5 ms·
While $1B seems excessive, and more of a number to make a point, it does seem outrageously egregious to send her a bill for her own photo on her own website tha
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
While $1B seems excessive, and more of a number to make a point, it does seem outrageously egregious to send her a bill for her own photo on her own website that she donated for public use.
It would be like coming home to find a naked vagrant sitting on your couch, demanding that you pay him rent.
- _yosefk 10y agoYour analogy is pretty precise up to the "naked" part. I've heard pretty bad things about Getty Images from their customers (much more expensive than competitors, much worse customer service.) Naked I've never heard...
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI'm going to add a post-hoc rationalization that has something to do with it being a ballsy move, though I wasn't thinking of that at the time...
- logfromblammo 10y agoTo distinguish from a nudist's casual disregard for garments and a hermit's inability to acquire substantial coverings, perhaps it would be better if Getty were not entirely naked, but instead had its underpants dropped to its ankles. That says, "I own clothes, and usually wear them in a socially acceptable way, but I made an exception just for you and your formerly unstinky couch cushions."
- steego 10y agoCopyright thugs have been punishing people with outrageous fines and settlements for years. $1B doesn't seem excessive. Live by the sword. Die by the sword.
- gozur88 10y agoThat's my take as well. It's bad enough companies make legitimate but lazy mistakes like filing DMCA strikes against works with the same name as something they own. But it seems like the absolute minimum you ought to do is make sure beyond a doubt you own what you claim to own.
- dublinben 10y agoIt's likely that Getty have also fraudulently charged many other customers licenses for these photos. It's not inconceivable that each of them could individually sue Getty for their own damages. This looks like it could become a very expensive case of sloppy (or deliberately negligent) copyright overreach.
- morninj 10y agoNit: by definition, negligence can't be deliberate. Edit: "negligence" means you should have known of the risk. "Recklessness" means you knew of the risk but acted anyway.
- newman314 10y ago"Extremely careless" Sorry, could not resist.
- simpsond 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_negligence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_negligence
- morninj 10y ago"Gross negligence" means you really really should have known of the risk. But it's still a contradiction to say that someone was deliberately grossly negligent.
- finnh 10y agoNot really, I don't think. That's basically the idea behind deniability - you kinda sort know about something, but you kinda sort make sure you never actually know about it. Gross negligence is often more along the lines of "we are 99.999% sure you are lying, but we can't prove it".
- morninj 10y ago
- overcast 10y agoFirst rule of any price negotiation, always start WAY too high :) On a serious note, Getty has been doing this underhanded shit for ages, and the amount they pay photographers is even worse. From what I've read, they don't even report to photographers, who downloaded their works. So there really is no accountability, on how many you REALLY sold. It's shady nonsense.
- mikeash 10y agoIt's only about twice the statutory damages. And it looks like the article is only using $25,000 per work for that number. For willful infringement, statutory damages can go up to $150,000, which would be about $2.8 billion for 18,755 photos here. I'd say she's being fairly generous by offering to settle for a mere $1 billion!
- thehashrocket 10y agoMaybe she's taking a play out of their own book? "We could have sued you for this much, but instead we're offering you a chance to settle for only this amount."
- Fuxy 10y agoHa ha... funny. I would have sued them for the full amount the law permitted for each image if the company goes under as a result that would act as example/discouragement for any other company that would think about doing that in the future. People get fined ridiculous amounts all the time as discouragement so why shouldn't companies have the same happen to them their technically a person in the US no?
- rbanffy 10y agoIf the company goes under because it can't make the full payment, I'd accept a transfer of the remaining copyrights and promptly place everything in the public domain.
- anarres 10y agoIt's because she's asking under DMCA 1202/1203, false copyright information, not for infringement.
- codingdave 10y agoYes, $1B sounds excessive... but that is also a valid legal strategy -- making your complaint cover everything under the sun, for as much damages as possible, expecting their lawyers to fight each point and amount, and hopefully the end result is something you actually find acceptable.
- protomyth 10y agoIt might be excessive, but we are talking about 18,755 images, and I bet Getty has won cases over single images in the $55,000 range. Its only fair they pay the same that they won from others.
- Fuxy 10y agoIt's not excessive it's too low now $1B per image would be excessive but not unheard of so still fair. Now $18,755B would make for a nice discouraging lawsuit that make any other company think twice about pulling this ever again. I want Getty to go bankrupt as a result of the lawsuit. I'm evil I know but it's what they would have done so I see nothing wrong with that.
- Lagged2Death 10y agoWhile $1B seems excessive, and more of a number to make a point... Broadly speaking, the "content industry" has habitually been dragging individual file-sharers into court and claiming life-altering, bankruptcy-forcing judgements for more trivial violations, in order to terrify the general public into compliance. If the threat of a $1B judgement is enough to threaten Getty with bankruptcy, if it's enough to scare other rights-claimers into making their businesses more businesslike, that's actually very comparable.
- jliptzin 10y agoI very much hope that a $1B judgment is enough to put Getty Images out of business based on their terrible practices but sadly I would imagine it would take much more than that.