11 ms·
British Columbia to target foreign real estate buyers with new tax
- JanSolo 10y agoToo little, too late. If a foreign buyer can afford a $2m house, they can afford the $300k of extra tax. Also, many of the properties bought by immigrants are actually owned by syndicates who are based in Canada and therefore do not have to pay the tax.
- jethro_tell 10y agoPerhaps, but it makes it a bad investment. Or less of an investment at any rate.
- selectodude 10y agoThey're not investing. They're getting their money out of China. A loss is still a gain for them.
- quantumhobbit 10y agoWhat is the main motivation for getting the money out of China? Are they hiding the money from the Chinese government? Trying to leave China or planning for political instability? I don't understand why all this money seems to be pouring into just a few oversold cities instead of more diversified assets.
- Daishiman 10y agoCapital controls. Their investment opportunities in China are limited as long as they have their money there.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoChina has more capital controls in place now to control outward money flow. I suspect a $300k tax that you may never get back is going to be a big demotivator to investing in Canada.
- thomas11 10y agoSo why does it need to be Vancouver where prices are already very high? Why not buy in another city that's more reasonable?
- emptybits 10y agoVancouverite here. I applaud this as a reasonable question. I understand why immigrating to Vancouver from China makes sense. It has great climate, is postcard attractive, easy China-YVR flights, has a dominant Chinese culture already with lots of Mandarin spoken and Chinese writing/advertisements, and it's generally very welcoming and embracing of Chinese. But for the investor only, who doesn't plan to live here ... it's a little harder to understand "why only Vancouver?" Some insight ... Vancouver has become very familiar to Chinese investors, so it's a known and well-researched entity to Chinese. Ask a friend, "where should I move my money?" and "Vancouver!" is a respectable answer. There is also now a large marketing machine that straddles China and Vancouver, whereby new and old Vancouver real estate deals are (sometimes exclusively) marketed directly to China. Systems like this (right or wrong) take time to develop and now have momentum. In short ... familiarity, habit, and support systems. Also, if an investor (or, often, their children) wants to spend any time at all living in their investment ... Vancouver tips the scales for the reasons in the first paragraph.
- hackerboos 10y agoBecause Vancouver's real estate is appreciating faster than nearly every other city in North America [1]. Not only are you washing money, you are likely going to see huge returns on your investment. 23% in a year would pay for this tax with a tidy profit at the end. [1] - http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/new-figures-show-massive-growth-in-metro-vancouver-real-estate-prices-1.3524888 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/new-figures-s...
- boznz 10y agoWhats the point, there is always a loophole for the speculators
- kazinator 10y agoA foreign buyer is also considering the future performance of the $2M. If they believe that this new property transfer tax will cool the market such that the $2M will not grow (or maybe even shrink), they might look elsewhere. The tax is a heavy burden attached to a property. Whenever that property changes hands, the government takes a slice, and now that slice is a whopping 15% if the buyer is a foreigner. If a foreigner is is willing to pay 1,150,000 for your property, you're only getting 1,000,000. The money is sucked out of value of the transaction; it's neither the buyer's money nor the seller's money; it's both!
- antonius 10y agoTake away Vancouver and Toronto, and the price of a house in Canada is nowhere near the asking prices currently in those two cities. Wealthy foreign inflation on Canadian real estate is quite evident.
- aianus 10y agoTake away Toronto and Vancouver and you have nothing but farmland and university towns. Not really evident of anything. Fwiw Toronto is quite affordable still; you can live like a king in a brand new condo with curtain glass walls overlooking the city for under US$500k.
- kejaed 10y ago"Take away Toronto and Vancouver and you have nothing but farmland and university towns" Spoken like a true citizen of the Center of the Universe
- throwaway1979 10y agoHow does 500K USD seen affordable? Also, try raising two kids in that condo.
- dleslie 10y agoI have numerous friends with several children and who live in a condo. Hell, the Mayor of New Westminster moved _out_ of his house and into a condo; he has three daughters. As usual, there's a Vancouver blog for this[0]. 0: http://5kids1condo.com/ http://5kids1condo.com/
- mahyarm 10y agoHave a large condo with 3-5 rooms. Maybe they would share a bedroom!
- wavefunction 10y agoBathroom - 1 room Parent bedroom - 1 room Kitchen - 1 room Living room - 1 room Kid bedroom - 1 room ..... Sounds lovely, for 500k USD...
- shostack 10y agoAny thinking around the expected impact from locals who bought despite the prices? Sounds like they could be royally screwed if prices plummet as a result.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoUltimately that has to happen. Housing prices that high (and rising) are a dumb intergenerational transfer of wealth from the young to the old.
- maxxxxx 10y agoWhen a bubble goes on there is always someone who gets screwed in the end. I don't think there is a way around it.
- eigenvector 10y agoI don't think prices will go down as a result. For dirty / at-risk money pouring in from overseas, the 15% tax is just the cost of doing business, and that's assuming they don't find a way around it like using a Canadian proxy buyer or shell corporation. If someone is buying a 50-year-old teardown with asbestos and mildew for $3 million, do you think they care if it becomes $3.45 million with the new tax? They just need to get the money the hell out of Dodge (China). What the tax can achieve though, is build up a stockpile of money for the government to address the affordability problems by improving mass transit, building affordable housing, etc. This is the realistic best-case outcome. Prices are not going down.
- trhway 10y ago>I don't think prices will go down as a result. of course not. How would adding new tax may result in lower prices in under-supplied market? If a person buys something for 2.3M instead of 2M it is higher price for that person (it doesn't matter who those money were consumed by). That person to make profit will be using the 2.3M as base to make selling decision, calculate profit, etc. Thus it will drive prices up. Only in oversupplied(buyer's) market such tax may have resulted in lower prices by deterring buyers and thus decreasing liquidity.
- serge2k 10y ago> The tax will apply to buyers who are not Canadian citizens or permanent residents, as well as corporations that are either not registered in Canada or controlled by foreigners. Aren't we still letting people just buy permanent residence?
- potatolicious 10y agoYeah but they actually have to live in Canada - the loopholes around buying permanent residence as an insurance policy and then just never living in Canada were closed a long time ago. So if someone wants to full-hog move to Canada and buy a home in Vancouver, I feel like that's not the kind of activity we necessarily want to discourage.
- eigenvector 10y agoCanada does not have exit immigration controls, so PR residence fraud is still an issue. An agreement with the US to share data on people leaving Canada via the US has been announced and re-announced, but hasn't been implemented yet. Which is all to say that if you land in Canada, drive over the border and then fly abroad, the immigration bureaucracy still has no idea you've ever left.
- mahyarm 10y agoYou would need a new passport for that to work, and it increases barriers to doing so. In any large scale endeavor it's often about decreasing the number, changing the balanace vs. reducing it to zero. And it's often a ratchet, adding a law here and there to get to a result.
- sergers 10y agogenerally canada has disallowed this, but the quebec government still offers this. http://www.immigration.ca/en/quebec-immigrant-investor-program.html http://www.immigration.ca/en/quebec-immigrant-investor-progr... they dont strictly enforce the must live in quebec rule, most people end up mainly Vancouver and some % toronto
- hoodoof 10y agoNow the government gets its cut, and comes to rely on the revenue, and works hard to ensure there are on ongoing streams of foreign buyers and revenue. When governments tax foreign buyers all it does is entrench the foreign buyers. Be it gambling or foreign buyers, governments always become addicted to revenue and the origin of the tax is forgotten. Future government: "We're short on money! We need more gambling and more foreign buyers!"
- dleslie 10y agoMembers of the BC Liberal cabinet are personally invested in the housing crisis; for instance, Mike De Jong and his 7 properties[0]. And maybe we should ask why the Ministry of Natural Gas Development is responsible for housing, as well[1]? It's like Minister Rich Coleman carries housing around with him wherever he goes; couldn't have anything to do with his sketchy behaviour[2]... 0: http://thetyee.ca/News/2016/01/11/Finance-Minister-Well-Invested/ http://thetyee.ca/News/2016/01/11/Finance-Minister-Well-Inve... 1: http://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/governments/organizational-structure/ministries-organizations/ministries/natural-gas-development http://www2.gov.bc.ca/gov/content/governments/organizational... 2: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/b-c-minister-cleared-of-allegations-of-conflict-of-interest-1.715815 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/b-c-minister-...
- dforrestwilson 10y agoHere in the U.S. people exploit an immigration loophole: http://www.ibtimes.com/eb-5-investor-visa-demand-booming-dominated-chinese-plying-cash-us-real-estate-1851706 http://www.ibtimes.com/eb-5-investor-visa-demand-booming-dom... I believe Canada has seen something similar? I'm very conflicted on this. I want the best people to come into my country, but I don't believe that being wealthy in an undemocratic country where corruption is more acceptable should qualify you for admission outright.
- hkmurakami 10y agoThey had this until a few years ago, but Canada ended the program with a prodigiously long waiting line. Predictably, there was an uproar in China. >The Canadian Immigrant Investor Program was created by the federal government of Canada to promote the immigration of business people and their families. It enabled qualified investors to obtain permanent resident status in Canada. Under the program, successful applicants and their families received permanent and unconditional Canadian residential visas and were then eligible to obtain Canadian citizenship. With the passing of Bill C-31 on June 19, 2014, the program was terminated and undecided applications were cancelled.[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Immigrant_Investor_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Immigrant_Investor_Pr...
- oroup 10y agoI believe this should be an "unoccupancy" tax instead, where owners are taxed if the home is unoccupied: * increases the supply of available housing * includes all the properties that have already been purchased for speculation and hits every year * substitutes an occupancy check (using data like utility utilization or direct observation) rather than a test of foreignness which is too easy to game. * doesn't dissuade foreign investors but facilitates the creation of safe rental infrastructure serving them.
- mahyarm 10y agoThey are also adding that, but the city has to legislate it: "The B.C. Liberal government will also introduce legislation this week that will allow the City of Vancouver to impose a tax on vacant homes; and follow through on an earlier promise to end self-regulation of the real estate industry."
- cperciva 10y agounoccupancy How do you propose to measure that? If someone commutes to a work camp outside Fort Mac and is only physically present in Vancouver for two weeks each month, do they pay the tax? What if someone spends 4 months every winter in Florida? How about someone who gets hit by a truck and spends six months in a hospital? Or an elderly couple who move into a care home because the husband has dementia, but want to keep the house they lived in for 50 years because the wife (who is still in good health) might move back there after the husband dies?
- mahyarm 10y agoI think it's to prevent the unoccupied house bank account. You could make an exemption for your official registered home address. That way if you own more than one house, the unoccupancy tax creates an incentive to put the locked up supply on the rental market, but would sidestep the complexity you just stated.
- icebraining 10y agoYou could make an exemption for your official registered home address. How does that work against foreign investors? How can you prevent them from having an official registered home address in both countries?
- oroup 10y agoI believe this should be an "unoccupancy" tax instead, where owners are taxed if the home is unoccupied: * increases the supply of available housing * includes all the properties that have already been purchased for speculation and hits every yeat * substitutes an occupancy check (using data like utility utilization or direct observation) rather than a test of foreignness which is too easy to game. * doesn't dissuade foreign investors but facilitates the creation of safe rental infrastructure serving them.
- hbosvismylife 10y agoDon't fuck with the free market. I know the intentions are good, but this will just create 100 loopholes and complexity up the ass. Fail.
- vkou 10y agoYou obviously don't live in Vancouver. The free market has completely failed the city. The median Vancouver house now sells for 1.4 million CAD, while the median family income is $76,000 CAD. These prices are not sustainable at local salaries. This isn't Silicon Valley, where a large part of the population is raking in cash hand over fist. This is a playground for the foreign rich. Supply and demand only works when supply isn't fixed.
- davidw 10y agoWhy is the supply fixed when there is a huge incentive to add to it?
- querulous 10y agothe supply in question is single family homes, particularly detached homes vancouver is bordered to the north by mountains, the south by the us border and the west by the ocean. there's already suburban sprawl 2+ hours to the east. there is simply no room for more single family housing there is a large amount of agricultural land, but it's part of a strategic reserve as it's some of the most productive agricultural land in canada and developing it is extremely controversial
- davidw 10y agoSo... build up? That's more expensive, tech wise, than single family detached homes, but at least it adds to the supply and constrains prices to some degree. You don't have to do skyscrapers, you can do 3/4 stories like most European cities. Not everyone can live in a single-family detached home with a big yard in a place with constrained land supply.
- PlaidGinger 10y agoI find it really strange to find this on HN's aggregator. This tax is neither novel, technical, nor an actual solution. There are cities that have solved the speculation problem with social housing and/or planning - Vancouver (and San Fran's) only problem is a lack of will.
- wonderingwhere 10y agoI question whether this will mount to anything
- c-smile 10y agoAs a consequence of all this: it is hard to find software developers (are they still middle class?) to work in offices in Vancouver core. The only reasonable option to live for devs is in 1.5-2 hours away of driving and public transit. 2-3 hours per day wasted in traffic just to get to and back from the office is too much. Half of the time spent in traffic are considered (or should) as working hours - thus increased salary demand as de facto there are not 8 but 9-10 working hours per day. Big software houses shall consider moving R&D offices outside of Vancouver (core) I think.
- yazaddaruvala 10y agoI grew up in Vancouver, went to high-school there, whet to UBC there. My family is in Vancouver. The majority of my friends are in Vancouver. I own real-estate in Vancouver. I eventually want to move back to Vancouver. I can safely say I love Vancouver. However, I currently live in Seattle. > "it is hard to find software developers ... to work in ... Vancouver" Plain and simply, even though software developers make some of the highest salaries in Vancouver, the salaries are relatively abysmal. It would be an effective 50% pay cut for me to move to Vancouver. The housing crisis is a problem, but its not one that effects the lack of talent in Vancouver. Vancouver's almost only tech talent problem is the lack of competitive salaries.
- maerF0x0 10y agoI saw a posting the other day for a Senior backend Golang developer - $60k. I laughed so hard. I made about that much straight out of school.
- briandear 10y agoI saw a senior Rails contract job in Toronto that was paying $40 per hour and a mid-level Rails Dev at $15 per hour. I find that rather hilarious as well.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoIt is easy to find developers in Vancouver. You just have to actually pay them, which companies in Vancouver are not willing to do for some reason.
- Geekette 10y agoThis seems more a gesture than putting a foot down. I expected the tax to be higher (15% may not deter overseas buyers already willing to overpay) and accompanied by comprehensive residency verification system with additional tax on non-inhabitated homes.
- maerF0x0 10y agoPeople often forget that foreign realestate investment is often a way to offshore money to keep it away from _local_ (to the investor) governments. Keeping $2M away from the PRC is probably worth $300k if you fear it will be entirely taken away from you. The main thing this accomplishes is: 1. It allows the current administration to claim they're doing something. 2. It gives funds to the current administration that can be used for things like politician pay raises, additional government worker benefits, and maybe, just maybe, some roads too.
- vkou 10y agoAt this point, some government worker benefits would be welcome. BC Teachers have been losing wages to inflation for the past decade and a half. (The raises are lower than the cost of living increases.)
- da989 10y agoThere also aren't enough teaching jobs to go around. If there are more teachers than teaching jobs, teaching wages are still too high.
- vkou 10y agoThere 'aren't enough teaching jobs to go around' because the government has increased class sizes, dumped special needs students in with the general student body, and has closed down a large number of schools. More work, less pay, worse public outcomes. Neo-liberalism in a nutshell. Mind you, BC is still much better off then many US states in this respect. Mind you, as it is not a petrostate, BC also needs a functioning education system more than some of its neighbours. I don't expect that teachers will see any of this money, of course. It'll probably go towards worthless crown corporations like ICBC.
- kareemm 10y agoI live in Vancouver and have been following this closely. This proposal is disappointing. The better solution imho is to tax based on where the owners file their taxes[1], not based on whether the buyer is a citizen or permanent resident. Reasons: citizenship is for sale through the Quebec Immigrant Investor Program[2] so if you're wealthy, you can effectively bypass this tax. If you can't, using a relative as a proxy buyer will let you bypass the tax. And preventing non-permanent residents from buying means any immigrants who come to Canada but aren't PRs will pay this tax. These seem like the exact kind of people you don't want to disincentivize from buying - people who are willing to take a risk to come to Vancouver, but aren't rich enough to just buy their way in. Taxing people based on where they file their taxes makes a lot more sense to me - if you're paying taxes in Canada, you're not using Vancouver housing strictly as an asset class which is what should be discouraged in order to have a healthy, diverse city of people who own where they live. 1- http://www.theprovince.com/business/proposed+could+high+cost+housing+residents/11659651/story.html http://www.theprovince.com/business/proposed+could+high+cost... 2- http://www.immigration-quebec.gouv.qc.ca/en/immigrate-settle/businesspeople/applying-business-immigrant/three-programs/investors/ http://www.immigration-quebec.gouv.qc.ca/en/immigrate-settle...
- Tiktaalik 10y agoThis policy affects foreign persons, but the issue is really foreign capital. As you say this does nothing regarding the issue of persons buying citizenship via the QIIP and coming over to BC, which is what the vast majority of people using the QIIP do. I have no idea what the process would be, but a real step forward would be to for the Federal government to work to end the QIIP, though I recognize this would probably open a can of worms and raise a bunch of new issues with Quebec.
- kareemm 10y ago> I have no idea what the process would be, but a real step forward would be to for the Federal government to work to end the QIIP, though I recognize this would probably open a can of worms and raise a bunch of new issues with Quebec. According to Ian Young the Feds can end the QIIP[1]: Although Quebec is in charge of choosing its immigrants, Federal authorities actually issue their certificates of permanent residency, and decide the speed at which to do so. According to Vancouver immigration lawyer Richard Kurland, there is no doubt that “the feds have the legal right, pure and simple, to cancel the program”. “This is not about a constitutional or legal barrier. There is neither,” he said. 1 - http://www.scmp.com/news/world/united-states-canada/article/1983336/one-point-plan-tackle-vancouvers-housing http://www.scmp.com/news/world/united-states-canada/article/...
- vadym909 10y agojust like Silicon Valley. Locals save and save but when they get ready to buy, the prices have gone up due to all cash offers from Mainland China whose buyers are buying sight unseen for god knows what reasons. The only solution may be to require such foreign buyers to publish their real names instead of some shell Hong Kong or Cayman Island companies. If the buyer is a corrupt official using bribe money or a crooked businessman hiding black money, making this information public to the PRC Govt/ people, could get them investigated. This should dissuade people using ill gotten gains to inflate house prices here causing a speculation bubble. If they are legitimate, then there should be nothing to fear.
- briandear 10y agoReally you want the Canadian government to act as an agent of the PRC? That's about as bad as the FATCA injustice foisted upon Americans overseas by Democrats. That is a horrible idea. "If they are legitimate, then there should be nothing to fear.." That's the same logic used by supporters of NSA domestic spying. Only the guilty should care about privacy right? Innocent people have no need for it because they aren't doing anything wrong?
- liber8 10y agoEveryone looks at this ass-backwards. Foreign buyers who park their money in unoccupied real estate are not a problem. These are essentially ideal owners from the city's perspective and what every city council should be courting: people who pay ridiculous tax rates yet use essentially no city services. The problem is the lack of housing supply. Get rid of the ridiculous regulations, allow more stock to be built, and revel in all the free foreign money that's being showered on your city. Yes, more housing stock is going to change the "charm" of your little haven. Guess what? Cities change. All of your precious cities are nothing like they were 50 years ago. That's how life goes. Every alternative you have results in a change to the status quo: (1) do nothing and watch all the artists and misfits (then the middle class) get priced out of the city, (2) impose even more regulations to try to keep rents affordable (which is never a solution, see San Francisco), or (3) build more housing. Only one of these solutions makes any sense. But, no surprise, it's always easier to blame the foreigners than it is to risk your political capital.
- wvenable 10y agoI disagree that they are ideal owners. They provide absolutely no other income or commerce to the city and it's actually becoming an issue. http://crescentmovingandstorage.com/problem-vacant-homes-vancouver/ http://crescentmovingandstorage.com/problem-vacant-homes-van... There may be a problem with supply but how are vacant properties a good use of the supply that already exists? What's the point of a city full of empty sky rises?
- auganov 10y agoIf it's enough of a problem to cause systemic decline of the city the property prices will have to drop. I just can't see how they would keep on buying and buying till nobody lives there anymore. Granted it is possible, but if they are in fact that crazy then you can still argue it's better to pocket the money and go build another city? Somebody else mentioned supply is being added at a decent rate. So perhaps there just isn't really a problem?
- wvenable 10y ago
- jpollock 10y agoI would expect this to run afoul of any investor-state dispute resolution agreements that Canada has signed with other countries (NAFTA, Canada/China have an ISDS as well) - since it is a stamp-duty rather than an import duty. Typically those agreements require that investors be treated as locals once the asset is purchased. Edit - Since this is typically aimed at Chinese buyers instead of Americans, here's the link to the agreement Canada and China have: http://www.international.gc.ca/trade-agreements-accords-commerciaux/agr-acc/fipa-apie/china-text-chine.aspx?lang=eng http://www.international.gc.ca/trade-agreements-accords-comm... Important Text: 1. Each Contracting Party shall accord to investors of the other Contracting Party treatment no less favourable than that it accords, in like circumstances, to its own investors with respect to the expansion, management, conduct, operation and sale or other disposition of investments in its territory.
- dade_ 10y agoGovernment policy is a blunt instrument. Whatever the outcome of this post-fact political pandering, it won't be the desired outcome. Vancouver has a long history of speculation by the locals as much as anyone else. Mortgage debt is completely out of control, but people see it as safe or good debt. This could very well trigger a devastating collapse in market value and scare foreign investors from BC altogether, but I live at the other end of the country, so I mostly can just kick back and watch the fallout.
- pennyhill 10y agoExperts of British Columbia’s Liberal governing administration have related its caution about acting on international investment towards larger charitable donations the get together reaps from real estate world together with the sizable budget strengthen it is provided with by way of the shift taxation.Need any bargains on online sales, check: http://www.crazysales.com.au/ http://www.crazysales.com.au/
- kazinator 10y agoThe property transfer tax is fucking stealing. End of story. They hit old people with this shit who have no income but sell their house to go live somewhere else. Oh, that will be 20 grand please. Why? Just because! Shame on this parasitic province. British Columbia fleeces anyone who comes here; that's why we locals say that BC stands for "Bring Cash".