5 ms·
Isn't the problem here that she donated all her photos to the Library of Congress without clarifying what that meant? Apparently, the LoC thought that the photo
by StavrosK 10y ago
Isn't the problem here that she donated all her photos to the Library of Congress without clarifying what that meant? Apparently, the LoC thought that the photos were placed in the public domain, and the photographer thought she was retaining the copyrights.
Also, why the hell is Getty charging for public domain photos? Are they not aware that people can use those without paying Getty?
- rm999 10y ago> "Ms. Highsmith has stipulated that her photographs are in the public domain" - Library of Congress (http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/res/482_high.html http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/res/482_high.html) > "Highsmith says she never abandoned her photo copyrights" -article Yikes, that seems like a big misunderstanding. I would guess the LOC has a process to transfer the ownership of photos. If so, she probably signed away her copyrights without realizing it (???) Either way, what Getty is doing is terrible and wrong. I don't see how she can sue for copyright damages if she doesn't have the copyright, but I hope they're punished for it. I'm not a lawyer, so someone please correct me if I'm misunderstanding something here.
- anarres 10y agoI believe you are correct, but I suspect that's why she's not actually asking damages for copyright infringement, but for DMCA false copyright information. Anyone injured by that can sue: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1203 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1203 It's a really big deal that this obscure section in DMCA (1202/1203) can be used for this, and I believe she has a good case.
- pavel_lishin 10y ago> Isn't the problem here that she donated all her photos to the Library of Congress without clarifying what that meant? No, because > why the hell is Getty charging for public domain photos? There is no amount of clarification there that allows Getty to charge for something. Either it's in the public domain, in which case they have no right to charge for use of the photos, or it's not, in which case they have no right to charge for the photos. I'd wager that this is some sort of colossal business fuck-up that's not anyone's fault. Mostly because I can't imagine anyone so baldly stealing money.
- donatj 10y agoPeople charge for public domain things all the time. I've bought plenty of books from the 17 and 18 hundreds on my kindle. Pay for the convenience and for them putting together a nice version.
- kuschku 10y agoBut the publishers of those nicer versions don't go around and threaten anyone who got them for free with lawyers. Getty actively threatened anyone using the public domain images.
- onli 10y agoActually, the copyright those nicer versions sometimes claim already lead to this exact situation, with publishers making the case that the derivative work should be awarded new copyright. Here however it is clear-cut, the photos are not modified.
- anc84 10y agoOh but surely the images were optimised for computer display in a non-trivial process!
- chillydawg 10y agoThat's actually not totally unreasonable. Also maybe getty ran some clever image recognition to auto tag them up and organise them all? That's all a useful charge-able service. Going after existing usage is clearly BS, though.
- artursapek 10y agoShe just had her photo up on her website. They clearly went after her without any reason to believe she used their "clever organization" image searching service. These scumbags were probably using an image recognition bot to scrape the web for all usage and spraying everyone with legal letters.
- johnloeber 10y agoRegarding your first point: you can place an item into the public domain but retain the copyright. See some of the Creative-Commons licenses that allow free use but disallow commercial use of your IP. Regarding your second point: Getty is a content distributor. When it comes to stock photos, many designers just go straight to Getty or one of its large competitors to browse for stock photos. The designers aren't going to know which of those photos are available freely and which are not. (By analogy, this is why you when you want to watch a movie, you immediately find it to rent on iTunes, as opposed to spending twenty minutes finding a decent pirated copy.)
- jessriedel 10y ago> Regarding your first point: you can place an item into the public domain but retain the copyright. See some of the Creative-Commons licenses that allow free use but disallow commercial use of your IP. That's not what public domain means. > The term “public domain” refers to creative materials that are not protected by intellectual property laws such as copyright, trademark, or patent laws. http://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/public-domain/welcome/ http://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/public-domain/welcome/ > Works in the public domain are those whose exclusive intellectual property rights have expired, have been forfeited, or are inapplicable...The term is not normally applied to situations where the creator of a work retains residual rights, in which case use of the work is referred to as "under license" or "with permission". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain
- overcast 10y agoAnyone can reproduce and sell public domain stuff, which is how you get old books published. The problem comes when Getty claims copyright ownership over something they DO NOT own.
- FireBeyond 10y agoThen they should be able to show up to court with information on where they -did- get the images (because they didn't create them), and the photographer's release, of course...
- tommorris 10y agoPerfectly legal to charge for public domain photos, just as it is legal to charge for software that's released under open source licenses, so long as you follow the terms of the license. People are lazy and will pay money so they don't have to think about licensing. If you are a graphic designer working in an ad agency and you have a choice between "go online and download a PD work and not be sure" and "pay Getty $50 and if there's a copyright issue, you can tell your boss that you paid Getty", which do you do? Pop it on the corporate credit card is the easier option. It's the same reason big companies were suspicious of open source for a long time. And some still are.
- ptaipale 10y agoIs it legal to charge for public domain photos, if you mislead the person who is charged to believe that the photos are not public domain? I guess this depends on local legislation, but in most jurisdictions, I think this would be called fraud.
- cookiecaper 10y agoIt's legal to charge for public domain content. It's not legal to misrepresent your wares to the buyer (fraud, as you said). There is no duty to inform buyers that the thing you're selling is available for free somewhere else, but when you're going around and demanding royalties from people using something that's PD and claiming to have an exclusive right to licensing the image, it's a different ball game. So yeah, just selling it on their website is probably fine, but extorting money out of people who have equal right to use the image is probably not.
- jessriedel 10y agoYea, this is an interesting effect. I wonder why there isn't an OpenSourceGetty company that charges a much lower fee for guaranteeing that the IP really is open source? They do the research leg work, and then you pay them $5 for a commitment to reimburse/defend you if you get sued. I guess someone else could just try to free-ride off them by not doing the research, but honestly the legal commitment ("bonded open source") would be the valuable and expensive part.
- syshum 10y agoIt is not simply that Getty is attempting to charge for the Photos But rather Getty is Claiming Copyright over the photos, and are Issue Cease and Deist letters to anyone they find using the photos that did not pay Getty for a License. So regardless of the status of Public Domain or not, Getty is not the Copyright Holder, and should not be issuing DMCA, or other Demand Letters claiming they are.
- tzs 10y ago> Also, why the hell is Getty charging for public domain photos? The article was not clear on where Getty got the photos. If they did not get them from the Library of Congress, they might not have known that they are (purportedly) public domain.
- jws 10y agoThe article doesn't seem to touch on why Getty thinks they own the rights to the images. I'll toss out a few possibilities: • Getty buys images from many people. Perhaps an unscrupulous individual bundled up a bunch of images from the library of congress, misrepresented their ownership, and sold them to Getty. (Bonus dickery to use a false identity so Getty can't find you to try to sue you back.) • Getty could have bulk loaded up on hoards of public domain photos to sell to people looking for images. There's nothing wrong with that, curation has merit. But at some point they might have missed setting or checking the bit that says "we don't own exclusive rights on this one". • Or the pitchfork and torch mob could be right.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoEither of your explanations of negligence on Getty's behalf could be correct. IMO neither should mean they avoid the full charge for infringement/false attribution/fraud (whatever) for the attempt to sue people for using works Getty had no rights over. Yes, it's fine they might have had a computer glitch that mislabelled things, yes they may have bought a batch of images with dodgy copyright/origin information. But, at the point at which they instructed personnel to issue a demand notice for infringement there is no excuse for not first checking they actually owned the rights to the images in question. The deliberate avoidance of checking their rights prior to their negligent infringement demand - for a company whose raison d'etre is handling copyright and licensing of image - is well beyond the bounds of criminality. Ignoring the information presented to then that they were acting tortuously, makes for reckless infringement (at best) on a massive scale and should really be leading to personal criminal prosecutions for those who oversaw (or neglected to properly oversee) the creation of such systems. The relevant investigatory powers should be inside Getty now looking to see if there is evidence that this was a known commercial practice of Getty to fraudulently misrepresent their ownership of other's copyright.
- bad_user 10y agoThere's no such thing, no law that allows one to place their work in the public domain! Yes, you can attach a copyright license that allows one to use your work for any purpose, but you still retain the copyright.
- dahart 10y agoYou can waive your copyrights in which case you do not retain them. You can also, as you say, assign a public domain license and retain copyrights, but that isn't considered "public domain" per se. 'Examples for works actively dedicated into public domain by their authors are reference implementations of cryptographic algorithms,[6][7][8] NIH's ImageJ,[9] and the CIA's The World Factbook.[10] The term is not normally applied to situations where the creator of a work retains residual rights, in which case use of the work is referred to as "under license" or "with permission".' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_domain
- grengineer 10y agoActually USA goverment works like the CIA World Factbook are public domain only inside USA. According to (S. REP. NO. 473, 94th Cong., 2d Sess. 56 (1976)) section 105 page 59 The prohibition on copyright protection for United States Government works is not intended to have any effect on protection of these works abroad. Works of the governments of most other countries are copyrighted. There are no valid policy reasons for denying such protection to United States Government works in foreign countries, or for precluding the Government from making licenses for the use of its works abroad.