8 ms·
Driverless Cars Threaten to Crash Insurers’ Earnings
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tw04 10y agoWhy would they lower prices? The government mandates we MUST have insurance, so they know they've got a continued source of business. They'll simply increase profits. The average American has absolutely no way to correlate the amount they pay for insurance to what it costs the insurance company.
- lg 10y agocompetition?
- techdmn 10y agoI'm convinced that the ability to shop for and purchase auto insurance online is the best thing (for consumers) to happen to the industry in a long time. Better rates, better claims processing, better customer service.
- bjterry 10y agoThey can't do that because other companies will undercut them to gain market share. They could collude to set prices, but that's illegal in the US. Also, some auto insurance companies aren't organized as corporations, such as the Auto Club of Southern California, which is a not-for-profit mutual. They aren't saints, but since they redistribute most of their profits to policyholders, they don't really have much incentive to keep prices high.
- cmdrfred 10y ago> They could collude to set prices, but that's illegal in the US. Interestingly, that is not true for insurance companies[0], at least at the federal level. They are exempt from a lot of federal law. >The McCarran–Ferguson Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1011-1015, also known as Public Law 15,[1] is a United States federal law that exempts the business of insurance from most federal regulation, including federal antitrust laws to a limited extent. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarran%E2%80%93Ferguson_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarran%E2%80%93Ferguson_Act
- jedmeyers 10y agoCorporations have been doing illegal things for a while now. All you have to do is to share a reasonable part of illegal proceedings with the government - it's called a 'fine'.
- notatoad 10y agoOnly if the industry as a whole agrees to not cut rates, and nobody new enters the market. In a competitive market, if the cost goes down (as would happen with fewer accidents) then the rates will drop. I'm curious if we could see a future where the car manufacturers provide insurance for their product, and you would buy a combined hardware/software/updates/insurance subscription package from a manufacturer. It seems like the inevitable conclusion of all the debate around who's ultimately responsible for the actions a self-driving car takes.
- klipt 10y agoIf a large company like Google, Tesla or Uber owns a fleet of self driving cars, they can just self-insure. (The claims will average out to a well understood statistical distribution, and they simply set aside enough money to pay those claims.)
- hyperbovine 10y ago> The government mandates we MUST have insurance, so they know they've got a continued source of business. The average American has absolutely no way to correlate the amount they pay for insurance to what it costs the insurance company. I have a hard time reconciling these two sentences. In the first, you sound like a passionate advocate of the free market. In the second, you act as though you have never heard of such a thing. N.b. Personally, I am much happier knowing that (almost) all the people potentially plowing into me on the highway carry insurance.
- undersuit 10y agoFree Market is the US does not contain a well-informed consumer segment. That is the issue of the second sentence. >N.b. Personally, I am much happier knowing that (almost) all the people potentially plowing into me on the highway carry insurance. Do you live in the US? Where 1 in 7 drivers are uninsured?
- hyperbovine 10y ago> Free Market is the US does not contain a well-informed consumer segment. So the claim boils boils down to, people don't know how to shop around for auto insurance? Forgive me for scoffing. And 1 in 7 is a lot lower than it would be otherwise.
- undersuit 10y agoJust because I can buy the same product from a number of different stores doesn't make me a well-informed consumer.
- cmdrfred 10y agoExactly, and keep in mind many states have moved to a 'no-fault' model. So they don't actually care who is at fault for the accident anymore. So the question becomes, why doesn't everyone just insure themselves (IE. Their own car/medical bills to the level they are comfortable with) rather than insuring everyone else and praying the guy that hit you does the same.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> The government mandates we MUST have insurance Actually, in California, the government does not. You must have either a certain specified minimum level of insurance or a post a specified minimum surety bond.
- busyant 10y agoThis sounds like a distinction without much of a difference.
- dragonwriter 10y agoIt makes a difference because insurance companies don't have unlimited ability (even collectively) to set prices, since there if an alternative that they don't control.
- koenigdavidmj 10y ago> The government mandates we MUST have insurance This becomes absurd with self-driving cars. There are three types of collisions with human-driven cars: 1. Those caused by driver negligence. 2. Those caused by the owner failing to properly maintain their vehicle. 3. Those caused by a manufacturing defect. With self-driving cars, the first one is impossible. A car that follows the law to the letter is by definition never at fault in a collision. The second one is still possible, but probably less likely. The car can take itself to the shop without your intervention, and I expect manufacturers would have it refuse to drive itself if you're too far off the maintenance schedule. The third category will now include bugs in the driving software, so the rate of collisions that fall under option 3 is likely to go up a bit. Option 3 means that the manufacturer is liable, not the owner of the car. Since this encompasses the vast majority of self-driving car collisions, personal liability will no longer be truly necessary like it is today.
- objclxt 10y ago> With self-driving cars, the first one is impossible. A car that follows the law to the letter is by definition never at fault in a collision. You can still be "at fault" even if you followed the law in a collision. Laws - particularly driving laws - are not always black and white.
- SilasX 10y agoNo, it (quite reasonably!) mandates that you must prove financial responsibility to a certain level[1] if you're going to pilot a two-ton hunk of metal at 70 mph around other people doing the same. That has the side effect of requiring the typical person to buy insurance, as they can't afford the alternate means of establishing it. Do you think that's somehow unreasonable? What standard would you prefer for determining when an activity should require such advance indemnification, and how does "driving a car" fail that? Edit: Sorry if you just meant to make the bland, neutral point that more casualties -> more insurance revenue -> more insurance profit, but your tone suggested you think it's an unfair subsidy somehow. [1] It varies, but here's California's form for alternately proving responsibility, which only requires you put up a bond of $35k, which IMHO is ridiculously low considering how much you could fairly be held liable for. I guess the logic is that "if you don't mind setting aside that much money, you must have enough seize-able assets in case you harm someone"? https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/3a81272a-0834-43b6-b3dc-b6965f799d80/reg5085.pdf?MOD=AJPERES https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/wcm/connect/3a81272a-0834-43b6...
- cmurf 10y agoMost any reasonable person can make ~$1500 a year investing that $35K. So it doesn't seem like such a good savings considering you won't make that money on investing it, and you're almost certain to lose a lot more than than $35K if you're at fault in an accident.
- BurningFrog 10y agoIf that is true, why don't they increase profits already? Why wait until self driving cars have arrived?
- tomjen3 10y agoThe I will buy 1 usd nominal insurance from my car manufacturer along with buying the car. Or more likely get it for free with my accident and theft insurance.
- hx87 10y agoShouldn't the drop in revenues be balanced by the decrease in payouts?
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoWhat they get from the customer covers operating costs and payouts. Insurance makes money by investing that mountain of cash. Smaller mountain, smaller profit.
- elgabogringo 10y agoThe article's title is a little misleading. This would shrink the market as a whole. Revenue would go down and earnings would go down as a result. However, it wouldn't have to affect profitability. In fact, profitability would probably go up on these policies initially since the safety benefit would be immediate, but the implied risk in the policies would only come down over time as the safety works it's way into statistics. (Apologies if I'm not using correct terms. Not an actuary.)
- paulmd 10y agoOnly if the insurer in question is solely involved in auto insurance. From the insurance company's perspective, they need enough of a capital reserve to mitigate the risk of a sudden shock in payouts. Spreading across larger geographic areas mitigates that risk somewhat, as does spreading through multiple businesses. Auto insurance is probably a particularly nice gig since it's relatively unaffected by things like natural disasters and would have a relatively smooth cashflow. So, less capital from auto insurance means more capital has to come from somewhere else - more borrowing, if nothing else. That probably translates into either reduced profitability, or higher premiums on other kinds of insurance. I'm not an actuary by any means, but that's my guess.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI disagree it was misleading. The reasoning is pretty straight forward; cars become safer and so insurers can offer lower premiums when 1/3 of your revenue goes away your earnings are harder to make.
- Artlav 10y agoCorrect me if i'm wrong, but wasn't "insurance" a criminal activity a mere century ago? If so, why is it bad for it to disappear again? Can't read the full article, since wsj have a competently implemented "To Read the Full Story, Subscribe or Sign In" shield.
- hughes 10y agoIs that accurate? Was insurance illegal in the early 20th century? Illegal to buy or sell?
- cloudjacker 10y agoThere are many forms of gambling that were prohibited until they were renamed in a way that appeased influential religious communities. Off the top of my head I can think of insurance products and the futures market. But if you can find citations that will be very helpful for me!
- sliverstorm 10y agoInsurance is used for a fundamentally different purpose, to socialize risk. A good quote I found: insurance transfers risks that already existed; gambling creates risk for entertainment.
- cloudjacker 10y agoA rationalization for Evangelicals. Once you realize the distinctions are all rationalizations to appease people that require cultural distinctions, you'll stop trying to rationalize a difference between financial chances. Think "why am I more comfortable with gambling because my state mandates I pay it" and think about what circumstances led to that, and then think about what prompted you to care at all.
- potatolicious 10y agoEh? "Insurance" has never been illegal as far as I'm aware... You're probably thinking about racketeering, but unless you actually believe your home insurer will set fire to your house if you don't buy fire insurance, the comparison probably isn't apt.
- paulmd 10y agoThe other bubble that driverless cars are going to pop is ticket revenue. There are a lot of police departments and cities who have structured a lot of their budget on heavy-handed enforcement of motorists. That's going to decline significantly once driverless cars are scrupulously following the rules of the road. And any tickets that get written will be going against a giant corporation like Google, with detailed information about what the car was doing at the time of the supposed infraction, a lot more financial ability to fight the ticket, and a lot more incentive to protect their reputation.
- zyxley 10y ago"The car was obeying the rules of the road too well. It was suspicious."
- toomuchtodo 10y ago"Your honor, witness testimony is notoriously inaccurate. Will you believe the officer? Or the cryptographically signed and verified vehicle logs?"
- dexwiz 10y agoTraffic laws are notoriously regional in the United States. The fines will adapt. There some potential infractions. Such as keeping your car in a minimum condition. Or having legacy system support. It needs to get patches to update to newer network types. Completely unattended driving (enter destination and taking a nap) is still up for debate. Requiring a machine to be watched seems like a pretty easy-to-pass regulation. Current traffic laws are written for human drivers. If there are robotic drivers on the road other traffic laws will be passed for those.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> Completely unattended driving (enter destination and taking a nap) is still up for debate. Requiring a machine to be watched seems like a pretty easy-to-pass regulation. Requiring a human to watch implies a means for the human to intervene and take over. Having a human second-guess the machine will increase accidents. And having the controls available for the human to do so will increase complexity and decrease reliability.
- squozzer 10y agoNot sure how it would affect prices, but if driverless cars (let's call them autopilot-mobiles) take over the world, they may not be owned by individuals anyway, but instead bought as-needed from corporations (e.g. "Just $100 a month for the Commuter Plan".) This would shift insurance industry focus from insuring millions of individuals to thousands (or maybe only dozens) of corporations, so they could also save money on advertising. I will miss the gecko. And Flo (a little.)
- shimon 10y agoAnd if it is dozens of corporations, there's no reason they wouldn't just absorb the insurance function. Right now because insurance is bought by consumers there's tremendous value in having a recognizable consumer-facing brand (Gecko & Flo). But if the car provider already has the ongoing consumer relationship, offering the insurance is a straightforward financial feature. Plus they'll be way more informed about the risk characteristics of their customers and vehicles. I don't see any remaining reason for separate auto insurance companies to exist if this version of car purchasing takes over individual ownership.
- paulsutter 10y agoAn improvement in safety is wonderful news. The public spending less money on insurance is wonderful news. All the individuals busy managing an auto insurance business have plenty of time to find a better use of their energy.
- finnh 10y agoIn a perfect world, we wouldn't need insurance (everything would go right all the time). The closer we get to that perfect world, the better.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoAm I the only one who bothered that seatbelts (1968) weren't included on the death per billion vehicle miles graph?
- dougmwne 10y agoIsn't a healthy accident insurance industry a form of the broken window fallacy? There's a few people in my life I'd gladly have back and shrinking insurance companies would be a tiny price to pay.
- nappy-doo 10y agoI'd expect the WSJ to know better -- this article (while technically correct) miscategorizes how insurance works. First of all, the article states that premiums will go down -- a reasonable, but not proven thesis. We don't know what will happen to insurance volume or prices, both of which go into calculating total premiums. Secondly, the article doesn't really describe to readers how insurers make money -- almost no auto insurers make money directly on premiums. They make money on the float they get from premiums. Competition prevents most from making money on premiums directly, with some exceptions (GEICO, with the low cost sales model comes to mind). A reasonable assumption is that float will go down (again not proven), but we're also in an extremely low-interest-rate world right now -- something that's tough on insurers anyway. But almost neither of these points matter. Auto insurance is a required by most states (some states allow you to have a bond instead of insurance). It's mandated. These laws have to be repealed, and likely will remain intact for years while the transition to driverless cars happens. Similarly, liability and insurance will be required for malfunctions, tampering, and bugs. IMO, P&C insurance, and specifically auto insurance's, imminent death has been greatly exaggerated.
- notahacker 10y agoI don't see insurance dying overnight, but if their cars are solely used in driverless mode[1] then it's in the manufacturers' interest to take on that risk directly: since they're ultimately liable for [virtually] all risks cars are compulsorily insured for[2] it makes sense to cut out the middle men and keep that float to themselves as well as streamlining the claims process. The ability to make mandatory insurance contingent on getting cars serviced expensively at approved dealers is a nice little bonus. So you get the mandatory insurance certificate with the car,[3] and a whole bunch of B2C auto brokers and insurers are left selling policies which are entirely optional and which consumers consider much more unlikely to be claimed on Sure, some parts of the industry (Lloyds reinsurance syndicates underwriting the portion of the manufacturers' liability they're not willing to self-insure, which is probably the idiosyncratic risk of a negligence claim over software updates) still exist, but all those B2C players are fighting for a much smaller share of the pie which continues to decline as more people switch to exclusively driverless cars and they don't really get stolen any more. [1]I think this is a very big if in the foreseeable future, but it seems to be assumed by the article. [2]there's still a market for insurance against vandalism, fires not caused by the car itself and [to a much more limited than before extent] theft, but that's probably not compulsory in most jurisdictions and so a much tougher sell for the insurance companies. [3] they could even build in the annual policy renewal fee for the design life of the vehicle into the purchase price if they really wanted to. I'm also assuming here that there's no legal impediment to individuals' motor liabilities being underwritten by a division of the vehicle's manufacturers in most jurisdictions.
- iamleppert 10y agoAnother thing that's going to take a huge it is police departments. Many of the initial encounters with police are by way of a traffic stop and patrol. With a self-driving car, there's no longer "probable cause" because the car is driving itself. This will cut off a huge source of income from the police and at the same time reduce the need to have so many police, which, in my mind, is a good thing. Expect entire highway patrol and regional agencies to be shuttered.
- bubbleRefuge 10y agoStill think there will still be a market for old school non automated cars. For the hobbyist or pleasure drivers on weekends. People still love their cars.
- chris_va 10y agoInsurance is a field in need of some disruption, regardless. A few numbers, in case people find it interesting. The average insurance company only pays out about 50% of its income as loss (heavily dependent on sector, but for auto it's about right). For auto, they all use more or less the same ISO policy docs. They mostly all use the same call centers. Their adjustors are usually shared. Honestly, the only thing that really changes is the marketing. Which is why 30%+ of every dollar you pay them goes to marketing. For auto, they are in this weird local maxima where 40% is loss, 30% is marketing, and 30% is profit. They expect to keep a customer for about 2-3 years, and then have to repeat the whole process. It is really sad.
- BurningFrog 10y agoOther declining industries will be emergency health care and organ transplants.
- jimjimjim 10y agoGood. just like universal unbreakable glass might hurt glaziers. just like getting people to commit less crimes might hurt for profit prisons. just like people not getting attacked might hurt self-defense courses. I realize this is perfect-world absolutist thinking but industries that exist because of something wrong in the world shouldn't have a right to exist when that wrong is removed.
- Aelinsaar 10y ago"Institutions will try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution." -The Shirky Principle
- heimatau 10y agoGreat quote. I call it corruption, self-preservation that hurts the masses, and status quo thinking. Technology is going to hopefully disrupt all of this.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoIt's the only thing that can, if history is any guide. Society and "ethics" are so often a function of our technology, however simple we now consider that tech to be.
- carapace 10y agoI can't say that it isn't apocryphal, but the worst example I've ever heard of this was an ambulance-driver's union campaigning against a law that was expected to reduce accidents... As I say, I don't know if it was true or not. I hope not!
- kaonashi 10y ago> just like getting people to commit less crimes might hurt for profit prisons Naw, they just lobby for new reasons to lock people up.
- thomasthomas 10y agoif the insurance companies can keep state laws in place, perhaps less revenue but also less payouts = more profit(?)