3 ms·
This article is neat about the engineering/marketing (seriously, it’s clear and direct and has useful pictures; that part is highly recommended). The part about
by jacobolus 17y ago
This article is neat about the engineering/marketing (seriously, it’s clear and direct and has useful pictures; that part is highly recommended). The part about vision and color is pretty sloppy though.
This sentence:
> “The reason this trick works is that rods are 20x as dense as cones in the retina, meaning the eye has approximately sqrt(20)=4.5x the spatial resolution in detecting intensity or luminance transitions compared to detecting color or chrominance transitions.”
... is simply false. The reason that we see lightness differences with better spatial resolution has (almost) nothing to do with numbers of rods vs. cones (indeed rods are almost absent from the fovea – the center of the retina – which we use for fine detail perception, basically the opposite of what was claimed), but instead happens because the signals from the three types of cone cells are processed into a single (monochromatic) lightness response, which we use for perception of fine detail. The signals from the cone cells are also processed into two color difference signals, but over bigger patches of retina: sort of a neurological analog to the “chroma subsampling” that happens in JPEG compression. In other words, JPEG compression does work because we see fine details monochromatically, but instead of “leveraging” this mostly irrelevant cone/rod difference as claimed, it’s really using the same basic approach (averaging/tossing out color data) that the eye itself uses.
Actually, the next few sentences are somewhere between misleading and wrong, too.
> “The eye is more sensitive to quantization levels of green light than to levels of red or blue light, which is probably related to the fact that the sun emits more power in the green region of the visible spectrum than in red or blue. (The eye's spatial resolution in each of the three primary colors is approximately uniform.)”
The eye is more sensitive to green light because we use three cone receptors with the biggest overlap in sensitivity in the green part of the spectrum, so that when you add up their responses to a signal (in the combined lightness signal I mentioned), green wavelengths have more of an impact.
It certainly has something to do with evolution and the spectra of reflected sunlight, but various animals have different spectral sensitivities, so the causality is complex. The sun emits light over a huge range of wavelengths (far beyond the visible spectrum in both directions), and exactly which part makes it to our eyes depends on time of day, weather conditions, altitude, etc.
The three “primary” colors are somewhere between extremely simplified model, useful engineering approach, and myth. We also have somewhat different spatial sensitivities to the three primaries in a computer display, as far as I know.
> “Also the blue and red subpixels are twice the size of green, making them twice as likely to be illuminated at the perceptual edge of a hard intensity transition than green.”
Let’s see here. 1/3 the total area is green, 1/3 the total area is red, and 1/3 the total area is blue. How is it that edges are twice as likely to fall on red or blue than green, again? (In other words, there’s some difference because of the different pixel sizes, but whatever is meant here is being poorly explained, and important assumptions about the edges in question are left unstated.)
Vision is complicated, and there’s a lot of heavy math going on in the neurons in your retina, before signals ever get transmitted through the optic nerve. It depends on adaptation to current light level and color, on what size blobs you’re looking at, on the surrounding colors, and on inferences about objects and how they’re lit. These complexities lead to all those famous optical illusions. So it’s worth using simplified models, to cut out complexity incidental to whatever you’re trying to explain. But that doesn’t give license to just make up stuff.
For anyone interested, this is a good place to start:
http://www.handprint.com/HP/WCL/color1.html http://www.handprint.com/HP/WCL/color1.html
------
One last thing. I’m pretty suspicious of this:
> “Overall, it is hard to see any really good advantages to the PenTile layout.”
Presumably the engineers who designed the thing had some compelling reasons. (It’s conceivable that it was driven by a desire to make a worse display that could be better hyped by marketing, but that seems extremely unlikely to me; I’m suspicious.) I’d like to hear what those are instead of just a hand-wavey “I don’t know what they are so I’m going to imply there are none”.
- hristov 17y ago"Presumably the engineers who designed the thing had some compelling reasons. (It’s conceivable that it was driven by a desire to make a worse display that could be better hyped by marketing, but that seems extremely unlikely to me; I’m suspicious.) I’d like to hear what those are instead of just a hand-wavey “I don’t know what they are so I’m going to imply there are none”." Probably it has to do with manufacturing requirements. I think the author of the article erroneously assumes that the different colour sub-pixels should be more or less the same. For example, the article says: "And the layout can't logically be argued to be a limitation in manufacturing capability, because it is clear that the screen manufacturing process is able to create full-resolution green subpixels that are one-third the size of a physical pixel." This is actually true for LCDs because there the colour of a subpixel is defined merely by a filter that is put in front of the subpixel. However, this is not true for OLEDs. In OLEDS, each subpixel is a separate light emitting diode of the respective color. The light is not changed by the use of filters, but is generated only in a specific color to begin with. However, the light an LED generates depends on the chemical composition of the LED, so each different color LED is a physically different device. In fact, if you remember some recent history, for most of the history of LEDs, there have been no blue ones (only green and red). Blue LEDs were a big relatively recent discovery. (This is why you only see blue and white LEDs in relatively recent devices). So the manufacturing requirements for the different colors LEDs are different, and blue LEDs are the most difficult. So it is not at all surprising to learn that the manufacturing process allows for green LEDs to be twice as thin as the blue ones. So the pentile layout was an attempt to minimize the pixel size given the above mentioned limitation of blue LEDs.
- joezydeco 17y agoOLEDs also degrade over time. Blue is still the color with the shortest lifespan. Making blue larger will give an equivalent output for longer.
- ssp 17y agoYes, the rods are not used at all for regular daytime vision, only for nighttime vision and in dimly-lit environments ("scotopic" vision). The rods are much more sensitive than the cones, but can't detect color. That's why you can't see colors at night. We also have somewhat different spatial sensitivities to the three primaries in a computer display, as far as I know. This is because the cornea and the lens are not perfect optical systems, so they blur the input. This blurring is much stronger at the blue end of the spectrum than in the red end. The retina has evolved to match this, so it has very few blue cones and many more green and red/yellow ones. The result is that we have very low spatial sensitivity to blue. This page: http://www.gamesx.com/misctech/visual.htm http://www.gamesx.com/misctech/visual.htm has a demonstration.