4 ms·
Who would design a feeder that only worked if the server was online? Wow.
by StavrosK 10y ago
Who would design a feeder that only worked if the server was online? Wow.
- forgotpwtomain 10y agoSomeone that has never heard of cron? I mean presumably they might have had some web-ui functionality to change feed-settings - but why that wouldn't just update a cron-tab is beyond me.
- csydas 10y agoCause that's probably outside the scope of the request tht was given. This is absoultely speculation, but my guess would be that the way this product came to life is as follows: 1. Company saw a niche for IoT products with pet owners willing to splurge on their pets (an aside, pets owners are very happy to spend...) 2. Requested IoT software for already existing auto-feeders to be written up as fast as possible 3. IoT part written and works, product is rushed out without designing an offline mode (either not interested or to be patched later) [1] It was an imagined race to be first with the product and get the pet feeder IoT device on the market first and build up a brand name. The end result is this silliness. Basically, I don't think they envisioned an issue where the servers would go down - if the customer's own net went down, obviously they're to blame for Sharik and Musya not being fed. I sure this sounds overly cynnical, but as was mentioned by someone else, this is just the first of many such things to come with shoddy IoT devices. The practical consideration of "well, what if the servers go down?" just doesn't seem to be on people's minds with IoT. [1] From their twitter, I was right - they didn't bother with an offline sync in the firmware, and had to build it out: https://twitter.com/petnetiosupport/status/758380813759033344 https://twitter.com/petnetiosupport/status/75838081375903334...
- Nursie 10y agoExactly what I was thinking - remote server activation of every single feed was just a fuck-up waiting to happen.
- personjerry 10y agoNot sure if you're legitimately asking, but if it were client-side, that would remove the need for the server, and thus the recurring payment. A greedy, unnecessary, and not well thought out design (i.e. see what happened in this situation), but one that earns good money in this luxury product field.
- imtringued 10y agoI don't think they charge a monthly rate, only an up front payment.
- FussyZeus 10y agoSomeone who lives in San Francisco, where Internet access is apparently bulletproof. I wonder if security systems work the same way. Robbers want to take in a smart home so they just cut the coaxial line and the whole thing goes 404, unlocks all the doors, turns off monitoring and can't alert emergency services. Hopefully they have the decency to feed the dog.
- Unklejoe 10y agoI think some have a cellular connection. They also have backup battery power in case the power gets turned off. Not impossible to circumvent, but probably beyond the scope of the average burglar.
- FussyZeus 10y agoI was being facetious. :) Imagining the world where if the Internet goes out all the smart home stuff just turns off.