5 ms·
When prices rise, the result is that the poor have less. The poor will have less water and less food, and those that are already on the edge will dip below what
by pron 10y ago
When prices rise, the result is that the poor have less. The poor will have less water and less food, and those that are already on the edge will dip below what they really need. "People" won't eat less meat; poor people will eat less meat. As the share of income spent on food is much higher for the poor to begin with, they will feel the worst of it. You really don't want to go back to the days when class differences manifested in basic nutrition.
- Houshalter 10y agoThat's such an easily solvable problem that I wonder why people even bring it up. Just distribute all the extra profit from the water sales equally among the population. The poor will get a check more than large enough to pay for the increased cost of water. Alternatively you could just subsidize water use up to some threshold and then charge more for every additional gallon.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoYour first solution sound like it would just inflate prices. Your second doesn't appear to account for any cost increases except for directly used water. This approach seems rather over-simplistic.
- Houshalter 10y agoThe first plan only inflates the price of water, but makes up for it. It's exactly equivalent to letting everyone have an equal share of the water, and letting them decide to use it or sell it.
- DefaultUserHN 10y agoBut everyone can't have an equal share of water, because there is already not enough water to go around in the first place. Unless you mean everyone will get only one cup of water. But then, the farmer will be fucked, because one cup of water is not enough to farm. And if the farmers can't farm, then you'll have another set of problems on your hand: NOT ENOUGH FOOD.
- Houshalter 10y agoThat's just nonsense. There is more than enough water for everyone's basic needs and then some. The problem is people using excessive water on their lawns, agriculture, or industry. And to some extent toilets, showers, and cleaning, which are all nice but could be reduced or cut in a crisis. If a rich person wants to buy extra water to use on their lawn, they can. But they need to find someone willing to sell it, and offer them enough money to make it worth it. If it really gets to the point there is only 1 cup of water per person per day, well then so be it. Everyone gets exactly 1 cup of water. That's perfectly fair. What's not fair is giving 1.5 cups to one person and 0.5 cups to another. Just because they are rich or a farmer or whatever. Such a situation would create huge economic incentives to find more water, to conserve existing water, to reuse waste water, etc. The point is to get the benefits from a free market with incentives, but to distribute the benefits equally among the population.
- DefaultUserHN 10y agoI agree with the free market part. I disagree with the equal redistribution part.
- freyr 10y ago> That's such an easily solvable problem that I wonder why people even bring it up. Edit: initially, I didn't think your first plan works, but then I realized people need water to survive. You can charge anyone an arbitrary amount if the alternative is death by dehydration.
- vmateixeira 10y agoI think he has a point if water market didn't need to generate profit for a private company.
- RobertKerans 10y agoSo then you get to have all the fun issues surrounding nationalised utilities ! (nb I personally feel there are some things that should be public goods, water being one of them, but saying it's a simple solution is naïve)
- Houshalter 10y agoThe water can be nationalized. But the government still needs to put a price on it to prevent overuse. If the price is higher than the operating costs of the water system, then they have profit they can redistribute to the people.
- RobertKerans 10y agoMetering water seems reasonable but there are upfront costs to more widespread adoption (financial + political/social) + a bureaucratic layer (with all the associated complexity/corruption issues) that would need to be implemented for metering plus nationalisation, so while I'm [quite possibly naïvely] personally in favour, it opens a very large can of worms.
- aminok 10y agoYou'll do massive economic damage that harms the poor if you price control or subsidise any commodity, including water. The economy is the way it is because of millions of individual decisions that factored in volumes of information that you could not fathom. Creating a law that with a stroke of a pen overrides the decisions of millions of people on resource usage, based on a simplistic formula created by a couple hundred people in a legislature, is incredibly reckless.
- freyr 10y ago> You'll do massive economic damage that harms the poor if you price control or subsidise any commodity Source? Is it possible the unfathomably complex economic machine will simply adapt to the subsidy? If the subsidy was limited to a couple liters per person per day (e.g., sufficient to ensure survival), could this be less reckless than letting people die of dehydration?
- aminok 10y ago>Source? This is logical extrapolation, and it's more or less validated by empirical evidence. It's not scientifically proven because we're dealing with incredibly complex phenomena where there are always potential confounding factors, but a reasonable case can still be made based on real world events. See Venezuela for an extreme example of the consequences of interventionism. The theory that intervention does harm is based on the fact that this complex system we know as an economy exists the way it does because of carefully weighted decisions of millions of people, each trying to meet their own needs in the most efficient manner available to them that does not cause harm to others (since harmful action is generally illegal in a market economy [there are edge cases of courses, like misleading advertising]). That carefully wrought symphony of welfare-maximizing human interaction is crudely disrupted by authoritarianism any time a legislature signs a law in effect that forces millions to act a certain way, that they otherwise would not have, or refrain from engaging in some voluntary interaction that they otherwise would have engaged in. An authoritarian intervention to force several million to do some action to benefit several other million is going to have innumerable unintended consequences, that could not possibly be a net positive for the world.