6 ms·
More Doctors Giving Up Private Practices
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoThe EHR money is a game-changer. There is SO MUCH waste in prescriptions, labs, dicom and billing.. once easy and affordable EHR is viable for the "long tail", we will enable the solo / small practice physicians.
- rdl 17y agoI agree -- and it's amazing how bad the existing software is. (I work in this field). It would be a great place to do a startup (there are a bunch of niches which could easily support multiple companies) -- it's mainly implementing open but antiquated specs from the late 1980s, doing interop testing with existing vendors, and being able to go through the long sales cycle. You would want some MDs on the team, which makes it kind of expensive (young MDs need to pay off their schooling, and older ones would be giving up profitable jobs). The $40-80k per EHR thing is a big market opportunity.
- fnid2 17y agoThe problem the startup will face is finding programmers who would put up with all the irrationality in the medical field. The reason the software is so bad is because the field is dominated by business types who can push papers through until their software is approved or bought, but can't find good programmers to make good software. There are a lot of legal issues too, so the risk can actually take you negative very easily -- like jail time or fines, so it's a different equation for investors, entrepreneurs and programmers.
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoThe technical issues are challenging, but the problem space is intrinsically motivating if you "believe in" the space. EHR is one of those rare opportunities where you can "do good" and be rewarded for it. Further, there is a HUGE amount of bizdev that goes into partner integrations, and you basically can't meet "meaningful use" (a requirement for ARRA money) going it alone. HIPAA compliance, security review, and on and on. Learning about the way healthcare really works in this country has been incredibly eye-opening. Thankfully, I work with really smart people who are all motivated and our company has a few unique strategic advantages. If any great rubyists want to join a company that is iterating our test-driven way to launch, my contact info is in my profile.
- rdl 17y agoYeah, it is nice to be able to work on something where you can be at a party and someone mentions a motorcycle accident or something, and you can point out how the product you work on was involved in saving his life. More meaningful than yet another social network game.
- akeefer 17y agoThat "irrationality" is fundamental to many types of enterprise software, which is a big reason why most of it sucks. You're codifying hundreds of years of established precedent, often heavily legally regulated in slightly different ways by all 50 states (not to mention foreign countries). The more established precedent there is, the more history in the industry, and the more regulation, the harder it is to write decent software.
- rdl 17y agoThat is more true for EHR than for a lot of the more specialized systems in radiology, pharmacy, lab, etc. For those, it's much more clearly a CS problem, with a UI component, and then some interaction with existing crappy systems (mainly the EHR). The EHR itself is the black hole of suck. It almost always ends up being like an ERP package, with either an off the shelf package (e.g. SAP) where the workflow is changed to accomodate the package, or a semi-custom consulting product built around specific workflow. Luckily, the more specialized stuff is actually vastly simpler.
- akeefer 17y agoSounds about right . . . any time you're solving a particular problem, things get a lot simpler. You need something to do x and y, so you make something do x and y, and it's pretty easy to tell whether what you've made sucks and x and y or not. Once you have to handle anything workflow-ish or manage any sort of business process, or any time you have to handle integration to arbitrary external systems, it's very difficult to make anything that doesn't suck. The "right" thing becomes very fuzzy, and there's no one purpose or problem you can use as your rightness criterion, so it all becomes very fuzzy. Things then get worse when some standards committee tries to please everyone, or when business users insist that they want everything to work exactly the way it used to just, you know, with a computer know. And since there's no easy criterion against which to judge the solution, it's an easy slope down towards even more suck.
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoAntiquated? but HL7 is XML!!! ;) The barriers to entry are pretty high just to have a baseline solution, and then you have to figure out how to reach the few people that have decision making authority to implement this kind of system. A lot of interesting things were discussed at HIMSS, very exciting things are happening in this space.
- rdl 17y agoI work with DICOM more than HL7. DICOM is very frustrating, especially because the task it tries to solve could be so easily done. I think DICOM-related products (an open stack for equipment vendors, various PACS and other tools, etc.) would be easy projects to get to baseline.
- nradov 17y agoIn particular, anyone who wants to sell a complete EHR product will generally need CCHIT certification. That isn't easy or cheap even if you have smart developers and good tools. http://www.cchit.org/certify/2011/cchit-certified-2011-ambulatory-ehr http://www.cchit.org/certify/2011/cchit-certified-2011-ambul...
- rdl 17y agoI heard this was about $500k in additional cost and maybe +6mo, starting from a reasonable technical basis, which doesn't seem that bad. There's also the "sell it outside the USA, then sell inside the USA" model.
- iends 17y agoI don't think this is true. The initial certification is ~$28k and the auditors just watch you demonstrate the list of criteria. Sure, there are interoperability requirements (and other requirements such as drug interactions) that may take some time to implement, but all of these requirements are simply features that many of your competitors have anyway.
- iends 17y ago
- nradov 17y agoAn EHR by itself has very limited value. To really be useful it needs to connect to many other systems for results delivery, transcriptions, eRx, lab ordering, billing, etc. Those external interfaces typically have to be implemented on a case-by-case basis, and require specialized technical skills to set up VPNs, do HL7 mapping, synchronize patient indexes, etc. It will be a long time before all of those interoperability issues are standardized. Only larger healthcare provider organizations have the economies of scale to really make everything work.
- ippisl 17y agoIn web based software the software providers have economies of scale and can connect many systems, and then offer them to single doctors. Does the integration problem steel exist for web based software?
- vinhboy 17y agoThe other day I was having a discussion with some other programmers about how our profession is slowly becoming a production line... pretty soon knowing how to program will be like working on a production line putting together a car. Only a couple of smart people need to design the specs, and the rest just repeat the steps. It's interesting to me that by combining the health care industry, doctors are also becoming assembly line workers. Go to the second floor for heart, third floor for feet, etc... I have not decided if I like this or not.
- jerf 17y ago"The other day I was having a discussion with some other programmers about how our profession is slowly becoming a production line..." People have been saying that for sixty years. It's less true than ever, at least for good programmers, as more and more of the accidental (in Fred Brook's sense of the term) gets automated away, leaving ever-more-refined essential behind. If you really want to make me laugh, why don't you go design the language+framework+environment that will complete the task of making programming assembly line work. You can call it "5GL". (Google it.) I would expect doctoring to go the same route over the next 30 years. More routine may be shoved onto checklists and perhaps even robots, but that will just make the non-routine something that becomes an even larger part of a given doctor's time. Although we may end up having more technicians and fewer doctors. Arguably computer programming has gone this way too.
- fnid2 17y agoI think it is increasingly true over time. The amount of software use is increasing and the quality of programmers required to solve problems with software is declining. There's a lot of open source out there, so you can see the code and see that it isn't that great a lot of times, but it gets proliferated with marketing, much like factory goods. Imagine the furniture artisans from the 1800's looking at the quality of furniture sold in the stores today... shoddy materials, weak joints, poor finishing. It's almost the same today in software -- or at least the trend is in that direction. You can still get quality furniture today with solid wood, great finishes, and sturdy construction, but you have to pay 10x or 20x the price of something from IKEA. Same is true of software. So you could say it is less true for "good" programmers, but it's also less true for good furniture makers. If it is true that abundance creates scarcity, the abundance of bad software and programmers has created a scarcity of good software and programmers, just like every other industry. Besides, saying it isn't true for good programmers is a like the No True Scotsman fallacy. What is a good programmer? Is a good programmer someone for whom it isn't true? Can you quantify what it is that makes a good programmer? Can software users tell the difference? I don't think they can.
- fnid2 17y agoFree education for doctors and more of them besides the arbitrarily limited 11,000 or so a year medical school seats mandated by the AMA would do a lot for increasing the supply of doctors and reducing costs. If more doctors could open practices, there'd be more choice for consumers. I mean really, why do we even let the AMA -- doctors themselves -- artificially limit the supply of doctors? Of course they are going to keep the numbers low. 11,000 (the last number I found) new doctors every year is simply NOT enough. It may be a little bit higher, but last I researched, for years it was 10,000 and only after a lot of controversy did they increase it to 11,000. The system is designed to force doctors into debt so they have to be money focused and charge a lot and keep rates high for all the other doctors. The doctors, many of whom are my long time friends, are not happy with the system. They want more freedom. They feel like slaves to debt. One good friend left grad school with over $250,000 in debt! It takes a long time to pay that off. She can't take on more debt to open a private practice, nor would she have the experience really -- she's forced into the big hospital system that she knows is flawed, but she's powerless to change it because the huge medical institutions call the shots, not the doctors. We think doctors are invincible and make tons of money, but if they lose their jobs -- it's a horrible experience, because it'll be very difficult for them to find another job -- doctors talk and bankruptcy doesn't clear student loan debt, so even that isn't an option. Add to that, the fact that individuals aren't even allowed to care for their own medical well being and you have a system that is way unfairly balanced toward doctors and away from patients. Not even the doctors really, the hospitals. Why, in the "leader of the free world" are individuals not free to care for themselves? Prescribe their own medications? Order their own labs and CAT scans and the like? Why do we give the AMA so much power? Why don't patients have any over their own lives? I suppose patients do have some power -- over the doctors. There are doctors out there who send patients with viruses out with antibiotics because the patient wants something. They prescribe drugs from tv commercials because the patient wants something. Why do we let them do this? There should be laws against prescribing antibiotics for people who don't have bacterial infections. I know that and I'm not a doctor, but doctors still do it. There's really something wrong with our system. It's completely irrational. There's simply too much money in it and people go crazy.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]