2 ms·
Yeah, that's where the discussion gets confusing. I will totally agree that a world without NAT would be better, but I will not agree that a world without home
by geofft 10y ago
Yeah, that's where the discussion gets confusing. I will totally agree that a world without NAT would be better, but I will not agree that a world without home routers that drop all inbound connections would be better. If the ISP gives out /64s, the right behavior for the home router is to assign addresses in that /64, but keep doing stateful tracking of outbound connections just like a NAT would, and drop everything else on the floor.
Of course, at this point you've broken end-to-end connectivity (P2P apps don't work, active-mode FTP doesn't work, etc.) so this may not actually resolve the reason people wanted to get rid of NAT. Maybe a good portion of the the no-NAT-in-IPv6 crowd wants inbound routes to people's homes so apps work, and the "but you don't need NAT for security" crowd is misunderstanding them
- DanielDent 10y ago"but keep doing stateful tracking of outbound connections just like a NAT would, and drop everything else on the floor" Here are two important behaviours which come with "just like a NAT would". 1) UPNP - a protocol which allows an application to request it be exposed to the internet 2) Hole punching. E.g. two hosts send packets with matching ip/port values to cause a direct connection to be established between them Applications don't really do those things on v6... And, FWIW, ISPs should be giving residential users at least a /56 - if not a /48. Sites should be able to have enough address space to route within the site and still use the features of IPv6 which require a /64. Route aggregation and routing table size is the constraint of the v6 world, not address space.
- api 10y agoHole punching still exists in the V6 world if you want an app to do P2P from behind stateful V6 firewalls. It requires a three party handshake just like V4 NAT traversal. But unlike NAT traversal it nearly always works since there are no symmetric NAT nightmares. V6 should make all this cruft go away but it doesn't.