4 ms·
The argument that programmers are ridiculous pedants who don't understand anything and should leave the law to The High Priests Who Really Understand These Thin
by AnthonyMouse 10y ago
The argument that programmers are ridiculous pedants who don't understand anything and should leave the law to The High Priests Who Really Understand These Things seems to get more than its share of support, but is that what's going on here?
Suppose there is some thing the law says you can't publish. You encrypt it with AES, throw away the key and then publish the ciphertext. It's not at all clear that the law is going to punish you for that -- nobody can read the information anymore, so whatever evil the law was intended to prevent is not occurring, and anyway the government is going to have a hard time proving their case since without the key they can't actually prove what the ciphertext is.
Now suppose you do the same thing but instead of AES you use 40-bit DES, which anybody can easily break with modern hardware. Now you're arguably publishing the thing, and the government can prove what the ciphertext is, so the outcome could be different. But that wouldn't have been the case in the 1970s when computers were slower.
So what is it about the conclusion that the law could depend on the state of computing power and algorithms that you find so implausible?
- tedunangst 10y agoThe focus on computing power misses the forest for the trees. It's not about available computing power. It's about the intent. If you know decryption is possible, then "wink wink, it's encrypted" is a poor argument that the data wasn't published.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> It's about the intent. And now you've got yourself some trouble, because the intent for publishing the free speech flag can reasonably be as criticism of laws purporting to make certain information illegal. Then you're publishing political speech which is a whole different ballgame. But the better point is that people have become quick to dismiss the math, as if facts and logic and reality are irrelevant to the law. The law has to live inside the universe. It has to do something when the problems the math proves can happen actually do. So for example, the xor situation is interesting. If you xor with random bytes, the result is indistinguishable from random and is capable of encoding literally any information of equal or smaller length -- at the same time -- by changing what you xor it back with. So A xor B is the Declaration of Independence while A xor C is DeCSS, C xor D is the Bill of Rights and C xor E is a trade secret document. Now suppose there are some websites allowing anyone to publish xor-encoded data (or arbitrary data). Somebody uploads A to one such website and C to another. Anybody who asks about A, you can show them B and it encodes the Declaration of Independence. Anybody who asks about C, you can show them D and it encodes the Bill of Rights. So now A and C are being published by separate sites, each is indistinguishable from random, but xor them together and you get DeCSS. DeCSS is being published, but who is publishing it? Who can be forced to remove their half, when doing so would also delete arbitrarily many instances of lawful speech that require the same random bytes (and could be the only copy)? What is the status of B and D, given that you can xor them with public documents to get back A and C? What if you can prove that A is preexisting and C is derived from DeCSS and A? What if there is no way to prove which existed first? If somebody does this, there has to be an answer better than hand-wavy dismissal of inconvenient math.
- nl 10y agoYour XOR case is exactly the same example as the OP posted, just that the encryption algorithm involved the XOR operation, random bytes and another document. In court the judge would attempt to judge the intent of each person involved and rule based on that. You seem to think this is a problem, and indeed it is hard. That why the law uses judges rather than attempting to legislate every possible example. But the better point is that people have become quick to dismiss the math, as if facts and logic and reality are irrelevant to the law. The law has to live inside the universe. It has to do something when the problems the math proves can happen actually do. No. This is the key thing you are missing. Elsewhere on this thread someone put it like this: "I would add the concept that the law, unlike software, is capable of openly defying logic. Courts are permitted to dismiss case law and rule in a completely new and unforeseen direction." The Law is lazily evaluated, in a specific court, in the context of a specific case. It does not follow that the logic in one case applies in another - sometimes it might, sometimes it might not, and things like the intent of the people involved matter.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> Your XOR case is exactly the same example as the OP posted, just that the encryption algorithm involved the XOR operation, random bytes and another document. It isn't. If you encrypt something with most algorithms, there is going to be one key that turns it back into something intelligible and all the others produce garbage. That isn't the case with xor. Different "keys" will produce different intelligible decryptions. > In court the judge would attempt to judge the intent of each person involved and rule based on that. You seem to think this is a problem, and indeed it is hard. That why the law uses judges rather than attempting to legislate every possible example. The hardness is the problem. Suppose somebody sends you a DMCA takedown for what appears to be random numbers, arguing that if you xor it with some specific other random numbers you get infringing content. But that proves nothing because it's true for everything, so what are you supposed to do? What is the judge supposed to do? > No. This is the key thing you are missing. Elsewhere on this thread someone put it like this: "I would add the concept that the law, unlike software, is capable of openly defying logic. Courts are permitted to dismiss case law and rule in a completely new and unforeseen direction." How is that supposed to solve anything? The problem isn't that the court is going to come across "this statement is false" and have a meltdown, the problem is that we can't predict what the court is actually going to do so we don't know how to behave if we want to stay within the law. And furthermore that there isn't anything good for the court to do. Of course the court is not required to do something good, but how is it OK when they do something bad?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- comex 10y agoNot implausible, but... uninteresting. It's like saying, if you shoot someone wearing a bulletproof vest, and the vest is able to absorb the impact and prevent serious injury, the law considers that one thing; but if the shot is too powerful for the vest and kills the person, the law considers that another; therefore the law depends on the state of armor/weapons technology. Sure, it does depend on it, but only indirectly insofar as it affects the outcome the law really cares about. In my hypothetical, that's whether you caused someone to be hurt or killed; in yours, it's whether you caused someone unauthorized to read the data to be capable of reading it.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe difference is, the technology can change underneath you. For example, suppose Comey succeeds in mandating encryption backdoors. Then the backdoor gets compromised and published. You suddenly have an obligation to use an encryption mechanism you know is compromised to transmit things you have an obligation to keep secret. Catch 22. In theory a court might realize the absurdity of that situation and let you out of one of the obligations, but how do you know which one it will be? Or that they won't still demand that you do both, effectively requiring you to shut down your business until the government changes the law?