5 ms·
Apparently the hacked one wasn't signed. Users would have clicked through a (very prominent) warning to install it.
by nailer 10y ago
Apparently the hacked one wasn't signed. Users would have clicked through a (very prominent) warning to install it.
- d33 10y agoIt's not something that people pay attention to anyways...
- IshKebab 10y agoYeah but loads of software isn't signed so the warning is fairly useless.
- fuzzy2 10y agoUnless SmartScreen complains, the order of dialogs and buttons on those dialogs is exactly the same for both signed and unsigned programs. They only differ in content/design elements. That's not what I'd call prominent. There's nothing like HSTS for signed programs, so it can't be helped, though.
- Someone1234 10y agoOn Windows 10 you cannot install unsigned installers at all without disabling SmartScreen.
- fuzzy2 10y agoThat's not true. Although the screen wide dialog thingy is a little tricky, you can still choose to continue. It doesn't even appear most of the time.
- StavrosK 10y agoI get warnings every time I try to run something I downloaded, so I've just tuned them out. Unless this one was somehow completely different from those, I wouldn't have given it a second thought.
- Forge36 10y agoI watched the video in this thread. I would not consider that a prominent warning at all. UAC uses a near identical prompt and I need to click through it daily (average of 2-3 times an hour while doing development). It is not something I would have noticed.
- Vexs 10y agoSeriously, I've clicked through that on purpose many times with a lot of open-source projects, in development stuff, hell, I've gotten unsigned programs from companies!
- Forge36 10y agoI once got a virus from a well known company as a dev preview. Had to say it wasn't something i considered a fix. IT was not pleased..
- ultramancool 10y agoYeah, but many apps for Windows still aren't signed so many users are trained to just click through.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoMS just made all drivers required to be signed and I suspect the next step is to disallow downloads of executables that aren't signed. No, I don't mean smartscreen warnings, I mean a refusal to download entirely with exceptions being put in manually via a control panel item Grandma will be hesitant to mess with and via GPO for enterprise. Then build out a reputation system for signers. I was recently given a link via steam to watch a video. It had an embedded fake Flash updater. The installer was very clever as it was signed by something like "Browser Company" and looked like the official Flash installer. My local AV and virustotal.com didn't detect it at the time either. I think the age of it being convenient to run arbitrary executables in Windows is ending. There's just too much liability now, especially in the age of ransomware and kiddie hackers doing it for the lulz.
- chrisper 10y agoThose warnings are as useful as the certificate error ones you get when browsing the web. Most (normal) people see them as annoyances and they do not really protect anyone as they will just click "continue." Same with the UAC pop up that tells you that the app is not signed. Most of the apps I downloaded are not signed...
- steve-howard 10y agoFrom the linked forum post: >When I installed it said it couldn't be trusted, I installed anyway but it did nothing. Users have no way of knowing which things are safe and which things aren't if almost everything comes with a "this isn't safe" warning.