12 ms·
I've never been as afraid of fresh water shortage as a lot of other people seem to be precisely because it is exactly the kind of shortage that is solved by mar
by CydeWeys 10y ago
I've never been as afraid of fresh water shortage as a lot of other people seem to be precisely because it is exactly the kind of shortage that is solved by market forces. Freshwater getting scarce? OK, so the price goes up. Now there's more incentive to conserve water by replacing fixtures for low-flow variants, letting your lawn die (why do you really need one in a desert anyway), and using more efficient irrigation methods in agriculture. The price of water still keeps going up? Then the price of meat goes up because growing crops to feed animals become more expensive, and people eat less meat. Meanwhile, increased price makes desalination more profitable, and more plants come online.
I don't see it as anything rising close to a civilization-ending threat. Seawater is abundant. Freshwater can be made cheaply enough. We are extravagantly wasteful with water as it is, and that can be fixed easily enough as it becomes more expensive.
- ph0rque 10y agoYup. The fresh-water problem is an energy problem, and it's getting solved.
- WalterBright 10y agoIt's also a pricing problem. Shortages happen when the price is not allowed to rise.
- gunnihinn 10y agoWell I'm glad you guys nailed the problem in three tweets or so.
- icelancer 10y agoThere's a difference between solving the problem (which it has been) and municipalities/governments/etc thinking the solution is palatable.
- tomjen3 10y agoNot all big problems have complicated solutions.
- sullyj3 10y agoThen why aren't the big problems with simple solutions solved already? If your answer is something along the lines of "politics", or "coordination is hard", or "people are stupid", I'd argue that those factors are part of the problem and a solution should account for them.
- sbov 10y agoWater rights are way more complex than platitudes pulled from a high school economics class.
- WalterBright 10y agoEndless economic troubles happen when governments try to repeal supply&demand or deny its existence. A topical example is the drought in California mixed in with the political distribution of water rights.
- jacquesm 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cochabamba_Water_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cochabamba_Water_War
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- azinman2 10y agoExcept the market doesn't let society prioritize. In CA, a big part of the water issue was what goes to humans vs farmers. That's not something that the market should be solving, that's for policy, because things like almonds being a status symbol in China cause major issues locally and distort the picture of supply & demand.
- sbov 10y agoEven beyond that, lot of those farmers bought the right to access a certain amount of water when they bought their land. Taking it away from them is like taking property away from someone in SF because they didn't pay enough for it back in the 80s.
- dpark 10y agoEminent domain is a thing. When public good demands it (or when cronyism pushes it through), we do in fact take property from private citizens. The idea that farmers' water rights are inalienable seems absurd to me. A state can be in a drought but farmers needn't curb their usage at all? If each suburban plot of land in California hypothetically came with a guarantee of 100k gallons of water a month, there would be no doubt that this would be cut immediately when a drought hit. It's only farmers' lobbying power that stops their water rights from being restructured wholesale. With that said, I do think agriculture rightfully gets a lot of water allocated. Much of it seems wasted, though.
- discordance 10y agoI've always thought areas where desert meets the sea present incredible opportunities. It has heavily under utilized land, abundance of insolation and plenty of water that could be desalinated If we grew crops in these areas, then both food and water would be a function of energy.
- justinator 10y ago> It has heavily under utilized land, abundance of insolation and plenty of water that could be desalinated Southern California is one such place where the desert meets the sea. It is not underutilized, but it is undergoing a massive drought.
- RijilV 10y agoThis ignores another key component of agriculture- nutrients in the solid. Land that hasn't had a diverse ecosystem on it for decades isn't going to have the required nutrients. Sure you can dump additives in the ground and boost this years crop but that isn't going to create long term healthy soil which can support farming. Fertilizers are just another dependency on fossil fuels. Water is certainly a part of terraforming a desert, but only a part of it.
- vkou 10y agoEnergy is a huge problem in many areas where access to freshwater is threatened. Wealthy nations can afford to get their water in whichever way they want. Nobody's going to pay for a RO plant in, say, Syria.
- JDDunn9 10y agoIt might not be a civilization-ending threat, but it affects several outliers. - If you live on less than $1 a day, rising food/water costs is a big deal. - If you are in a land-locked country, desalination isn't an option. - Desalination plants aren't built over night. In the meantime droughts would have consequences. - If water became a major percentage of the cost of food, it would shift what crops are grown. Towards monoculture and away from diversity. The poor would especially be constrained. - If we let our lawns die, we'll see more property damage due to soil erosion.
- jogjayr 10y ago> If we let our lawns die, we'll see more property damage due to soil erosion. Replace them with native plants.
- shitgoose 10y agoNeighbours will complain and city will fine you. So better let the fucking lawn die. /sarc
- CydeWeys 10y agoA lot of cities in the US that are experiencing severe drought have prohibited watering lawns. So they won't fine you for letting them die, just the opposite -- they'll fine you if they catch you watering your lawn to keep it green.
- wahern 10y agoI tend to agree. But the devil is in the details. When it comes to agriculture and industry (the largest consumers, by far) demand and supply isn't as elastic as you make it out to be. And that's exacerbated by volatility, both in demand but especially in supply--a drought isn't always a slow decline or even a simple precipitous drop in supply but often manifests in wild fluctuations. That kind of environment makes capital investments, including investments in such things as desalination and power plants, risky and thus quite costly. So it's no surprise that most of these desalination plants are either government owned or otherwise heavily subsidized. That's not exactly the outcome one would expect of the free market if it were as simple as implementing a proper pricing scheme. Rather, I think the takeaway is that water is one of those areas that proves that while the laws of supply & demand are utterly inviolable, price signaling can't always be readily accomplished through basic monetary schemes. Because of far reaching and pervasive externalities that make price signaling difficult. (Consumer pricing is obviously well suited but only the tip of the iceberg.) And because the capital investments required push the envelope of what the capital markets can efficiently handle. And yet because water is so fundamental its one of those areas where even governments (at least, well-functioning governments) can be relatively responsive. Those that don't handle it well tend to be winnowed out rather quickly--either by change of government or just societal collapse.
- nstj 10y agoTheoretically the volatility should be priced in to the elasticities (it's just a backward looking concept so providers of capital can see how erratic these demand and supply issues are). Also what do you mean by the term "monetary scheme"?
- wahern 10y agoBy "monetary" I meant pricing in cash or equivalents, generally between individual economic agents. I don't know what the correct terminology might be. I was alluding to the fact that politics is also a kind of market for price signaling. Regulatory schemes are a signal to either reduce supply (literally, as in the Federal regulatory scheme for the wholesale electricity market) or to otherwise stop externalizing some cost. Economists quantify that in terms of the effect on market pricing because it's a much more useful and mature model for analytical purposes, but fundamentally that's just semantics. Political power is subject to the dynamic forces of economic laws like anything else, we just lack the ability to quantify it as well. I like to think of government as just another large firm, and its product is legitimacy. Government does have the power of violence, but from a regulatory perspective (as opposed to criminal law perspective) that's often irrelevant in the aggregate. For example, in San Francisco there are many thousands of illegal in-law units. But never would the government go around house-to-house to enforce the law, and rarely do so even when given notice. The politicians would be voted out of office the moment anybody caught wind of such a thing. The problem with water is the externalities, some of which are extremely difficult to price. So it's irrelevant that we can use e.g. futures markets to mitigate volatility. Imagine that overnight somebody said that Silicon Valley is unsuitable for technology firms. Everybody needs to get up and go somewhere else. We could probably price the immediate effect fairly easily--cost of relocation, for example. But now consider that the economy of the entire Bay Area and indeed of all of California depends heavily on the technology economy. What's the cost of all the unemployed engineers who didn't get relocated? The cost to the companies and people serving the tech industry? The cost to the state of not only lost revenue, but of past and present budget allocations. Of unemployment? Of crime? Of the path-dependent evolution of economies, generally? Some of that is impossible to know given our current understanding. And how do we internalize some of the benefit that will accrue to where ever those companies migrate to? Theoretically that should be possible, and ideally that would be done to minimize disruption. Now imagine somebody told you that if the government intervened and did X, Y, and Z, then the tech industry was viable and could stay, at least for the time being. At best everything will continue as before, at worst there'll be a moderately slow wind down. But in any event things will be much more stable. What do you think is going to happen? Are we (society) going to choose to develop a futures market for pricing the volatility, or are we going to turn to government? Whatever we do, the environmental forces against the tech firms will remain, it's the mechanisms we employ to manage the direct and especially indirect costs that is different. That's water in a nutshell for many areas of the world. For example, the entire economy of the Central Valley of California is dependent on agriculture. In total dollars the immediate benefit of agriculture to the California economy is surprisingly small. But there's a reason California bends over backwards to sustain the industry. It's not just about corporate campaign money. Again, the industry is small by dollar amount. And if the costs of sustaining agriculture were so inefficient you can be sure other corporations would be using their political donations to fight such laws. After all, it's _easy_ to import water. We don't need futures markets for water, or even to build desalination plants. Certainly not in California where there's more than enough water for residential use. The most efficient solution to drought is to import industrial and agricultural products which rely on water. But for various reasons there's a limit to how far countries wish to go down that track, or at least how quickly they want to.
- huuu 10y agoIn The Netherlands they are testing the growth of potatoes on salt water. So we can also try to adapt to salt water
- dogma1138 10y agoThat's because the salt water penetrates deep into the land due to the topography of the Netherlands. There Dutch have practiced salt water farming and management for a long time. That said you can't drink salt water ;)
- witty_username 10y agoStrictly speaking you can drink salt water. But it wouldn't hydrate you since you would still be thirsty.
- CydeWeys 10y agoC'mon, everyone knows what drinkable water is. You can technically also drink boiling water, or battery acid for that matter, but nobody would classify those under the category "drinkable liquids" which is what we're talking about here.
- vacri 10y agoWhat happens if the [state|country] upstream taking water is the source of your shortage? What happens if you have no leverage to make them stop?
- dogma1138 10y agoWar happens. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_over_Water_(Jordan_river) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_over_Water_(Jordan_river...
- eximius 10y agoUnless the efficient market hypothesis is bounded by time, it doesn't really help. Saying that eventually we'll realize what the correct price for an asset should be is incredibly unhelpful if we've already done permanent damage to ourselves or our environment.
- nstj 10y agoThis is an excellent addition to EMH.
- pron 10y agoWhen prices rise, the result is that the poor have less. The poor will have less water and less food, and those that are already on the edge will dip below what they really need. "People" won't eat less meat; poor people will eat less meat. As the share of income spent on food is much higher for the poor to begin with, they will feel the worst of it. You really don't want to go back to the days when class differences manifested in basic nutrition.
- Houshalter 10y agoThat's such an easily solvable problem that I wonder why people even bring it up. Just distribute all the extra profit from the water sales equally among the population. The poor will get a check more than large enough to pay for the increased cost of water. Alternatively you could just subsidize water use up to some threshold and then charge more for every additional gallon.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoYour first solution sound like it would just inflate prices. Your second doesn't appear to account for any cost increases except for directly used water. This approach seems rather over-simplistic.
- Houshalter 10y agoThe first plan only inflates the price of water, but makes up for it. It's exactly equivalent to letting everyone have an equal share of the water, and letting them decide to use it or sell it.
- DefaultUserHN 10y agoBut everyone can't have an equal share of water, because there is already not enough water to go around in the first place. Unless you mean everyone will get only one cup of water. But then, the farmer will be fucked, because one cup of water is not enough to farm. And if the farmers can't farm, then you'll have another set of problems on your hand: NOT ENOUGH FOOD.
- tomjen3 10y agoThere is one problem with that - the farms that have water rights that means they can make almonds in the desert. If there were a free market for water I would agree with you, nothing in the world will end a shortage of anything faster than a free market.
- nitrogen 10y agoIf almonds grow better in the desert than anywhere else, then people should continue growing them there and import water from elsewhere. It's easier to move water than sunlight.
- flushandforget 10y agoHow does Dubai do this? I like the idea of piping water about, but could it change local eco-systems/weather?
- Torkel 10y agoThere is a good episode of the podcast 'Econtalk' on this subject. My take-away from listening to that is that supply and demand and setting the price according to the supply would solve most of the world's water problem. Except that's not the way it's done. They mentioned so many silly subsidies and flat out craziness going on in the water markets that it made templated C++ code seem sane in comparison :/
- vmateixeira 10y agoAnd how would you regulate the market? How about the poor?
- tim333 10y agoWith the poor you can give everyone a free allowance and charge over that. Regulation is complicated though.
- ekr 10y agoYes, but it may destabilize the economy. The price may go up by such a degree that a significant percentage of the population can no longer afford food, which may lead to social unrest. I'm not sure if your attitude, that supply and demand fixes everything, is the most probable outcome.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoThey're right, supply and demand fixes it - you price out the poor people, they die, then demand is reduced. Capitalism usefully values human life at circa zero when resources are limited, or when there are lots of humans available to feed in to your luxury goods supply chain. See, no problem.
- tinco 10y agoIt's not entirely zero though. I learned/was reminded of this by 'Capital in the 21st century': Poor people make up society, when they are pushed over a certain line of comfort they will apply pressure to the system to rectify. In these situations rectification can mean one of several things: Decapitating all who are or seem to be in power or inflating currency until being rich loses its meaning. Obviously those two solutions are not very attractive to the capitalist market players, so there is an incentive to form structure with the goal of sustaining society. Though history shows capitalist markets are not good (enough) at forming that structure (thus their heads roll).
- eggy 10y agoValue, or market forces, supply and demand are inherent in any system where the numbers of people of more than a few are involved. The poor don't get priced out and die as you write. A potential market attracts problem solvers, yes, to make a profit (not a dirty word always), and new solutions are found to new problems - that is technology. Sometimes it creates new problems, hopefully less of a problem, and the cycle continues. Look at Cuba for what happens when you are cut off from trade, don't allow individuals to decide what they want to be when they grow up, and don't utilize technology and your natural resources efficiently. I don't think any system, Capitalism, Socialism, what have you, allow you to meet and greet 7 billion people and get to know them to determine what is best for each individual, so yes, I'll go with market forces, supply and demand unless you have the ability to create something from nothing. These things emerge for the most part, and are not fully intentional constructs.
- k-mcgrady 10y ago>> "do you really need one in a desert anyway" Do you really need to live in a desert? Why would a human civilisation choose to live in a place that lacks an essential ingredient for life? It seems we choose to do this in deserts all over the world so there must be a reason.
- StavrosK 10y agoBecause it looks like human civilisations choose to live everywhere.
- massysett 10y agoBecause the desert might have other things humans find useful, such as minerals.
- CydeWeys 10y ago99.9% of the people living in Phoenix and Las Vegas aren't there to mine minerals. This is just a complete non sequitur. For an actual example of towns that exist primarily to supply labor for resource extraction, look at the Canadian towns in the Alberta tar-sands region. They are much, much smaller.
- massysett 10y agoMany of them probably live in Phoenix in part because they like the climate--thus, there is something there that people find useful.
- jlg23 10y agoFirst of all they usually settle within walking distance to a source of fresh water - some areas in Israel are the great exemption here. And there is plenty of reason: * historic: a lot of trade routes for sought-after goods went through deserts * economic: rich fishing grounds just off the coast - see Western Sahara for an example (Boujdour and Dakhla being the main cities) * economic: a lot of nomadic farmers live in deserts because they provide just enough food for the livestock * politics: keep disputed areas occupied (Israel and Western Sahara as examples) * politics: borders - these things tend keep people from freely moving to more hospitable areas * nature: some think deserts are beautiful (count me in) * spiritual: very low population density and a very tight connection to the forces of nature appeal to some people
- pipio21 10y agoRemember Arab Spring? People in the West believe that it was about "freedom", but it was about food and life getting so expensive normal people needed to spend most of their salary just on it. Poor people not being able to eat well or not eat at all as there were no jobs. People will revolt if they can't buy food because it is very expensive. That is the civilization ending treat: war. War is really the worst experience you could experience. I will remember things I have seen in Congo all my life. For example WWII was created because Germans lived a miserable life paying for WW1 and Great depression. Just interest in the WW1 debt grew faster than their productivity meaning they were slaves forever, just like Greece is today. Americans were very careful not making the compensation for war for Germany excessive in order not to repeat History. People will choose whoever person that promises an easy exit for their problems, and the easiest thing is to steal from others. You don't have water, you take the places that have water, like the Golan heights. And that is war. For market forces to work you need a long time. Inventors will only discover innovative methods after working for decades in a problem. Letting your lawn die? This is a really stupid idea. I have worked in Sahara desert precisely helping people stop the desert just putting vegetation in place(that holds sand and makes soil so wind does not move it).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 10y agoThe Arab Spring happened precisely in those countries that were already totalitarian and dysfunctional anyway. If not this crisis it could've just as easily been something else, like what's going on in Turkey right now. A lot of the Middle East petro-states are only propped up by their oil wealth, the profits on which go mostly to the elites, with token handouts and subsidies for everyone else. They've already had to subsidize food and water for a long time in order to prevent their societies from revolting, and increased costs due to desalination is thus only a difference in degree, not kind. As for the World War II comparison, well, the world is simply different now in a huge number of ways. So while I don't disagree with the examples you bring up, I just don't see them being relevant to developed democratic societies, which I believe can solve these problems. A lot of the remainder already has problems anyway, and water scarcity is one of a laundry list of problems on their plate, which also includes displacement due to rising sea levels, climate change, you name it. As for letting your lawn die, what I really meant but didn't say because it doesn't sound as pithy is to replace your lawn with landscaping or native flora that require much less water to maintain. There are many parts of California, Phoenix, Las Vegas, and other places that are all essentially desert, and rapidly tend back towards desert in the absence of voluminous irrigation. It makes no sense to waste thousands of liters of water per lawn per day keeping non-native grasses alive in the middle of a desert. For the cost of only several months' water you can replace your yard with something that doesn't need watering and won't blow away in a storm, the simplest and cheapest replacement being gravel.
- madaxe_again 10y agoThere's another side benefit to desalination that nobody seems to have mentioned here yet, which is solar ponds, as you can use the resultant "waste" brine to make the required halocline. Solar ponds are a means of generating usable energy from the storage of solar energy within a body of brine. Israel actually made headway with this tech in the 80's, but shelved it as there was no real urgent need for it - but there's new interest in it as a renewable energy source. Anyway, wikipedia gives a bit more background: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_pond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_pond
- flushandforget 10y agoI'm in the UK, and recently tried to make sense of my water bill as I've a change in how our waste is managed. We are off the sewer network with about 50 houses with a treatment works. An annual water bill from average figures for our region (different water companies), is about £400 for a two person household and £600 for four. You pay more for your waste removal than clean water intake. Waste is measured against clean water intake. We are now looking at a figure of over a pound per day for waste removal. The figure feels steep to me. If I could separate liquids and solids easily, then actually I could dump both in the garden. If you have the space then composting seems like a great solution. And would save flushing all that clean water down the toilet.
- CydeWeys 10y agoModern plumbing, freshwater, and waste removal is literally one of the top five inventions of all time for increasing lifespan and quality of life. You don't realize how good you have it until you go try to live in a village that doesn't have freshwater or wastewater disposal, where you have to trudge miles per day to fill up large heavy containers from sources that are already polluted anyway, and that needs to be further treated with boiling before it's safe to use. So in that context, it's absurd to think that £1 per day is steep to get all of those benefits. Back when I had a house our water bill was way more than you're paying, and I would've been willing to pay way more still. Having fresh safe water available at the flick of a tap whenever you need it, and all waste products disposed of without spreading contagion, is a modern day miracle.
- flushandforget 10y agoRather than a miracle it's a partially solved engineering problem. Using potable water to transport poo seems rather wasteful, when a low tech composting approach is rather simple. Or perhaps the sewerage network should be replaced with a multi-purpose, transport network, or some other innovation. You can process your own waste by pumping air basically through black water, all very good. But at the same time you can just throw a turd on the compost heap if you have the room, and nature will do its thing, and you'll build up your soil. Education of good habits and some simple practice goes a long way.
- __Joker 10y agoThe problem with this kind of thinking at least in developing and undeveloped countries is water is seen as kind of right and most of the time expected it to be free. Most of the time there will be a political out-lash if water is commodified.
- billions 10y agoGlobal warming will be fixed in the same fashion - via a mass market, technological solution.
- FLUX-YOU 10y agoLots of food wastage as it is, so that would just close that gap. After the media panic wears off, it'd stabilize at a lower wastage rate.
- andrepd 10y agoNo, you've never been afraid of water shortages because you live in a first world country and earn thousands of dollars per month, plain and simple. If you were living with 2$ a day and rising food costs meant a meal cost 3$ I would like to see you sing a different tune about "food is expensive? just eat less meat and let "the market" figure it out".
- thinkcontext 10y agoI urge you to look at "Climate change in the Fertile Crescent and implications of the recent Syrian drought" [0] linked to in the article. It describes mass displacement in Syria following a severe 3 year drought, which in turn have contributed to the conflict there. While not every drought is going to lead to a civil war its a dramatic example of how the type of market adjustment you are talking about is not a smooth, painless experience. [0] http://www.pnas.org/content/112/11/3241.abstract http://www.pnas.org/content/112/11/3241.abstract
- cmurf 10y agoI'm guessing you haven't read the Grapes of Wrath? Any ideas why the Dust Bowl wasn't solved by market forces? It actually was civilization ending in affected areas of Oklahoma, Kansas, and Texas. And the massive migration that ensued had negative impacts around the country too.
- adolph 10y agoMarket forces prevented the Dust Bowl until the US govt induced settlement by farmers who used techniques that were ecologically incompatible in the longer run. It was a mistake and civilization learned from it and resources were revalued accordingly. I suppose that the US govt is a market force of sorts, but probably not what the parent comment had in mind.
- fnord123 10y agoDesalination plants are expensive and take a long time to build. It's not something that can be built to react to market forces. The Sorek desalination plant in the article started construction in January 2011 and was operational in October 2013 at a cost of 400m USD. It's owned by the government. So, really, the market did not solve this.