestrian does not have the right of way. In the U.S. this is ingrained into all driver education courses, but in Singapore they do not even slow down around pedestrians who are crossing a street. The other observation that jumps out to anyone I know who has visited Singapore is how the buses are driven. A Western bus driver would likely lose his job for driving as erratically as they do in Singapore. In fact just a couple weeks ago one of these drivers killed a pedestrian [0, 1]. I'm surprised it doesn't happen more often. Self-driving cars would be in for quite a test on the roads of Singapore. [0] http://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/pedestrian-dies-after-bus-runs-over-him-outside-toa-payoh-bus-interchange http://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/pedestrian-dies-after-... [1] http://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/bus-driver-jailed-for-killing-pedestrian http://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/courts-crime/bus-drive...
- dharma1 10y agoIt would, but there are a lot of "uncles" driving cabs today who would not have any jobs left once self driving cars took off
- system16 10y agoThere were a lot of uncles who lost jobs when rickshaws were banned. Progress requires change.
- jakeogh 10y agoOf course totalitarian regimes want self driving cars. They take control away from the people and all kinds of ways to track the people.