10 ms·
This is the perfect being the enemy of the good. They should be calling for secure, validated SMS. Thinking that "Joe and Jane Six-Pack" are going to use Goog
by ams6110 10y ago
This is the perfect being the enemy of the good.
They should be calling for secure, validated SMS.
Thinking that "Joe and Jane Six-Pack" are going to use Google Authenticator, is frankly laughable to anyone who does end-user support. But everyone understands "get a text and enter the code here"
- ptoomey3 10y agoAgreed. The choice isn't between SMS and TOTP for most users. The choice is between SMS and just a 6 character reused password (maybe an old pet name with an exclamation point on the end for extra security ;-)).
- lloeki 10y ago> maybe an old pet name with an exclamation point on the end for extra security Nope, this is the answer to the recovery question ;-) which amounts to a password anyway. I wish recovery questions would just die finally. A pattern I've seen often is people not remembering their password and just resetting it via SMS each time, making SMS 1FA. Although very real, taking the real-world risk of SIM cloning is pragmatically still better than reused, ridiculous passwords and/or ones that end up in leaked lists which amount to no auth.
- Spivak 10y ago> They should be calling for secure, validated SMS. Does such a think really exist? More to the point wouldn't adding an (optional) standard push notification API to TOTP clients be a better solution. You login, your phone pops up a notification, you hit accept on the notification, done. Way less annoying than even SMS.
- voltagex_ 10y agoThe Microsoft Account app does this when an MS app sends an additional challenge. I'm not entirely sure how secure it is but it sure beats looking at a code on GA or Authy.
- icebraining 10y agoMore to the point wouldn't adding an (optional) standard push notification API to TOTP clients be a better solution. You login, your phone pops up a notification, you hit accept on the notification, done. Way less annoying than even SMS. How would that work when you're trying to login on your desk/laptop?
- askvictor 10y ago2fa via the Google app (not authenticator) does something like this. Login on computer, prompt appears on phone, tap yes to log in.
- bigiain 10y agoThe problem is - none of the Telcos have any profit motive to provide secure, validated SMS. For _them_ easy phone number porting, customer service reps being able to "fix" a paying customers message problems, and making it as easy as possible to have their customers send and receive more SMS messages are all directly bottom-line positive things. Making any of that _harder_ for their customers will only reduce their profits and increase their support costs - at zero benefit to the Telco. Your bank or ISP or email provider's security is not the Telco's problem - and they can't be expected to invest effort into it on behalf of non-paying 3rd parties... This is what my local Telco Alliance told the banking industry here in .au back int 2012 (and 've kept it bookmarked ever since for all these discussions...): "Stanton told iTnews that the telcos have decided not to extend the security mechanism protecting the mobile number portability database for reasons of competition and database performance. Apart from making the porting process more time-consuming and less convenient for hundreds of thousands of Australians every year, additional ‘security’ may be seen as a tool to lock in customers, hinder number portability and thus be deemed to be anti-competitive," he said" http://www.itnews.com.au/news/telcos-declare-sms-unsafe-for-bank-transactions-322194 http://www.itnews.com.au/news/telcos-declare-sms-unsafe-for-...
- tajen 10y agoIf telcos can't do it, senders can switch to Whatsapp when possible. And everybody is able to understand Whatsapp (although the delivery isn't reliable). And that may even give them more information about the profile of the user, and that could be billed by Whatsapp as a service to senders.
- bigiain 10y agoSure, but at the loss of the ubiquity of people capable of receiving SMS - Googling suggests ~4.5billion mobile devices worldwide, but only ~1billion Whatsapp users (a number high enough to surprise me, but still under 20% of the total potential market for SMS 2FA...) It also introduces yet another 3rd party reliance and avenue for attack - Brazil and Turkey have blocked Whatsapp recently, and India and the UK have discussed it as well. I doubt Id want to rely on my Whatsapp 2FA tokens arriving in China either...
- original_idea 10y agoHow about PKI secure data networks like... idk, the Internet?! Google and Apple already provide these mechanisms. Couple it with Authy's REST API and you're 1) secure and 2) in business.
- iEchoic 10y ago100% agree. Several products that offer two-factor auth have data to support the fact that accounts with SMS-based TFA enabled are compromised at a substantially lower rate than those without it. TFA has been empirically proven to be effective, why is this recommendation being made? I can't find the answer in the article or the Github.
- raesene6 10y agoI'd suggest that is because there are enough low hanging fruits (single factor password based sites) left to attack. Phone 2FA is, to me, a bad idea as SMS was never designed as a secure transmission and there's a number of known unfixable weaknesses as a result 1) many OS's are allowing SMS to be viewed on the user's computer. so a standard malware attack can get both the password and access to SMS 2) Web sites exist to provide access to a users SMS messages for a number of providers. So an attacker who compromises the PC gets access to SMS messages as well. Whilst app based 2FA (e.g. google authenticator) isn't perfect, it's better than this, and should be what companies are aiming at in 2016...
- smsm42 10y agoMoreover, did you ever try to port Authenticator data from one device to another? There are rumors it's possible. I work in the industry since forever, if anybody can be called qualified for such simple task, it's me. I gave up, too much trouble. Imagining that a regular person would even think about getting into these woods is laughable. Sure Google allows you to port authenticator data with an easy 5-step process. Almost nobody else does even this. Without portability, it means losing access to your Facebook, Instagram and Pokemon Go when you change your device? People would revolt if you do that. So what's the alternative? We either use SMS, or we use email (which will have like order of magnitude higher failure rate with no added security) or we don't use 2FA at all. Or we think really hard and invent better 2FA than SMS that works on every mobile device and is simple for the user. Then we can deprecate SMS.
- bdcravens 10y agoWhile it makes it a bit insecure (as I know they must store the data), using Authy as an alternative TOTP client makes for easy syncing.
- smsm42 10y agoThank you, I will try Authy, maybe this will make sync problem better (I now have about 10 2FA accounts there and if one of my devices dies and has to be replaced it'd be so annoying).
- bigiain 10y agoI always refuse to use the "scan QR code" thing, and everybody I've tried that with (at least Google, Amazon, Github, Dropbox, Linode) give you a TFA secret to type in as an alternative - I then store these in 1Password and can back that up and use them to key Google Authenticator on additional devices. (I've never tried to extract or backup.reuse secrets from Authenticator.)
- rahkiin 10y agoIn 1Password premium, you can put the secrets directly as TOTP in a login item (on your phone) by scanning a qr or entering the secret. Then 1Password will generate the OTP for you. It then also works nicely in the desktop browser.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- greggman 10y agoAs someone who travels SMS sucks for authentication. Maybe most people don't travel but I suspect once they do and wind up unable to access their accounts would not be too happy
- gurkendoktor 10y agoI used to travel a lot, but even my cheap prepaid (German) SIM card had reception in most of Asia, and I haven't had any trouble with SMS 2FA. In the worst case, I've had to swap my SIM cards for a minute to receive the token. It was a bit of a hassle, but not enough to be a showstopper. I wonder how this is implemented - when Apple sends me an SMS 2FA code, do they pay extra because I'm abroad?
- cmurf 10y agoNo, you pay extra https://www.att.com/shop/wireless/international/roaming.html https://www.att.com/shop/wireless/international/roaming.html That's mainly a texting fee since that only gets you unlimited SMS, not data or voice. If you don't get the Passport plan in advance, sent texts go from free to 50 cents each. When I travel Europe, when I'm in the country that issued the SIM in my phone, sending texts are maybe 3 cents, if I leave that country they're maybe 9 cents. Receive was always free.
- efaref 10y agoSurely "Open the BankCo app on your phone and enter the code" is just as simple. For banks, for example, I already have a banking app on my phone (which was originally authenticated via, ahem, SMS), so they could very easily put the OTP generator there.
- kabdib 10y agoThat's not going to happen, internationally. Secure to-device messaging over IP would work. Perhaps if you narrowed it to authentication the telco providers wouldn't see it as a threat to the very, very profitable SMS feature.