15 ms·
Apple Taps Bob Mansfield to Oversee Car Project
- antonius 10y agoMansfield has a successful track record with respect to Apple products. With that said, this is his most difficult challenge to date and I'm not sure how successful he and the company as a whole will be given the difficulties of bringing an autonomous car to market.
- arjunrc 10y agoI believe the goal here is an electric car with autonomous features, branded similar to the S-Class or the new E-Class (instead of going all the way like Tesla's AutoPilot).
- pgodzin 10y agoWhat's the point of that? Why would Apple want to make such a huge bet on an industry they have never been in just to create an incremental improvement on cars already billed as luxury items? If they proceed with the Apple Car, I would imagine it would be a disrupting concept that Apple would be uniquely prepared to handle.
- nostromo 10y ago> No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame. Apple could release a car that has fewer features than a Tesla or Mercedes, and if it was designed very well, with seamless integration with the iPhone, lots of people would buy it.
- tammer 10y agoThe real evidence of this is the news today of Ford (as far as I know last of the major car companies with presence in the US) incorporating CarPlay into their console software. I've heard the reason for the swift industry-wide uptake of the platform is very high consumer demand - even to the point of driving the purchasing choice for a number of customers.
- atonse 10y agoIt was a non-trivial factor in my picking a Kia to lease. I'm not a car person so I mostly can't tell the difference in power, nor do I need it, from other cars. I didn't care about reliability since it was a lease. But I did care that I had to use yet another shitty car-company interface, so having CarPlay support was a huge plus. The car companies brought this on themselves by designing such bad software for their in-dash systems.
- serge2k 10y ago> I'm not a car person so I mostly can't tell the difference in power Bet you could if you tried. ;) I really like my car. It's comfortable, I like driving it. I really really really really hate the fucking sync software. It's just awful. Full of the stupidest bugs. I don't even have the full nav version, I have the smaller radio system. If I could find a decent replacement console that let me keep my climate controls (physical HVAC controls are a must. no touchscreen BS) I'd upgrade to carplay.
- atonse 10y agoSorry, to be clear, I couldn't tell a difference between the 3 Compact SUVs I drove. :) I drove a Tesla and it was like a dream.
- mikestew 10y agoI'm not a car person so I mostly can't tell the difference in power, nor do I need it, from other cars. If you lived close, I'd take you for a ride in our 4000lb. VW camper van that cranks out a massive 68 horsepower. You'll notice the difference on the first hill we encounter. :-) (I take your point, though; I've a similar attitude: if I want to go fast, I'll get on the motorcycle and do it right, otherwise I don't care much.) But I did care that I had to use yet another shitty car-company interface, so having CarPlay support was a huge plus. Between rental cars and our Nissan Leaf with it's fucking abysmal in-dash UI, I've decided that any car we buy from here on out will have CarPlay or no deal. I'm just not going to put up with crappy car UIs anymore. Plopping a CarPlay-compatible dash unit in our old Scion xB was a revelation. Nothing earth-shattering in CarPlay, but it's familiar and non-annoying. I was driving my Mom's new '16 Corvette, and having not memorized central Florida roads, I found the UI to be annoying as usual. In fact, I can't remember if I ever found the navigation function. What I do remember is tripping across the CarPlay icon on the dash and thinking, "thank $DEITY!"
- Steko 10y agoApple could sell a lot simply by offering a superior car buying experience. While others have tried/done this, the median car buying experience is still as garbage as it's ever been.
- lastyearman 10y agoBuying a new car is a nightmare. You start with a baseline model and think that's not too bad, tick some reasonable boxes and whoops, your car is now twice as expensive. Usually buying something is a pleasant experience but when it comes to cars? Hell no. If they just offered one model that has everything and you pick the color, pay a monthly fee and they'd take care of the maintenance, insurance and whatnot.
- ghaff 10y agoHonestly, if you handle your own financing so that doesn't get mixed into the deal, have a hard and fast value in mind for a potential trade-in, and go to a no-haggle dealer, I'm not sure how it's a nightmare. The experience is probably better buying higher-end cars but if you know what you want, what its price is, and get a bank check for what you owe, there are a lot worse experiences. The reason a lot of people have bad experiences is that they're trying to buy something that they can't really afford, they need financing, and have a trade-in they want to be worth more than it is and the whole transaction becomes this complicated shell game.
- Steko 10y ago> Honestly, if you handle your own financing so that doesn't get mixed into the deal, have a hard and fast value in mind for a potential trade-in, and go to a no-haggle dealer, You just described less than 1% of car transactions.
- ghaff 10y agoBut not 1% of transactions that involve high end buyers and high end cars. As soon as you bring ordinary people and the mass market into the mix many of the "horrible things" inevitably emerge. Sure you can and do have no haggle dealers who could offer take it or leave it finance options and trade ins. But I wonder how many mainstream car buying customers would consider that an improvement when told "that's what the car costs. Sorry if it doesn't fit your budget." ADDED: I'm sure the experience of buying a Tesla is nice. But it's nice in the context of people who are not going in with no dollars to put down who want to find a way to get themselves into a Tesla.
- jms18 10y agoBallmer in a 2007 interview with USA Today: "There's no chance that the iPhone is going to get any significant market share. No chance. It's a $500 subsidized item. They may make a lot of money. But if you actually take a look at the 1.3 billion phones that get sold, I'd prefer to have our software in 60% or 70% or 80% of them, than I would to have 2% or 3%, which is what Apple might get." Palm CEO Ed Colligan in 2006: "We’ve learned and struggled for a few years here figuring out how to make a decent phone," he said. "[Apple is] not going to just figure this out. They’re not going to just walk in."
- mikeash 10y agoThey laughed at Einstein, but they also laughed at Bozo the Clown. A smartphone was solidly within Apple's expertise in 2007. It's a small consumer electronics device (iPod, Mac) with a graphical UI (Mac OS X). Apple had tons of experience building (or more accurately, outsourcing the building of) small electronics. What was tricky about the iPhone was the RF stuff, getting the carriers to cooperate, and cutting data usage to squeeze into the crappy data plans available. Except RF stuff is nearly off-the-shelf, and Apple cut the Gordian Knot for the other two items by partnering with an underdog carrier in exchange for unlimited data plans. A car is far outside Apple's expertise. Are they going to outsource it to Foxconn like they do with the iPhone, and ship them across the Pacific? Doesn't seem feasible. Will they buy or build their own factory? Doable, but totally new for them. What about sales, service, and support? The iPhone was able to use Apple's extensive network of existing retail stores for that, but cars need garages and mechanics. Obviously, it can be done. Tesla pulled it off with far less. But there's plenty of room for Apple to crash and burn, too. (Figuratively, one hopes.)
- baddox 10y ago> Are they going to outsource it to Foxconn like they do with the iPhone, and ship them across the Pacific? Doesn't seem feasible. I have no idea, but they seem to be pretty good at outsourcing manufacturing where it makes sense to do so. I don't see that as a significant blocker to an Apple automobile.
- 10y ago
- Roritharr 10y agoI think it has to do with the car industry being the best out of a bunch of bad options. You simply don't need the kind of liquidity Apple has on hand to run a business with the current Product Lineup Apple has on offer. Sure they could do more here and there, but compared to the insane amounts of capital Apple has, any effort in the computing/telco space is just pocketchange. If Apple ventures out of computing and into areas that need that kind of capital to be feasible, you start comparing lots of medium to low margin industries, the car industry being one of them. When you look at Apple's brand, company focus and in-house experience, there's only a few industries where diving into could make it a relatively safe bet for the capital involved. Cars make sense because they are complex technology, already very brand and UX focused in their usual sales processes, and there is a lot of money to be made in the optimization of the supply chain, all things which Apple is second to none. There were surely other options and I imagine are still being discussed in Cupertino. Large Scale Urban Development seems like a similar viable candidate, but the salescycles and product lifecycles are probably too much at odds with the rest of Apples business. But the prospect of an build to order Apple Campus must seem quite exciting to some people that are having a blast building the new spaceship. Among other industries, i could also imagine the Hotel industry being on their marks for similar reasons.
- coredog64 10y agoThat supply chain optimization comes at the cost of having to fight 50 pitched political battles with some very entrenched interests (dealerships).
- csours 10y agoThe supply chain is on the other end of the process from the dealerships. Supply chain -> Assembly (manufacturing) -> sales (Dealership)
- Bluestrike2 10y agoI can't see Apple (or any other car startup, for that matter) going any where near the dealership model. There are too many problems with it and too little flexibility. If it weren't for legacy agreements that effectively hamstring manufacturers, it's likely that there would have been some significant changes made years ago. Anyhow, Tesla has already done the hard work of confronting it and making consumers aware of an alternative. The biggest problem will be dealing with their influence over state legislatures. Tesla already upset dealerships; the idea of someone like Apple (with their capital on hand, experience, and influence at the federal level) following in Tesla's footsteps will be enough to terrify dealerships into some pretty heavy-handed action. As for the supply chains, there are a lot of differences between the supply chain for consumer electronics manufacturing and automobile parts, but Apple's experience is still intensely relevant. I think it's likely that they'll have a lot of successes in dealing with it, despite those differences.
- skewart 10y agoMy guess is they will rethink what a "car" fundamentally is all about. They'll create a vehicle that has new features that play to their strengths, even if the "car-ness" isn't a big improvement on existing models in the market. Back when the iPhone first came out a lot of people dismissed it because it wasn't a very good phone - the audio quality and reception tended to be worse than a good Nokia. Who cares if it has all these extra whiz-bang features like a touch screen and a web browser if it's not a very good phone, the thinking went. A lot of people didn't appreciate that Apple was creating a communication and information retrieval device, and not just a traditional phone with some extra features. I suspect Apple will create a car that provides a great experience for people getting from point A to point B. It will probably not be a great car to drive. But it will probably be an awesome car for passengers. My guess is that they are betting that there will be more passengers relative to drivers over the next decade or two, and that passengers will, in a perhaps indirect way, become a bigger force in car buying decisions than they have been in the past. So, by the metrics traditionally used to compare cars it will probably be only an incremental improvement over existing models - or it might even be a step backwards. But by the metrics that we'll use to evaluate cars in ten or fifteen years it will be an amazing improvement.
- pgodzin 10y ago> But it will probably be an awesome car for passengers. Isn't fully autonomous the goal precisely for this reason?
- skewart 10y agoIt is. And the move towards autonomous cars is part of the reason why there will be more passengers relative to drivers on the road. But it's not the only factor, or the only way to improve the passenger experience. For example, I'd gladly forget about Lyft and Uber and use a new ride service if their drivers all had cars that offered me a better experience than what a Toyota Camry provides today. Also, in-car entertainment has become hugely popular for family cars like mini/sport-utility vans. My guess is that Apple will create an in-car infotainment system that makes current systems look like phone web browsers from 2005.
- wvenable 10y agoIsn't that what they did with the smartphone market? The big difference is that the iPhone is a computer running OS X -- all things Apple has huge experience with. A car is something they have no experience with.
- martin_bech 10y agoI drive a Tesla daily, its basicly an iPhone on wheels.
- wvenable 10y agoWould you argue the most significant part is that big tablet in the middle or the combination of the wheels, steering, axles, interior upholstery, steel frame, aluminum body panels, battery, etc? Apple hasn't manufactured anything larger than can be easily Fedex'd. It seems like calling the Tesla an iPhone on wheels misses nearly all of the significant details.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agowheels, steering, axles, interior upholstery, steel frame, aluminum body panels, battery, etc Musk has made the point that a lot of that stuff can be purchased from or outsourced to third parties. Which is what the traditional car companies now do. Which is what Tesla does. The traditional manufacturers maintained their expertise in engines, but, ironically, that's one thing that Tesla had absolutely no use for anyway. That being said, I do share your skepticism.
- simonebrunozzi 10y agoWhy Apple went into music with the iPod? Well... The rest is history.
- jpalomaki 10y agoBringing something truly disruptive to the automobile market could be impossible. There's so many companies actively working with cars that maybe there is no room for disruption. Think about the smart watch market. Many other companies are iterating their products in public. Apple couldn't really surprise the customers with their product. Maybe they build a better product than others, but it was no iPad (which took the whole market by surprise).
- pgodzin 10y agoAgreed. But building a smart watch isn't that much different than building an iPhone. It's quite a jump to car manufacturer.
- kalleboo 10y ago> If they proceed with the Apple Car, I would imagine it would be a disrupting concept that Apple would be uniquely prepared to handle. That's what people thought about the Apple Watch as well, but it seems these days Apple is content with releasing products that simply complement their portfolio rather than create new markets
- pgodzin 10y agoEvolutionary consumer electronics. The infrastructure and ecosystem they already had in place was easily adapted to manufacturing the watches. I really can't see a marginally better car ever being worth the gigantic entry cost to the market.
- boznz 10y agoSource? Only rumor and speculation on the internet at the moment
- dexwiz 10y agoApple's goal is to make the first well polished version on the market, and then claim they invented it. Looking at MP3Players/Smartphones/TabletsWithPens.
- thevibesman 10y agoI have a feeling Apple might be working on a completely autonomous design; one that would not be legal to be tested on public roads due to current laws requiring human UI elements such as steering wheels and pedals.
- scoot 10y ago> "instead of going all the way like Tesla's AutoPilot" The name "AutoPilot" is misleading - it's anything but. An advanced lan-assist, sure, but compared to google, Tesla's technology is very far from going all the way.
- ams6110 10y agoI am guessing not a full EV but a hybrid. Full EVs still have competitive vulnerability in range and refueling time. And they likely will for the next decade at least. It's the reason that EVs are still off the table for me. Something in an innovative hybrid, like a Volt but better designed, would be much more interesting to me.
- mikeryan 10y agoI don't believe that at all. I'd guess fully autonomous and fully electric. I mean everyone here can see the writing on the wall that this kind of thing that is going to happen. If I'm Apple I skate to where the puck is going to be.
- ibero 10y agoi find it interesting that the project is described as the "autonomous, electric-vehicle initiative." isn't there a compelling enough productin the electric vehicle aspect, without the autonomous piece as well? or does apple believe that the "autonomous" component is the real stand out feature?
- mikeash 10y agoWith a product targeted at 2021 and which will likely see delays, not building in autonomy from the start likely means that it'll be behind the curve when it ships. "Skate to where the puck is going" and all that.
- Razengan 10y agoBy 2021, (hopefully) the primary mode of individual transportation in developed cities will be using your phone/watch/R2D2 to call a self-driving electric car to your location. Things have already begun to fall into place for that reality. The cars might then use AI/ML/networking to optimize their individual routes and schedules for their daily passengers, to ensure a continuously smooth flow of traffic. Few people may even need to own a personal car. What might Apple's advantage be in that world? The same as today I guess; seamless cross-device integration and maybe an ecosystem of in-car apps. Would it be enough to compel someone to purchase their own, likely very expensive, car?
- mikeash 10y agoWhether the cars are individually owned or shared, somebody's going to have to build them. Apple could easily sell into a shared pool too, if that's how things are by then. (Although I think you're 3-5x too optimistic for how long it'll take to get there.)
- Razengan 10y ago> Although I think you're 3-5x too optimistic for how long it'll take to get there. Yes, well, skate to where the puck is going and all that.
- csours 10y ago> But building a car is complicated and Apple has struggled to define a differentiated vision for its vehicle, these people said. Some of the automobile industry veterans have clashed with longtime company employees on how best to proceed.
- astrodust 10y agoConflict can be a good thing in this case. Instead of Apple running off and doing the "Apple thing" which isn't grounded, they get pulled back in by veterans. Likewise, veterans have their assumptions challenged.
- csours 10y agoAgreed, it will be very interesting to see if "Apple Scale" [1] thinking works in automotive design[2] and manufacturing. Apple can buy 10,000 CNC machines for an iPhone frame, but there are a couple thousand parts at least that size in a car. The difference in physical scale between a phone and a car should not be dismissed... but I'm very interested to see what comes out of the process. 1. https://blog.bolt.io/no-you-cant-manufacture-that-like-apple-does-93bea02a3bbf#.smhful8w4 https://blog.bolt.io/no-you-cant-manufacture-that-like-apple... 2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjcm-ru-9iI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjcm-ru-9iI (this talk is good, but incredibly frustrating because the slides aren't shown)
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoThere is also a big difference in the importance of reliability. Half the people I see with iPhones older than a year have broken screens. But with a car, you can't engineer it to last for two years and then expect the owner to scrap it and buy a new one. For all the talk of AR, shiny UX etc, keep in mind that a car has to retain at least some resale value for at least ten years, preferrably closer to twenty. Otherwise you'll be left with a lot of angry customers. Planned obsolesence is out of the question.
- rodgerd 10y ago
- bluthru 10y agoIn the short term I can see how an incredibly well-made car with AR tech would make people want to own them. Long term however I believe cars will just be a shared network of autonomous vehicles for moving people and things. In other words a shared commodity with cheap rental prices versus ownership. That doesn't seem like a market for Apple. But hey, if they're investing in electric vehicles then that's better for everyone.
- TillE 10y agoI agree, but I think we're at least 25 years away from that vision being realized. That leaves Apple a couple decades to sell a really good electric car which may have some "smart" safety features, but probably zero automation.
- sounds 10y agoIt appears the key success metric will be companies who: 1. Entered the emerging electric vehicle space with a "good enough" product that people will buy it. 2. Continuously innovate with new models. Since these are large pieces of machinery, this appears to be the money Tesla is leaving on the table by doing all their cars in-house. (maybe) 3. Autonomy. Nobody knows what this will come to mean, and lawmakers are being wary. Add to that Tesla's direct-to-consumer model stirring up the lawmakers, and autonomy may get killed by the lawyers (non-zero risk, not trying to predict the future with any certainty).
- bluthru 10y agoTesla will be offering automation for (presumably) less money in 2021. I don't think Apple can afford to not have automation, nor do I think they could offer something appealing enough to overcome not having automation. If Tesla can create automation in a short amount of time, I have no doubt that a massive computer company filled with smart software engineers and a maps group can do it.
- threeseed 10y ago> Long term however I believe cars will just be a shared network of autonomous vehicles for moving people and things I doubt it. The majority of drivers on the road are your typical 9-5 commuters. For them it will still be more convenient (no need to wait for another car) and cheaper to just buy a car and there is still something intrinsic to human nature about "owning" something. People leave all manner of goods in their car. I see autonomous vehicles taking over taxis however.
- wehadfun 10y agoIf the past is any indication Apple will most likely improve on what is already out there Mp3 player, Cell phone, buying music over internet, GUI, ... were all around before Apple made them big. Tesla is probably their target this time.
- vessenes 10y agoIt's interesting to speculate about what a 'fast follower' model looks like with cars. Cars have been around a long time. You propose that Tesla has sort of v2.0'ed cars with their fast, attractive, semi-autonomous, electric thing. That could be. But a fast follower model doesn't admit for autonomous cars; nobody is doing anything like that yet. And we are all sort of imagining like the self driving Apple car "carved from a solid billet of aluminium" (cue Jony Ives), I think. Apple seems to have the market lead in UI/UX, Product Design, Supply Chain and some forms of Silicon. I guess that could all add up to a greenfield effort at just a car, but better. I think it's more likely that this is a turning point in Apple's strategy, and that they see the need to make some big bets, like Google. In any event, I'm super curious about what will come out in 2020, or whatever.
- DigitalJack 10y agoApple is going to seamlessly combine Uber, ZipCar, Tesla's Autopilot, and the US Drone program. Here is what they are going to build: A fleet of vehicles piloted remotely like drones, using all the the "tesla autopilot" safety features as augmentation to make the job of remote piloting easier. The vehicles will be summoned by the iphone. The fleet will have all-electrics and hybrids, where hybrids are a fallback depending on availability and trip range. The "front" seats will face the "rear" seats. Windows will be dynamically shaded from transparent to opaque. The "doors" will slide to open, including part of the roof, allowing passengers to embark/disembark while standing.
- nerfhammer 10y agoYou will steer using your phone's accelerometer. Tilt the phone left to turn left, and vice versa.
- stcredzero 10y agoThere will be a separate app for auto-steering in every set of road conditions imaginable. If you want to be safe, all you have to do is to find the right app out of 100's of thousands that's highly rated and doesn't crash. Seriously, I think there will be a change in scope and timing with regards to the roll-out of automated vehicles. I suspect it will happen first with trucks and buses in contexts with limited exposure to urban traffic.
- carterehsmith 10y agoTilt up to fly? That would be something. How about tilt down. Not obvious. Maybe you could dive if you were in water?
- nerfhammer 10y agoDon't drop your phone while trying to use it to steer. Shattered glass
- capkutay 10y ago> using all the the "tesla autopilot" safety features I can't tell if you are being facetious given the short-comings and risks of Tesla's autopilot (frequently discussed here).
- guimarin 10y agoI've thought a lot about this and don't think that full autonomy is necessary for Apple's car to be successful. I don't even think they need to be anywhere near as good as Tesla. In fact, they probably can't because Tesla Autopilot gets better through the experience of the cars, and that kind of software data expertise is not in Apple's wheelhouse. Recently I've tested all the auto-sensing, autopilot, and what not features of the latest generation of cars. I've gone on dozens of test drives and I think that something around as good as Honda Sensing will be sufficient for the next car cycle (5-7 years). If they can make iterative improvments that will be even better, but I don't think we are as close to the kind of car Apple would want to sell in the autonomy field. Well understood driving cities like NYC and SF are just not a big enough splash for Apple. Why Apple will be very successful: Recently they've started to revamp and expand their retail Flagship stores all over the world have recently been remodeled, all to be much larger. I think this footprint of stores, larger than Teslas, will be huge in getting people to buy the cars, thereby circumventing the dealership model. Tesla was the pioneer here, and Apple will ride on their coattails. Apple has incredibly supply chain leverage and capability. In the last 5 years, the cost of batteries has gone down significantly. Yet all the hybrid cars utilizing batteries are still very expensive. The brand new Volvo XC90 is $20k more expensive for a 9kWh pack. With Apple's supply chain and margin control capabilities, they should be able to comfortably source Li-Ion batteries in the $200-$300 range per kWh. Apple also crushes every single other computer and phone manufacturer when it comes to their onboarding experience. This and their experience in UI/UX will be key. The knob-less experience in cars is total dogshit. No one does a good job of realizing that the user experience should not be a monolithic touchscreen for things that are NOT media related. Sure make all Media touchscreen enabled/driven. But not the AC/Heat, and in my mind the volume for the AV system at the lest. If apple can solve that, and make it easy to pair a phone with the infotainment system, then with their competitive pricing and superior experience they will destroy the competition. All the legacy manufacturers are still stuck in the wrong paradigm. Only Tesla is positioned to compete with Apple, it's a shame they didn't buy Tesla earlier and let Musk run both companies. Tim is great don't get me wrong, but with Musk at the helm they would have been totally unstoppable. Tim is a genius at what he does, but he's not the kind of visionary CEO that can launch the car like an Elon or Steve could.
- 10y ago
- ascotan 10y agoanother paywall.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoIn the long term do people see the automobile industry as a growth industry? Will there be more cars on the road per capita in the future or less? Some trends make me think there will be less cars around in the future. The average age at which people get drivers licenses is rising for example as it is becoming easier to live without them. The car sharing network Car2Go, which one could look at as an early example of how a vast autonomous car network would work, has shown to take 11 cars off the road for each that it adds[1]. Lastly there is a renaissance in many cities right now with planners turning away from car oriented infrastructure, and more strongly focusing on pedestrians, cyclists and public transit. It seems to me that a lot of the car oriented thinking of the 1950s that resulted in the cities we see today is discredited amongst planners and they are trying to move us away from that. I wonder where Apple believes the car market share is going. Even if automobiles aren't a growth industry they may think it's worthwhile to them to try to take a good share of the luxury market. [1] http://www.citylab.com/commute/2016/07/car2go-car-ownership-vmt-ghg/491825/ http://www.citylab.com/commute/2016/07/car2go-car-ownership-...
- ryanmarsh 10y agoYes. Cars are a growth industry. Which is kind of crazy but look at it this way. How much bigger will the global middle class be in 50 years? 100? Oh, and don't forget Africa. Lots of growth opportunity there.
- ddebernardy 10y agoAfrica is a prime destination for second hand cars coming in from developed countries. I'm skeptical there is much growth opportunity there for car manufacturers. For the middle class, I can't help but wonder if it'll make much sense for them to actually own cars in 50-100 years if there are company-operated fleets of cheap self-driving vehicles - or at least more than one car per household. Time will tell.
- AnAfrican 10y ago>Africa is a prime destination for second hand cars coming in from developed countries. I'm skeptical there is much growth opportunity there for car manufacturers. That's mostly because New Cars were unafforable to All. At least in the places I've visited there are more and more new cars. - because people are richer than a few years ago - because financing options that didn't exist now do - because laws banning imports of cars "older than x years" also help (even if they have unintended consequences)
- nardi 10y agoWhat I feel like everyone is missing is that an Apple Car makes sense for the same reason the iPhone made sense in 2007: The existing technology really blows, and Apple can make a significant contribution. Remember what "smartphones" looked like before the iPhone? No touch screens, physical keyboards, tiny screens, almost no native web browsing. Now imagine what Apple could do to the inside of your car with that kind of thinking in mind, and $80,000. Edit: I forgot one of the biggest problems with the old smartphones is they were ugly as sin, which is also true of modern cars.
- wavefunction 10y ago>The existing technology really blows, and Apple can make a significant contribution. This is absolutely ridiculous. Apple is starting out at 0 with no real competence in this area, the least of which is interaction with regulatory bodies tasked with consumer protection.
- jameshart 10y agoAll of which is also true when Apple set out to make a phone. They had no competence in RF engineering, or interaction with the diversity of cellphone network providers throughout the world, the conventional wisdom at the time was that an outsider couldn't just break in to the phone market without acquiring an existing manufacturer.
- maroonblazer 10y agoThe difference is that cell phones can't inadvertently kill people to the degree automobiles can.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoThere's a huge difference between iterating an iPod into a phone and moving from consumer electronics to a completely different market that just happens to depend on some electronics but requires a whole lot more engineering know-how that Apple has in its stables.
- 10y ago
- Zigurd 10y agoSo Richard Scary wasn't available?
- ourmandave 10y agoBob Mansfield? But John Sculley is tanned, rested, and ready.
- elchief 10y agoApple is pretty good at scale manufacturing and lithium batteries and metal and better at AI than any car company except Tesla. Electric cars are much simpler than ICE ones. So they have a chance...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ryanmarsh 10y agoThis. Is Apple going to start making a world class ICE from scratch? No. Could they eventually? Yes of course. But why would they want to? A car without an ICE is a reduced complexity space to engineer a vehicle in. I'll bet they can figure out how to iterate from an electric mule to a safe vehicle just fucking fine. People unfamiliar with the auto industry may also be surprised to learn just how many parts on a Model S tesla doesn't make. But an ICE? Fuck I wouldn't want to start that war with zero patents.
- Animats 10y agoApple could easily make a branded car. The entire dashboard is usually manufactured separately and installed as a unit.[1] Apple could build those, with screens and Jonathan Ive design. This would come with a matching interior package and exterior logos. Like the "Ford F-150 King Ranch Edition". The next step up would to have some car company, perhaps in China, build them a chassis, powertrain, and body, to which Apple would add their dashboard and interior, and possibly the sensors and actuators for self-driving. Here are 10 new electric cars from China.[2] Apple could help them open up the US market. There's no reason for Apple to get into the sheet metal stamping business, even though Tesla did. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxeFEvEQKTU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxeFEvEQKTU [2] http://www.forbes.com/sites/tychodefeijter/2016/05/18/10-new-electric-cars-from-china/#15fd56361e2f http://www.forbes.com/sites/tychodefeijter/2016/05/18/10-new...
- kalleboo 10y agoMy pet theory is still that the Apple Car project is all just to keep Jony Ive around - he's bored of designing square rectangles, and every day when he gets in his Tesla he swears at the crappy plastic interior. He went to Tim Cook and said "I'm leaving for Tesla to fix their design", and Tim Cook knowing that Jony Ive is probably half of Apple's share value will do anything to keep him on.
- btian 10y agoJony Ive gets around in his chauffeured Bentley Mulsanne.
- danpalmer 10y agoNow that does not have a crappy plastic interior.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoIt has some of the finest plastic money can buy.
- tooFastFuckYou 10y agoYes, because Jony Ive's "fixes" are so incisive. If Jony Ive worked at Tesla, their cars would have a one-mile range. Have you ever heard this pompous hack weigh in on why the iPhone doesn't need a usable battery?
- omarforgotpwd 10y agoTesla's market cap is $33 billion. Apple has $200 billion in cash. Why don't they just buy Tesla? They'll spend more than that trying to recreate all the work Teslas already done. I feel like this would help make the future happen faster.
- btian 10y agoBecause you can't actually buy 100% of Tesla for $33B. Elon Musk owns 20% of shares. Does he want to sell?
- omarforgotpwd 10y agoTesla has been working hard to raise additional capital so they can deliver Model 3. Apple has a lot of capital. Perhaps they could come to an agreement. An acquisition he didn't agree to would probably be unwise since he's so key to the company.
- _ph_ 10y agoI am both a Tesla and an Apple fan, but I really hope this does not happen. We need all the competition in the electric car market we can get. So I want Tesla and Apple to compete who makes the best car. And considering, that Tesla invested perhaps 1-2 billion into the creation of their cars, I don't think that buying Tesla would save Apple any money.
- ksec 10y agoThe more important question here is, why Bob? Does it mean Apple has an culture problem that is hard for other high rank managerial grade to fit in? Why has Bob Retired and then Un-retired?
- _ph_ 10y agoThe car industry is ready for some disruption. Current car makers are good at what they are doing, but there have been few entirely new developments. So it is no wonder that one of the most desirable cars at the moment is the Tesla, a car which comes from a "startup" and is electrical. The transition to electrical cars is what is shaking up the industry. All the special knowledge around the creation of combustion engine is no longer needed. And a lot of the non-engine components are sourced by suppliers, which are also happy to supply companies like Tesla. The Tesla shares quite a few components with the well known German car brands. This allows new car companies to enter the market relatively easily. And beyond the fact that Apple can hire car engineering veterans, Apple is an excellent product design company. The Apple watch should be a warning. All discussions about the usefulness of smart watches aside, one important thing is, that Apple enters an entirely new product category, but if you look of the design and quality of their stainless steel bracelet, it is much better than most of the Rolex bracelets at a fraction of the price. So I would not be surprised, if while the pure driving part (electrical motor, suspension) is rather off the shelf, the overall construction of the car could be both different and unexpected by the current players.
- tooFastFuckYou 10y agoAnd nothing "disrupts" like Apple's design ineptitude. Let's see: If Jony Ive gets involved, we'll see an Apple car with a one-mile battery or a one-gallon gas tank, one door, one gear, and no horn.