3 ms·
This is an interesting point. My wife is Chinese and she explained this to me: people like her grandfather are thankful for Mao while they acknowledge his failu
by jhedwards 10y ago
This is an interesting point. My wife is Chinese and she explained this to me: people like her grandfather are thankful for Mao while they acknowledge his failures. The reason is simple: before Mao there was a long period of Chaos, and before that the Qing dynasty was an extremely oppressive government. Without going into too many details, the peasants were being screwed for hundreds of years. Because of Mao's efforts China became a unified country. Sure, there were decades of terror and famine the severity of which are astonishing, but they were relatively brief historicaly speaking and the people were just happy that China was "theirs". Moreover, the government was stable enough that the people who came after Mao were able to improve things, which didn't always happen historically.
It's not a great comparison but a similar thing happened with the Ming dynasty. If I recall correctly, the Ming emperor was terribly brutal, but people were so thankful that it wasn't the mongolians that they didn't care.
- eru 10y agoIn a broader Chinese context it makes some sense to see the suffering and rebellions of the late Ming dynasty and perhaps until Deng Xiaoping as the 'usual' chaos of a dynastic transition.
- khuey 10y agoPresumably you mean the late Qing here?
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoWell, unless one assumes the entire Qing dynasty was about suffering.
- eru 10y agoI do, thanks for correcting.
- hack_dcl 10y agoChinese author LuXun summarized China's history into two modes: 1. People had stable right of being slaves; (stable oppressive mode) 2. People didn't even have the privilege of being slaves. (chaos mode) Mao put China into mode 2 from mode 1 (maybe a most harsh and disgusting one). That is it.