5 ms·
I've got a hunch brexit basically isn't going to happen. The vote was advisory and our new PM was a remainer. It's incredibly difficult to really leave without
by tim333 10y ago
I've got a hunch brexit basically isn't going to happen. The vote was advisory and our new PM was a remainer. It's incredibly difficult to really leave without screwing the economy. See http://www.politics.co.uk/blogs/2016/07/14/everything-you-need-to-know-about-theresa-may-s-brexit http://www.politics.co.uk/blogs/2016/07/14/everything-you-ne...
The article concludes May will probably kick the problem into the long grass which she seems to be doing by saying it won't happen without Scottish agreement which probably won't happen.
- Nursie 10y agoShe hasn't said that. Sturgeon painted her comments that way, but what she said was a solution that worked for the whole nation, nothing about Scottish agreement or consent. If Brexit doesn't happen then the mainstream will be handing power to UKIP who will, quite rightly, be able to say that democracy in the UK is a sham. I don't want that, Brexit must happen.
- cstross 10y ago> She hasn't said that. She can't say that. If she said it openly, it wouldn't be a viable strategy. The problem we've got right now is that multiple political power centers are locked into a multi-way game of chicken over Brexit, which can only be resolved by pulling the trigger on Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty or by definitively ruling it out -- and whoever takes responsibility for making it happen (or not happen) will catch a career-ending shitstorm of abuse from the other side.
- lucb1e 10y ago> who will, quite rightly, be able to say that democracy in the UK is a sham. Except that there is also a large amount of people that had no idea of the consequences. Lots of people were calling for a re-vote afterwards because "oh shit this is actually not so great after all". Which is okay, actually -- it should be possible to change your mind when you see something doesn't work the way you want it (it'd be great if politicians did this more).
- UK-AL 10y agoThe people calling for re-vote originally voted remain. I have not met a single person in real life who voted brexit, who change their mind other than in the media.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>”quite rightly, be able to say that democracy in the UK is a sham" // A marginal advisary vote on which headline campaign points on the winning side were demonstrable lies? I don't think that demonstrates our representative democracy is a sham. It is a shambles, but your conclusion is unsound. If the populous now would vote the other way, how is pressing for exit of the EU democratic. All you're proving is that good liars can pervert a vote.
- sievebrain 10y agoThe losing side made many, many more lies, much more severe and important. Just a few: David Cameron, "I will not resign even if the vote is out". He resigned immediately. Osborne, "if you vote out there will be a 'punishment budget' of huge spending drops and tax rises". Reality: he was gone immediately. "If out wins Boris will be Prime Minister". Reality: May is PM. "You will go to the back of the queue", Obama. Reality: State Department immediately reversed the US position. "I think given what has happened, the president is going to try and do both [trade deals with the EU and UK] at the same time," Kerry said. "He knows how to multitask." http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/state-dept.-in-damage-control-mode-over-obamas-back-of-the-queue-remark/article/2595242 http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/state-dept.-in-damage-cont... Osborne again: "EU will cost every household £4300 a year". Reality: this claim was garbage and was quietly retired after focus groups showed that nobody believed it, not even pro-EU campaigners. http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36073201 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36073201 "Leaving the EU means migrant camps moving from Calais to Dover". Reality: Le Tocquet agreement is independent of the EU, exists for practical reasons and France has confirmed it will remain in place. Economists in general: "here are some models. believe them". I posted about what Krugman thinks of this elsewhere in the thread, as he has shown the problems with the way economists have behaved better than I can: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/06/30/the-macroeconomics-of-brexit-motivated-reasoning http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/06/30/the-macroeconomi...
- anon1385 10y ago>this claim was garbage and was quietly retired after focus groups showed that nobody believed it The public believing something is totally unrelated to how true it is. This kind of facile populist attitude is what people are criticising about the Leave campaign.
- s_kilk 10y agoAs another commenter pointed out, not doing Brexit would be politically un-tenable, as it would basically hand power straight to UKIP, and further enflame right-wing/fascist sentiment in the UK. Denialism is not a useful response to our current situation.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoIt would split Conservative voters across the Tories and UKIP and give Labour or some coalition (Lib-Con, Lib-Lab, rainbow?) chance to hold power. So, the question is what do there Tories care more about, their party winning or the right result for the country - so, yes Tories will keep the UKIPy edges of their party. Long-term though the plan must be that once the NHS privatisation has been forced they allow much more immigration of those with medical training, the private health companies will need workers. At that point they're going to be losing the right and left wings of the party. Screwing up Europe will buy May's Tories an extra term I imagine so they presumably don't care beyond that.
- alva 10y agoAlways worth remembering that UKIP have taken a humongous number of Labour supporters, not just Conservative.
- sievebrain 10y agoYou appear to be in denial. "Our new PM was a remainer" - but, she was eurosceptic her entire career, the very first thing she said was literally "Brexit means Brexit", she has repeatedly confirmed it's going to happen and she has set up an entirely new ministry to ensure it does. Meanwhile the EU is so impatient for it to happen they are demanding it starts immediately. There is no way back. With respect to "it's difficult to leave without screwing the economy", that seems hard to justify given the number of countries that are not in the EU and yet which are not "screwed".
- jacquesm 10y agoYes, because no politician ever broke a promise when it came in handy.
- anon1385 10y agoOf course, but you have to take into account the strength of feeling over this issue in the UK. The referendum was the most acrimonious vote in the UK in my lifetime. Turnout was very high. The majority of people who normally vote for May's Tory party supported Brexit. There is a staunchly anti-EU party (UKIP) waiting in the wings to pick up large numbers of votes if the Tories don't follow through. UKIP already got 13% of the popular vote at the last election, despite the first-past-the-post system (they only got 0.2% of the MPs). It's not just general public sentiment that constrain's May. Many of May's own back bench MPs care far more about making Brexit happen than they do about keeping the Tories in government (the number of single-issue anti-eu diehard Tory MPs is greater than the Tories majority in parliament). They will bring down her government if she doesn't move towards Brexit.
- jtrip 10y agoThat is assuming that the media, backed by recent and coming economic figures won't scaremonger and break away all the other popular arguments against Brexit, as 'no foreigners' wasn't the only argument. Not to mention that procrastination and fearful reports by the government will also help. The longer it takes the easier it will be to kill it. Of course, all of this assumes May's intention to not exit.
- unfunco 10y agoShe also said "Brexit means brexit." Roughly translated to: "an undefined portmanteau means an undefined portmanteau."
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nmbr213 10y agoThat would prove that democracy is a smoke screen for populi. Well, nothing else to expect of European "Redo votes until we get expected result" Union.