7 ms·
To be honest the dot com crash caught me unprepared, and the feeling of having 10+ million dollars in future equity go to less than $100K is not something I'd w
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
To be honest the dot com crash caught me unprepared, and the feeling of having 10+ million dollars in future equity go to less than $100K is not something I'd wish on anyone. But not all of my investment value was "future", I had a bit more than $500k in Sun stock that I could sell at "any time." When I sold it when Oracle bought them it was worth about $12K.
I did not make the mistake of buying a big house on the promise that in the future I'd be able to afford it. A friend of mine bought his house and his neighbor's house to combine into a larger lot, but since the stock was going up he got jumbo loans and was selling stock periodically to make the payments. When things went south he ended up selling the neighbors house at a loss refinancing his own house at a lower rate to stay in it affordably. But I did make the mistake of not paying off my house when I could have using "bubble" stock (like that Sun stock). 2001 to probably 2006 were very wintry years.
I analyzed my behavior during the last dot com bubble and my biggest driver was tax avoidance. How stupid is that? I would say "sure this stock is 'worth' $500K but if I sell it I'm going to have to pay a huge amount of tax on it and that will net out to a smaller number." I was looking at "losing" 25% of the value of the investment by turning it into cash. Ridiculous right? Well now I think it is ridiculous.
Every 3 months I take a long look at my assets and debts and future plans and re-balance as necessary to avoid a single thing from killing me financially.
- flush 10y ago> I would say "sure this stock is 'worth' $500K but if I sell it I'm going to have to pay a huge amount of tax on it and that will net out to a smaller number." I was looking at "losing" 25% of the value of the investment by turning it into cash. Ridiculous right? Well now I think it is ridiculous. Not that ridiculous! Give yourself some credit. One of the reasons taxes work this way is to incentivize people to keep their money invested.
- boucher 10y agoIf you're holding all of your assets in a single stock solely because you don't want to take a tax hit, then yeah that's a really bad strategy.
- harryh 10y agoA good mental game to play to counteract the endowment effect[1] if one ever ends up holding $[some_large_number] of [tech_stock] is to ask yourself "If I had $[some_large_number] in cash, what % of it would I spend investing it in [tech_stock]?" Very very rarely will you find yourself saying 100%. Act accordingly. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endowment_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endowment_effect
- Swizec 10y agoThis is the most succinct phrasing of the best advice on "How much to value stock [options]" that I've ever read. Thank you.
- seizethecheese 10y agoIt's interesting to use this reasoning in the context of tax-avoidance that the parent mentioned. Would you rather have $[some_large_number] of cash, or $[some_large_number + some_large_numer*(tax rate)] in [tech stock]?
- harryh 10y agoIndeed. I don't think that the question I posed is the only question worth considering. Taxes matter and should be paid attention to. Really, stepping up to an even higher level of abstraction I think the most important advice is to pay attention and think about your options. I think that far to many people fall prey to inaction and sticking with the status quo simply because it is easier.
- seizethecheese 10y agoExactly. It's far from obvious whether it's better to be 25% poorer with diversification.
- sokoloff 10y agoBut you're not 25% poorer, because your basis is now stepped up. In order to access the value of your current shares, you're going to pay the taxes. You either have $100 on paper and owe $25 on it, or you have $75 on paper and owe $0 tax on it. Unless you think the tax rate is going to be lower in the future, once you've hit the long-term capital gains threshold, I don't see a reason to believe that paying taxes now and switching investments is worse than holding investments and paying all the taxes later.
- mikestew 10y ago* I was looking at "losing" 25% of the value of the investment by turning it into cash. Ridiculous right? Well now I think it is ridiculous.* Reminds me of a stock options seminar I went to, presented by an actual Fidelity options trader. The question came up along the lines of "so something something, what would the tax implications be?" His answer was something that I remember to this day, and remind myself when I'm worried about "something something capital gains": "I'm the worst person in the world to ask about investment taxes. If I'm getting taxed, then I'm making money, and that's as much thought as I give it." I couldn't even tell you the capital gains rates at this moment. If I need to get out of a position, I get out. And to quote the above professional options trader, if I take a tax hit then I made money. If I try to avoid the tax hit by holding on for a few more months to avoid short term capital gains, I might very well lose money in the interim. So I just don't pay any attention anymore and settle up with the government come April.
- gohrt 10y ago> If I'm getting taxed, then I'm making money, and that's as much thought as I give it." This is true, but if you are making money and getting tax, but if you are also losing money and not reducing taxes (because you are trading a lot and getting gains taxed some years but not saving on taxes in down years), you will hurt yourself.
- Retric 10y agoYou only make money after a sale, up to that point your still gambling. AKA a big stack of chips is not the same thing as a big wad of cash you have to actually leave the casino without blowing it.
- ori_b 10y ago> You only make money after a sale, up to that point your still gambling. AKA a big stack of chips is not the same thing as a big wad of cash you have to actually leave the casino without blowing it. Yes, but I want to sell off to diversify the kinds of chips I'm holding. At the moment, the tech stocks I'm holding on to as a result of work are doing quite well, but I'd like to insulate myself from risk anyways.
- gohrt 10y ago> I would say "sure this stock is 'worth' $500K but if I sell it I'm going to have to pay a huge amount of tax on How is that possible? After 1 year, you are in Long-term capital gains territory, so selling now vs later is tax neutral (except for gains on gains, but that's rather minor unless you think you are in a growth stock) The only reason to delay selling for tax reasons is if you also have a high income (over $300K?) that boosts your Long-term capital gains rate
- muzz 10y agoThe higher long-term capital gains rate is a recent addition to the tax code starting in 2013. During the dot-com bubble, long-term capital gains rates were essentially the same for most brackets (only the absolute lowest bracket had a lower rate)
- bgentry 10y agoWith options (at least ISOs), you don't qualify for the long-term capital gains rate until you've held the shares for at least a year after exercise AND waited at least two years from the grant date to sell them. It's possible that the second requirement is what affected ChuckMcM.
- swolchok 10y ago> The only reason to delay selling for tax reasons What about if you live in a state with high income tax and no capital gains relief from said rate, and you think that maybe at some point in the future you might leave that state for one with a lower income tax? For example, moving from California to anywhere else.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoAs others have mentioned, taxes are vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. I was fortunate (or not :-)) to have a mother in law who was both a CPA and ran a tax business. In my case I got to consult with her on a variety of "what if I did ..." scenarios. In the case of my Sun stock it was clear of the option restrictions but having been acquired (remember that $10M+ of "future" wealth?) I had a pretty incredible "income" on paper. But really it was all about restricted stock (as part of the acquisition) and 89b elections etc. Anyway, the meta question of whether or not to pay off my house was real (my mother in law advised against, after all you get the mortgage deduction). The endowment question is also good and I find myself in the Vancouver situation in a house that I probably wouldn't spend as much as its "worth" to live in it. Future risk/reward never goes away.
- bradleyjg 10y agoHindsight is 20/20 and all that, but in case anyone finds himself in a similar position, there are hedging strategies that avoid the 1259 constructive sale rule. You have to take some risk but you can put a floor on it.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoAbsolutely, when times are good, pay off your house. This may go contrary to most investing advice, but owning your home is a great safety net.
- mark-r 10y agoIt can make good investment sense too. Remember, someone with a lot more money than you decided that they couldn't make a better return than financing your home loan. Paying off a loan is an illiquid investment, but it's the highest guaranteed return you're going to find. And so what if you lose the tax deduction for interest? You'd pay taxes on any alternative investment anyway, so it's a wash.
- ghaff 10y agoRight. I run into a lot of people who will argue passionately about how stupid it is to pay down your low interest mortgage early given alternative investments. At the same time, many of them will not agree that taking out a HELOC so you can play the stock market is a good idea. The two situations aren't really equivalent given liquidity, etc. But at the margins they're pretty much the same thing.
- fossuser 10y agoMakes sense if you've already got a mortgage, but house buying seems tricky to me. With property tax and home owners association fees even with your house paid off you still basically have a permanent rent. I guess in some sense you're playing the housing market, but seems like having more options and ability to move is a pretty good deal. Renting also seems a lot cheaper (even with bay area rents).
- OneOneOneOne 10y ago> someone with a lot more money than you decided that they couldn't make a better return than financing your home loan I'm not sure this is how fractional reserve banking works. Banks only supply a fraction of depositors money against a mortgage with the majority supplied by the fed. They basically make their money by investing other peoples money (including fed "imaginary" money) and by keeping a relatively low default rate.
- zubat 10y agoRisk assessment is really hard for individuals. If we did it rationally we'd never get anywhere. But I think "money in the bank" and "defense in depth" are pretty good rules of thumb. In the end your goal on any one investment is to not lose.
- limeyx 10y agoI had somewhat similar feelings about the taxes (different company) (went from $7M to < $2 over the 6 month lockup period alone!) Ended up paying a bunch of taxes i likely could have avoided and got something out of it (but it was painful) Now over 10 years on after the "corrections / bubble burst" I'm finally about back where I started ... oh well I guess. I have a house and a job and all my limbs ...
- superuser2 10y agoI don't have any vested equity yet (very early career) but have decided upfront on a strategy of "sell every share the moment you can, reinvest in diversified index funds." Being long on your employer just seems like a really stupid idea. I don't consider myself likely to be fired for incompetence and I'm not high enough on the ladder to be fired for political reasons. If my income stream ever goes away, chances are it'll be because my employer stock is doing the same.
- groovy2shoes 10y agoWord of warning, from experience: don't ever think you're too low on the ladder to avoid politics or the implications thereof. I've seen plenty of "individual contributors" and "front line managers" become collateral damage in some bullshit company politics game. The worst part is that there was nothing they could've done to avoid it, other than either climbing the ladder to engage in the game and hope for the best, or simply leaving for greener pastures before the pendulum knocked them out. Unfortunately, if you're not paying attention to the politics in the first place, there's a good chance you won't see it coming. Otherwise, I totally agree with your statement here. Especially considering that your employer is not likely to be up-front with you when business gets bad (at least, not right away), you can wind up with the "corporate blinders" on and not notice the signs around you that your stock is about to tank. I've only worked for three different companies at this point in my career, but the quarterly "business group communications meetings" always felt much more like pep rallies than real status updates, meant primarily to boost morale rather than to inform. In this day and age, to place trust or loyalty in your employer is to misplace it, as employers are highly unlikely to place either of those things in their employees. What I'm trying to say is: your logic here is sound, and your strategy is a good one, but be careful about ignoring corporate politics.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoSelling immediately isn't necessarily the ideal plan. Often when shares vested in my career they were worth only a bit more than the "strike" price. Often times I have "sold to cover" which is to say exercised the option, and immediately sold enough of the stock to cover the cost of exercising the option and paying the tax. At that point you have shares in your company in your brokerage account where the "basis" is the fair market price when you exercised them. A year and a day later (to convert to long term gains) I've sold half the shares. When my RSUs at Google vested they would automatically sell some to pay my tax obligation, but I would instruct them to sell half as well. Same philosophy. Get some of the money diversified, keep a bit of skin in the game in case it had a gain.