4 ms·
You're looking at the PR, look at the actual technology. Anyone can build a big enough supercomputer if you throw enough money at the problem. This high level
by klodolph 10y ago
You're looking at the PR, look at the actual technology.
Anyone can build a big enough supercomputer if you throw enough money at the problem. This high level of spending is getting hard to justify, however, because most of the problems you want to solve can't be solved just by throwing another order of magnitude of computing power at the problem. Building a supercomputer becomes a bit of a boondoggle, a public-relations move.
But China can't build the components for those supercomputers. Nobody can build all of them, but China can't fab the processors. Search for "list of semiconductor fabs", find a table, sort by node, and then scroll down until you find a Chinese node that does something other than just churn out flash memory. You'll find SMIC with a couple 40nm or 45nm fabs. That's not just the last generation of tech, that's three generations old (14 [current] => 22 => 32 => 45).
By comparison, the market is flooded with cheap 32nm Xeons being dumped from our data centers.
- jdietrich 10y agoTSMC have two 16nm fabs and are building a 10nm fab.
- umanwizard 10y agoTSMC fabs are mostly in Taiwan, not China.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoAnd Taiwan would never let those fabs go to China, they have plenty of laws against that. Only oldish fab tech can be exported to the Mainland.
- akiselev 10y agoTaiwan is not China. Where in China is TSMC building cutting edge semiconductor fab?
- jdietrich 10y agoThe Republic of China is not recognised by the UN. It is no more a state than Transnistria or South Ossetia.
- akiselev 10y agoComparing Taiwan, which has been functionally independent of the PRC and under control of the ROC since 1945, to South Ossetia or Transnistria is absolutely ridiculous. Just because Taiwan isn't widely recognized by the international community doesn't mean that it isn't an entirely separate socioeconomic entity. A brief glance at the last two decades of politics in Taiwan will show you as much.
- umanwizard 10y agoThe UN is totally irrelevant here. Taiwan operates as an independent country in every practical way. (So does Hong Kong, kinda, but Taiwan even more so.)
- klodolph 10y agoTo clarify, by "China" I mean People's Republic of China, not Republic of China (which is usually called Taiwan).
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoThis. China built that supercomputer as a pure PR/face move. It isn't very interesting otherwise, and the west stopped building those kinds of things a long time ago because it moved on to more detached distributed computing.
- skynetv2 10y agoYou need to look deeper into the latest system. It's not a pr machine. Even the pervious one tianhe-2 isn't. If you think it is, you're looking at the wrong sources. And no, we have not moved away from supercomputers or building bigger ones.
- nl 10y agoSMIC is down to 28nm now[1]. I agree this isn't competitive yet, but they are working on 14nm[2] with some reasonably credible partners (including Qualcomm), scheduled to be delivered by 2020. That would close the gap to Intel/Samsung/TSMC to one generation. [1] http://www.smics.com/eng/press/press_releases_details.php?id=365551 http://www.smics.com/eng/press/press_releases_details.php?id... [2] http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1326948 http://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1326948
- klodolph 10y agoIt will be interesting. I'd call that about one and a half generations, if 10nm ships in 2017 like Intel says. Of course, it is anyone's guess whether SMIC will ship 14nm on time, or whether Intel will ship 10nm on time.
- skynetv2 10y ago> Anyone can build a big enough supercomputer if you throw enough money at the problem That statement shows you have no idea what's involved in developing one.