9 ms·
How Silicon Valley helps spread the same sterile aesthetic across the world
- fnbr 10y agoI was travelling in Eastern Europe with a friend last summer, and we noticed the phenomenon independently. We were searching for good espresso by looking for cafes that had the industrial aesthetic- bare wooden tables, vaguely scandinavian furniture, Edison bulbs. It worked without fail; every cafe we stopped in that subscribed to the aesthetic had great coffee. I suspect the reason for this is that the aesthetic works as a costly signalling mechanism. If you're going to start a cafe with expensive coffee machines (a high end, commercial espresso machine will be ~$20 000, with a similar cost for a grinder), you're likely to also invest in design that's trendy. The key will be seeing how the aesthetic evolves as style changes- when industrial chic is no longer fashionable, will AirBnBs still subscribe to it? I suspect not.
- k-mcgrady 10y ago> We were searching for good espresso by looking for cafes that had the industrial aesthetic- bare wooden tables, vaguely scandinavian furniture, Edison bulbs. It worked without fail; every cafe we stopped in that subscribed to the aesthetic had great coffee." Did you try any cafés that didn't share that aesthetic? It's quite possible that 'good coffee' in that region is the standard. Or that you simply got lucky when selecting.
- return0 10y ago> the reason for this is that the aesthetic works as a costly signalling mechanism. I suspect these materials are mass-produced and thus much cheaper than having a wholly authentic (but probably very expensive and risky) design.
- twoodfin 10y agoIt's hard to deny that there's a dominant Airbnb aesthetic, and that it shares many genetic traits (mid-century modern furniture) with the "hip" interior design that seems to have taken over at least the urban Western world in the last 15-20 years. But first, even as this aesthetic is becoming passé, we should recognize its massive penetration into our commercial lives as a huge achievement (one certainly assisted by technology and a more mobile, wealthier society). The coffee shops, restaurants, and department stores that served most of our parents 30 years ago had terrible design even when they could be said to have design or style at all. Second, I don't think most design trends emerge as sudden and radical departures from the norm, especially when it comes to commercial endeavors that can't afford to be too risky or off-putting. But when we look back at the style of the mid-2010's from 15 or 20 years from now, I doubt we'll agree that it simply stagnated. It will have evolved into something noticeably distinct—humans are creatures of fashion—though the degree of cultural and regional diversity we had before modern telecommunications and travel is probably not coming back.
- squozzer 10y agoI happen to like the look. But certainly one's tastes, should they deviate from the AirSpace aesthetic, could be incorporated into the search parameters. Having stayed at BnBs before AirBnb was cool, the usual style I encountered was one of the following: 1) Antique-y, i.e. an attempt to decorate the property in period-correct furniture, usually unsuccessfully; 2) Unapologetically kitschy. Both "styles" require lots of loud wallpaper.
- smacktoward 10y agoIt would be interesting to see a demographic comparison between the people who frequent "conventional" bed-and-breakfasts and people who frequently use AirBnB. My (completely uneducated) guess is that the regular-B-and-B crowd skews considerably older, hence the predominance of the Thomas Kinkade-wannabe aesthetic in that segment instead of the more millennial-oriented "AirSpace" aesthetic the article describes.
- zeveb 10y ago> But certainly one's tastes, should they deviate from the AirSpace aesthetic, could be incorporated into the search parameters. That would be awesome! Me, I'd love to stay in some cozy Collegiate Gothic, pseudo-Oxonian place with layers of paint on the plaster, a lush garden, musty books, the lingering odour of pipe smoke — that's my idea of pleasant. Spare & bare, by comparison, is … sterile. I want to live someplace made for living, not for performing surgery.
- abstractbeliefs 10y agoWe all know that "Like Uber but for <X>" is a bad idea, and many people worth listening to say that the real value isn't in disruptive verticals, but in disruptive business models. So why do we continue to apply it to cities? We see this in every capital city council scheme trying to be "Silicon Valley for <country>". I think what we'll see is a bit of an iconoclasm and fall in grace for these cities and styles. In the same way no one has been able to be better than Uber or really capture much market, cities trying to displace their native style with the Valley's will only end up losing their own and being an obviously poorer copy.
- trevyn 10y agoOr maybe humans inherently enjoy clean, natural building materials and avocados.
- crpatino 10y agoHow do you explain the diversity of cultures across history, and across different continents?
- trevyn 10y agoClimate and GDP per capita.
- rvense 10y agoWhilst there's obviously some influence from climate on the differing clothing fashions in Australia and Greenland, do you honestly think that this is able to account for cultural preferences for, say, water colour landscape paintings versus intricate calligraphy in Japan and the Middle East, respectively?
- trevyn 10y agoYes, because climate dramatically affects how nature presents itself in everyday life.
- rvense 10y agoAha. How does climate explain changes in art the co-occur with political changes? Like when Alexander reached Asia, suddenly the sculptures there started resembling the ones they made in Greece.
- Joof 10y agoCultural separation due to lack of communication and transit.
- compiler-guy 10y ago
- golergka 10y agoIt's all part of the creation of globalized culture. Just as billions of daily active users on Facebook, global blockbusters that don't use a lot of language to be localizable in all the different markets — we're slowly, but steadily entering the age where humanity is truly no longer divided along country, language or culture lines. And it's affecting higher classes earlier than lower; the same effect was already in place in early 19th century across the whole Europe's fashionable salons, with the same interior design fashions and french books. Now it's truly spreading to middle class: it's not only about lattes, it's also about cultural and social values, TV shows that we watch and books that we read. And in my humblest of opinions, all things considered, this can only be a good thing.
- hyperbovine 10y ago> we're slowly, but steadily entering the age where humanity is truly no longer divided along country, language or culture lines. Not exactly sure how you reached this conclusion in an age when overt racism is being plainly embraced by large swathes of the electorate throughout Europe and North America. I don't feel like we've ever been more divided in my lifetime.
- maxerickson 10y agoDoes covert vs overt really matter to measuring the division?
- Analemma_ 10y agoIt's possible for both of you to be right. I don't agree with everything Ross Douthat says, but he had an interesting column a little while ago claiming that the non-nationalist "global elite" constitute their own tribe, which has identical characteristics regardless of where in the world they are: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/03/opinion/sunday/the-myth-of-cosmopolitanism.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/03/opinion/sunday/the-myth-of.... It's possible that this tribe is growing, but is not currently all-encompassing, and the reactions against it are the movements that you are referring to.
- noonespecial 10y ago
- mbesto 10y agoI wonder if the author has ever been to the Nordics (Sweden specifically)? I would argue IKEA (and Swedish design) has largely to do with the sterile aesthetics of minimalist living and local coffee shops.
- ktRolster 10y agoThe author mentioned the idea that Ikea is what is spreading the aesthetic: But the similarities went beyond mass-production [like Ikea]. The ideal Airbnb is both unfamiliar and completely recognizable: a sprinkling of specific cultural symbols of a place mixed with comprehensible devices, furniture, and decoration. "It’s funny how you want these really generic things but also want authenticity, too,"
- pluma 10y agoIt was always my impression that the "startup" look had more to do with limited finances and cheap IKEA furniture (compared to significantly more expensive designer furniture) than with some kind of desire to look like everyone else.
- angersock 10y agoOnly a passing mention in the article, but does anyone else kinda roll their eyes and groan at the mention of "digital nomads"?
- SpeakMouthWords 10y agoWhat's your preferred term for that lifestyle?
- alonmower 10y agoYes
- alanwatts 10y agoWhat word/phrase would be more apt, in your opinion? Marshall McLuhan wrote about this phenomenon back in the 60's >Men are suddenly nomadic gatherers of knowledge, nomadic as never before, informed as never before, free from fragmentary specialism as never before - but also involved in the total social process as never before, since with electricity we extend our central nervous system globally, instantly, interrelating every human experience. -Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media (1964)
- kristopolous 10y agoI despise the aesthetic. I find it fake, disingenuous, a tinsel town bland look, some ham fisted conformity. All of the repulsive veneer of the bay with its superficial niceties but deeply dispassionate and insincere roots, as architecture! It makes me nauseous. Hate it, hate it, hate it. So passionately... It's antithetical to a semblance of humanity and devoid of culture. A cold unwelcoming thing that screams "screw off, you're not welcome here"
- ktRolster 10y agoThat's.......very passionate
- kristopolous 10y agoI honestly think, not to be insulting or childish but actually literal, that there's some part of many tech people's brain missing... Like Aspergers and ASD. (I'm certainly not a doctor) I feel that many tech people lack some human connection. I think this guides such aesthetics and its disavowing and denial of community and collective conscious. It's the only working hypothesis I can think of for why such decisions are proactively made and why such inordinate amounts of money are spent in such ways...work-world mcmansioning; a sanitized and saccharine white gloves of latex treatment. Maybe I need to form a more detailed pro-vision of what I mean instead of being all "no".
- tomc1985 10y agoIt comes from living in a bubble with other nerds who deal with machines all day. The machines don't care, they don't have emotions. It's why techies have always struggled with the "human" aspects But what really kills me are the leaps in logic a lot of SV dips like to breathlessly promote to their users, who often genuinely look up to their tech lords and will take their words without further thought. Just the other day Yelp posted this whole screed about facilitating free speech rights (as in, preserving the freedom to review businesses on yelp), getting everybody fired up and diverting attention away from their shady advertising and business practices. All of this advocacy, all this diversity, all these stupid little bleeding-heart SJW tactics... ALL of them are red herrings for deeper agendas, which are often very weird on account of a prevalence of the personality attributes you've described.
- JustUhThought 10y agoKeyword: spread Just as finance has done for resource allocation, information technology is doing for culture. For better. Or worse.
- mmagin 10y agoI think it's just a newer version of how much American-produced television was having this affect on the world a generation ago. (Including the dominance of the New York/Los Angeles dialect.)
- jahewson 10y agoDesigners and architects have always been an international bunch. Fashions are global and have been for a very long time. The Romans built things in a deliberately Greek style. French Gothic architecture was copied across Europe. Neoclassical architecture saw the Greek style return and used in government building around the world. The Victorians built the same stuff everywhere. Hollywood brought Art Deco to the world in the 1920s and 30s. The style which the author complains about so much is predominately the Mid-century Modern of the 1950s and 60s. So no, fashion existed long ago. And it was global long ago.
- return0 10y agoThe difference is, these architectures grew inside a culture without external influences, and reached some maturity before being imported and remixed by others.
- roymurdock 10y agoThis reminds me of a fundamental concept of New Trade Theory. This is a theory that Paul Krugman won a Nobel Prize in Economics for in 2008 (although the theory first gained attention alongside "globalization" in the early 1990s). Tyler Cowen of Marginal Revolution provides a good explanation: Consider the simplest model (based on Krugman 1979). In this model there are two countries. In each country, consumers have a preference for variety but there is a tradeoff between variety and cost, consumers want variety but since there are economies of scale – a firm’s unit costs fall as it produces more – more variety means higher prices. Preferences for variety push in the direction of more variety, economies of scale push in the direction of less. So suppose that without trade country 1 produces varieties A,B,C and country two produces varieties X,Y,Z. In every other respect the countries are identical so there are no traditional comparative advantage reasons for trade. Nevertheless, if trade is possible it is welfare enhancing. With trade the scale of production can increase which reduces costs and prices. Notice, however, that something interesting happens. The number of world varieties will decrease even as the number of varieties available to each consumer increases. That is, with trade production will concentrate in say A,B,X,Y so each consumer has increased choice even as world variety declines. Increasing variety for individuals even as world variety declines is a fundamental fact of globalization. In the context of culture, Tyler explains this very well in his book, Creative Destruction; when people in Beijing can eat at McDonald’s and people in American can eat at great Chinese restaurants the world looks increasingly similar even as each world resident experiences an increase in variety. In essence, variety within local flavors/variants decreases, but the best brands are exported globally. When applied to furniture/interior decoration this means that you can find archetypes of the popular styles everywhere but that variations within those archetypes is very limited - every coffee shop, loft, restaurant of the same overarching style feels the same. The solution for those tired of one style - pick another completely different cultural style! Read more here: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2008/10/what-is-new-tra.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2008/10/wha...
- samstokes 10y agoIt's slightly ironic that Foursquare, the article's first example of this trend, is based in New York City, not Silicon Valley.
- jdoliner 10y agoAll tech companies are silicon valley companies when they're being chastised. When they're being praised though they become evidence that SV's dominance is waning.
- someone7x 10y agoThe headline had me expecting to read yet another SV polemic: it's not just SF, but now the whole world is under attack from the bad SV people and their imperialist ambitions! /s But when I read the article, I see it's a lot of charged words like "gentrification" to describe the phenomenon of "it's gone mainstream", and "depersonalization" to describe "it's not as good as it once was". Airbnb is becoming popular and converging. Seems like a very believable and predictable possible outcome.
- notaboutcode 10y agoWhile the minimalist Nordic aesthetic of IKEA certainly plays a large role as others have pointed out, I find the aesthetic has more to do with what I've seen Brooklyn homogenize towards over the past 10 years. And behind many of those spaces are the Haslegrave brothers. [1] I'm sure this design aesthetic has arisen independently in many different areas of the world and has seen a convergence due to the factors the article points out, but at least here in Brooklyn this aesthetic arose in the lofts along the waterfront and were pushed around the city by the Haslegraves. Now the loft building that they live in has a steady stream of AirBnb tourists, unbeknownst to them that the aesthetic they see around the world in no small part has to do with two brothers living down the hall. [1] http://thescoutmag.com/features/design/1066/the_brothers_haslegrave http://thescoutmag.com/features/design/1066/the_brothers_has...
- raziel2701 10y agoWell I guess that's the effect of interconnectedness and globalization no? We're converging towards a more homogenized society in which everything looks the same. People who used to live and be exposed to their own local environments and ideas are now exposed to a much broader and non-local view of the world. Ultimately this an example of how good we are at exporting culture. Yeah it kind of sucks that quaint little towns will change to become more like everything else so perhaps we will lose some sense of identity as we try and reinvent ourselves according to the new culture. But well, that's the way things are after all. People change.
- bogomipz 10y agoThe homogeneity is certainly becoming more prevalent however I think the author is placing a disproportional amount of responsibility for this phenomenon on Airbnb. The bigger issue is the confirmation bias that social apps have engendered. I only follow similarly-minded people or I only get certain type of news pieces in my feed therefore my frame of reference becomes smaller. Add to this that many products are not content to be a utilitarian commodity any longer, everything seems to be aspire to be "brand" or at its logical conclusion "a lifestyle" with its own flagship stores and flagship stores must exist in all major cities. As the noise gets louder the signal for brand identity gets louder and louder as well. Its not just cool hotels and coffee shops however. The previously mundane has gotten in on the act as well. Any recent visitor to New York City will tell you there is Citibanks, TD Banks, and Bank of America on almost every block now, often times many per block. This is in an era where few people have a need for a retail bank branch. There's an interesting phenomenon whereby these hundred of banks leave their interior lights on all night because their real purpose is advertising. None of this bodes well for society. My optimistic self used to think that there would eventually be a reactionary element against this homogeneity but I'm not so sure any more.
- Animats 10y agoNot Silicon Valley. General Motors, 1958. Watch "American Look"[1], and you'll see most of the design styles the author is talking about, including the Eames chair. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gS6HZv4GXj8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gS6HZv4GXj8