4 ms·
We have feudalism because spam and abuse make everything suck. That means you need user accounts that are at least somewhat hard to abuse or the sock-puppet pro
by skybrian 10y ago
We have feudalism because spam and abuse make everything suck. That means you need user accounts that are at least somewhat hard to abuse or the sock-puppet problem becomes unmanageable, and automated filters for the spam, and ways to block abusive users, and moderators to appeal to when users can't solve things on their own.
These things can't be fully automated and they aren't fun for volunteers so businesses end up hiring people to do them.
- fulafel 10y agoPseudonymous identities with reputations and decentalised webs of reputation would be the solution in the old school spirit. But since things like Google and Facebook are financed by ads and trade of personally identifiable information, the incentives don't really align.
- skybrian 10y agoThe way you talk you'd think real names were invented by advertisers. Um, no. There are plenty of good reasons to use real names that have nothing to do with advertising. Handles work well for CB radio, BBS's, games, and other geeky pursuits. In the early days, your friends and relatives weren't online anyway, so why not use a handle? But they don't work for relatives, offline friends, businesses, politicians, or really, any of the other ways we use our real names.
- fulafel 10y agoYou could still publish an assertion about a real name, but the foundations need not require it to be public information.
- vertex-four 10y agoSee, the idea of a singular real name is interesting to me - I have a small handful of names I'd consider "real". It's the same with a fair few people I know, to varying extents, due to the groups I'm involved in. The ability to use many names is strongly tied to the ability to identify yourself. Being forced to use a single name in all contexts, whether you want to or not, is relinquishing that ability - it's being told who you are permitted to be by an external force.
- Joof 10y agoReally? Most people call me something other than my birth name. This is why some forms ask for aliases.
- ktRolster 10y agoYet another reason to encourage ad-blocking.
- api 10y agoIt's not just financial. Those things are incredibly hard for ordinary people (or busy technical people) to understand and use. Only nerds with lots of time on their hands use such systems. My UX rule of thumb is: every step required to set up or otherwise adopt a new technology cuts adoption in half. Example: if your audience consists of a million people and it takes 10 steps to set something up, about a thousand people will end up using it.