11 ms·
Police had woman’s Facebook deactivated during standoff
- ben_jones 10y agoThis is going to get upvoted because of the title, I really hope that people read the actual article before posting. The worst part is that this women put her children in extreme danger and had a history of instigating police and threatening extreme violence through social media. Furthermore others on social media actively encouraged her violence which directly led to her death and serious injury to her children. It reminds me most of the school shooting in Oregon where the attacker was actively encouraged on internet forums to commit the act. Though like in that incident I think this women would have acted the same regardless.
- duaneb 10y agoI would advise avoiding commenting on how people vote. It is never interesting compared to just watching what happens.
- thelock85 10y agoAn alternate explanation is a woman was protecting her child from a threat --real, perceived or otherwise. Poor choice? Probably. But I think you've only explored one side of the story and a lot more information has become available in the last 12 hours.
- rbanffy 10y agoA shotgun is not a reasonable way to protect oneself from a state. The state probably has more police officers than you have bullets. You'll only make it worse.
- mywittyname 10y agoUnfortunately, the common narrative today to is to take up arms against what you perceive to be an oppressive government.
- stevenwiles 10y agoActually, the narrative today is to take up arms against the haters and anyone who tries to get between you and your dreams.
- williamscales 10y agoThis seems entirely appropriate. It would be consistent with the practice of news outlets sometimes not showing an ongoing police operation live.
- NeutronBoy 10y agoAgreed - why would social media be treated any differently than disconnecting phone lines or mobile phones during standoffs and negotiations?
- pgrote 10y agoPerhaps because it is against the law for local authorities to shut down telecommunications? https://www.publicknowledge.org/news-blog/blogs/why-shutting-down-cell-service-not-just-again https://www.publicknowledge.org/news-blog/blogs/why-shutting... "More than seventy years ago, Congress made a choice to take that option away from local authorities. It conferred jurisdiction on the FCC and the state Public Utility Commissions to provide oversight, and gave everyone a federally protected right to access the phone network. That right applies to all phone networks, whether wireline or wireless."
- 0xCMP 10y agoBut to be fair, in this situation they asked Facebook which is allowed to block/disable any account on their service that they want.
- williamscales 10y agoI would put forward that it is because live-streaming on social media is not the same as using the phone line. When Facebook chose to shut down her account (which is within its rights) then she still had access to the phone line. The federally protected right to access the phone network is unaffected. There is no federal requirement that would require Facebook to only shut down an account after receiving a court order.
- erdevs 10y agoWhat is the rationale for news outlets not showing an ongoing police operation? Is it so that the suspects / perpetrators can't use the external information against the police? If so, does that rationale applicable when it is the suspect / perpetrator broadcast their own available information? I don't know the background for these policies, so asking the first question non-rhetorically.
- erdevs 10y agoTragic and unfortunate, all around. I wonder what FB's policy on this will be going forward. In many ways, these livestreams are a public good and provide transparency and additional accountability in these situations. If people elect to stream them, it seems wrong to shut it down. On the other hand, perhaps there is a public good in not showing an ongoing live police operation? I think I'd lean toward not agreeing to shutdown such streams, unless perhaps it's a hostage situation or terror event of some kind. (Getting into squishy definitions there, I'm sure, which is why I qualify it provisionally.) As to this particular incident... I wish the deceased hadn't resisted. It seems in this case the police exercised much more caution and restraint than has been the case in many other recent examples of shootings. And I think one thing generally stands: if you threaten to kill a police officer and especially if you do so while holding a weapon (or certainly pointing it at them), you're likely to be shot.
- HelloImDumb 10y agoThis was a hostage situation. Was the 5 year old boy, not a hostage to his crazed, gun-wielding mother in this standoff? I love Monday morning quarterbacks.
- throwaway201607 10y ago>I love Monday morning quarterbacks. honest question, what does this mean?
- nocarrier 10y agoPeople who watch a football game Sunday night and then talk shit at work on Monday about all the things they would have done differently if they were coach/quarterback/etc.
- chipperyman573 10y agoMight have something to do with this[0] >The definition of a Monday morning quarterback is someone who is always criticizing and saying how he would have done something better or differently after the event has passed. [0] http://www.yourdictionary.com/monday-morning-quarterback http://www.yourdictionary.com/monday-morning-quarterback
- nolepointer 10y agoConsidering her followers were encouraging her to not give in to police demands, this was entirely justified.
- erdevs 10y agoI think this is a good point. I wonder if livestreams could be enabled but perhaps comments/feedback could be disabled or invisible to the poster. This could also address concerns that external viewers might feed a suspect/perpetrator intel on the police operation which might impinge their efficacy in an already difficult notice.
- johansch 10y agoThen the poster could just instruct the viewers to send their comments to some other social media post/service.
- MichaelGG 10y agoPolice aren't allowed to jam cell phones, so why should they be allowed to do this? Making the cops' jobs easier isn't something that always benefits society. (I'm totally for the cops in this case, but still they shouldn't be able to censor like this.)
- microcolonel 10y ago>“She was intelligent, strong, determined, beautiful. She was a dedicated mother, an awesome friend. She was determined to enlighten people. There’s not enough accolades I can give her,” A mother determined to endanger the life of her son in a firefight with police. Though it seems it may not have been her fault that she turned out that way. Quite sad.
- cloudjacker 10y agoRight, she sued over lead in water and so far seems to be a very accurate assessment of her deteriorating mental health by the time of encounter. If some police departments can deliver bombs via drones, maybe warrants can be too!
- Kenji 10y agoI wonder if there was a way to resolve this standoff without her death. I.e. letting her shoot all the shotgun shells she has, or just waiting until she gets tired and slips up, gets hungry, etc. Yeah, it requires a lot of patience but hey, you can save a human life. I don't think she would have harmed her kid so waiting in cover seems like a relatively safe thing to do?
- lighttower 10y agoAbsolutely right. They have all day and night she needs food and sleep.
- _audakel 10y agoif police are about to shoot, and have good cause to, then it would seem reasonable that they be allowed to use sleep gas or tranquilizer, similar to what doctors use during operation. Seems better than killing them. Downside could be lawsuites against the police for "damages" that the sleep gas caused.
- trvrsalom 10y agoAs nice as it would be to have a reliable nonlethal alternative to firearms, there simply are no nonlethal weapons capable of stopping someone who is presenting an immediate threat. Tranquilizers and anesthesia are administered by an anesthesiologist, a doctor trained to determine a dosage based on a person's body mass. Too much of a dose, or even administering it too quickly can cause serious complications, or even death. Even under the controlled environment of an operating room 1/20 patients die under full anesthesia a year. Sadly, the most reliable method of stopping a person presenting a threat is with a firearm.
- Overtonwindow 10y agoI think this is a very unfortunate situation, but the thought of Facebook disabling her account at the behest of the police, that doesn't feel right. We seen that we cannot always trust the police perspective in shootings, so instead of disabling the account, perhaps Facebook should have instead continue to record the feed but disable the comments.
- nness 10y agoIf you think about it from Facebook's perspective though, do you really want to be responsible for broadcasting a video where the women, her child or a police officer is shot or killed on camera?
- MichaelGG 10y agoFB isn't responsible; they are a platform. The person broadcasting is "responsible". And even if they were, yes, why should that be a problem? At worst it'll be flagged mature (and deleted?).
- adamsea 10y agoFB isn't a platform; it's a business, it makes money. If something interferes with FB making money ...
- douche 10y agoAt best it will go viral, and the clicks and ad revenue will rake in millions.
- stevenwiles 10y agoUh.. The fact that FB is fully capable of pressing a button to turn off the stream suggests that they are, in fact, responsible for its broadcast.
- 2bitencryption 10y ago"Mr. Zuckerberg sir, an incredibly violent and hostile individual with a gun is livestreaming a standoff with the police. It's very likely this livestream will involve somebody brutally dying or getting horrible maimed. Also, this stream could jeopardize an important police operation underway to neutralize this dangerous person. Should we pull the stream?" "No! Of course not! The internet is the land of Freedom! Hosting this content isn't bad for us at all!"
- chendies 10y agoThe ACLU has an app that can be used to record police encounters. Fortunately, the ACLU won't be shutting it off at the police request.
- aab0 10y ago> According to a police report from the March stop, which the department released after the shooting, Gaines was stopped when an officer saw that in place of a license plate she had a piece of cardboard on her vehicle. The cardboard declared, “Any Government official who compromises this pursuit to happiness and right to travel, will be criminally responsible and fined, as this is a natural right and freedom.” So she was a Sovereign Citizen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_citizen_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_citizen_movement)? http://heavy.com/news/2016/08/korryn-gaines-instagram-videos-full-before-shooting-with-son-police-traffic-stop-shotgun-shesyourmajesty/ http://heavy.com/news/2016/08/korryn-gaines-instagram-videos... quotes her spouting more of the sovereign citizen legal gobbledegook. Apparently there's even a black version of all this stuff: http://www.rawstory.com/2014/08/sovereign-citizens-express-fears-of-lawlessness-by-rejecting-laws/ http://www.rawstory.com/2014/08/sovereign-citizens-express-f...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rahimnathwani 10y ago"quotes her spouting more of the sovereign citizen legal gobbledegook" It's sad that the top comment on this thread is just name-calling. Why do you consider her views to be 'gobbledegook'?
- smcl 10y agoI don't see it as an attack on their views in general (though the sovereign citizen stuff is pretty odd, IMO) but that those sorts of people tend to ramble in an extremely weird way. If you haven't seen this specifically then think of a sort of madder, less coherent version of Glenn Beck or Alex Jones.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoSo, it's not a vague attack on their views, but a vague attack on their communication style?
- donatj 10y agoA [dead] poster commented this, but I think it bears repeating that there is an ACLU app specifically for recording police. [1] I'd personally trust that far more than Facebook. [1] https://www.aclu.org/feature/aclu-apps-record-police-conduct https://www.aclu.org/feature/aclu-apps-record-police-conduct
- erdevs 10y agoThis is a great reminder, thanks. Slight concern that the developer on ACLU's behalf is something called Quadrant 2, Inc, which seems to be owned by an individual operator as opposed to a larger established company. Not sure what the company's track record or policies are. But just an aside there. This is cool to see and great to have as a reminder.
- tonmoy 10y agoCouldn't they have just cut the Internet for the place and block her cell phone?
- catuskoti 10y agoWell, this new incident will certainly help justifying new killings of policemen. It will make other people who were already close to the line, now cross it. In that sense, nothing comes for free. As a libertarian, I certainly believe that these things should never come for free. I am now waiting for the news that at least half a dozen policemen were unceremoniously killed somewhere.
- marcoperaza 10y agoAre you kidding me? She was shooting at police in order to resist arrest. This is about as justified as it gets.
- douche 10y agoYou're thinking rationally, which isn't a strong suit of these scum that get pissy about ambiguous police-involved shootings, and conclude that ambushing and murdering police officers is a valid response.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- erikpukinskis 10y agoMy first thought was they are trying to prevent a similar situation to Antonio Perkins in June: http://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2016/06/17/man-shot-killed-while-live-streaming-orig-vstan-dlewis.cnn http://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2016/06/17/man-shot-killed-whil... Where he was live streaming to Facebook while being shot by police. If the police can prevent streams like these from being seen, it gives them a huge legal advantage. It means the public won't be able to see what happened and can't put political pressure on DAs to prosecute cops. It's much better for them if they can keep that footage internal to Facebook, the police force, and the DA if at all possible. Very smart.
- rwallace 10y agoThis incident didn't really have anything to do with Facebook. The cause was buried in an offhand remark in the middle of the article: apparently the woman's behavior was a result of brain damage from lead paint. The headline should have been 'Lead paint claims yet another victim'.
- codezero 10y agoI'm curious if the police would have entered and shot at her if they couldn't get the live stream shut down.